Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/83/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/83/2005 Généré par l'IA

Workplace Injury Negligence and Employer Liability

Numéro de cause ATAS/83/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The plaintiff sued the defendant for damages arising from a workplace injury, alleging the defendant failed to maintain a safe work environment and provided inadequate safety training, resulting in the plaintiff's injury due to exposure to hazardous substances. The court analyzed whether the defendant's safety protocols and training met established standards, reviewed the evidence regarding the nature and extent of the plaintiff's injury, and considered the statutory requirements for employer liability in such cases. The court ultimately held that the defendant failed in its duty of care by not adhering to mandatory safety regulations, thus finding in favor of the plaintiff and awarding damages commensurate with the established liability and proven harm.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Workplace Injury Negligence and Employer Liability: The court analyzed whether the defendant's safety protocols and training met established standards, reviewed the evidence regarding the nature and extent of the plaintiff's injury, and considered the statutory requirements for employer liability in such cases. The court ultimately held that the defendant failed in its duty of care by not adhering to mandatory safety regulations, thus finding in favor of the plaintiff and awarding damages commensurate with the established liability and proven harm.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
devoir de diligence règlement d'entreprise travail dangereux responsabilité pour cas fortuit prestations d'assurance-accidents milieu de travail

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the procedural costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/1523/2008
Employer Liability for Incidental Occupational Injury
C/19310/2004
Workplace Injury Liability: Employer Negligence Versus Employee Protocol Violation
A/1499/2003
Employer Liability for Scaffolding Safety Violation Causing Employee Injury
C/9544/2003
Damages Assessment and Comparative Fault in Workplace Injury Claim
C/27869/2008
Employee v. Employer: Workplace Accident Compensation and Damages

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the procedural costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

    $%&'$())* $+,$())-

!!.

/ !0/   /!  

# , 12 ())-

,3  4 5

  

# 6666666666   !  " # !   $% &'  ( !) ) *  +! )

!

   6666666666 + ,,,,,,,,,,' )) 

! 

7   / /! 8 ) "' -..- 

!

7 / /  '  !' /.00 $ # )+1) 

                ! "#

2 0342

 7

-7  89! ) : )+;  0..:'  ; )  <  ! )  +;* ! ! ) <= > ?  )   )=    9 ! !+  -@ !;  -55:  ") ,,,,,,,,,,' + ,,,,,,,,,,' ! " ,,,,,,,,,,7

07  #11  / ) )!1 ) 89!  +!+'    )+ ! A  ! )   ) )  !9  !+  =  )  +=B  1 *  # ) +A ) !   97

:7  89! ) )=  ! )= )+1!1  0@ 8= 0..67

67  ; ) +  !+ )  !   )  !!! )  +=B7

C7    ) -- 8 0..6' " ,,,,,,,,,,  A*+ = ! =+   +!+  % ) -550 D -554 ! = ! +!+  #E9 ) !

** ' =! ) +!+9  (!     )   -55@ ! )(F!  +11+  G%   H   % %  % %%% %       % % >2 < I G%   H   %?7  ( *!!+  :- J! 0..-  F!  11+ D  G       % %%  % >2 < I   % ?7

47    )!    ) + D      %  0. J! 0..:

)!   ! *  ! =  !!   D G 7 :.K6-@7L >B     !! ) ;  9 ) G 7 0:K/667:. M ) G%   H   %   )(!;  0..-?7 (   ) G%   H   % )!+ ) -0 J! 0..:'   !    * " ,,,,,,,,,,   +!+ 11+ ) -   -55@  :- J! 0..- ! *  !!!+ )   !! )  ! ! 1+ + D   %  +!+ * )!  ) + )  97

@7 <  '  ; ) +  ! +   %   ! !! ) <  )  *  !! ) =  * ) !   9' ! !   -@ !;  -55: !  0@ 8= 0..6 >)! N  89! ! )= )+1!1 !

A+! ?7

/7    ) -C 8! 0..6'   %  1 +  ; ) + * (!+ + (+!!  11+ )  :- 8! 0..: ! *' (B! 8 M   )+ ) ! 1 !    !! ) ;  9'  =!  ++ 

3-4530..6

2 :342

 ) ;  9 O 4/:...3/-.. > 4-:5:?7  !! ) (= *  0@ 8= 0..6 (+=! D G 7 :.K5.67-C7

57    !  +!+ ))+  G%   H   %  *( +!! )= )  !! +   )   <  11! ) " ,,,,,,,,,,7    ) -6 8! 0..6'  G%   H   %  1 + * (!+ +  =! +!+ 11+   <  1' ) 

- !;  -550  :. 8 -55C' ! *(D   !'  !! ) ;  9 ) G 7 0K.047-C =! +!+ ! 1+ + D (!!! %+!=' D $ #7  !!!+ )  !! =! +!+ * ) !   97

-.7  04 J! 0..6' " ,,,,,,,,,,   )!    )  G  %    %   >! ) ;  9 O @.@7@.70/C7--@?

)!   ! *  !! )   !! ) ;  9 (+=!'  )+;  0..:' D G 7 --K@0075.7  11!' !   !! ) G 7 0K.047@. = +   G%   H   %  !;  -55C'  !! ) G 7 /K0C:7-.

=! +9! +!+ = +  05 8 -555    H  G %%   (%   " >  ?7

--7 % )) ) ; ) +'    ) @ !;  0..6'  G  %    %    +!; *  !! )   !! ) ;  9 ) " ,,,,,,,,,, + ) !  + ) )  9' ! ) -@ !;  -55:  0@ 8= 0..6' (+=!  ++! D G 7 --K@667CC7

-07  (; ) + ) ") ,,,,,,,,,,' " ,,,,,,,,,,    )*+  ; *(D  = '  A2+ =! ! =+   !   G  P "  % ' % Q % % ' P  % !   0...7

-:7 2 ! ) +!+ ! +7 % Q %  1 + (A! )( ! ! ) ! = = (!+ + ) 0C !;  0...  0/ 1+=  0..- R  !!  =! +!+ = + D     %%  % D 7 ! 9+' !! ) <   )*+'    ) 0 )+;  0..6' *  !! )   !! ) ;  9 ) ") (+=! D G 7 :@076.  0/ 1+=  0..-7 %(9! ) + ) (+!)! )  )! )  9  0C !;  0... ! ) 0/ 1+=  0..- D  )! ) )= '  (! +1+ + D (!!!  ++)! I  G)! +!=  D $ #7

-67 G  P "  %  1 + * (!+ + =! ! =+    )

0   0C !;  0..- ! )*+ *  !!  +=+    

3-4530..6

2 6342

=! +!+ = + D  $ %%% 7 !! ) < ' ! 9+'  1 + (11! ) ") ,,,,,,,,,, ) -   :. !;  0..-7  0@ 8= 0..6'  !! )   !! (+=! D G 7 5-:727

-C7 P  %  11 +   ! = !  ) ") ,,,,,,,,,,     B+7

-47 1'  G  %    %  '  )*+'    )

0. )+;  0..6' *   !! ) ;  9 ) ") (+=! D G 7 C-:7-C7

-@7  )! ! +!+ *+ A  !' *   !  !!+7

 !

-7   9=  ( 9! 8)  >?  +!+ )1+ !  !!+' )<  - J! 0..:'  ; ! )    > %?' + ) * 89' )!   +)! !  =2 +)!' * +! ! S 89   > !7 - !7 ! C4 ?7

%! D (! ) (+! ) S 89     ; 1+)+  > G?  0@ 8= 0..6 > G -:.  -.4?'   )  9=  )!+'  -: 1+=  '  )! ! !   9! > !7 -40 ?  !!!  % ) +9   ' D !  89 !! ' ) (!!! ) (+! ) =A 89  7

07 K !7 0C )   1+)+    ;  9 )   +=B  1'

='  ==! ! =)!+ ) -@ )+;  -55: >G?' ! +  =9  - 8= 0...' <9   +)    ) )= 7   ) )+ ) ) 8!    !! )  ! D  !9   ) )=  > !7 -00 ! -0: ?'

 89 )  ) )=  +!!   ) K !7 @: 7 - ' ! D <=  ; ! )    )  - J! 0..: > !7 - !7 ! C4 7 - !7 ; ?' )!'  < * K11    +!+ !  > !7 -60 ?' A+! )K11   !9   ; )  + ) + !! )+! +   89 ) )= 7

:7 % K !7 00 G >= !  =9 )  - 8= 0...?'   ) )= '   !! )  ! * ) !   9 !  !9+ 1 +! A  !7 -00' -0:' -6- ! -60 R   !7 : D C G K*! 

3-4530..6

2 C342

9  !! D ! 1+  >7 -?7  #* 8!'   !! )  ! D  !9  ) D  )11+  !    !! )  !' 9!+ ) =  ) ;  9 A!! +=!!  ! ) )= ' !   !! )  !' 9!+ ) =  ) ;  9 A!! +=!!

 ! )   )  9 >17  !7 06 G?7   '  8! D   !! )  ! ! D K= ) ;  9 A!!  ! )   )  9  !+ F! )  ! ) )=  > G -0/  0:.R G -05  666?7

67  (<'  89 )  <  !   )+   !9  !+ ) =  !1 * )!  ) + )  9' ! ) -@ !;  -55:  0@ 8= 0..6' )! D *  89! ) )=  ! )= A+! '  * (!  !!+    !7

C7 %  )!  )!'   !! * )!   9  " ,,,,,,,,,, ! ) G 7 60K46/7@. >G 7 :.K5.67-C T G 7 --K@667CC?' !) *  *   A2+ ! ) G 7 -(@5/7CC >G 7 :@076. T G 7 5-:72 T G 7 C-:7-C?7 <  '  ;  )  D (!!! )  +=B ) " ,,,,,,,,,, ) ! 1+   !! ) G 7 0.K60C7.C >UG 7 60K46/7@. 3 0V W UG 7 -K@5/7CC 3 0V?  < )  1)! )  +=B )  A2+7

47 1 +! D  8  )' )  8 )+! !    !9 8*K ! ) ! 1 ! )   !! )  !  )  ) '  8!

)= + ;++1  ) !!  !!  ) ! D ) !+ F! !    !! ) 27  !+ F! ! +  !A  +9  +=  K !7 -0 ) K )    +=B  1 ='  ==! !

=)!+ ) -/ =  -5/6 > 0?    !A +9! '  2 !

+  > G  ;+  :43.0 ) -/ 8! 0..:?7

@7  +!     M'   +)  +!! 9 !! > !7 @: 7 0  !

/5& 7 -  ?7

3-4530..6

2 4342

!  7  !0/   /!  

# 9:1   ;  8   <= %&( >?

-7 =!  G       % %%  % D ! 1+  '   )+;! ) ! ) " ,,,,,,,,,,'   ) G 7 0.K60C7.C   ! ) ;  9 ) ") ,,,,,,,,,,' + ,,,,,,,,,,' = !  < )  G  %    %  >! ) ;  9 O? R

07 (=! D =  '   )  !!' ) !+ F! ! ' )<  0@ 8= 0..6   ) )+ ! R

:7 (B )  !! * ) ; R

67 ! *(     M  +!  + )()!+ R

C7 1    ! )  *K =! 1    !    +!  F!

)  )+ ) :. 8  )<  !1!   )+ ) +  ; 1+)+  )  ' %#XS #1* 4' 4..6   '  !  A 7  )+  ! F!   9+7  +  )! I ? )* A!! *K )+   ! )+  ;!   !  )  )+ !!*+R ;? A  * !1  ! = )) !! !  )+R ?  !  9!    )   +!!7 %  +   !!   !  ++! ++ +  !!  ? ;? ! ? 2)'  ; 1+)+  )       !   !<      *K )=  )+   =;7  +  )   !     B )  =' *  ! 8!'  *  )+ !!*+ ! K= ) *   +!+ A+)+   ! > !7 -:0' -.4 ! -./ ?7

 9 11<  I   +)! I

 GG P  % P

  1  )  +!  F! ! !1+ A  !  *KD K11 1+)+  )      9 11 

3-4530..6