Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/724/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/724/2005 Généré par l'IA

Lien Priority Dispute Based on Recording Dates

Numéro de cause ATAS/724/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute involved competing claims over the priority of certain liens, where one party asserted a senior lien based on a 1990 agreement, while the other argued for a junior status or reliance on subsequent recorded interests. The court determined the relative priority by focusing on the clear language and recording dates of the governing security instruments, ultimately upholding the validity and priority of the interest established by the earlier filed documentation, which governed the progression of subsequent attachments and priority disputes among the various secured creditors.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Lien Priority Dispute Based on Recording Dates: The court determined the relative priority by focusing on the clear language and recording dates of the governing security instruments, ultimately upholding the validity and priority of the interest established by the earlier filed documentation, which governed the progression of subsequent attachments and priority disputes among the various secured creditors.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
procès-verbal de séquestre priorité découlant du dépôt créance contestée gage immobilier titre exécutoire pour les créances non contestées titre représentatif de marchandises

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The court ordered the appellant to pay the judicial costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/1911/2007
Property Title Priority Dispute Based on Recordation
A/1803/2004
Lien Priority Dispute Based on Statutory Recording Requirements for Assignment of Mortgage Interests
A/2189/2005
Lien Priority Disputes in Property Transactions
A/3963/2005
Statutory Lien Priority Over Previously Recorded Mortgage Despite Unrecorded Agreement
A/2087/2005
Lien Priority and Fraudulent Conveyance Dispute

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court ordered the appellant to pay the judicial costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

               !"#$%!"&&% !$"'!"&&%



( )(* *+*  (* +)

, - .

 # / - "&&% 

 !"#"$%$#"&%""'()  * " + %,$)%())

()" !

(%"

--   .   - -    /    -. $7" -  !#(%0123!4144   44

--     /     -  -      +- 5      -    -   + -           !  #(% 426!4144   3

* 0)

                 

  1  



45 ":;%13<")1990! ")=#")>")%$#=), %%(><)(#")<("");(%"%$19:)4??3 #" !$ !%()" 5

15 @)77"A)#()%)7:;%#"$)%$! ")=#")>")% ("($  #"%; #" ()%)$ %"  $#(B  " <()"  #"$<(C #"(7)( $ "%  ");5  :;%! %"$  7("  2:)1990!$%$%") ")=%("()7), ")"$%")(%%,)()%D%"%%")=$E@$#(B5

F5 ")),$D%"%)%)"+(#%)="#;(<"%#">   --     /     -  -      +-        -    -   + -        G).#">H  I5

A5 %E"!($D%"%)%)"+7(#"$<(C #">   --   .   - -    /    --  G).#">H  I5

05 %%")>")7("$ ")=$!#"("")"14:)%1990!, #"%%)(("%)"+$<)%E"5A1J091540(% )<("! % ,  (%%   #"%%)(  ("%) E  %  ");! ;%$+)%$"D%$;!+$<)%,%E)E"54J?1?5005 #"$)$<()" "'"53J1A9560   --- F4"199A%"511J02A5. ---  --  !1A#%="199A5

65 " ("")"  13 :)% 1990!      ---   )),$ ,  (%)%)(#"$<$#("%)%"#$")(4":<)"F4$="199F %,%(%+$#";(%)%$+<)%($%$"%");5

25 % E  ---  --  !   #"$)$! #" ("")"  44 %  1F (K%1990!,")<)%$%$77))$4"(%(="4??3F9:) 1991%,+(%%"54J042500)<)%$%$%")%14(%(=" 4??3 #"       /                  5

35 -+;)%"!  !#"("")"4?:)%1990!)),$, #"%%)()="#;+$<)%,%E!)%$"D%(#")!E"5F1J0?3540 (%)<("5$%$#"$)$,#"%%)()="#;F9:) 4??3!()%(%");!$%)%"54J22F529!)%$"D%(#")5

    8142081990 F  



?5  (% (% $%$ %") B #"%)5  (% $%$ )7("$ ,! 7 (=:%)(  " #"% +))  F9 (K% 1990!  :;% ")% " " %% =5

* +)



45  () ;<() " +(";)%)( :)))" GI  $%$ ()7)$ %  )%)%$! >  4" (K% 199F!  ")= %(  " () G -I! (#($),:;!(%#"$)%%<).#"$)%!),##$%% )L:;"G"%54%5"%06 I5

 -)%E+%)(+$%)()L:;"#" ")=7$$" G I12:<)"199AG 4F9496I!" ();<()(#%$! 4F7$<")"!)#()%)(%")%()"";%G"%5461I#"%%% -  )$;"  "! E %"() :; %)%)"!  +%%%  +$%)(  (<B:;"5

15 J"%5 10   () 7$$" "  )=" #;   #"$<(C #"(7)(!<))!"<)<%%)<))%$42$="4??FGI! %"$<);"4":<)"1999!">;#"($")<("5(", (:()%(%#+(""#"%%)(("%)E#"%;"G"%5411% 41F ( )<) . I!  :;  )  )<(" (#$%%    J"%5 2F 54()7$$""#"$<(C#"(7)(10:)4?31GI! ()%E>< ")=%("()#)4"(K%199F! ()%! #"> , J77)" )  $%$ %") G"%5 4A1 I! B$%" J(77)  #"%;"=$"$#"%)%)($%")$#":;)<(".

F5 -(J"%511 G(<%"<);"#)4":<)"1999I! )<("!#"%%)(("%),)"%");(%#"%;$ (7("$%B"%5411!41F!4A4%4A1 M"%5FE0J##),% #"(;)(%%E%"7$""G54I5("@,(:()%!#"%%)( ("%)E#"%;"(""#(E)77$"%"#"%%)(("%)!;%$  <()"  )=" #; B)%% $<%%  (%  )<("! %  #"%%)(  ("%)! ;%$  <()"  )=" #; B)%% $<%%(%()(");G75"%51AI5(" !(:(%E#"%%)(("%)%EJ<()")="#;B)%% (%   ()(  ");  )%$"D%   (%  )<(" G 4131F9M 41?AAAI5

    8142081990 A  



A5  +#>!  :;  #")>" )%  ("($  #"%; #" ()%)$  <()"#"$<(C5%#"%)%(%!+#"%!");! 19:)4??3!+%"#"%2:)1990!%E,:;%)<("% <B$%()"5

-(  (% #"()%!  #"%%)( ,) #%  "); #"  "%"5F9+31A5A0GF1+0?3540N4+22F529I%),,) #""%"5A9J021569GA1J091540N4J?1?500I!)%$"D%C% $:E $%$ $ #"  )%)%%)(  #"$<(C $7"5 ))  " ()% E ( B.$#(B  (%%  "5AJ32A549 GOA9J021569 8 1P N OF9J31A5A081PI5

05 (7("$% E  :")#"! #)  :(" $%")% #("  #"%; :,J (%  %"7"%   #"%%)(  ("%) (   "!  (:()% )<("$ =$$7)))"  %% #"%%)(  "()% E  )%$"D% (#%()" "  (%%  .)5  )%$"D% (% $  %B )) $; ( J"%5 41  J("( "  #"$<(C #"(7)( <))! "<)<% % )<))%$  43 <") 4?3A G 1I ( (  %B "$;%)"! ) ).) % #$")" G  ( #=)$  F6891  43 :)% 199FI

65 $(%"#"'!#"($"$%%;"%)%G"%52F51% 3?Q54()"#"($"))%"%)<41#%="4?30I5

RRR



    8142081990 0  



  +)0  )(* *+*  (* +)

 12343   5  /33 3  6 #7" +8

45 <)%  --   .   - -    /    --   E %"7$""! #"  $=)%  (#%    !  (  "5 AJ32A549 "  (#%  )=" #;  ()"  ! (<"% #">   --     /     -  -      +-        -    - + -        M

15 <)%  --   .   - -    /    --   E <""!  #   (%%!  )%$"D% (#%()"    ()$"%! >  (%  )<(" :,J (%%"7"%M

F5 +C(%%,=()M

A5 )%,#"($"%;"%)%M

05 7("  #"%)   ,J #<% 7("" "(" (%"  #"$% ""D%   $)  F9 :(" >  (%)7)%)( #" #) "($ "$  ")= 7$$"  "! -@S)L"@(7,) 6! 699A   !  %"() B#)"5  $)  #% D%" #"((;$5  $()" ()% H I ))," B%% , $))(  "("% $)" (=%)"  ) % #   $))(%%,$M=IB#("#(",(%)7)%)#(<()""%% %"$))(MI#("%");%"(("#"$%%5-)$()"  (%)% #  %"() $$% $$"$ ( %%" I =I % I ).!  ")=7$$""#(""#%""%)>"""(",J) <"$"")""<=5$()""("%)("("(C  #"<! ,) "(% :()%! )) ,  $))( %%,$ % J<(##  ,$%$B#$)$"("%G"%54F1!496%493I5 ;"77)>"  "$)%H     ) T")- T (#)(7("#"$%""D%%(%)7)$B#"%))),+E+77)7$$" "()#";"77

    8142081990