Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/704/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/704/2005 Généré par l'IA

Statute of Limitations Tolling Based on Jurisdictionally Defective Prior Filing

Numéro de cause ATAS/704/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The appellant challenged a lower court's decision regarding the application of a statute of limitations to their claim, specifically questioning whether a prior filing in a different jurisdiction was a timely commencement for the purpose of tolling the limitation period. The court reasoned that because the previous filing was jurisdictionally defective—lacking proper venue—it did not qualify as a commencement under the relevant tolling statute, which requires a filing that could have been maintained had the initial jurisdiction not been waived or transferred, leading to the conclusion that the current claim was untimely because it was filed after the prescriptive period had expired.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statute of Limitations Tolling Based on Jurisdictionally Defective Prior Filing: The court reasoned that because the previous filing was jurisdictionally defective—lacking proper venue—it did not qualify as a commencement under the relevant tolling statute, which requires a filing that could have been maintained had the initial jurisdiction not been waived or transferred, leading to the conclusion that the current claim was untimely because it was filed after the prescriptive period had expired.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
délai de prescription dépôt tardif incompétence ratione materiae forclusion pour tardiveté preuve insuffisante d'aggravation médicale vices de forme légaux

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The court imposed the costs of the federal proceedings on the appellant.
Généré par l'IA
A/2619/2006
Statute of Limitations Tolling by Prior Filing
A/1402/2000
Statute of Limitations Tolling Based on Incapacity Commencement Date
A/2210/2005
Statute of Limitations Tolling Due to Absence from Jurisdiction
A/2810/2005
Statute of Limitations Defense in Untimely Claim Filing
A/3362/2006
Statute of Limitations for Appeal Jurisdiction

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court imposed the costs of the federal proceedings on the appellant.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

   

#$%&#'%%& (#)%*#'%%&

(

 ( +(   +  +

,- +.  " ,/ 0  '%%&

  

  1111111111 

" 1111111111

 

+2 3+  4 5+     12 ( ( 2 (  4! "   "  #$ % & ' ()

6  (  (((  (4 ! ""  "  *   "+ *& % ,"-

((2 +  ! .  "(& )  " /0 % 

          !"   !" /3$

 6(

#6  7&  /8 )+ /00$!  $( -+  "+  *"( "   *1  ")  9 ::::::::::! 1 ::::::::::  #/ 7)" #8;<  9" ::::::::::! 1  #$ 7" #8;;! "1     /8 7)" #8886

/6 =  -"22 $  7& *1" 1!  "+  *"( "   1  * & * " "1  )"  *1). *2" >" * -  1*?   "&6   "    "+  1 * > "@" *(      % 216

46  7&  ")  ) 12"" "2  // 7)" /0056

$6  "+  1  "" 1       " "  "  *1). 16  " 1  ! 21 % A? " )"!  1 1  1  &22 )   " B  " " " )+ C6

56  " "  " 12  1 1 *"1  ">      )"   * " >"   "&! "    /8 7)" #888   // 7)" /0056

;6 =  "   D@ ==   E    =   = == 9  = D=  =      #0 " /005!  *  " >" *  "& *     $<F;<5 26 456 =  "   G  =    =    /# 7" /005    H D  D 9  $ " /005!      /IF48/ 26 85! " * ") /F884 26 I0 J I<A;I# 26 K?> " )"  1" 5$F/I# 2 I5 *1   *  "  "+ *& >"   "&! . *"  " 1L   /0 7)" #888  // 7)" /005M6

I6     1 1 " ? * "     /# 7" /0056  7"" "   "">1 >F% 12 F+) " F""  #0 N /005!  L "

    +6

<6  F+ F+7 "   1" 2"?1!    1 1 &1 % 7&6

  (

#6 F 6 /5   " 211   "+ *&   *1). *2"! )""! )")   ")"" 1  #I 1+ #884 KGM!

 1  )"&  # 7)" /000! (&  *1    ")6 >

34053/005 43$

 7"    * A   *  "   " % * & K 6 #//  #/4  ")" @ M!  7&  "  ") *1     F 6 I4 6 #   " 211   *1). *2"  /5 7" #8</ KM! " % ()  "+     " *"  # N /004! " !

*( > F22" "  1 1 " K 6 #$/ M! ?1  F22"  * &   +   1  1* " " 1 "1 *  7&  ").

/6 = F 6 // G K)   )"& *"  # 7)" /000M!    ")!  *  "   " >"   "&  * &1 21 ?  6 #//! #/4! #$#  #$/ O   6 4 % 5 G F"> * &"    % 21 K6 #M6  -> 7" !  *  "   " % * & * %  "221    *  "   "! & 1  )"  "+ *& ?"  1)     ")!   *  "   "! & 1  )"  "+ *& ?"  1)      "  "& K26  6 /$ GM6   !  7  %  *  "   "  % F)"  "+ *& ?"      "  "&  " 1L      ") K G #/<  /40O G #/8  $$$M6

46  A*(!  7&  *"( "   1  * & * " "1  )"  >" *  1*?   "&6    * "   !

A * !   "&!  /8 7)" #888! A  *  // 7)" /005!

  % >  7&  ")  ) ?1 "6

=    *" !  *  " >" *  "& * 9" ::::::::::   /IA48/ 26 85! " >  >" * 9 ::::::::::   $<F;<5 26!  " 1L  . 17% 1 1 1 *  " "  "  *1). 126 "" 9" :::::::::: " %  ?@1*     #4A;8; 26 50 K/IA48/ 26 85 P /M  @" " % "@%     /$F4$/ 26 <0 K$<F;<5 26 45 P /M!    > A 9 :::::::::: >" " % 9" ::::::::::     #0A;$; 26 406

$6 21 %  7"*! *"  7 1 " *  * & 7>F   2   *  "   "    !  7" ")1 +112"""    *  "  " %  " 1L  * "      @"6  " 1L   1  ?

"" 1&  F 6 #/  F   *1). *2" )""! )")   ")"" 1  #< )" #8<$ K /M    ?

1& "! " "@"  *1" K G  *+"1  4;30/  #< 7" /004M6

56  1   *Q!  *1 1  & "  K 6 I4 6 /   <8D 6 #   "   *1 ""  ")  #/ * + #8<5M6

34053/005 $3$

 + (6  ( +(   +  +

"

789   :  0   ;< ,/'  !=

#6 )"   D @ ==   E    =   = == 9  = D=  =     % 21!  *   9 ::::::::::

   #0A;$; 26 40 %  H D  D 9 !  2)  9" ::::::::::6

/6 )"   D @ ==   E    =   = == 9  = D=  =     % )!  *     !  " 1L  * "    "1 ! (  // 7)" /005 7>F   2 6

46 A.    >  +"6

$6 " >  *1  & " 6

56 2  * "   >F *) 2     *1 L   1"  40 7 (   "2" " * *" 1 1  "+ 211  ! =-R"S-2>" ;! ;00$   !  " ?*"6  1"  * L  *&16  1" " P M ""> ?  > 1""   1" + "  "  *   1""  >1O +M ?* * >  "2 "  " *)"      1""O M *   "&      *1  6 ="  1"   " *  " 11  111    M +M  M "@!  "+ 211    * *     "(    >F" ) 1 ")+6  1"    "   .  *)! >"  7" ! "" >  1""  >1  F)  >   1 1 ?*1"1   K 6 #4/! #0;  #0< M6

 &22"(  1"  P

9"@"  , " H     *" 2  *1 L   "2"1 ? * " "" >A% A22" 211   " *  &22

34053/005