Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/700/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/700/2007 Généré par l'IA

Surety Agreement Waiver of Condition Precedent

Numéro de cause ATAS/700/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerns a dispute arising from a financial transaction involving a surety agreement where the appellant sought to avoid liability by arguing that an agreed-upon condition precedent to the agreement was not met. The court reasoned that the appellant's subsequent actions, including engaging in significant conduct consistent with the obligations under the agreement after the purported condition was allegedly unmet, constituted a waiver of the condition, thereby rendering the surety liable for the obligations.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Surety Agreement Waiver of Condition Precedent: The court reasoned that the appellant's subsequent actions, including engaging in significant conduct consistent with the obligations under the agreement after the purported condition was allegedly unmet, constituted a waiver of the condition, thereby rendering the surety liable for the obligations.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
caution action en responsabilité transaction financière concours de responsabilités contrat de vente acte préparatoire en droit des obligations

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied to award costs against the appellant.
Art. 64 LTF
Applied to grant the request for legal aid.
Généré par l'IA
A/165/2006
Contractual Right of First Refusal Waiver via Failure to Meet Condition Precedent
A/4051/2007
Waiver of Condition Precedent by Non-Cooperation
A/1748/2003
Contract Interpretation and Condition Precedent Dispute
A/902/2005
Surety Liability Under Broad Waiver for Subsequent Obligation Modifications
A/532/2005
Breach of Contract - Conditions Precedent

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied to award costs against the appellant.

Art. 64 LTF

Applied to grant the request for legal aid.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

           ()*()++, #(,++()++,

#

 #$ #     $

"-.  / ' /* 0' )++,           !"##$ %  ''( &'()!(   *!(+('  '     ('    ,,     * -- %      ' ( ! ./$ 

       !  "  #$#% ! &' ' 

   %#0/%  

 1$#

/2   !  "/2$  !(! ) (  * 3( ')  #$ )4'"//#5 (677'(*.'4%)'(!4' 3' 68  (')  (  -   6 (!  7  34' &  !4'"/99(!(!  !&'&.')77(:1; "//:8

#8 ' !    < (4' #11" *,,     * -- % '

    = %&'>  ?    ! >  "  ' "///   %'( '(   '( &!( ' &'  !&@ (  7(8    !'! 6(( (5(!*'!' (@'!( ) (!'( )5 %(& ( !  (@ * )  (!  && (    !(3 *!)(   @(8  *( 7! '  (@ * & (!  (')   "11A 6 6  ( *( ) (! ) B!(* & (!5& '(')@!B'#1A(  '( B'!* )  (!21A8

:8 ' ;B(  "$ ; ( #11#     (  '' -%  '&!((';(!''7'!('((!  &'*'!8

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

E8  '  &.3 ('  !(! (! &' *  &' &'!' 5  @&'(  &.3 (' 68   '&&'(  #$ (4' #11:  !   ((! 6 *'! &'!( (  !&  !&' 7 . ) .' ( 6 &'!( &  "//9     ( (  4 (B  B3 3' 6 &  "//:8   6 6    ((   & &3. 6 '('4 '(&&.3 6((&(3 ( '( (&.3('87 @5E1A& (!'! (') 8 !'6 77 (!&'  &'('!&'*'!(



0#/0#11$  %:0/%   !B(!B''( ((')@  ('( 7('    ((  !((  *''  E1A8  &'!  &'  ' 6  (')@   ('( 7!B=&'!&'( (& (7('?(B!!'( & &'!&@ ' &&!(%6 '( *&&'( B '*@&'( !8

  (  "' )4' #11:  '  (( 6   ' F( ) (!!B .!B''( (  *@!(   (')@  4   '( ( &'  (')@   ('( 7 (  ' B4( ( ! 5 E1A8   6  '  (') & (!'! (( !56('3'&';'5E1A8*@&'( * B'!  * 5) ' )  (!( !5E1AF8

' '' '  #" )4' #11:  '  ! %   *   ! 5  '   &!('  @&'(   '!&(@@6(  )(G

% &(% ' 3'   (')@   ('( 7 (  (')@ ' &3. 6(  '   4B  6 (( '! &( 77('  (')@'  '*!B&'(&(&6*'  'H

% ( I%)6((!)( = )  (!E1A? (C('&'  ((4!'*!(((!B!!'5) '((&( 4  *!((&3. 66&.3 6H

' '!&&' &F F@@6( 8

28 #'#11<''>)6*7 (F3'  77 (!&' (')@  ('( 7('( (')@' *.&3 &(4 .&' &''' *(&('> 77  !&'4;(*   5  ) (' J  !7( *'! &( '!&'( '  3'B  ( &' @&@7 B (  '5'((F8

$8 '!  #/)' #11E*  7'!*'!6&((7 ( 6   '    '('  &C3( 6 &' & '  (K3   ('( ) (  (')@ '  (  ( 6 *&C3(#1A6 ) (!(!  ( ('(!( (7'5'! (!8 7 '>'' (*'!5&'(( ''&(5B'! * )  (!21A ( %'(>"''"///((' %6'( '( >  "' ;) ' #11< 7'!( 5 *('!  ) B'   6(' > '!)   'L'% )  (!"/; "/E/= ?8

98 '&&'(&!( '5*6C(!B>'"E #11"!(!!(4 "1 )4' #1128  4'('   *  6  ) ( &'!! 5  &' >' 6C(  4')!6G



0#/0#11$  %<0/%   % &' F  (   !BF  *.  & *&C3( &'(  ' 5  B'M

% &'&(F (( F *.&4&*&C3(!((&'! ! 6* &'+(&@ 76' &'!&'(' '&&' M

% &'  &( F('(   B(F  &'(  &(   '  6  & *& '('(' 7 '6('(@ B 4M

% &'F&(((' )'F (@ B 4' 6* &B *'!7 &' M

% &'F )(*('( )C((F' ('&'('4   B!((&'! !6* ( 'B* 4(3'B!*('(  4' M

% &'F @7(F@% (5&'!(KB!3 ('!)( (& !&(8

/8 *'!  7'! && (   "1   #11E 5  !    #/ )'  #11E ( &!(!/; #11E8

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

""8 *'! '&'!(! &' +(' '     (';(! ''  E ;) ' #11$(' (!  8

  '>) 6   '&&'( &!( ' 5 *6C( !B>' '! !  "1)4' #112  4'('   *   ((  '&'' (  !)&&'     *6C(  (  !(( &'! ! 6* * & ') *'!* (')8



0#/0#11$  %E0/%     ' ( *'!  & (    ) (   &'  &  *(' (!   3 ;B!((5*(' *'(( >'* )  (!>"''"///(5 ( * 5)'' 77!'( '!('( 7'(>((( ) (!'C(5EA5&('36!3!8

"#8   '!&  #/ ;) ' #11$ *  (( ) ' ) !  &'  &  *(' (!   3 ;B! & 6  (@ *&C3( !  '( &' *@&'( &.3 (' *( &'! !( & ((!8  @& 6 6*   ((7  7 ( && (    ;' &' '( ) 5 *4 B(     '  B (  B6 !'( !(*&'6 *('' &6 .! (( 7D ( (('5&'(('  &'' '  6(      (   B &'  4    *  ' 4(@ B 4('4'7 8>' ';(''8

":8 '' '!(!(' 5*'!(B'!5;B'8

 $#

"8  B) 'L'B ( ;   '=?!(! 7 !( ( (!>  "' N( #11:  ' 4 (  '   ((( 7'!( 5 *'(8 E2 8 " (8  38 #   (  6 '  ((( &'!)5L'(8E2 7!!''&'( B!!'' ( '    2 (4' #111 = ? 6  ( '( ) 5    ' L'% )  (!"/; "/E/= ?8

-&!(&';B'L&>(  !(4 8

#8    ( ('!  ) B'  "' ;) ' #11: ('+(   7 (  !B ( ) ((   ' (  *'% )  (!8  & (  ) (&'(&'  &&& 4'>B' () B'(O  7 ( ;'  6( !(' (  ( &' ( (  ;B  '  7&'  &&'&&'! ''*!((7 ('! !5 (!(' (!  '&& (  ( B = ,"#/< 8"8#M "2/ 8"M:E2 8"(''C( (!?8

-' 7 ' 4 !'>)6!   ( B  !(!' (  "E )4' #112   (( '  !((  7 ( ;'  6( !(' ( (!' ' 5 *! #11:8  &'!(  ( B ' > ' @ ! 5   >'   & (      (   '>B(  ) B' ;6* :" !4'#11#( &'&!' &(!' '87 *B (  7 (       #" ' #11: ('!  ) B'  "' ;) ' #11< '( (!''&'( 8



0#/0#11$  %20/%   :8   6  '  &'!' ( 5 !7(  '>B (' ( ' (' '   ('*&& ( *&& 6('!')>;'' ('!) B'= ,""$/: 824M""#:21 8<M  "//9 P:$&8:"2 8:4?8

!&!   7' ( !  &'!) &'     &'!( '' ( ')4 ='(821 ?8

<8 *4;(   ( B    ( 5 *!)(   (@ *&C3( 5 & '  (')@!B'8

  6(   3 @   !(3 *!)(  (   (@ * & (!  (')   *@'   *( ) (! '( ) ( !(! '!B! &'  ,    ''C(<7!)' '#11:8 ('Q(;'  ( 77(7 '!*&'(6 ((( @() (C('&& 6!5' E1A&'(')@34 (( E1A &' *( ) (! '( ) ( *(' &'( 6* (@  "11A * & (!  (') &'*( ) (!'( )) (C(''8

E8  *6C( !B>'  ( (    R)'  "E   #11"  '!( (  (@*&C3(#1A8 , (((6*'!77' (('4 &.3 6((7 '&&!6*(6C(*!( (&.&') !6( '6 *&C3( '!(  ('4 *'' &.3 6  ((( ! !((&( &'7 @'(@& (!(')  ' 4( @ B 48       )'B ('  '!((  *6C(! 6'!B(((( *''! '( )5 & (!*& '(')@34 (% (%'>BB!!' &  &  6 *6C( 5    =''C(  &4 !  "$ ;) ' #112 2:/0#11<M - #11< &8 ":$?8 *(  '  &' 6  ,   !  !  *   6;B( ' 4!( ').! 8

28 *      (!  '  &' @ ' *'!8  '&&'(*@&'(  '!(& (!'! (') E1A8*  4(((7 ''(@#1A'(&'*6C(!B>' "E   #11"  7( ( ( '  '&&'( &!( ' !(4   "1)4' #112 &'  C 4'('   *   6  (K3 6 &)(C('& &'*'!(&'' 8

 ,'((('67 (*  B'&'(( &(*''C(  , 8(#'#11<'('7 (!((6   77 (! &3. 68 '  ,   ').!   5 *  &' 6 &'! !(  @&'(  !   ( ! )  ('4 &.3 6 &'!(!&'*'!!(('&&!6* )'B('  !  (   *6C( ! 6  .     '>B B!!'   7''&' >'8



0#/0#11$  %$0/%      ) ( > ' & &' 6 '  *   ! 5 *('  *6C(!B>'  ( *&&'('4')( &!( '6 *)>'( (  & 6   ,   ( 6C( *( &'! !( & &'&'5*!)(   ((  !5('4&.3 68

*  >'6*6C(!B>'( (N(&(*&'( *4 B( 6  45(('!'! 'B(*('&'(7 ( 6  '    '(  4'  (K3 !B>'8  .  &'((   *4')' 6 (( 6C(  !(! @ ! &'  ,  6  *  &   ').!5* &' ('( &!( '8

$8 .   7'''&&'(*@&'( '  6  ( !(' ( &' ;B'   & (!  *'! 5 & '  (')@ !B' &' (( 6*   ( )' &'4(     ;' &' = , "#E:E# 8:"##"21 8"('!7!'?8

(4 & ( ( B @.(7 (*4;(*!( '( ! '&&'(7('@&(( *@&'(!(( N( ( )!8 (( ' >'   '& '!  "' !4' #11: 5 * '' '@& ( 7''8

,'    (  ((' 6* (@ *&C3( 5 & '  (')@ !B'!(!'(&'' 8

*'! &'!(     && (    !(3  @( *!)(   * )  (!B'!* )  (!$EA5&('"''"///6;( 7  *(' *'(( >'& (((='(8#9 ?8

98 *'!  ((' (!'C(EA& "''"///8*!((7 ( ;'  6( !(' ( ( !&  ' ( !)( 5  (!'C( '( ' *( '! ! &'( ( )( ( &'( ( &'> *('!  ) B'    8 '  &!'  *!(( ;6* :" !4' #11# *@   ( (!' ' (5&'((  (') (&'  &!(4  @ , ""/  9"  8 : = , ":1  ::<  8 28"?8 '  &!'  &(!' ' ( @ *77( *&'>  '>B  *'(8 #2 8 #    6  (!'C( '( ' (  &' (( '!  &'((  *' 5*!3!*! #< 5&('  ' ( &(S("# 5&'( '(O*'!7 () '' ( &' (( 6*    ( ( >'( 7'! 5 *4 B(   4'' 6    4= ,":1::< 828#?8

 ) ( (( *4' *@ '   *'!  ' (  )'( * (!'C( '( '  &'  &!'  &'!!( *('!  ) B'    8 6*5 *('!  ) B'  ((    ' 4 7!!'  '  !' ( &  B(& !;5 6*  *. ) (  &'  & & & &'  (!'C(



0#/0#11$  %90/%   '( '   ' O  *!( ( & &'!) &'  !B ( 8  @&(  5  &'  & !( (   4  &'!  R)'   (  &'( ( '*''8*(' * (!'C('('3.&(3> ) (&( (') '6*)'(8  !(! !'!6* *.) ( & *(('4 B( B!!')'' (!'C(5B'& (6 (( &'(  >'&) (5( ('@&( '  5('!((6( (' (!( (3'(! >'&'(  >' = , ""/  9" 8  8 : ( <    6  ''C(  (!M 78 !B( , "#$<<28 8<?8

 *'' '   ;( 7  *('  * (!'C( '( '8   ' (  &'(  ''&'3'5* R)'   (&'( ( '8

( 5  &!'  &(!' '  "' ;) ' #11:  (!'C( (  7'!( 5 *'(8 #2 8 #   =78 !B( ,   &4 !  ##!4'#11<"E$01<?8(5!(' '& 6(8&)( C(' )'! &   "' ;) ' #11: & 6     ''(  (')' ( > ' 6  ' ( 5  &'((   &'    )( *('!  ) B'  '& ( 7 (*&& ( *  ' (;6*:"!4'#11#6  *&& 6 (>  &'((   (!'C( *!((      6*5 *!3! * !   #<  5 &('      ' (8 '((  ) ( *((' 6  ( (!'C( )(C(')'!6*5&'( ' "';) '#11E= (#<  & *('!) B' ?8

/8  '' (  !6   *'! &)( &'!(' 5 *('  * '( ( >' &   "' ' "/// ) (!'C( 5 EA 5 &(' "' ;) ' #11E8



0#/0#11$  %/0/%  

  3#$1  #$ #     $

'

  4 -

"8 !'''')48

' 4 

#8 *(8

:8 !  #/)' #11E("E)4'#1128

<8  L ( ! 5 )'' 5  ''(    "*111 7'8 5 ( ('  &'(  &( 57' (!&8

E8 *!(7 @!5#117'8( 53'B* ( !8

28 7'  &'(    6L &)( 7'' '' ('  &'!( ''C(   !   :1 ;' >  ( 7 (  &'>  ' 4 7!!' =-3T I'376 2211<  ?&') ''( >'' ( &4 7'!(@'(89# 7!!'' ' 47!!'"$ ;  #11E = ,?M  ! '  ''  (  6'    ( 7 ( .&')(&'(' B('''(( 'M  ( C(' '!  ' 4 7!!' &' )  &(  &' )  !(' 6 @  (   *'(8 <#  ,8  &'!( ''C( (  & >  &   ''( )6!.&') )(C('; (5*) 8  B'77 >'  '! (     ' %  U ' V 

& 7'&'!(''C((( 7 !@&'(   6L5L77 7!!' ' &'B'77



0#/0#11$