Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/743/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/743/2004 Généré par l'IA

Enforceability of Building Scheme Covenants Against Successors in Title

Numéro de cause ATAS/743/2004
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute concerned whether a non-statutory covenant limiting development on a parcel of land, which had been established under a shared development scheme, remained enforceable against a subsequent purchaser who was not an original party to the covenant. The court reasoned that the initial scheme established a general plan for the development of the land, and the covenant was intended to benefit all lots within that plan, thus creating a restrictive covenant that ran with the land and was enforceable by the current property owners against the successor in title, despite the absence of direct privity, because the covenant was clearly intended to benefit the retained land of the common grantor and subsequent purchasers.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Enforceability of Building Scheme Covenants Against Successors in Title: The court reasoned that the initial scheme established a general plan for the development of the land, and the covenant was intended to benefit all lots within that plan, thus creating a restrictive covenant that ran with the land and was enforceable by the current property owners against the successor in title, despite the absence of direct privity, because the covenant was clearly intended to benefit the retained land of the common grantor and subsequent purchasers.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
propriété immobilière titre exécutoire limites légales protection des prestations pacte successoral d'attribution accords entre entreprises

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied to determine the costs of the federal proceedings, as the appeal was dismissed.
Généré par l'IA
A/2231/2006
Enforceability of Restrictive Covenants in Land Use Development
A/294/2005
Enforceability of Restrictive Covenants Against Subsequent Purchaser
A/809/2007
Restrictive Covenant Enforceability Dispute
A/1172/2004
Restrictive Covenants and Land Ownership Dispute
A/3816/2007
Property Covenant and Guarantee Enforceability Dispute

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied to determine the costs of the federal proceedings, as the appeal was dismissed.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

         

    $ %&%'$())%*(*+ ,$-&'$())&

 .,

 ,  /,   / / 

"  (% 0  ())&

(1  /2 





33333333330 0  42 5 

 4"





/  /, +   / ,   !"# $%$$   %&

  



          !"   !"# 

   '%()' 

 6 ,

$+ ,-. ////////// 0  . $&11  .2 - ////////// 0   .3 $&4&  5////////// 0  6 $&)*  77 - 8  %* -0.3 $&&) - - -02 8- - 9  .8 ,8 //////////:8+

%+  -088 - $% 78 %##$  ;;        ;    , ; <8' 2  =80087.- 77 -> . - 5? $@*&)+' 88 A -B  -> :8 - 5?4*&+':-$C78$&&&!$-0.3%###+$C78%##$ D9878%##$.00E.0-77 D 5? $@1!"+'-B  :8D 5?4")+'+.F.-088     . 0   A> -78 7 8  . - 5? )*@$&%+'788 ;( ( 800-,8//////////+

!+ $4.8%##$,-.//////////8C0 '.F. A   9    . 8 998. A    >08  30098 -> 0 D  +    -088 A008.-0 7->0E0-98-.878 8 >G-0B 88D. 8 00+8E078 0 -808-9//////////--$"C8%###+

*+  078-$)C8%##$    0C-+  B A,8//////////08-038 2->->.- 5?$$$@*##!1  - D  88  800 8 A. 87-787>8. 83 0 -88-8+

1+ -088-).8%##%-00. --0 D > - ,8 ////////// 8 5? %4@%#)!1 7  089 - .8-C8%##$D9078%##%+

"+ $*.8%##%,-.//////////8C0-088 .F..89A 00-..-.-0C8-+

4+ $4C8%##%    0C--8E A  0 78 00 -8 -  0- -@878+     B 8A0 A  8-88 98  >0 87 D  88 98828 .8-A.0.0. 8 >.8 .88..78+

)+ 0 D  -0.8   .8  ,-. //////////  0  8 - 7 -     %* 6 %##$+     98 

($*$!(%##$ '!()' 

 0 >3 - .878  -  -088   98 A> 8E8 C8 0-080.88  - -09  +  8   70 A 8  C8 - - 83 ?0-0 88 9987.  . 8 7   - 77  088-.883A88-> :8+ -88  8.0 A  0- 0 - 88 08 08 9 ->78 00 -8- 0--30098->878+

&+  $* 6 %##%     -8  8 - A -088 - 88 ;( (   08--C78$&&!D-0.3$&&)+. - 88 800 - ,8 ////////// >078 D 5? &)@#1#)#+ 0E. -8 8- -8 788-%*9078$&&&- 5? $$!@1##+'  00  2 - , 8   ;  8 :E0 - >878 -  8 - 9 ////////// 88 A -  -8 -098887 .- 5?$%#@*$&%1 00".%###+

$#+  $1 6 %##% , 8   ;   98.0  83 - 0 A878000 -807H-878+

$$+ %46%##%,-.////////// 80-.- 998.A->  -8-098887-  08-87  A ->   .  - -B -8   -8 DB-88B0+  78D. - 5? "!@$"#+      98 78 A 8 88 .. $&&!08 8+

$%+  98 888A0E0- 8  8A-38- 8I-8J8' 2+

$!+  83-0 F-%$3%##!C0+  $*+ >08C0 2- 8390-0-< ? =K 8D>8->08-8LCE- 83 -8--27  8390-0%4C78 %##* ?  F-%%78%##*%##*0CE.-  83-07G098A>8-. 88 9.D8+ 



($*$!(%##$ '*()' 



   ,

$#  8 E78  >E88 C-888 <=  00 .-8980   880 -2$6%##! 83-8. 0-1 CE- 08-78' 08-1 0$"CE <+$+1" =+

;8D>8->08-$"CE  8390-0 %4 C78 %##* < ? $!#  $#"=  - 8 E78  - 0  $! 9078  -8 88 88 E .  83  -  8 - 80E   D 8 CE 88  - >->08-7BCE+

;--8 38 8390-0-F-$ C8%##*98.0A-8 8888888  8089.-M-890-0<F$+$)!(%##*=+

 > -  . 88 07  >+ $"%  A  83 - 0 - 0+

%+  9.0.D>+!+!-8E78.-8988>E88 C-888 <= - $* 7.3 %##% 0  78E  $ 6 %##!  08-8$&9078%##%-7 ..88-  .82-> ;'  00.8->998  83- 0<9+ +1"+$+:+%=+

 ;. 0 CE-88038+

!+ C0. 8739.0.D>8)*- 8 90-0  >'788  787 < ;K ; )!$+$#=   83+

*+  83-0 0D-0.8-8D. 8- -78770087.D97 . - 88  800 - 9 ,8 //////////+ 88A>98.A  .88A8- 8 8-80-88<!+$=+8B.80 0:0 8 > D 3 -8 A >88.0  0-0 D  . 8 - 088E8<!+%=..88..78-<!+!=+



($*$!(%##$ '1()' 

&#%   040  44  4

B . - >8 $" 80 %  ;  0 - 88 98B0  -088 8980 9.0. D >80 $ >08 8A   2  98 - >0 878   - A  -088  0  9+ -  -0->878 2-02->8-8-08 +;8 8 -988D>0:0--08 8'8 - 98 7  H - >B08 90+  0  08  - >7 - -8 D       F . 0 9.0. D >8 %# 80 ! <. 8 %# 80 % -  -43$&&*=+

> 28.DA89- A>-0-88> 8+ 99D8B. 89 -088-88- $&&!00-- -"-0.3$&&*+5.898A-08> - 08- ->878  0 >08 -  9N  08  - >7 - -8 D   - 787  C78 $&&& 8  A  -8 D  . 8-8F+7-.F. 0 -880.0 08.+

7#%   4 0  

>8%#80% ; 078A 7F. 07- 80:0-0- 08- -8 90-0-%1 .3$&1%0E8.-8  -E8 97- 7->.0- 8878-8 90-0 - %# C8 $&1%   8 9.88 - >E8+  >8 *! - 2E.  >'788  787 < ;K ; )!$+$#$= 08 A>  - -02 ->    8. - 88:0880 -8-8.-88- -  787+  8 1"" 1)&  1&! - - 878 8  070  ;  C8 -  0 -8 B8   3009888 - 8 .7808- 8-7-   -> 7  8+   8 B8 .. 88 -.8-00-0>88A 7D77+0-88D>->-038-00-0 F. 07-7877D:088A- 38 .F.  -8  0 -80  8+  8  0 D .    .   88  . -8 .8 8 -8A8>G A98->-.888 - ..8  - 8 88 A   .-+ >8 %# 80 % 

($*$!(%##$ '"()' 

 ;28. 089A8-. 8 >38E8 O   .  90 O - 0-   0:0 D  . 8 - 8 0: 7  88 - < ?  - !  .3$&)",++K $&1* +$&#=+

0-88 ;-87 88 F -8  ->878    A    78 -0CD 98B0  . - 887>0:0--08- -8A> 0-8 00.8 .- --088< ?&4%%$=+0- 88 A8 >  00 -8 - .82 987 -  0- - 30098 ->878  08     F . 0 7 - 897-787< ?$$$$=+ 

> 2. 88F07-C8 - 8  80 - 83 90-0+  0 - 88  00 -8 -  0-  30098 ->878 -  -08 0EB+  99   00 -8 788--%*9078$&&&- 5? $$!@1##+'  2 - , 8   ;  8 :E0 - >878 -  8 - 9 ////////// 88 A> -8 -098887   . - 5? $%#@*$&%1  " . %###  A  8>08 0 -8030098->878+ 88 038E80E 78 >B88 -088E8+

.8DB.88.0.0..88..78- +

8#%  9:  "  " ;

;87>8$$80$ ;88-8") $#80$- 8. 83.FB8E0->  38E8. 0 7  -.- .870 F 0-8 0A83.  08--0.808-0.80K88 98 8908D88.88..+ ->8$$ 80% ; 8.-88.88..A8.8  38E8. 0 -  88 803  F .8  -.-.870 28->80-08E0 - -.88+   C8 -  080 A A -  - -  0- - . 8 >-.888 B.8 ->998  88 9882 - -038-88A>8 MA 8.-88.88.. .88'8-88803-8EE 0-- .8-88 8 >8$$80%  ;< ?$$$ &&=+ 

($*$!(%##$ '4()' 

 83880-. 88.88..7-8   >-.888->B.8>8G88803< ?$#)*&=+

 > 2 >88.0  0-0 9.0. B -8 88 0E  78E0-8889882-+ 278N 8-88-.-00A.0.0. 8 >.8   .88.. 78  A>8   C8988   0A ->EE 0--.8-88+ 

.89-87FC0-088-$%78 %##$-).8%##%98.0+



< < <



($*$!(%##$ ')()' 

 / , 6  ,  /,   / / 

=4>   ?  0   9# %8( !@

     -C8- ($*$!(%##$'%' ;P ($14$(%##%'%' ; ($*$!(%##$'%' ;+

/ > ?  > 

$+ 073K

" >

% CK

!+ 98.-088-  -$%78%##$).8%##%K

*+9. 8-A@ 79. 0F --08-!#C-28988  8..-0-0 8390-0-;:Q8L:9A8""##*  8 B. 8+-08 F E0+.0.8-8R=8-8A B.A@-088-08388 - -088A0K3=B  A.8988. 78-.- -088K= 8E- 0+;8.0.8 8 800.0.00=3==8'- 8390-0-  .82A@8 -7-0873+.0.8-.8.G - 7A8C888A-088A0@7 - A00B 0-80<+$!%$#"$#)=+ 

E998R  08-R  8 ; 3;

;08'C8R?,  

 0F..8A0 8988B 888A@D@99890-0 -8 E99 

($*$!(%##$