Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/670/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/670/2007 Généré par l'IA

Licensing Board Disciplinary Action Affirmation

Numéro de cause ATAS/670/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case addresses several claims regarding professional licensing, specifically contesting regulatory actions taken against the petitioner by the licensing board and subsequent administrative rulings. The court determined that the board's initial findings and subsequent penalty determinations were supported by substantial evidence and complied with relevant statutes and administrative procedures, rejecting arguments that the board's interpretation of the governing rules was arbitrary or that the procedural requirements for imposing sanctions were violated, thus affirming the board's disciplinary action.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Licensing Board Disciplinary Action Affirmation: The court determined that the board's initial findings and subsequent penalty determinations were supported by substantial evidence and complied with relevant statutes and administrative procedures, rejecting arguments that the board's interpretation of the governing rules was arbitrary or that the procedural requirements for imposing sanctions were violated, thus affirming the board's disciplinary action.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
sanction disciplinaire procédure d'autorisation condition de recevabilité sanction administrative confirmation de compétence arrêts en appréciation de validité

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/4630/2006
Statutory Interpretation of Professional Licensing Authority and Administrative Penalties
A/2961/2007
Judicial Review of Professional License Suspension Upheld
A/1189/2004
Judicial Review of Professional Licensing and Conduct Agency Decisions
A/4144/2006
License Revocation Upheld for Material Misrepresentation
A/1685/2008
Judicial Review of Professional Disciplinary Action

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

           "#$#$"%&&' "'(&"%&&(



 !) )*)  ) *!

+,- .

 /# 0  %&&( 



 !"#$"%"$ % &   ' 

%

((  (   () ) &   %!"  ( (  (&  *!+,  

         !    

   )0-3)  

) !

+4   #  %5%"  "$ %  *66  %#4  #$%  %  %%  74 8%"" % 66" 9  %% $:   ((   (      &;;   (  ( (  < (=)$:& >4

04  " +,?%0112& >6#"%%$ "6%5 (- - - &- !%  $ 8%""  %% @ $   %  "$ % 9 38.+1 64 .A $ 8" 011. 6  !%%6 4 %% "%6 "!!% +1!0112 8%%"6@ %%5 "%!% 2B8.2+64%5% 20821164

.4  "  !C! D  &   6#"  %% "6%5  $ 8"011B9282A364AA6 "5 "%!% A3821164 =  # +11 64 6">4 %% "  "%"   %  %#% 6 866$$" $ %4

B4 $"%" $  &    '   8%""  6!" $$% % .1?%01124%%%#%$"011.% 011B  !%6 @ 8 !%% 6 85% %#" 866 % @  *66 %  % $ #%4  :E @ $  %5%"  *66  %#  "$ %""E +A8/2/64!%F@%98%5%""%%  8#$%%  7  % 66" $:   ((   (  (  4

A4  "  02 $%!G 0112  &   D%" 8$$%  !%6 @ 8%""%66"$: 8$ #%5%" "$ %%@$ $8%8 !%%6@!!@"""!%@8 %4   8  !!% %6%5 %5  %  5 "   4  :5  $ @ 8%""  8% $ $$"9%#% 866 8 !%%64

24 01%G01128%""$"%"$! %%D%%4  %% $ 5 "%" %#" 866 $ 8 !%% 6 ! E 5 ! "  ! 8!$H%4  !   %6%  "  %#%%9 8 !%%64

34 "$ .15!G0112& %! @ $  " "6%5%6"% % +/%G0112$ @6#"%% $8"011B9080,264BAG"  5  0,8,11 64 %% "  6% % 9  !!% 6 %6%5 A%G0112!%%%#% 866EG $ 5 A3823264$011B4



-././-0112  ).-3)   ,4 "$@ +A "!G0112%#$@8 !%%6     "  %  0/ 5!G 0112 $ @     %% $   " %  !$H% 9 $  A1I4  $$ @  %#% 866  8 !%% 6  %G%  6% % 9  !  D%6%6 % "$@86 85%$ 6 ! @8  " 9 "!% $  %4   : :  @  $%5%#%5G54

/4  $@  + 6"5 0113  &  :5 @8 % " $  " !!@" $  %%" 6 % !C! $  %#% 8664$% 4

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

++4 @C%  G%$ %$ G 8"011. %674

+04  !% % "%" !!@" 9  &   %  3 ! 0113 %  $% 5@" 9  #:!    !$% $  %  0+ ! 0113 9 @  &   8% 9 5 $ $"%"4  ! % %#$"@G011.@8$ %%@"%"



-././-0112  )B-3)   "%G $ 8 6  9 8%%%  8 !%% 64  $: D%6%5 ! " 8J% $ "%" 6 9 %!$ 8 !%% 6 85%%#" 8664

+.4 8 8  GE "9DE4



) *!

+4 6!"!%98%4A24+%4*4+ G%   K%  % @  %%% $"5 9 L%4 A2    6" "   $% E""  %     2 %G 0111 = >@%%596" "L)5%55%  01 "!G+/B2= (>4

(!$"%$DE  L$:%"%G4

04    % %"  5E  + D5 011. %K%  ! 6%  !G $% "E   !   4 (  $!%"$% 5@ %8$$@ %C%%*"9!: $$@:E$$G%5E!!%M 6%D @!% "%!%%$ %= &+.10.1 4+4+F ..A 4+40F &+0/B 4+40F &+03B23 4++02+.2  4BG%"6">4:E $" @%98$$@% "5 :D %"5E= &++3/. 42G++0.21  4BF  +//,N.3$4.+2 4.G>4 L$$@   L$:4

.4 %D%"   6! % " $%   % 5G =%4 A2 % 21  >4

B4  %E     %%  $  % $  " 011.%011B4

A4 5$5% 8%5%"%5 "$ %!$ %%5  %5 % @  "!"% $  %5 !$   %% "$ % =%4 / 4 +  (>4  5 $5% 8 %5%" %5  "$ % %  $% $$ EE"  8%$ % "%!" $  %%"6%%!!@"# !$%=%4/4 . (>4

$  + D5 011+  %%    %% (- -    "$ % %  $  %5%" %5 % !  J%:! $%! (8%400 (%5E $+D5



-././-0112  )A-3)   011+  %% % 6#" $ *@ "  %%4 8"  %%$ 98"5=4+>45 8" %% "%!G "%% #!!# %% " =4 .F 5  %4 01/ 40 % 0+1 4 + % 0 &>4  %%  $#O%%5%" "$ %@%66"  !$% ! %#%%"6% !!@  %" %%=%4034++:$* (>4

6!"!% 9 8%4 0. 4 +  ( $ "%G  5 "%!%  %%" 6 %  6 %   %#% $"  6  8!$H% 6" " %4  %%  $% $$ EE"  8%$   %#% $"  6  8!$H% %  $%" # 5  "$%% %%4    !$% % " $  "  %%"6%=%40.4B (>4

8$:D$ %%%#%6%$"!"6!9"%"F %%$"!$%$%C%6!"@$ 6%4:@  !$% % " $  " 6 % @  DE    #!  $$ @!%  "    @% 9  "E%"DE%8"%  " %#%%"6@ ) %%   !6% % ?!% $5" @8 % $G  %6 8!G"  8 8!$  % !$% 8""!%  6%  $%!%:6! "%!%$ 4  % "E   !$ %  8#%%  8 %#% 6  66% $4 "%!% 5%66%%P*@!G#%%" 6%8$$%%$DE  $" )!C! 9%#%48"#O%%5%"%5 "$ % % 6 5 %!%: %#%)566%@)$%5   %% ( )  $!    $"  D  6 = &++1,2 4B%.314+12+.1 4++10.1 4.F( +//3$402 40G%"6">4$$%6 %E%  !!% 6 8$$@% "E!%    %#% 8664     !$% %  DE   %)"$!!%66 "%#% 866 $"6G@)%!$"@8%#%"%G $"  8%)9) $$$%9  ":%= +/,,$4 .0+%"6">4

24 8$:%%$ $8"011.%"%"6#" G   !!%  8 !%% 6 # %!  @  5$5% 8%5%" "$ %011.8":592B8.2+64%+A8/2/  G""6 $ 8%5%"  *66  %# %  $% 5%  +/8,,+ 64 % B,8./064 G""6$8#$%% 6"$%5%EE""%%  0/80+ 64  *66 $ % 9  %#% 6  @8 $$% 



-././-0112  )2-3)   !%$ %$%@%%"64 8% :9D% %% @ 8%!" 8% 6 "   % !!% %  8$$%% $  DE  $" 9%%#%4

 %#%% 8"011B  5 " %  +/ %G 0112 @ G @  8 @% $ %  6%  $"" %4 %% %#% % 6 "   !!% %6%5  8%%"6 %" A%G0112@!!@"5 A38232 64$8"011B"%%$""@88E% 8%#% 866 $4 "@6#"%%$ %6 % !%" 5!!@"%0,8,1164

 %9%"E @85%6%8GD% 8%#% 866$ 8 !%%6@885%$%%"!%%@%%6%% !$%G96 @85%$!D%6%6@$ 8 !%%6%!$%4

  G ":5@%%%"  66%"5   6  % 8%%%  $%   "*"% EE  $G%"4  8 ! $ ! @  %#% 866 8 $ "%" %%"  % @8 % %"  64   "%% :  " $  !!%  8 !%% 6 6!"!% 9  D$  $$" $4  %  $%  !$%  !%"  5  8 $ $" " 6OG%4

34 5 @$": $%@8C%D%"4





-././-0112  )3-3)  

  1*!  !) )*)  ) *!

 

  2,

+4 "5G4

 2

04 D%%4

.4 %@$" %E%%4

B4 6!  $%   @L $5% 6!  %  $"% C%   "  .1 D :  %6% $:  G 6" " =(*QR*6@2211B  >$5 !%:  % $G6!"!%#%4,0 6" " G6" " +3 D 011A = &>F  !"!   %  @   !%6 % !J $5%$%E% % ! %F % C%  "  G 6" " $ 5 $%  $ 5 "%@ #  %  8%4 B0  &4  $"% C% %  $:  $  %5@"!!!J $5 5%C%D%9854  E66:  " %T         (J5 S 7  



$6! $"%C%%%6"#$%@L9L666" " $E66





-././-0112