Slip and Fall Notice Requirement Affirmation
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe litigant sought to recover damages for injuries sustained in a slip and fall incident on the defendant's premises, alleging a dangerous condition existed and the defendant had actual or constructive notice of it. The court affirmed a judgment for the defendant, reasoning that the evidence presented was insufficient for the jury to reasonably conclude that the defendant either created the dangerous condition or knew of its existence and failed to remedy it within a reasonable time, thereby defeating the essential element of notice required to establish liability under premises liability law.
Regeste Legislator
Officiel; AI(ASSURANCE) ; LOI FÉDÉRALE SUR L'ASSURANCE-INVALIDITÉ ; LOI FÉDÉRALE SUR L'ASSURANCE-INVALIDITÉ ; RÉVISION(PRESTATION D'ASSURANCE) ; RÉVISION(DÉCISION) ; RECONSIDÉRATION ; DÉCISION ; CHOSE JUGÉE ; FAITS NOUVEAUX | LPGA17
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IACited in the dispositive for the allocation of judicial costs.
Cited in the dispositive for the allocation of legal aid.
Cited in the dispositive to declare the appeal inadmissible due to inadmissibility of the appeal against the decision on legal aid.
Texte complet
"#$%$"&''$ (")%"&''*
(
( +( + +
+,- & ! #' ./ &''*
!"#$#% & ( !'()"( !*"( +( ,
(
-- * ,, . (!" /%0
! !
.$1#5. 0 (
#6 7.'8(9 *:':"#%3$( !; '<6()"=8)>#%?36
$6 ! )!@#%?3 ( () A@ (!(!=! (6@""<" *( *) (" $4B (7 96
26 "'" ( #5!#%?? ! '(('8 *<< ( *.) (" 7.'8 9 )( = ! " '((6
C6 , ! *.) ("7.'8 9 !" ('"(-&!" ()<<("D'(!" ( %>#%?%6)""(E/!EA(!'((!(( <( ':( ( ( !)!( ' (6 , !" *"(( (" ( !@( *F( '(G( ::)" '8 D ()( E: A ( " ( (8 G(" ':( (6 "(A*!('<')( F( ):@ ! ''( ): )( (( E6 '"" A* (( !'( <<"( E ' ( * ')( !(( ) (" ' D(6
56 ! <")#%%4"(")(! * ( ( A @<( (:E6'":"<< ":!@6
36 ''( ( *@)(!" *.) ("7.'8 9 #? "!@ #%%4 !" E< ( E< A >(((("A :('' ("(("(E/!EA")8A " ' ( ()( ' ( A D! E!(:A ( :A*)(''!((") @((:A6 ( * ( )(!#%%4'"("<( (:E ) '(( : ( !E <<6 :'E A D'( ( '(A" !((( ") ")( <)@ ' E: '!( <"!.(@ ( !: *: /('E6 ( A( '(" () *( ' ()" ' :A ( '/E(A '(E: '@ * '(" ()!F! ()(" !;6 D'(( (("A((!(*"(():"A( *(+=((! "")@')(()((<'(" () !8 "<()6 ( (!" A ! " '(( *"(( = ): A*'8 "( ):6 "(( ' > D */
123#31$443 .21#5. "( ()(" ":8 !":( ! (6 (( '!(A('() " *!('" *((( ">=")8!'(" E "( (6 ( <!( A*= *"'A */ )( !" 'A(()'6
06 " $0>(#%%2* !(@""< *( @ * :" *) (" #44B 8$0<")#%%#6
?6 " #?(@#%%C( ! *<<<" " * "(!'" " $0>(#%%26<!" (A*'(( *.) ("')(F((/" (!= *) (" *"(( '""6<<((=(: *@)('<<<(" 0 "!@#%%$3!#%%2"((''A()('(" ()A*''(( !(()6
%6 ( $# )!@ #%%C ( (>(" '8 !!( !(8 * ,. (=*( * ((8@ *) (" #44B6,(: *@)( <<(" )( @( = ((( A* "(( '@ () "(( (' !(" !)!(6
#46 >:!( #5 > #%%5 7 H ##$?1%C9 !! ( !(8 * ,. !'"(( D!" " #? (@#%%C')()@!(!'" $0>(#%%2A"(((" < ( "(( "<() ( D"( ( "(( < " A( = (6 !! A ( * ") *"(( ' !'6 <<( *) (" ( *"(( ' ! <" !8 = < ( = ( ' " ! >( #%%26 "( "(( D " $0 >( #%%2 )( (!( ( !'( '8 ( *!@ (6 !" )((((" *'(" () ( '< !;(D'(!" )(<D"*) ("=' D(( <!"*!@ )!" D6"A(" " #?(@#%%C(<!" $0>(#%%2A(/(((86 (("A'(" () ("(( !"( !;(A!'(( E '*D *('<"(( 6''"A" '(()("(">("'*<<": A "(( E:" *D! @ ''( *@)( '<6
##6 (@#%%?* <!"( *)( *'" ") (=( *) ("6
123#31$443 .C1#5. #$6 ''( %!#%%% ! * E< A D 7.'8 I"(@!( E'(I9 ( !" .((DI"(@!(E'(I('"!! :( <(!'A" *)(@ ( ( ()#%?3(( '8 <( ( :E ( ( #%%4 !@((((!()EE"'(EA E/'( '( ( ) J'E: ( (( '8 "!'( (:8 : #%%# ( (@:!6 !" ( ((" A *"(( (" ( "(( (( A* / )( '(" () #44B '! )!@#%?3(A ! '<"(( A"6
#26 ''( (" ! ; ' * $0 )!@ $44# -!" ((( ('"!! :(/( "' '(" () (( '8 (!(! ! ( D()(E:)"A ( "<( <((('8<(!!() (:E)" ( :( ( ("/(E8 ' :.E@: ( :E 5 ! #%%4(!! :(*/("''(" () (('8))'8"(E/!796 ""A*"(( (" ( "((((A**/)(E:!( :((A*'(" ()"(((> #44B6,!" !'<*"((' A"'(6
#C6 !!( 24 >) $44$ * ((" ") A :" *) (" ( *)( ' E:" '( *< (=(6
#56 ? >( $44$ !! '( !"( @K(!( I J)I ! ' ''( "(@ ' * (G E( ( (6 , ''( ( "(" ' ( "'/ ()(" '( "E @( * !" 6 *:( () 6 ('" = >( D'A"' 5'(!@$44$A(*)( ()" A D > ' * = ' )D D A* )( J)" <; (! ' ( "!":!( A* */ )( ' '@ E( ( A *:( A* )( ! ' ! *"(( ' '( ( * ' '" = ) (( ,1 6 A" A* )( ! " ' ! ( A "(( ">= '((!' !6
#36 ''( (!" $? >) $442 ! * - <!" A *"(( (" ( "(( (( ' $44#6!F!E:!( :(*"((=:6
123#31$443 .51#5. #06 *) ,)!" ":.) ("7.'8,9 #0 ! $44C & ( !" , ( ''" A * '( ) ((!( !" ( " = *( * ( *)( >! "(" !'6 <<( "<"( = *D'( %(@#%%4( A"A**/)(' ''( ("(*(((=("(*'(" ()6' (:"A " *()("("''(> (A !( <("(( *""!() ' !" 6 "A( ( A* *)( :!( !" = < ) ' !(( A( ( (6 ( ::"" !(( )> A *.) ("' ")6
#?6 ''( C L( $445 ) " '(( '< ''"*((A*)(#2'(!@$44C6 ( (( ( )( A" A "(( (" "(( (> !F! A*)((><(!((':(:E(A:( <((>((<<6 A( )*'(F( ! () ()("'((!(("' A* *:( *()(8":'(A*'D()("! (!( ' = ' (!'6 ( () <<(" EM A *'8 ( ' A" A* <<()!( " ' = ' *''(!( . ' ( ! *!6"(((A**:( *()6":!( A" A (!' (!' ' ) ( )" *D *( ()(" '< 6 *:( (> '(( ()(" A ')( = /(E! (( (!' ( !((AA ''(')((*F(6 ,*:( '(" *D ()(" '< ":8 '(" ( ((!'( !((( (A*'('')( /(E! EM !'/ <( ' ( ( !( ! " ( A*= '( AA '(( ()(" '( ' ') F( 'E/A!( '@ *! !'6 ) " '(( '< " " !(( ' (: ( *@)( '< .) (" 7.'8 9 < *D! '(( " '(( '< ( '(" ()6 (: " 5'(!@$445$(@$4456
#%6 , ''( ## (@ $445 '(" ( I( !'(@) ()("":8= ( ')('( (1<AA'=(!'!'(() !( 04B!!! ("!A!6(!'( <( " (!(( !" !( '" * '(( ( "(+!( ( "6I!+( " '((( A"A()(" *!'/"
123#31$443 .31#5. @ (@ !:: ": ( ! <;: ": !! ) * !"A ":8 "(( !'(@ ) '(" (6 (:( ""A*"((DA* () = #44B */( ' '(" ' < ! A* ")( '((!D!!=54B6
$46 ( #$ (@ $445 !" (( :" A ' ):( *" ( * ' *()(" '< ( A* "(( :)!( " (" ' '<6 , !" "(( I ( ((!( *!: (')( *()("'<I6 ((" * '( A (: <<(" )( !(" A ( ')( I(E"A!( ) ()(" '(" = #44B ) !( * 04B (8 )!@@!( !"@ ' "(+!( = *<<(I ( *( '( A ! '(A '(" (E"A((" (: "(('@@!()"=*"E= ( ((:'" *('( ()6
$#6 ''( #0)!@$445 ) " '(('< A* ')( ' ) *:( @ !( 24B '( IAA ' D:""I6 <<( ")A" <( A ( "(" "" ' !! '( !"( @K(!( I J)I6 "( A( A *(GE('((("(( *<<( ()D '( "E ''(!( !'8(")(6' *(()(#2'(!@ $44C )( A" = ) " '(( '< A* )(":!(<<("AA('((()("' < !6*"(('I " ("IA*)('!( (:6 ) " '(( '< ! " ( ''"!( #5BA((!'( ((""(:8 !A ":(" *D * ()(" '< ( A ()(" ":8"(('@6'" "= "(!( :" *) ("=* !' )6 !'" A ( '('"( ()("":8 '("=!((<( = ' (!' ( C%*5#4 <6 ) A* ( ' :: ()(" !J) ) (" ( 5?*$C0 <6 ( )" = (D *) (" #5B6
$$6 " #? )!@ $445 * ''!" ( *) (" ( 8 D8! ! A ) (<( (( " !(<A :" *) (""((<"=C4B6*'8"(( #5B @( ) " '(('<6
123#31$443 .01#5. $26 ( % "!@ $445(<!"''(= " #? )!@ $445 ( = ( ( = *( * ( *.) (" '("="(( ("6
$C6 "( #3 <") $443 ( !'"(" ''( <( ) (!( A "(( (" *"(( ' ! <" '( *< ( = ( "(( " A* "(( (( ' !@"6
$56 " ''( C '(!@ $443 * >(" *''( <!"% "!@$445(!'"("#3<")$4436(("A '!" ! <((@*)("(""(@!A'(" :*"((!<(!(! <"6"A(/)(@!(< ") ! <( '(" : "(( 6 ( '(" ()<D"=#44B@ !( #5B(' "( #5B "(( >(<" (( @ !'( *!@ 7<6''( ) " '((96"A()(D *) (" "(( #5B ("("''!"6 * (!"A*"((= @ ( A* )( <" ! '< ' ( )( <( ') '(" = () ()(" '(" = '@(" ()( <! * 6 '"" A* ! '!( ')( F( ( ( '8 ) !'"(( ''( *(6#? 6
$36 5(@$443((>("'8 @ ( 7.'8 @9(=*( "''( C'(!@$443=*( *( *.
) (" '(" = "(( (" = *( ! " '(( '< ( = !( * !(" '" 6 ,@ !( = A ( )/" = * ' (( !'"!( ( A* D'( !" ( "6 ' 8") (=(>)$44$"(( ("*(' !"" A *(!" 6 ( ((" A *(!" *)( <<("((!" < '"(( ("( '("" ()!" !(((("6,(<( )*"((()A>(<(''"(> A <<"( *"(( ("( (=(6 A"A**)(>!((" ) )" ! ( '(" () " 6 , <( *D '(( ()D ": :<( ' A* '( * ' '(" ()6'(: *@)('< "!("A* '"(( '(" " () 04B ( ' #44B !! *(!( < !( * 6 ( "" A (D ' "( = ( )( F( $5B ( ' #5B6 ) ! <(@((= :" *) (" 55BA )( (=
123#31$443 .?1#5. !.( *) ("6 < (!( = A '"( ( *(!" ( * <!" ()("' A6 ) ( 8 ' F( '""'* (!(A* '( *''(" ()6
$06 "' $2 (@ $443 *(!" ''" >( ( !( "6 :!( )A" ' ( *"(( ' '(@ *!=''"( <<"( 6
$?6 "(!'"!( $$)!@$443( A" = "'"'A(<!"(6
$%6 0 "!@$443 @!!A"(("(=*(!"(: " =>:6
(
#6 :)N:(> 79"("! <"(((" 8 #L($442 @( !'" 5>: ('" (().'" (5''"((#3>:7(6#(6 (53 96
,(=N( N"( #3>:' @<" " $0>)$44C7 -#24#439 :) '("#2<") '(((:('!((( @( ": = ( >: (( N((( N"( )D>:6
$6 <!"!( = *(6 53 6 # (6 E6 $ @ ( +((A ((('")=N( 53 <" " '( :"" ( 3 (@$4447 9A(()=N.) (" #%> #%5%7 96
,!'"('>: N'8("(@6
26 ((" ): # >) $442 (+( ! <( !@ '( ": ! 6 , '!("'( )A (*''A (F((E"=!8 ''A8:''@():!!(O <(> A!( "(!((' (7 -#24$24 6#6#P -#$%C 6#6$P -#$0C30 6##$3#23 6C@( "<"96 A '" ( = "<( 8: (( ( ) ( *''A ") 8 > (" ):7 -##0%2 63@##$234 6CP #%%?Q20'6 2#3 62@96
123#31$443 .%1#5. *'8 *( <( "(!( !( = ( '(" = *("): (!!(''( ( " * 6 "A( *''A '"( (:6 8: .) (" ( *.) (" #% >#%5% (#>)$44C7 96
C6 (>(" <!( "":D()@<!"!(D (6535%(34 6
56 (:'(A( )*(=>(((A* ''!" ((8 (@""<((6
36 D(! *(6#06# (D *) (" @""< ( @(! <((@(( *<< ! ")"' *)=):!("" ("A''!"6
( ( ' @( (! *(6 C# *.
) (" ( >A* 2# "!@ $44$ ( A '' >' ( ")''" !(8 !( ''@ 7 - #24 2C2 626596
,*(6?06$ 8:!( *.) (" #0>)#%3#7 ( 24 ! $4439 7 9 ") N<< AN '") N! <(!'(('@ (D N) (" :" N!'( @ "( N) ("(!"("<D"!!( N( ( N( ' !'(( A : N ( <( ( ! A ')( (+ ! <( !'(( (D N) (" :" N!'( @ "( N) ("6
,'(" :'(" N!'()DE@( N" N!" A !'( @ "( N) (" N(("/ "AE:!(''!"E"((( '( ( D '(( 8 AN '( N(( = A N!"((("!( (M:'" 6 ) !F! AN ( E:!( "(!( " ( ! ">= ('((@(AN!'('E(= 7(6?? 6# 96
!('' (' <<(('(G('! > D8! ! A ( (<( " 7(6 9 ( "(()!(= (O" ' D ( N"N N( <( ((@ ":8!( N !A" = !!( " = N@:( : A !@ @!( N(6 00 7(6 @9 7(6??@6$ 96
123#31$443 .#41#5. D(! *(600 N/( ('"((":A(( ' ((" = A '(( ( '/" ( !!A !!" (!( = N<< (( E:!( !'(( A '( ) "' ( D '(( '( E:!( A ( N"(( (" '(" : () N!'( @ "( N) (" "> "(!('<D !(( N( ' !'(( (( ' ( ")(!( "!A N"6
, >' ( '( F( ")" !( ! <(@ *"(( ("!A.((" !F!!A"A'(" :(@E:!( !'((7 -##2$05 6#(F(("P)":!( -#$4 #2# 6 2@ ##% C0? 6 #@196 ( E:!( !'(( ( '' = < :" *) (" ( ( = ( '( !() ")6 '( ( !! D!' !(< ") *:!(( @ ) *) ) * ' ) ! <( '( ": ":!( !'A( ( (=(':'((7<6 ( *) ("(*!'( *.) ("7.'8 9E<<544596
*/ ' !(8 = ") A ( '" * ! <( = (8 ') A ! <( () !(() ( ( ( = ( ' (( ( '" *")(!'!( <<"( *((A('*((" !F!7 #%?0'623P<6 E<<544396
!(< ") *(6#0 (!((
7 - '@" #2>($443C43145 6C( 2#>)$442 55%14$ 626$96
>:(E:!(*(' (<(!'<((A* '"(( !!( " ( ( ) ( ":(=*"'A "(:7 -#242C2 62656$P -#$5 23% 6$P -#4%$3$ 6C96
06 D (! *(6 52 6 # " ( " ''( <!!( '" < ( ! = ") N" N ") @"A!!( <( )D !'(( () )D!/ ')A')(F(' (')(6*:( ") ('" 6
,>' I<()DI(DA(' (>A* !!( O '" '' ":( <( "(( )@!A*"((' (!:"(( :6
123#31$443 .##1#5. ( )(F(!'((*(.=. A* )(F( (=! < *"(( <( A ( = @ *F( (' ( = = >:!( <<"( <( * ''"( > A (6 ') A( = )( ) = ') ( <( )D !'(( A !()( ") ( <( A "(( ( '" '"" ( !A*)(''F(')" "(!( A"(6,)D !/( ("=') <(":"("!(A"( ( "!(A*')(')A '"" ('" 6 ') ( "" !! ( A* <( !(( A* ( (>:=(((!(*)( '" ''6 A ( "< *( A !/ ') ) ' = *''"( <(!(!=*"(@!( 7 - 2>($44$&#$#14$P ,13251$443 #4>($44396
?6 < ( *")('!' " ('( F(")(!(! <" *'88:''@= "( " !(()'"<6
'' :"" ( A * !(( '((((!') *<< "<!!('"< A*' "=>:!(< A.((!( " ( A (<( )F( !'( ''"@ *!'( '" ")6 * !(( '( ! < " ( A ( ") *(6 #0 ( ' !'6 , >: ( '! = (( A " ( "(( (!( " '( <! )A( !(< " ")''* !((7 -#$523% 6$(F(("P<6 - ##$ 202 6 $ ( 2%4 6 #@96 "( ( D'"!( '") = *(6 52 6 $ D (! A IN '( ) " " ''( <!!( '" < AN ( !<(!( " ( A (<( )F( !'((@I6
>:*( !@ " "'!(<A*( ( " <( < (( > A D(( !!( O (( " "(" !'( ( '(A ): = *"'A 7 - ##% C0% 6 #@1 ( "<"96 ' (8 @(@!( ( <( A (<( )F( !'( :<() ( A " *( ' ">= "(" ' ' (@6 7<6 E<<542#9
@ "( : ''( ( " ( !F!A*(((""(( *''"( <(6 E:!( '(A >' ( '' >(<
123#31$443 .#$1#5. "(7 -##0#0 6$##52#C 6C196( !F! A* ( )( F( " ( ''!" !(< A* ! <( () !(() ( ('(( 7 #%?$'6$5$P<6 E<<54229
, * ,1?231$443 $# '(!@ $443 I " ( ( " !( A* "(" ' @ 8: ( ( '''" ! A '( !'(( *( '"("''A"*("(" !8'''"7 #%%31%0H$?'6#5? 6 296 : "(" > A " !(() (" < (')F(! <"'@ "(A ")8!<(!( "6 ((D: '!(A "( )(!(((()D! (= @ '(( : "6 '( : *''( ('" (((!'=)''"( (('8 D! ' ''< <(6 D(( !<( ( F( !A*( '(( "' (!(" ( *D!''') *''"(A(=( '( ""!((A "'( !@!'(( (( <(( (7 - '@" #% "!@$44$$$$14$ 626$( "<"96I
%6 *'8 @(((( *@ A*) >:!( #5>#%%5 ' ((" > "( ( D6 "A( *:( )('" *!(< ")6)( !' (( ( ( A* '"(( #5 > #%%5 ( " *( * ( (8 *) (" ( A "(( !!( "''( C'(!@$4436
>:!( #5 > #%%5 !! ( !(8 * ,. (("A'(" () ("(( !"( !; ( A !'( ( E ' *D * ( '<"((!:"( *(: *@)( '<6>)$44$(((")* (((A :" *) (" (*)('@ ! <((@6
*"(( (" *(!"(("!F!(>:!( #5>#%%5( "''( C'(!@$4436* (('6
* 8)EA*E:!(*(' (A '(" : (6 <<( ( = "( !!'( !"( @K(!(I J)I* )( '" ")6 ! "A*(: (<<("6( ''( ##(@$445A('(" ()
123#31$443 .#21#5. #44B) !( 04B! ()("":8() '@(" *( '(6
)( '' * '( A *''"( "! * ((( *.) (" ( <( ( !'"( " !" D!( 8(!( A ! *" ( = !F! !(()'(" ()( :!E" ()7 - '@" $C(@$442251$442 6C62P ,15C31$44C %>( $44C96 *( '( ( F( ( !'( A <!( * (: *@)( ((( !'"!( " !" ""!((=*''"( '("" () * " ( ''( *) L!( !()" * !" = A ''(('!E< '(>:!(*"(( (" *"( * A A ! ( ' A ()(" . ( '@ ()"E"(A()D'(@!(D:
7 - '@" $$'(!@$443202145 6C6$P ,10##1$44396
*'8((A*/( (( ( ''( ( !" '"( ( !" ((( ("'(6<<(!" 8(A(( (> '(" () = #44B6 (( ( :!( (A=A'")(#%%56
(( !()D" '((()("'< ' )(' < !6(=/(E!(*/ )( ' (( (!' ( !(6 A ":!( A* * >! ((" ) '(" () " A ( !" !( (((" *D'( A (( A( '(" () *(6
@ (! A <( A * *( @" < ( ' (=")=*( >' <" "("'E(7 #%?0'62396<<('(" ()A( ''( *( A (E"A6 ' ''( ( (( ( ( ) ''( !" D ' "( ( <( ') D !( '(( ()(" *( ' <<( ' A ( <<()!( ()" ( ' '(" () ( '(" () <<( = !(( ( = ( (86 * '('(! <( '(" :A!( <(6( (!F! *(A ''( (: !#%%26
, * ( ( '( ''"( ( ''( :( D'( !" ( *( <; !'8( A(
123#31$443 .#C1#5. ()("<<("'(6*"(( @(( A* */' !(< ")A(!( *(6#0 ' <()D *(6526# 6
#46 ( ! ( " (: "6 (A@((: (= "'<D"*'8=#*5446.6
+ 1( 0 ( +( + +
!
234-- 5 6 78 %$& 9
4-
#6 ")@6
! 4
$6 * !(( " #?)!@$445(C'(!@$4436
26 *"!!(<D"=$44<6(!=E: * 6
C6 ! * = ) ( !(" #*544 <6 = (( "'6
56 <! '( AN ')( <! ( '"( F( " 24 > 8 (<( '8 @ <" " 7,ERME<A3344C 9') !(8 ( '@<!"!(D(6?$ <" " @<" " #0 > $445 7 -9P !"! ( A !(< ( !/ ')('(:( ( ! (P ( F( " @ <" " ' ) '( ' ) "(A D ( *(6 C$ -6 '"( F( ( '8 ' ()A"!!!/ ') )(F(>(=*)6 :<<8 '" (
123#31$443 .#51#5. ST U @,
'<! '"(F(((<"D'(AN=N<<<" " ':<<
123#31$443