ATAS/761/2005 · Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

ATAS/761/2005 · Breach of Implied Duty of Good Faith in Business Transaction (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerns a dispute over whether a party's conduct in a business transaction constituted a breach of an implied duty of good faith and fair dealing, specifically involving the alleged failure to disclose material information or act in a manner consistent with the reasonable expectations of the relationship, which allegedly caused financial detriment to the other party. The court reasoned that while a general duty of good faith exists, it does not generally create obligations beyond those explicitly or implicitly agreed upon in the contract; therefore, without an express term or clear indication that disclosure or particular conduct was required, the actions taken did not rise to the level of a breach sufficient to impose liability.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Breach of Implied Duty of Good Faith in Business Transaction: The court reasoned that while a general duty of good faith exists, it does not generally create obligations beyond those explicitly or implicitly agreed upon in the contract; therefore, without an express term or clear indication that disclosure or particular conduct was required, the actions taken did not rise to the level of a breach sufficient to impose liability.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA

violation de la bonne foi obligation de conclure relation d'affaires action en responsabilité transaction financière garantie d'une activité irréprochable

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Généré par l'IA

A/2379/2004

Breach of Contract and Implied Covenant of Good Faith and Fair Dealing Claims Dismissed as Derivative

A/322/2005

Implied Covenant of Good Faith vs. Express Contract Terms on Termination

A/1415/2003

Contractual Interpretation and Breach of Business Agreement Dispute

A/1701/2002

Contractual Dispute and Breach of Agreement Enforcement

A/1777/2006

Contract Valuation Dispute and Tort Claims Dismissal

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Texte complet

"#$%#"&''( "$)#"&''*

++

, +!, ,+ !

-. ( $ /. &''*

0000000000 !" #$$ ( % &&'$ &()$$

(

11! 2,+ ! !! $ $) &*(+,- ( ./01/11 12

!

5/365

1!

17 !&) 8888888888 10 )$ 1+0. 9$ &$ 1+62 : ;<$ : $9$ $ & =9 >$5= ;? '$ &%@ & ( #*@$=7A(BB &()C@$&%#$&$ &%$(&*$ &($ #($' %$ $ $$ ( & 9$ &$ + 9$ /44/7 &( $9$ D04E)/4427

/7 %$ &( &)& & $( = & %BB$ ( & %5$9$&$ >$5= % ? 1F )C /44/ ($$ ($ $((B$(() &(9(B$(7

27 ( ( & D % & & /. )C /44/ 8888888888 $&$' ' $ (B$ &% #$ &$ 05A1 &%$(&*$ #($'&($ 7%$$ & 9$ $ &144E&$ + 9$ /44/7 $ & $)$ $( B( $( & C &($ &9$ 9$ )(9) $ $B 9$ ($ $( 9$ ( & (& #@7 () & $)$ $( $ & 9$ $(C) :$@$C &144E&$9$/44/7

.7 1FG$ /442 8888888888) $(' $ 9$ $ ( $9$ D 04 E7 $ D 144 E % $ ($C $( & &$@( $7 $9$ & $ & 9$ $ &144E7

07 6( (C/442$9$$(&& $((B$(&% C$ ( : ) &' % $ H D B$ B() $( B$ & (9($ : $9$ '$ $ )$: (9 D $)$ $(7 % ( $(&(I@ &($9&% &'%$@$ &# D & &$BB$ ( (9 (9 $9$ 7 B C&( %$&&())B() $($ $&%@@) D144E (9()($ D04E79 $( #($'&%$9$&$ ((7

F7 &$$(&+( (C/44.% BD%$ %( ($&) (B$( )( $B '% ($ & $9$ & %$& $ @= $ B() $( C7 &$$( % ( %$ 7

,7 &$$( & 1F ) /44. % (& D %$ ' & &$1 9$/44. (&@&%$9$&$ &.,E7 ( $B( $(& & 1 9$ /442 21 ) /44. B$ %(CG &% &$$( 7 % ($&'%$ $ $ & 9$$&& 144 E & $9$ @= ($ $ @$ & 2,J.46 B7 ()

31,+13/44. 52365 &% & $( & /4 E7 () @$ $ 9 %$9$&$ & ,1J4,+B7&@&%$9$&$ $ &.,.4E7

67 !#$$ %$ B()(($ $(& & /6 9$ /44. B$ 9($ '%$ $ ($C & 9$ D 144 E ''($ &% $9$ $$' 8888888888% $ & ( $B$ )&$ & , 9$ /44.7 ( @) 9 $9$&$ % @ '% )() & %( ($ & /442 $ %9$ D ,2J6F1 B7 107 ( ( $ '% :($ $) $ & 9$$& '9'%$( $ ('9& )$ (&@&%$9$&$ %=9D04E7

+7 0G$ /44.% G %(($ $(&%$ 7

147 %$ )&$$&(($%$ $ G (& &/,(K /44.7 =@ '% &(* & BB( $@$B$ $B ( (9 )($ )($ (& D 144 E '% BB @ : ; ( &' $)($( =7 ( $$9$&$ % ( ( &() & $ /442 &$ %9$ D,2J6F1B7107 B=D%9$&)&$5($&;( ' (9$ ) #$ & #@ &%@ & ( 5 #*@$= )H) D ) $ ) @9) &@ 7 ( (9($: $9$ $9D144E7 B$($&='%$ %*$(&)@$&%$9$&'%$BB $9) 9#*( # $'7

117 (&/2 )C/44.% =9')H) () &% 9 $9$&$ & ,2J6F1 B7 &@ &%$9$&$ $ & .+ E $BB$ ( (9$ &($ D &)$5 &%$9$&$ 7 $)( $'%( & 9$& D( & %$ $H (( ( )(* $ (9$ & $ () & %)C & & 9$ (BB )# & 9$ '$$C7 % ( G & (7

1/7 9$ D & )$ ( ( ($ & 9 & % ( '$ D 9$D144E7 ($&='%$ $$ &%:$@ &%'%*D$ )& C# #(&%$ $ $( (' 9$& /17

127 #& $$ &($(7

31,+13/44. 5.365

+!

17 ($@9($%(@$ $(G&$$$>? )(&$B$ $ $ &= 1(K /442 $C (&($()(&0G@ &( $& 9$5$& 0 1FG@> 71 7 0F ?7

A$ D% $(&% $(&1FG@ $CB& /,G9$/44.> L12414F?& ($@9($&( 12B9$ &$($ $( $ ($@ ) $C (& ($ & $@ D ($ G@ $ $ & % & % $(&(9:G@7

/7 (B()) D J 7 0F 7 1 7 #7 / $C ( & ($(" $ $'&( $(9D% $ 0F & ($ B& $ @ & &($ & ($ & F ( (C/444> ?'$( $9D($%5$9$&$ &1+G$ 1+0+5 7

A() (G@&&%= $$ C$7

27 9$@ 1 G9$ /442 " )(&$B$ $( & ()C &$($ $( @ & &()$ & ($7 A ) $($ &9($'&($ J$'&($ H #D)$= &$$('=@$C( 9$@)() (M B$ G$&$') & )$ ( (&$ > L 1/, .F, ($&7 1 1/F 12F ($&7 .C B?7 %( ( ( D %( ($ &% &)$5 &%$9$&$ &= 1 9$ /442N (9 &$($ $(@( ('& )$ > L124.22($&7 1?7 D(&D&B &=@ $ ($( $(9&($ J$'9&=G(&( 9$@> L11,+2($&7 FC11/2F4($&7.- ! 1++6O2,721F($&72C?7

G &B() &$@:( D @&9C> 7 0F F4 ?7

.7 A( % 7 . 7 1 %$9$&$ > 7 6 ? &% $B$)$ (@$ &% )&$ ( &% $& 7 & J 7 6 7 1 $9$&$ J$$ & @$ ( ( $ '$ ) ) ( & (@ &7 9 &= '% @9$ (D(9$&($ : $( ($& $(7

31,+13/44. 50365 % $ D % &( D & )$ $ ($& $( ' & ) (M " $$ & 9$ * &BB $ &@$&%>!*5&@ PQC&$ 9$&9$#@R$#1++,76?7

*$&$'(G$&( $(&%$9$&$ & &($ &($ ( $((()$' ()&$-( (' (()$' (CG $9 & %$$ B( $( '%$ $)( &%9 > L 114 /,0 ($&7 . 140 /4, ($&7 /?7 ('% $(&%$ $9$ &%&((()$'B( &B $*$& B(& &( &%(& )&$ & ) (M ) &%9 $ & 9$ & %$ & & $9$ $(C) :$@$C> L110122($&7/140106($&71?7

A(% 7/671 > 9$@G'%21&)C/442?% &($ D $=%$ $9$&DFF/32E)($D&)$5 %$ $9$& D 04 E )($ ( D ' & %$ $9$& D .4 E )($-&$C% &%=% 7/671C$ & &)$5 %$ $9$&D.4E)($7

07 (9 :&%$9$&$ 9'%$ (C $%$% $ $9$& ()9$'%$($ (C $:S % $9$ '$ $(C) H :$@ & $ = $ ) ) & & $()#'$$C& 9$> 71F ?7

((9($&@&%$9$&$ %&)$$ $(>(G@%$* (? C($ & &() ' )&$ 9 ) $ &% $$ &($9 $B($7 I#&)&$($ D( G@) % & D$&$'&') (' $9$ % $C& 9$7 ( &()&$( $ ) $ ( & )$ ' 9: ( ( $(C) :$@ & %> L1/0/F1($&7.11012.($&7/11.21.($&72140 106($&71?7

%= $ & ( C$ /. )C /44/ 8888888888 ' ( #$ &$ 05A1 & ()C($ @$ &($ #($' $(&*$ #($' &($ &$ )$ /44/7 $ ( $$ ( & 9$ &$ + 9$ /44/7 %:( )&$ 8888888888$&$''& $9$ 9$ )(9) $ $B ( &#@$ & 9$ $ &144E7A$ D)$( $(&( & ( $ ( $9$ &%@ &( #*@$=:;D04E&=2)/4427 1FG$ /442 8888888888) $('% & $($ ' ( $ ( $9$ D 04 E 9 $( &

31,+13/44. 5F365 9$ $C & ( & #@7 $ D 144 E % ($C $(&&$@( $7

$9$$(&& $((B$(&% 9&(( &6( (C/442'( $ H D9$@B() $(B$ &(9($:(B$('$$ )$: () &$)$ $(7 BB 9$'%(&$&/4 B($&( )$ $ H )@ '' B( $( & ( #&$ %(& I#&)$$ $9'7 $(&(I@ & ( $9 &% & $@$ & & & @( $' $ G)$ C&($ ()$5 ) 7 B C&(%$&&()) B() $( $ $ &% @@) D 144 E (9 ( )($ 7%$ $)$$(&D9 $( #($'&%$9$&$ 7

F7 ( ( (9($: $9$ $9D144E&'' $9$ ' ($ 7 B(&( &1.)$/44/ C$ 5'TO ! D% $(&$9$$(&(#)$ & ; : ) &' ( & ( 5$&$' B()) ( $& 9$D(( )H)D ) $7

$C&( )$$'( C$= %$$ & 9$ ($ 88888888887 ( B($ $ $( $ D $ & 9$ & ( ) /442 & )H) $9$ )(* & $( & I#7 TO ! (($ & 9$$&& $9$ & D% & 7$ ('9($9(C D @&7

*$&9'&%9$)H)& 8888888888 $9$ & '$ $() &$)$ $( ($CD144E7 ) & &($) &% & $ $(7

,7 D:)$&@&%$9$&$ ' ( (& D ()$( & @$ ' )() & )$ $ & %(9 &&($ D ($ %/442> L1/+1//-1/61,.?7

( 99 $9$&$ $*$& $)( &,2J6F1B7 /442 >$&)$ & 9$ $ UV5& ()$? ( $B$ & $/442(&$ ( 7

A%@$ &9&%$9$&%$ $)% B(& C:&% 'H $ &$> AA?/444 C 1 $D/442& $9$ $) $ $9 >$9 .? '% /442 ( $ (C $ $ & .FJ,F4 B7 ( .1+ # & 9$

31,+13/44. 5,365 )$7% BB (& $(@(C&/4E&( ' 9&%$9$&%=9D2,J.46B7

( ( @ '%$(9$ & $@$'% $BB $9) D04E&( '(&@&%$9$&$ %=9D04E7

$C&'9&%$9$&& )$C& $ ' % ($ (C $ :S % $9$ $(C) :$@$C'$ %()($D$ )& $9$ & 7 $)( ' % : BB $9) % $9$ ' $(7 = ( )H)$( 9$D04E&($ $9$ 9'% (C $ 9$ & B ( @$ &%$9$& % $$ $) $ & 9$$&7

9 & '$ =& % D G $ ' %$ $) % B(& C AA '%$ @$ /442 & .FJ,F4B7 & $9$ & $9.> $9$ $) $ $9?7 $' :&& $(@(C &/4E% % )( < @:&( '@$&%$9$& &2,J.46B7H BD$ $'7

&@&%$9$&$ % C$ &=(())$ N>,26F1W2,J.46?:1443,26F1 X.+20E7

L( & ( ' &@ &%$9$&$ $BB$ ( (9$ &($ D &)$5 &%$9$&$ 7

!B(&(&($ H G 7

31,+13/44. 56365

+ !1 +!, ,+ !

34565 7 /55 5 89 #)& :

65

17 (9C7

65

/7 G 7

27 $ '(& @ $ 7

.7 B() $ & '% 9 B() ( ( H & &$ & 24 G( &= ( $B$ $( $ ())& & $C B& & A#U$P#(B'$ F F44. ($ :)$7 &$ H ((@7 ))($ &($ N ? $&$' : ) '&$$(( &$(C $$ &&$$( '- C? :( ( ' )( $B $ $) (9($ &)& &$$(- ? ( $@ ( & ( 7 A$ ))($ ( $ ($ ) ) ( ? C? ? $5& $CB&&( ) $=('%$ &9&$9C7))($&() $(()(* & 9 '$ ( G($ $$ ' &$$( ' %9( & ' :&$( > 712/14F 146?7 @BB$ $& T$& ! $

($(B()& H ( $B$: $$$'%D%BB$B& &($@BB

31,+13/44.

Breach of Implied Duty of Good Faith in Business Transaction

Synthèse Legislator

Regeste Legislator

Mots-clés

Dispositions légales citées

Décisions connexes

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Texte complet