Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/646/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/646/2004 Généré par l'IA

Statutory Disclosure Requirement Retroactivity Dispute

Numéro de cause ATAS/646/2004
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The matter concerns whether a specific section of a statute, which concerns the disclosure of certain financial transactions, applies to a plaintiff's claim seeking damages related to an alleged deceptive business practice, where the practice predated the statute's enactment but continued afterward. The court reasoned that the statute's language did not expressly indicate retroactive application, and applying it retroactively would result in an impermissible retroactive imposition of liability for past conduct; therefore, the statutory claim based on that section could not proceed.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

; PRÉVOYANCE PROFESSIONNELLE SELON LA LPP ; RENTE D'INVALIDITÉ ; AI(ASSURANCE) ; PRÉVOYANCE PROFESSIONNELLE ; COORDINATION(ASSURANCE) ; SUSPENSION DE LA PROCÉDURE | LPA.14

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
condition légale déclaration de la situation financière objet du litige rétroactivité de la loi hypothèque légale du vendeur d'immeuble statut en droit international privé

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Provision cited in the dispositive concerning court costs.
Art. 64 LTF
Provision cited in the dispositive concerning the granting of legal aid.
Généré par l'IA
A/816/2004
Statutory Interpretation of Retroactive Application of Financial Disclosure Law
A/4283/2006
Settlement Disclosure Statute Retroactivity in Injunctive Relief Cases
A/1310/2004
Statutory Disclosure Requirements in Commercial Transactions
A/1951/2004
Statutory Citation Retroactivity Dispute
A/739/2005
Statutory Financial Disclosure Compliance Dispute

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Provision cited in the dispositive concerning court costs.

Art. 64 LTF

Provision cited in the dispositive concerning the granting of legal aid.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

               %&'(%)+,), -%.+.%)+

 -

 -  /-   / / 

)0  12  " 1 )+ 3 )+ 



" 4444444444 !" !#    !" $"% "&&'("&



"!

/     54444444444)*!"!+,-! "( *" !!* !" !# .$" % "&&'("&/



          !"  #"$

   6+076  

 6 -

1/ #! 8888888888 96 !:  !!"; (  1,47 & ""( !"*  ("(  <(  !: & =8888888888 &  1,,5/   ("(   "( & "!$ &  1,,>  -  !"!" " ( - 45? &:   &%"@!+551A-!"!"" ( :"& &B+55+/

+/ !!"&( (&&& !"" &!1,,,' &(   !: "!" -  !B" &% "" & !" & %AA " & %!6$&"( 96 !:  ; & +4 B" +551 " -  &(&!"&11A($!!+55+!&"&6!"!@&% "C &%"$"( & 45? &   1! B$! 1,,,  ' & !"  ("! !B""A"/

2/ !:" - %"!" ! %   =8888888888 " !(&( -  "!" (& '  &(  "" -  C !" & ! 8888888888  ! +555 ' &(!"  ! ! & "!$  ("" !/

3/ '"!!"!:*!"$-%$&"( !A @ C!(& &45=8888888888"$!(!!"&:B +55+!"":!&%$&"(/

4/ ! !!! & > D" +552  =8888888888 " A!(  !!" '% ! &  &( & %  AC" %$&"( - 45? " & A" '  !E !($ %("" !($ '% +557  =8888888888 &&"  !(C &  &!/ !:" "  F B!  %&!" - ! !$ (&  ! &&" & !(C!  &! ""  " "" & A" ' %$&"( !A $" ("( !&( - "!"  !!"%<" 45/

7/ !&(&+,D"+552=8888888888"A!(!!"' &*!( &%$&"( &$" F"! & "( -  &(&( ! %  " !( ! ('"-45?&!"' &%$&"(!"!$- !"!&1!  "@!+552=8888888888!G"-""&&&!@!" &"! 6 !G/

H/ #*!(  !""" (!" " && &%C " & !!"  =8888888888 " " ! " & !" '  !!"    !@ & (  &" & +3 A($!! +553 &% &&  "/  " -  '  &!" -  !" ":!  " ! &   1!  "@!+552< !!" ("!"$!($"(!F" & 4?  '% " & &( /  &:!  !(( '  " &%$&"( !($ !  !:*" &   &  =8888888888 (""

 01+2340+555  62076    !* '  & %!6$&"(  =8888888888  "  ( !&(&% /#C&$"%(!"!%!! ' %C !" & ! 8888888888    !":! ! & "" ! ! &%"$"(/   =8888888888 " ! ! &( & !" ":!  "&(&%  $"!$!! !:!&(/

>/   !(  & +2 $! +553  .&" & !($< I  &  =8888888888J 96 !:  & ; "  !B" &  &&/  C ' ' %" ! !!! '  "C &%$&"(  ("( AC( - 155?  !$ (& & =8888888888 <" C(  &&  (""  &% $&"( !A   & %!"/ +1 & !:*"  @C <(K*(&45!($/'%%*"$(!"(&% $&"( !  "( & *   & %!"/ +5 & !:*"  " &%$&"( " @@ -  !($" & %!6$&"(/  (' &  $"$@"!$! !:!&( "  A&! !  "C &%$&"( !" ! % /  & "!  !" $!(&&A"&"C&%$&"( !% /

,/  !!"<"(*"""(&(&%  !(&!" "" &"  ":! &%   !: & !@ & (/ "" !(&!$'(&& !" !&&"! >B+553"""!&%"!"/

15/  !(" AA!  (*" A" %@B" &% & &  !" & &"! -  F &"/  ""   !!"  & '%  %*" &&%$&"( !A&"&%K* %("" ! / !"" !(&(-(E*&$!'" &  & !("B'%-&!"B*(":!&%!6 $&"(/ !"%("" &%!&"!! " !@ AC(&(C !"+4B+553 !&("!"!'"&  /

11/ ! !!! & , B +553   &   ! ( '  " &%$&"( ("" &"' -  ' !($" &   ! %!6 $&"(  @" B&C &  &!  !(" !(&! B'%- &!"  &  !(&!  ( !:"/    "!!  "  &(@"" ! "   & &&! ("" !(( '% !(&!" ! -  & "" &  !"" & %E< "E: L  !@ & ( &$" &""!  ":! &%!6$&"(  "C  (!!-45?/

 ! (!"! & +4 B +553  &&! %"  ( -    &  / &:!@"' B"A  !&C !/ % !" ! '  " &%$&"( " 'M !!" &

 01+2340+555  63076   !:*" &   &  "  !* '  & %!6 $&"( & !" '   &  %"  ( !  &( & % "'%('F !@&(&$"A!! &(&% AC""C&%$&"(-45? & !  &  &$" !"!  @( !  "C &%$&"( & 155?/ C:" !' &  $" !$!&( &  ! L &% !"  &( & %  $" ("( !& "(!!" &%"! !" '%  %*"  &% !!!  & % "&&%C !"&*"( !=8888888888/

1+/ !:"C !"&(!"! ! &14B"+553 !@*!&(-B*!!'"& /

   -

1/   *$ ! M!*" B&! 9 N  + 54;  ("( &A( "  ""( &:  1! D" +552  !@ " & ! / A!(" - M!" 2 ( 2 & & " "!"!   "!&"$"M"!($*!&" &"&$"  " & !!  ":! &M O " &M  " ("( "! &MAA  !@"&!""""'9A/!" 47;/ ("& !@&("("@ !B*!& &M :/

+/ O%*" &% && & " @( !  !"/ H2 / 2  42 & !:*"& & =8888888888"47/1@&& "!$@-A!/

2/ C"!&%!"/13&*$! !(&!&"!"$9 ;  !(&! " F"!  & !'  !" &( & &  " &% '" & "! $ (  &"!"$ &" &$"  "! "!"( B'%- &!"  !  '"/  A!"!    "6 @!'&C" &"&$"FB!&"/

C"!&B! !&A(&(! "&%$&"(&& &  !($< !A @*"! "  !   F ' & %!$&"(9A/ .114 *+14N .11> *35;/  %"""& !($<" ! ( !%($"&%$&"( ! %AA "  -  ' "" ($" % ! &%@( "@9 .114 *+14N .11> *24;/

  ":! & !($< !A @*"! & !(   !  !($< !A  '" & C*  & !" '  """ & !($< $" (!*!  " (* " B! !&" & %$&"(  !P"!  &!" -  !" $&"(

 01+2340+555  64076   !'6"&%&*!(A(!!-C!" ! / & "" !  <": &%($" & %$&"( &AA(!" &  & % /   !"'  !"! ! C   " &% "( !A !&!" &(A  % "( &%C!! %"$"( !A E@" "  "!" ' %$&"( & %  9A/ !!&   %$&"(& !($< !AB! !&& !@ &!$&%! *15+6114;/

3/  % :  !:*" &   &  !($"  &CQ &% !" %$&"( &" I !  "( & *J !($ - %!"/ +5 ' "!$  "I!'! !"&"!$&%AA("!(( !'- "&%&&%&"%AA(%" !&%C!! A" "(!!   "! "KE ' !!" !@"  F"! A( "&(@"&% "(& *' !$'(%$&"(("" !(& & !""JN&%"! !"%$&"(&" !A I!'! !"&"!$&%AA(K*(&45!($<"'&C &"""!(( !% <!-"&%&&% &" ! ' %!( %"   ! &%C!!  A" "(!! " '% "! "$"(  " !@"  F"! A( ! % <!J !($-%!"/+1&!:*"/

   !!   &*!( &%$&"( " & "( !'  &" @" & &A" @"" "" !' %  & "  !""9!"/+5/+&!:*";/

 "" $&"( ! I "( & *J !! & & - %$&"( ! !" & * ' P" !(("     <": &%($" & "" $&"((""F '!:*"!$C&(&% /

 &C:$&"( !A" !*% ''%C  <(K*(&%45/

   !P" & &% !" ' %" AA"$" ! !!! '   &    '(  !!"  %$&"( &" !A '% % ! "   &"/  ('   $" !$!  &(@(!(""&A"!!(/%"! !" &  %"  " &% '!  !("" & $"*" "  & %  A! " & ""! '%    A"(/  "!  !@ & (   "&B! !&A(&(!%(!" ":!& !"" &%($"A" !% !'%!! &CC*& B! !&/

  !(&!!"$-AC"&!"&%$&"(& !%  " ""  ! &%"!" " $  &AA(!" "A $'( 6

 01+2340+555  67076   &   B"A &  &!  !("  & %""" & !" &  !(&! /

 / - 6  -  /-   / / 

" " 1

718   9  :   ;$ <.) !=

  8 

1/ (!&&!$@/

" 8

+/ O & !(&! "&%!"/13 B'%-&!"&  0171>0+55+6+6 /

2/ A!  !" &  '% $" A!! !! "!  !(" !!F" &  &( & 15 B! &:  "A" !  !&( &!(  !@ A(&(! & ! OERS!EA' 7 7553     "! C !/  &(  " F"! !*(/  (! &"Q ; &'! C""'&(!!"&(!@"!" &&( ""'(N @; C ! ! ' "A  " $! &&! "" "! &(N ; !"!  *"!   &  ! !(""/ O  (!  ""  "! ((" ((!(  ""! ; @; " ; 6&  !@ A(&(! & !  !!  "!!  ":! !  !! '% &$! &(!! !!$@/  (! & !! "! !  < & !$'!"B"'&(""'("%$ &' ("(C (&(!!"9!"/12+157"15>;/  *!AA!Q  !(&"Q       !! O @O 

 A!& !("!!F"""A(C !"'%-%AAA(&(! &! !*!AA

 01+2340+555