Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
ATAS/686/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/686/2004 Généré par l'IA

Enforcement of Prior Settlement Agreements and Judgments

Numéro de cause ATAS/686/2004
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Frais judiciaires à la charge de l'autorité

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case involves several related actions concerning the enforcement and interpretation of prior settlement agreements and judgments. The court addressed numerous objections to the evidence presented, primarily concerning the admissibility of documents and testimony related to prior proceedings and settlements, ultimately affirming the validity of the settlements and the court's prior rulings regarding their effect on the current dispute. The reasoning consistently upheld the finality of the previous settlements and judgments, dismissing arguments that sought to relitigate matters already concluded or that failed to properly demonstrate grounds for relief from those prior determinations, thereby enforcing the existing settlement framework against the challenging party.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Enforcement of Prior Settlement Agreements and Judgments: The court addressed numerous objections to the evidence presented, primarily concerning the admissibility of documents and testimony related to prior proceedings and settlements, ultimately affirming the validity of the settlements and the court's prior rulings regarding their effect on the current dispute. The reasoning consistently upheld the finality of the previous settlements and judgments, dismissing arguments that sought to relitigate matters already concluded or that failed to properly demonstrate grounds for relief from those prior determinations, thereby enforcing the existing settlement framework against the challenging party.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
règlement du litige procédure d'exécution interprétation de l'arrêt argumentation motivée nullité des ententes antécédents

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Généré par l'IA

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court ordered the appellant to pay the court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

               %&'((%)+,-, .%/0/%)-

"".

 ."  1 .   " 1 1

-2  34   & 5  )- 



   67777777777 !" !# $!" % & !!" '"( "))*+")



"!



881 1 .   9" 1, :. !) "+ ,-./0'



                !" #$

   74187  

 8.

29 #) %:::::::::: ;7 !0  !!"< +  2-35  =!+ )'! "'"+ !>  !0  !"+9 ? >!"  !!"  "!'+ )   2! '! 2-8-  *"+ )('!0! /  "  )  "! !)!)"!/0'9

49 @A'!2---!!"+"+B++>)( "+"") "!'  ! ) !'7B!$C " )( >" !$" $!*9   B++>+ )()"+ A!0! )  ) ! "') ,!A*(4A'!45529

69  !!"  )+ +  )) ) !""  !0 ) (!7 ')"+)")4DA'!2---9(>>")(!7')"+ ;7 !0 ( <  )"+  "! )(B!'" +) ) (!7 ')"+ ;7 !0 # < ! = !"9  ! ! !" ) 44 )+B! 4555  = !" ) #  " +  )C" ) ,)! ) )+>+ "$!*  +!! +!!"$!" ) (+  )!" ,)! )!= $!* "!B =" )  !"+ " $,  ) ! " B"+!9! !+"CB= !""/ "+) "!'!+))(!)!)35E)"'"+) "+9

@9 ? >)" ! "" = !" (  ! )+ ) 24 'B! 4552  !/!!")C!+)(')"+)35E"(B++>)( )7!")(')"+)0)A'!45559

39  - 'B! 4552  !!" '" >" !'! / (    )( )+ ) (>> " ) (  ;7 !0  <  )+!"  "  ")024!45529DF"4554!!""! +(  "")!'!)0!*( ('")+!+ ""!'9 + )"/*"! !!+')!"4 "B!4554 !!")+!+*+"")"+(+""CC!'+ !C!'")  4552' !"'!CC!'"))!)+"B")!" =+"+A!9

D9 ! !"+)+"B/("")( )")43 "B! 4554  ! ::::::::::  )+!+ * (!+ !+""  +"" =7 )+ !>) 45F"4554""+!+')!"')( !""0!)(')"+9

.9 ! )+ ) 48 >+'!! 4556 (   !>+ )(C"!  !" ) (!+  "> *( !+"" ) !C" ! )  )! ) ("!")))*( '"=!!+"!)('!0! )>B!*)!)"!/35E9

 123..14556   76187   89 !!!!)!+/( 2.!4554! ::::::::::)+!+ >!!! ! ") ""9 ! +* !(!7 ')"++"")!!")$GC*)'""! !"!'!  " / 35E  ""  " ) "" $,* BA"' ! ) (+'" ) # 9 !  $GC '" )+!+  ""  HB I) !>)>")""")JC9!!" '" ""+ ) "!'! ) ""  "  09  ! ::::::::::  ! + *  "" ,$"!* '"   +') + ") "+) ""') ""9

-9  44  4556 (   !A"+ ( " )  !!"  "> * ) (' )  !' +) /  "! ) !+" ++"  !"+ !  +) "!""  '" ) "!   ) (= !" !) ! >>"+ !  #   F" 45559   )+!+ *  )+ ) (  (+""  )+"!" )  ! K  " )( "")  "!'   )   ! (! $GC (+""   I*)(!7')"+9

259 !("!+)!)(!+"!A"+!!)")45A 4556  !0 )   " ) !!  "0! )(!7 ')"+9  ! !$ / (  ) (I"! !+>+!+  = +)  +"!! !")(= !">>"+ ! # 45559! B"'))+!")+)"!""*+"") "+ (+"" CC!'+ " ) >" *  "" ,$"!* '"   +')  + " )   "+ ) ""' )(!)!  = +) +"!9I( !")F=!*") !+) "")!K "+!+))"!')35E!" ! ( (+"" ! !!C)(!7$GC9 ")0 ! /  *( = !" +) " !)+ > )(+'!   "+ ")"!'*+'" B"+)!"9

229 ( )!+ )2-F"4556= *!!""!!I" )"!') A'!2---)+ ")(=")( "+!+)) "!'+)""""+"!0'*(+"")+ !>)!!""  +"!" '  )>>"+  "  >B !' >"! +"!C! / (')"+ )" (! (  / !+ )!9  ' ) (B )( )C" ' / !"0! ')"   )   (  (" +C"+ / )+!! *( (,   "> ) !+' " "  !A" ) !!9

249 !+ *)48'B!4556!!"= *+"")"+ ("CC!'+*! ::::::::::("+)! !") 2.  "B! 45569  !)" ) ! !" +)= +"B !  ! ::::::::::" ::::::::::)2D "B!4."B!".'B!4556

 123..14556   7@187   *"""!"CC!'"),)!!'"B! !! !" "")2---9 ""*( (+"" )!")!>!!+' ))!"/!"""/>)!!! !") # +"B 45559

269   !+' ) 44 )+B! 4556 (   !0' *  )+C!)" ) (+"" ) "+ $,* )  !!"  +"+ ""+ )0 (+"+ 4556 " "+!!"/)+! ")4445569

2@9 !!" !"+)"+"+C!)+/AC!9



 ".

29    C' ! (!C" A)! ;<  +"+ )>+ "  ""+ )02!F"4556 !B")! +)3 AC)" !+)""'7 !+)"3 +""2DAC! ;!"92"9!"3D <9

?"/(")(+")2DAC! ! !B>+)+! 4. A'! 455@ ; L 265  25D<  !)  C'  ) "+  26 >+'!!  ) " "!"! !C" !"""  !B " ) !  ) +C!  ! / "! AC ""!  ) (""")(+")'=AC!;!"92D4<9

?"""!!!))!" B !B>+)+!)!!I")2! A"455@>!+*) ""!"!""""  !""+"">!)!!M")!">+)+!;!!I"292861455@<9

C")*")(""""+) !B ") !    )+!+ *  !+" )  "!B  '" I"! !'>!)+!C"!))!">+)+!"(!!(!"9 3. )   >+)+! ) D "B! 4555 !  !" C++! ) )!" ) !; <9

>!+"/(!"96+6)) ""!"!))>" "!)"'"("!+'C!)" )")'"   " ) !!  "0! )(!7')"+ " +"+ "! )(>>  !B " ) !  * M"  " * ) """ !"' /   >+)+! ! (! ')"+ ) 2- A 2-3- "" ;!"9 3D + 2 ""! < <9 ?  +""+"B !AC!))( 09

 123..14556   73187   49  )+ / N!C ) !! )" "   !B ) + ," +"+ !)  4556    "!+  'C!  2! A'! 4556 "  B9 """!M+)>")B!) "+C)  )""!2!A'!4556")+"!"9

69 "!A"+ )  )+ " >! +C=  !! " !'B ;!"9 3D " D5  <9

@9 ?(!"2.+2 "=)(')"+)B++>!)!" B")>""B!"")(>>!))!+'+ ! ('! / '! C"+  !+)"  +*  !  !+9 !*( )) ) !+' " )+ + 7 )" +"B! ) >H B*(')"+( ")(!+(")>+)0!/ >!)!";!"98.96 <9 )+>"()"!")" !"! )+ !B / (!+ ! *( )+   , ) !'  ('!""*(("!! "0!!))(>! /A"; L )2DA'!455@34156<9

 (!!("+""!+"0!!)))!+'*( "">!A"+9

 " $C"  !"" ) !" ! ! / >!  )C!+ )(')"+))!"/!" ")!/!+')79 ")'!"$C"(" !)")"I"!"!$+ !" >""*( !+"""))+")!"" !"!+C"/(+ *))+"C; L2436D-)9 4 "  !+>+!O L 224  6.4 )9 4B " 6-5 )9 2B<9 ( !0  A! !)  !" " I"! !+'+  "   ) )>" B ) (+"" ) "+   !* 7 " !"+    I  *  +* !   "+ ) C " B  $C"  !""; L2264.3)92"!!I""+O L2246.4)9 4B"6-5)92B<9

39  !!"  !) B  CC!'" )  +"" ) "+  * ("""! ::::::::::)! !"+))43 "B!4554 ; 0 8 >!! 6  <9  +) +'*  !+ )( +"" =7 )+ !> )   45 F" 4554 ' "!B )  !'"+ " !  )!* !"))!!9  !++* "$,+"""!"'C !"")!=)>>"+" !B0)()7!"9

 ("+)+!+*(+"")+ !>)(!++""+"!"' )>>"+  "  >B !' >"! )" (!7')"+ ('"  / !+ )!9   C+  *  !!" ('"  ! ! )("'"+ C!+   "+ ) "!' !+) ) 35 E )  !++)"

 123..14556   7D187   "'"+9 ("! !"  )+ ) (  ," )+!+ (!+  "  "" ( )0!*(+'") "+)"!'" ) C ("   I )  )= !9 ("+ ("  +* !+>+!+ /   "+ ) "!' !+) !" !  = !" ) #  ) ! ! !" ) 44 )+B! 45559 " = "! 0 !)"  ! ) !+)! ("+ !0' *  = >>"+ " "+!!/)+9

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

  !B ) + "" *  !">" +) +"B !  ! ::::::::::  4. "B! 4556 >" +"" )( CC!'" ) "" !$"C* ! ! !" / 2--- ) I *  ! !" )  ! ::::::::::" "+!!/)+"C)!"*( '"  !  I"! ! "))!) !+" !+)!9

 ?(C")! !")! ::::::::::)44 "B!4554, ) !'! *( >" +"" )( )+ " !   ,$* '  !" )( C  !"" ) "!B )  " ) !  )!++"'=*('" +"+B!'+!)(= !" ) # 9 +)""!"*(C +"")!= )>>"+ O  B!'" * !)" ""> B  +C+)(!+*"/CC!'")+"")"+9

  !B !0' *(/ !"! ) " K (  " "!+  "0!   '"  ""!  ))!  = +)  +"! / 

 123..14556   7.187    +" ) ! / (B ) +A!"   )     )("" *  ,$"! ) #  '" )+A/ !'+  4555  )" ) !! ) ""' ) (!+9  '"  +* ) )+"!! *+""C!'"+"())'="!B !+"+ !(!+ ! "+)"!'!B"=CB9

 ')* !+0)!!!)"!',+/(  ! "!" +"!>!)(= !""')+9

 

 

































" 1 .8  ."  1 .   " 1 1

 123..14556   78187    3;   <  5   9$ &/) 

  ; 

29 +!!'B!!"!A"+ !#)%::::::::::"!)+ ! ")444556O

 ;

49 ()"O

69 +*)+! ")444556")+) 48>+'!!4556O

@9 '/(  !"!" +"!"')+O

39 ) ("+ / '!! /  !!"   ) >!9 2N355977 / ""! ) !" "/>!")+ O

D9 >!  !" )  *( '" >!! !! "!  !+" !!I" )  )+ ) 65 A! )0  ">" !  !)+ )!+  !B >+)+! ) ! ?$PQ!$>* D D55@     "! = !9  )+  " I"! !C+9  +! )"R < )*! =""*)+!!")+!B"!" ))+ ""*+O B< = ! ! * ">  " '! ))! "" "! )+O < !"!  C"!   )  ! !+""9 ?  +!  ""   "! ++" ++!+  ""! < B< " < 7)  !B>+)+!)! !! "!!"0!!!!*( )'!)+!!!!'B9+!)!!"!!, ) !' * !" A"  *  )+ ""*+ " ('  ) *+"+= +)+!!";!"926425D"258<9  C!>>!R  !+)"R     S)  #     

 >!) !+"!!I""">+= !"*(/(>>>+)+! )! !C!>>

 123..14556