Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/668/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/668/2005 Généré par l'IA

Multi-Party Financial Dispute Summary Judgment and Interlocutory Appeals

Numéro de cause ATAS/668/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

This decision addresses various motions related to a complex, multi-party dispute involving financial relationships and alleged breaches of duty. The court considered numerous interlocutory appeals, motions for summary judgment, and other procedural challenges raised by different parties concerning claims such as breach of fiduciary duty, fraud, and contract interpretation. The court's reasoning largely involved applying established legal standards to the voluminous factual records presented, often denying summary disposition where genuine issues of material fact remained, such as the extent of control exerted by one party over another or the specific intentions behind certain transactions, while granting relief where claims were legally or factually unsupported by the evidence adduced.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Multi-Party Financial Dispute Summary Judgment and Interlocutory Appeals: The court considered numerous interlocutory appeals, motions for summary judgment, and other procedural challenges raised by different parties concerning claims such as breach of fiduciary duty, fraud, and contract interpretation. The court's reasoning largely involved applying established legal standards to the voluminous factual records presented, often denying summary disposition where genuine issues of material fact remained, such as the extent of control exerted by one party over another or the specific intentions behind certain transactions, while granting relief where claims were legally or factually unsupported by the evidence adduced.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
décision incidente interprétation de l'arrêt manquement au devoir transaction financière questions procédurales contrat fiduciaire

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied to impose the costs of the federal judicial proceedings on the appellants.
Généré par l'IA
A/3215/2005
Summary Judgment in Complex Financial Contract Dispute
A/45/2007
Complex Financial Transactions Litigation
A/1222/1999
Financial Transactions and Collection Disputes Appeal
A/188/2005
Financial Transactions and Contractual Dispute Liability Appeal
A/1115/2006
Contractual Disputes and Payment Obligations Appeals

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied to impose the costs of the federal judicial proceedings on the appellants.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



               #$%&'#())& #+#()),

""

- ".-   /   -"  /.

0 1 &  $% 2 ()), 



 3333333333 !"   # $%& ' 

' 

.  /  ! 4/.  5/ !( * *1 !' )* +,' --./0-00   -

           !"     4-2.4  

 6.

05 !'* 6666666666    1) 0.7+    88   '*  96666666666 #  :*4;  '* <  =*  ( '1 ) >  * ( / ?&*-,,0'*1) (@A3.,B5 *CB'*D''   ( &*(-EB&*-,,05

-5  '* ( 0, (1) -,,- D1'F  **  '   '  /0 ?&*-,,/'*'''1*=5

/5 D D  **  > D'BB*  ' ( D1'* :*4;  <  . ?&* -,,/ (1(>)B**(*(1* (GH18(;0B&*-,,/5

+5 B*G(*'(* B'   (D*1) (@AE,,B5'*  (D* (@A,@EB5.,5

@5 (**'(-E'I -,,/* '8&'*(GH18:*4;  <  B  &1  (D*(1*  ( GH18 > D  1' *B =D* D&*   '   & ( &1  BB *B (D * 1   (  **'((' * *'(*J1'*5

75 ( (-. 1)-,,/DB'1''* *'>(**'* 5 B* &'*) =D* * '*('* ' '*(D 1'  (@A,,,B5=**&* *  1*> * B*(**'; = &*  *) D1) ( *  '*5 D D *  ' B'*  '*((* '* =* * >D'=*=*( *'(**'( '*=*D *  /,?&*-,,/5

 J'*=D*D&* KD *('*'(  -,,0   -,,-  *' ( (*BB*  B**; '   ' 1'F   =  1'   ' K &*    8*;1  **   *B ( )* (  '* 5 D* 8*  (   * * &*    &* >& ('115

35     ' 1 > D  & ( '1  )* ' '  (1'    &1  ( * ( ?&* -,,- > ?&* -,,/ ** =  ? *B* *B  *B  '( ( * ( &  ?&* -,,/5  *  81  (1(  & ( (1G  * ; (  * ( '1 *' #B*(F' * *''*'((*5

E5 '*(@?&*-,,+D*(*=>  =*  '((*&?&*-,,/&*  FG' 1*(D =*  > D1'F5   *   L   1 ( '(* ( *; '1 ) '&     (  B*    *(*= =  (*& * & *' ;('1 )D&* )' *5



203+/2-,,+  4/2.4   .5   D '((* 1 >D1'F*'1 )' 1*;? *B* *&*5

0,5 D)('('1 )*4* '&'==* ( 1'*  (&     > = *  ( &'* ( D* 8*  ( *; '1 )1*'D )*1 ()*>D*'(1(* ( ' ;5   '   '1  * ( / &* -,,+ (= *   = D* K*1 (@A,@EB5.,'-,,-5

005  (**'  ''* *' ( 0, ?*  -,,+     ?   1 *' B'1D5

0-5  (  ( 0E 'I  -,,+ D  ' ; ( *)  ' (  '*     =D* &*  )   )* 'G ' * '11 ' ' 11 (( *'B*5

0/5 '(03 1)-,,+D* *1=' D&*  B'*  *; 1   ( '&  &1  BB *B (D *   =D'1* '11 '* * *&GD8   B*8   (  * =  *   '( 8 *B ?=D '&1) -,,-5   &  * =D  *  B*8*  (  '1  (  '*   B& ( '    =  ( *' J *1H  (D & 1 ( @AE,, B5  ' * *    & (   *'BB *&(*5

0+5 ( (00' ')-,,+' =D*&* BB *&1  'G '*'11D  ( *'('1 )>D* *1 ='( (**&*  &'(*=*( *'('* 5

0@5 '*(-7' ')-,,+D* *1* ( 1((**' ''* *'5

075  *'    '&'= '1 *' '0(1)-,,+5 ' 'B*1='0/;1**&* ?1* & =D* A&* KD* 8* ('**'((*BB* B**;( '* M*K+A,,,B51'*-,,0 +A-,,B5-,,-5#';* F*  ' *  G B'*    B'* B'*  * &1 5'((*B*8'11*('1 (  '*    *    F >  *=*( *' (  '* 5   * ( @.A3+3 B5 3/ ''(*  >  ' *  ( * *1F  -,,0   -,,-5 D* *1&= B*8* (1*)*/0(1) -,,-    = L    '  '11  *   = (  '( )* 1*   B*(**    DF B*8*  5  '    '&* (*' J (L 5



203+/2-,,+  4+2.4  

035 ' (   *'(* )*D1'F 1* *) (    N( *' (  *   '11K  :N <  0+ (1)-,,+=' K*(+,A,,,B5(01-,,0 /0(1)-,,0 (@,A+,,B5'D-,,-5

0E5 #* >D(*('1 *'''  1* *) (( *'B*'0... -,,/&*( J *' '-,,, -,,-'  ( &***=* *  *& (* #&-,,0 -,,-5*=D*(* J '*  B*  * (I   '  * BB *&1  K ( '  = (  '  ( D -,,/ * D&*   (  * ( * K5  1'   (    * ( * &*    &  ' ;   '1 ('* ;(**BB*?&*-,,/(' =D (;&1 '* L  '&(1((D' ('1 5

0.5 '*(0+B&*-,,@  &=( *'(* &D1'F' B'   (D*1) (+A,,,B5 ' -,,0   ( +A-,, B5 ' -,,-   =D ('1   B*  B >  &  &1  (D* ( ' * *' '*  B& ( D*   -,,/5   81  '   =  * ( J  '*  B*  *   & = *  = *  ' * > D #    = '  ?*(( *)B((('1 (*>D #  ( *'B*' * * &BB* (&1  BB *B(D*5

-,5 '&'1 *''( * '&'=-@1*-,,@5  '  =* D *  B*  J  *     ' &'  =  *(*= = ' *  D&*    '&     *' ( *  '(*  &  ( *' (D*1H    = 4* &*    (1( J  '*  B*5 #D8*  (   * ( @.A3+3 B5 3/ &  '   ?&* -,,/  *    &  G   *=*( 5     =  >  '**   '( *' ( ('1  ')  =  >   *' ( *  -,,0   -,,- '11  =*  ( * *8 D**='1 )*('* '5 (*-/?*-,,@ '(' '('('1 =*5

-05  0/ ?* -,,@  '   '(*    *B*  ( * '   -,,0 -,,- 1*D(1**  *'B*(=*' =* )  * (/-A,,,B5'-,,0 (7.A7,,B5'-,,-5

--5 D* *1  '   =  '  D&*   '   & ( &1  BB *B (D *   B&    *  (  1 (  (**'  ''* *'(07?* -,,+5

-/5  8(>?85



203+/2-,,+  4@2.4    "/.

05 '*8&'*D'8* *'?(***:< 1'(*B* * * (; 0'I -,,/ *) '('*'1'(@?8 (' *(  &*4*( @  07?8: 50 5  @7 <5

#* >D *'(D *'(07?8 *)B( -3?&*-,,+: N0/,0,7<( '*8&'*(' 0/B&*  (*'* *' * '*8 1   *) '( '* ( *8   > '* ?8 * *  ( D   ( D *'('&J?85

-5 'B'11  > A 5 @7  5 0  5  G5 E   *)  ' ( '*'" * *=('   *'&>D * @7('* *8('*: <=*'  *& >  '* B(  D4GH18 ')*8 '*   D*(1*    (D*'&)** (-@?*0.E-: <5

#'1 '?8((D; ** )*5

/5  ? ((* B'1&'*' &): @7  7, <5

+5 * *8' ('* (' >(  *'(D4GH185 D8*    ** ( ( 1* D*  J   *&*  '1* > ' * *' ( *J1'*1'*(*1* ((*4(5

@5 #' D 5 0/ 5 0   :(    &*8 ?=D /, ?* -,,/ *)D;<*=*(*1* ((*4(: 5.5/ <  J (  *J 1'*  1'*   *&*  '1* > ' * *' 1*   '(* *' *&>*'((' * *'5

75  *&* '1*>' * *'*B  ( '  *&* (A( * > A')  *' (A & '1* > ' * *' (   ( (A '  ( &*:G(O'11 C1 )* '&*G88 CP Q '1  '  E (  5 0/   5 03,<5 AJ* BB *B (A  *&*  * BB*11  ' H) '11 J*8 =* ('*  L   *B*  ' (1  =  '(* *'  *& >  *'( ( ' * *' '  1* : N 00/  /@-M   0... R 0E 5 0,0 '*(5 -    BM G'1 )1 )* '&*G8 * S #GT*C*G (&T 8G  P#Q 57+G515070 ' R/-@ /-7<*1*=81 =A**  1  & &*5 '=*AF(A *&* '1*> ' * *'  A) (A 1 *' & > A :  -,,0 R -3 5 --@<5( *'(A*1H  B'1*(**8A ( *



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

35 ('1*('*?8B'((**'B(*'* *' ' * (  '*   B*  =* B  (AL   )* ( 1*; *B ) * '11&*1))A 4>4(*=*  (8( &*1)'( 5BB* ('=AB* *L '*( 1 '11GF' G;'*)51* '1 (B* 8 '&*8)?8('* G  *J=***  ')): N0-7/7,'*(5@)0-@0.@'*(5- B<5 * AJ* 4 4*   ('*  (  '*  ** ' = A(1**  *''?8(&*   ((' B&(A: N 0-7  /-- '*(5 @<5  *  '(   8*   ** *=** '* ' =  B*   *  (   ('*&  L  '   (A'BB*?85!***A )'5#'   *  (&'* (  * ( ')' > A*  *' ( ABB*5 *4* '1(   ** A')*8 *' (  * (A'  (  1 'U    L  *')1 J*8(A&'11( (* *8  B* *&'=B (='**= ((&'*' '=( A)(&: N0-@0.@'*(5- B<5  E5  '('(' '(*  '  ( &*=* ** > '*  96666666666 #  (;  / ?&* -,,0   =* &'F*   * 1) (@A3.,B5 *CB'*DD&*( J *''-,,-B*    (D&) (7.A7,,B5* *  *&(*1 (*' -,,0 ( = * '  =  * ( '   *  ( /-A,,, B5  ( *' ( * &  D1'F > D  *' (  * ( '1 *''U" *'' (+,A,,,B5*'( (01-,,0>B*-,,0'*( *B* (*'-,,0



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

 *   (  ( '  **   *B ( )* (  '* (D)'('1'  (@.A3+3B53/*'1'  (/,D/++ B5.-''('( *'(' (1* 1>



203+/2-,,+  4E2.4   L  '( >  '*  *  (&*   ' ( '(    *&  '( ( * (I5  *( ( & >   8( =  '11 ( * ' & D=*&  *  1* 1'   ' * > * B*8    (J*;1 &*' ( )*5    8(   ( (J &*' (*BB    ' (* '*  B (&*  L  '( >  = D*  &*  (' ' =A*  *8'*   '= ?*(*=  J* *' '& '&  L  '*11  ' '  B*  ( BJ*'  *: N0-0+3'*(5-00@0+/'*(5E<5 D' (' B*8 *B()* ('* ''(* ('  H >L =D>*5

 1*;(*; B*8 ('*=* ' *     = (&(&1 BB *B(*1 ( *( '*'  *) ( ( ')  '  (8 (  &*1) '(  DJ* BB *B (D  *&*  * BB*11  ' H)  B* =** 1  &:L $5(.1*-,,0 -3.2,,<5  B*( *'('1 ) *;B'**4*>D* *1 1    '  (D'   & ' > '   1'* ( ( &*1))&1 BB *B(D* 8*  ' 5 BB  '1 )*(*=='1 )**  * BB )(('1  1*   *  '  D) ( *;   *(* *'5 #D8*  ( * ( '  * *(*= = '  '1  * (  '*   ' V* KW'11 (@A,@EB5.,5D('  ( * (&1 (*' 5  0/5 !8  '1) '*' ('  '  ( '(* ( *;    (&1 (*'11(&('1 )*''  (=* (**8*41L1'(1*('*' ( *;  *& > ( (1G  * ; (  N  '  *1 (' * *''*'((*K*D 1 (D'   & (   *' BB *&   8*; (D * * ( &1 (D*(* ('* '= ' '= (D)(&: N0-@0.@'*(5- B<5  '1B'(('* L ? 5



203+/2-,,+  4.2.4    "  /.6  ".-   /   -"  /.



789   :  ;   <= $*( / >

  9 

05 K'* '5

 9

-5 ? 5

/5 * ='( 8 * 5

+5 B'1   * (  =D &  B'1 ' '     L  (  (* ( /, ?' (;  ' *B* *'  * '11( (  *) B( (  #GT*CG'B=* 7 7,,+     '* J1*5  (*    L  ''85  11'* ('* S < *(*= J 1 =(**'' (*') ** ((**'  =M )< J' ' = 1' *B *  *1 '&'* (1(     (**'M < '   *8  '  ( '   5 #*  11'*  ' *    '* 1  1 '   < )<   < *4(  *)B((' 1 *;'=D* (&(*&)511'*('1 *''1'F ( & =* '  ?'*  ** =  (**'  =   D&' ( = J(*' : 50/-0,7 0,E<5  8BB*  *( S     * # *       *4?* S    G*   ## 

 '*'B'1(   L  ' *B*J * # * (D  > D''1*8BB



203+/2-,,+