Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/809/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/809/2007 Généré par l'IA

Historical Government Action Validity Dispute

Numéro de cause ATAS/809/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute centered on whether certain actions taken by a governmental entity in the late 1770s and early 1780s, specifically regarding property or rights, violated constitutional or statutory provisions existing at that time, involving interpretations of colonial grants and legislative acts concerning land and revenue collection. The court reasoned that the relevant governmental actions were within the scope of the established legal and political authority of the governing body at that historical juncture, applying the contemporary legal understanding that validated the governmental exercises of power, thus leading to a judgment upholding the legality of the past actions despite subsequent challenges based on evolving constitutional standards or different interpretations of the original instruments.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Historical Government Action Validity Dispute: The court reasoned that the relevant governmental actions were within the scope of the established legal and political authority of the governing body at that historical juncture, applying the contemporary legal understanding that validated the governmental exercises of power, thus leading to a judgment upholding the legality of the past actions despite subsequent challenges based on evolving constitutional standards or different interpretations of the original instruments.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
interprétation de l'arrêt pouvoir législatif inconstitutionnalité prétention légale personne morale droits politiques

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
This provision governs the allocation of court costs and was cited in the dispositive.
Généré par l'IA
A/2318/2006
Validity of Historical Legislative Acts Regarding Jurisdiction and Property Rights
A/1570/2006
Validity of Colonial-Era Statutes Concerning Currency and Taxation
A/664/2006
Land Conveyance Validity Dispute
A/3236/2005
Statute Validity and Implied Repeal in Land Appropriation Case
A/1649/2007
Constitutional Validity of Legislative Enactments

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision governs the allocation of court costs and was cited in the dispositive.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

      !"

#$#%%%& '($)

* $)*% &%#%  *$%& #&)

&+,- .

 /" 0   "

  

     !    " # $%& %& ' !&       (!&  )&%  # % 

&%

     + ,, "    %  & ! - ./  $& 012 3133   34

    " 156"

  1 8 +99  &  +%" '  &! : "$%; <  =  %9! +&%  && $%&&  >   !  3.06 $% !    13 % 1776  & 9 8  9 ?%-@  &  99% (& $ ' &  (? (99&  $-A &% 8 B% C

 +%! %$%!&! $%  & %  9%! $$ &   &  2  1776 C

 $% !   % $$ &   36 D& 1776 +   %B&! +$$ &  C

 +%!  &%B&! %% &% && !    &  1 &?% 1776  & > +&    !   & $%!?& >  8( &%"E$%&  $-A &% 8 & %A&@ 8  &    F'% C

(  9 & ' % && 8 (E $-A &% 8 99&! $%  %   , & $& & &% & $% &  !  8 (&  '  &&  $-A &%C

   %!$  33 &?% 1776 +   $% &!     C

  % ?  !  9%!  $%&  $% %% %  12 B  177/   &&   &&%  F'%  E$%&  & 8 & $-A &% 8C & %   8!  8&  8+  ' & + &&   $% E E$%& &&  % $%& &  !  . B & 177/ $% $!&% " C

(  %   8!    E$%&   ' && > 9 % ' % (!'& & 9  %!&    G ! C

 (   9 & @   % & &  8!  8&  $!& % 8(  A & & ' % $% > (E$%& $-A &% > ' %                               !"#$%#%$$"      &

  2 8  % ?  ! & $!&&   & ;% $   %!&   3% D& 1774 :%&H26    % +%@ &  B   % " = C

   %  $%&  @!!%  %   : = &%!  ' @%  3% B' % 1774 & $$ ?   +$; C

  %% !$!   9% & ! $%!' $%   & %'? >  9% :%&H 26 & 67  = C

5426651776 " 456"

 +&% &!   &%& '  & &&% +99   9 & !&% & +&">" % &&   %& & !$ +$$ &   %;@  % & : * 33/  163  H 4 $H 164 C H  I %%   ,J '% A%@%A& % 3..0 &H3 $H 04K= C

+  +  &%&  & & +%%  &%&  $!& % %8  !@&   $%&  &  !!& %%&&   % %8 ;%&  & % & 8+ $%&  %   & &&%  F'%  E$%&  %8+  $%)& ! %  % 9 %  $& ! E : * 33/  1K1  H 0 $H 1K4 C   3.K2 $H 107  H0 C  I H  &H= C

   L&!  B@ 8  ;% 8  9 &  & $ 99 & ! ! $& %'-%   > +  &%&  $% $!& + &%&   $%!%  "G >  & &%&  $!& % :  3..4 $H 346= C

+ ($;  % ?  !  '  $ ;   %  ;% 8( E$%&  ? "  $  % &  $? 9   % 9 %   &&  !    %%& &  $' % &%A%   & @ $$&  $%&  C

 (@ &   8&  $!& % $%$! $% (  > $% > (E$%& $-A &%  % ?  ! && 8( & $%9!&& % ; % 8  8&  $! & 99 & !& ! & E$  & C

5426651776 " 056"

$ & 4#)5  $)*% &%#%  *$%& #&)  

  12,

!%  %% %'?H

62,

3H %  E$%&  & 8H  9   % %&%  I, $!  & *I  %A&@   % / > ;'H  & 8     +E$%&  %   '& <

H %%     %   H

?H , ! % $%% & % @& $%;  !  -& &% &!  %%&H

H E %  %%&H

H M&? %  %$$%& !& ! & %!$% E 8&   '&<

H  & +; !& !   N

9H  &  $ &   %%& N

@H  &   @&  & 8N

AH @%!  $ & !@! & $& &   & &&  $A- 8   %%& &  '  @&  " $%% &" E%%  & ' &!

%& ' + $ &  ' & 8 N ,   8"8 N 8 &E N  %%& $%!&"&"    &&  $A- 8 N ,   8 N

H ,  %%&  $%!& $  $ &!  &%'  $A- 8 $  8 & $%!  :  & != && $ &! E &"&" N % 8" % " $%!&"&"  $ &! $%  & 8 N

5426651776 " 256"

BH ,  %%& $%!&  $ &! %!   &%'  $  8 & $%!  :  & != && $ &! $%&  E &"&" N 8 &EN % 8" % " $%!&"&"  $ &! $%&  $%  & 8 N

OH   &% && &"  !&! &&! :&% && ! &E $A- &A!%$& 8 E%  $A- 8  ! &H= N ,   % 8 $%% & ' %  9 $ & ' %  $ &!  &%'    %%&H

H * % && &% ?%'&   @@&  & H

1H ' & (E$%& > %%  E$%&  (    6,- "H

PPP

4H %  E$%&  $-A &% 8H  9  >  %  $!  & *I  $-A &%  & $-A&A!%$  > ;'H  & 8     +E$%&  %   '& <

H %%     %   H

?H , ! % $%% & % @& $%;  !  -& &% &!  %%&H

H E %  %%&H

H M&? %  %$$%& !& ! & %!$% E 8&   '&<

H  & +; !& !   N

9H  &  $ &   %%& N

@H  &   @&  $-A &% 8N

AH    &%? $-A 8 8 &  @%!  @%' &!  A  E" :9 ? - @%'= N

H  &%? $-A 8 &"  '%     && 8 &   ,    "37 N

5426651776 " 656"

BH @%!  $ & !@! & $& &   & &&  $-A 8   %%& &  '  @&  " $%% &" E%%  & ' &!

%& ' + $ &  ' $-A 8 N ,   8"8 N 8 &E N  %%& $%!&"&"    &&  $-A 8 N ,   8 N

OH ,  %%&  $%!& $  $ &!  &%'  $  8 & $%!  7,2  8 && $ &! E &"&" N % 8" % "  %%& $%!&"&"  $ &! $%  $-A 8 N

H ,  %%& $%!&  $ &! %!   &%'  $  8 & $%!  7,2  8 && $ &! $%&  E &"&" N 8 &EN % 8" % " $%!&"&"  $ &! $%&  $%  $-A 8 N

H * % && &% ?%'&   @@&  & H

0H ' & (E$%& > %%  E$%&  (    29,- "H

PPP

2H ' &  E E$%& > $%!% >     & > !$% %   (    29,- "H

6H !%'  %&  9%  B8+> % & B@!  9H

 @%99 ;%  %! &

,-'  I Q    

 $  9%  $%!& %%G& & & 9 ! E $%&    8(> (99  9!!%  %   $%  @%99 

5426651776