Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/791/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/791/2005 Généré par l'IA

Premises Liability Negligence Appeal (Falling Object)

Numéro de cause ATAS/791/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Frais judiciaires à la charge de l'autorité
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The litigant sought relief after being injured by a falling object while on the premises of the respondent, asserting that the fall resulted from the respondent's negligence in maintaining the property. The court, after reviewing the evidence regarding the condition of the structure from which the object fell and the respondent's knowledge or constructive notice of the defect, concluded that the evidence failed to establish a breach of duty on the part of the respondent, thus affirming the judgment in favor of the respondent.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Premises Liability Negligence Appeal (Falling Object): The court, after reviewing the evidence regarding the condition of the structure from which the object fell and the respondent's knowledge or constructive notice of the defect, concluded that the evidence failed to establish a breach of duty on the part of the respondent, thus affirming the judgment in favor of the respondent.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
manquement au devoir lésion corporelle par chute responsabilité pour cas fortuit avis des défauts qualité pour recourir action en revendication

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive for the allocation of court costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/2239/2006
Premises Liability Slip and Fall Notice Dispute
A/2243/2007
Appellant v. Property Owner (Premises Liability/Open and Obvious Hazard)
A/1168/2007
Premises Liability for Defective Step
A/904/2005
Property Owner Negligence in Slip and Fall Case
A/3616/2006
Slip and Fall Notice Requirement Affirmation

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for the allocation of court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

               $%%&'$'(() *$&+%$'(()

*

" * " ,*#  ", #, 

,- ! .

 %. / ! '(() 



 !"#$#" % &&   $   ' &       & &   & 









$

''     & & &  &!$( $2# )*+,!"$-./+!0100   -





         ! "#  

   %13-%    0 *

05  !#04$607.8! 2#!(#"#(2(( "$$ 2"#2$ "9 ( :;; $ ( " <=# >% "9:  ?($(08;#@144,5

15 (#(11@144,!:  $A#B:$##$B#"( "$$ 2"#2$ ;#(# ( .+. ;5 " 2 (9  0 ;#@ 144,!  C: 6( (:%2( 2 ( /78 ;5  "$$ 2"#2$$$#$#@);#!2$;C: "@$ *$ $A# D " C $ )  22$ (  $$  "$ ( "#@A ";   $ " (: $ $ C :$ #B$6$C"#@A5

.5 "#$# " : ! :$##  ;2# ""$  . 2 144,5  (2$ @ E  22$ (  $$ $"#!  @26 1441!  22 ( 001F/1. ;5 ,4 (  '($ $25  D"C C $$ 22  #$# $#  "2$ ( :2"G$   "$  C " #= ( ($$5  $2@("$#$$$("6!(6$(:#@$"#(( "$C$6$B"$("#@A$ 5(2($C"$$$$(#$$2"$ (:$)A"$)#$C(6(5"($("9H$;$@ $$$$ ( "2$ "  2$$ ( 77F--, ;5 7+!  ( A$ @ B 26(##(:2"G$!(($$"9((D6C!(#@$( $!@$)$#=C:2)B@5

,5  (# ( 1. 2 144+! :    H$# :""$!  2$; C :$##:@$"#"$B(;("#@A( ("$ #= $! ( $ C:  "@$ *$ 2  6##; ( "$$2"#2$$5

+5 :$2#((2($!:$##$H$#($(07 @144+5(922=C;$(""C2*2$$2$ C:B"C$("(#"$("#@A"((#" (@ $ (  " $ 2"$ ( ($$ )#5  "" C:  @$ ""# ( $ 2"$ (   ( "$$ $ (: $ )A"$)#$C "($ B  $ C: $ " "@   C: $ ;$""$($;B(6(5$B:$( (#$B@5

-5   #" ( 1. 2 144+! :    "$# (  !  #;#$B(#""$5

/5 #$#$2$$=(#BH=5



300/13144+  %.3-%   

 # *

05 =@:=$H(>?#$#2(;#$$$#!(9 0I$144.! 6$(!2"#(+H=! ($"#($$@%"#($!+""#$$0-H=>$50$5 $+- ?5

&$B:$(:#$(0-H=!" 6;#(# 1/H@144,> '0.404-?!( =@("$#!0.;#@!  ("$$$=$"2$$$ 6$(  ( #=   B $ H= $$! ! ( :$$$ ( :#$(@DH=5

15 ;2#2$ B :$5 +- 5 1 $5  !  6 $ (  J$!$C!($$$"#@B:$5,.( $"$$$2"#2$B:%@$ @@$$B:%@($#(1+$607-8> ?5

&2"#$"H=((:"9$#$65

.5 D$2(:$50 !"<=#!@@!")$ @($($B@222$(:(C$=$ "  @2$ ( "$$ $ 2"#2$ B :% @!@@$$@($#5

@222$(#;B:$5. !2"#$#":$5.(9=2$ (:""$> ?5

,5 :6H$($=$B(#$2:$B6($C:$2#;# $ :$ ( "$$ 2"#2$ $ "  2$; C:  $#"$("#@A";B(:$;C"#@A5

D$2(:$515, ;;$!"C$)!22$ ($$!"$("#@A";$"(:$ $C:$#B$6$C("#@A"@$6##; ("$$(#""$($5

+5 :"9!$(2$@E"$("#@A(:2$$ ( 001F1/.;5,4@261441!($$$"#$:@$# "26(@($$!C")$(=(@$$ :)$ (: 2) B @5  9= C:   ("$#  2"$2$ "6!@$B#@$("$$("$("#@A    $5  (2(  #C B 6##; ( "$$



300/13144+  %,3-%   2"#2$$$$(2$$"($B $)A"$)#$CC:$"E""C$$;D6 (5

-5  :$ " $$# C  $ : " $#  "$ B  6$ ( "#@A5

 22 $ (  &% !  2"#$$  2$9 ( $="$$"$$2"#2$;#(#$$!@$ : ( H=   (: 6##; C @$ E!   $ " (  $!  "$ 5 :    @$ #  ($ D "$$ $ 2"#2$2$;C6$("#@A"#@":$515,  :@$"#$###5H=$"($(##C:$$"$B @$(6@$D!:@$#B6$("#@A (:$515, >;5H=2$ 55(0.;#@1441?5

' $ "($ ( $$  :"9 C :$## : " #  $$$# (  "$ B  @$ (  6 @$DK  #$  ;;$ ( "9 "($ C:  26# (@ ($$ $$# "9 ( :& $   "$L!:$C$$#(:##(:2"G$!((#@$($! )$#  2) B @ $ )$#  = (  @$! "  $$ ( 77F--,;57+5

/5 $$:$("$$2"#2$$(9;#@ 144, $ "" ( $ 2"$! (  ! $ ( 2$$ (  $ ( "#@A)A"$)#$CC:$"E!$(6(5

&:  !:""$(:$515, D$($B("$$ 2"#2$$5

 ("$  "#!  (  !  (  9=2$! C  ; (:( ( "$$ $ 2"#2$  :$5 1 5 ,   (@ *$ 2$# (  $2"!  C: ;($ "#( B    $$ 2"$(2$$($C:$"E(6(5

#$($@D"#"$"6#(#2(( C $$ ("$  #$# "#@ M; ( "#@  6 M >#2 ( ( 3"55-+8,?5(#=$(:#@$6! C "$ @ C  C  )  "$! ("( %   "#" ( :@ " (2( 22#($2$  "$$ $2"#2$5""J$C:$$(#=$:" #$#("@#(($D"$$$2"#2$C   :$$=$ "  @ 222 $ (:(   22$ N  "$ $! C C:  $! #$# #"# : @$ @ B  @$(6@$D5



300/13144+  %+3-%    6 ( # (9 C: $"#$$ $$@ ( :$5 1 5 .    H$; $ C :  $ #$(  $ ( 6$ ( "#@A B (:$C@$(6@$D5 !($$($ "@$*$"2"$!2*2"$@$6$B(5 ("$#=C$";;$;$CH=$$ (:""C52*2!:$#;#$;D6( >;5 &(0."$26144+5 &3/++3144+?5

85 @$#C(:D2B"$(C(:#"$"#$( B ( "$$ $ 2"#2$ : @$ $#  "$ B  @$(6@$D5

&  "9 ( (!   ( :$## $ (  #"  2"$(:$2(@("$@2$0F,-+;5$0F+08 ;5! DC :H$$  "$$ 2"#2$ ;#(# ( .+. ;5 " 2! "  6( (: 2( "  #"D ( /78 ;5 " 2 >;;$?! $  $$ ( ,F0., ;5  )= :#9@$ B 0F177 ; >A! )= 2"?!"/78;5("2(:%2(""!$1F47/;5 $B("$2$$(1F4.8;5"2>1,F,,,;5"#?" "5

!@22$(:(=$$(.,:+-4;5"# 1F884;5"2>.+F10-;5"1:7.,;5/4"2(90H@144+? ::=$(:"!($:(H$$$$:<=($$>$5.5 0 $5 6? ( 9=2$ (:""$ (     "$$ $ 2"#2$% ?5#$(;;#(8,1;5"2>1F884 O 1F4.8?! $ 04F04, ;5 " #! C "#$  ( C $ "2  $$B#"(:@$2"9$(6@$D (($$5

 @26 1441 B ;#@ 144,! :$  2$$ ( 01F-.4 ;5 > 8,1 ;5 D  0+ 2?C$$(I"#@"$"@$( 6@$D5

'$($$C:22$((2(!;#@144,!$ :$ "  #"#  "$ : :@$ $# B  @$ (  6 @$D  C:B D (  #"5  ($ D "$$ 2"#2$$($*$!#C!#5

 2C#B@$(6@$D($*$!#)#$! @$""$$(:$5







300/13144+  %-3-%   

 , #* 0  * " ,*#  ", #, 



123   4  /   56 %7' # 8

  3 

05 #@65

 3

15 H$$5

.5 $C"#($=$$5



  =;;  #($       P(             ";2("#$*$$$;#D"$"=;;





300/13144+