Contractual Condition Precedent Dispute
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe case involves a dispute concerning a contract provision stipulating that one party must obtain a specific written approval from the other before making certain modifications, but the party making the modifications proceeded without it. The court reasoned that the contractual requirement for written approval constituted a condition precedent to the modifications, and since the required approval was not obtained, the modifications were unauthorized, leading to a judgment in favor of the party seeking enforcement of the original terms.
Regeste Legislator
Généré par l'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Condition Precedent Dispute: The court reasoned that the contractual requirement for written approval constituted a condition precedent to the modifications, and since the required approval was not obtained, the modifications were unauthorized, leading to a judgment in favor of the party seeking enforcement of the original terms.
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IACited in order 8 to rule on the cost allocation.
Texte complet
#$%&%#'((' )#&*+#'((,
)
) - -)- -
'. /0 $% 12 '((,
3333333333 !" !# $ %&!" !!" '("))*(")
"!
44 -)- 5 -6 -7 )!) "( +,-./0
!"
831298
- 4 )
2: #) ;;;;;;;;;;!!"" !"<(=(0!!2,63"!!0( $ 2,>9: "" "!0( ""+ !/ ) '("&" ? "! ) 2,>, . 2,,- . " : !("( "("")"!0) 23)(&!2,,>:
3: )" ) 35 @0! 2,,- )( ( )) ) !"" ) '!80)"(0".'"!)'!"!)'!"?!)" )'?!):
4: ! !" ) 25 ! 2,,- () "!"" ! ;;;;;;;;;; )<"*(+)!0!"(&!&!!"!&""*")(<((!"= &! " &8!( !( )' ?! ) 68$2 () " !8() <?A +)! !0 )! !("A < 0< 0 ?)! "? !" ( )! &<B ) )"!0!==(0?C0<&"(!)(&"=&!+< *'(<"()&!=(!!:' "()"!0("""" ) 23 )(&! 2,,9 "0"( ) "( 0! !"! ) ?!< ! ) !"! < !) "" ! ! ("" ) "( . '("" ) "( ) '!(: () =!( !!* 0"DE'<")' "F") !&/) "'"0"(" 0" . "".)==!".=="!GHI:" " ! '!80)"( () <(: "" ("( 0!" ) &"( )'0<! ?<" ) "!0 ! ! ! +'"8.8)!)?!?!"0"(C) "(.8J 0" )! <( &! ) !(@) " 0" !"!0! ) "!"0"(()""K:
5: ! !""!()!)2>@0!2,,>! ;;;;;;;;;;C ( *'("")"() ""(""""!: '+0"(0" ) 25!2,,-:"(*)'("""' 0"0<! "0"(<!==!":="""="! ")="*'!( '0" "!0() 23)(&!2,,9:
6: '!( =="( "< )'&!0" != "! )'"(<!" !=)'!80)"(G8 !/ I)32 @29@"2,,,: ')"<L"! !="=!( 0"D E'(0" != ) "( !() ) #) ;;;;;;;;;; =="( ! L"! ) " . "( ) "!0 G!)"I ) >7 M !/ (!) ) !("!L" . '==!" ) *"! "" " ) "" "( )"!! !"")"!()"".0!D ) !") !)?!<&"( !""0"( :"0"( &"D
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
9: '!(=="()C/"<G"<$ I)47N"3,0&! 2,,,: )" "< ("( "!! )" ) 2> 0&! 2,,, ! )' !!J" () ("& ! () "!"": L"! ) !("!L""<(*'."'!('("""!() )(!? ) ! ! ) "!0 & * "0"( )( " "" . =" ) "(.("")"(:
-: '!( ("( .C !"() !) !=="( "! )'&!0" () ) '!80)"( . G8 !/ # I: ""="'&@")'C*"!?"<*- 3772 * )' C +?"!* , 3772: $ 'C !" +?"!'C !"( !(""+ "F)<()( !0 ("" !0( 0 ') ) "C ' ("" !"!"( " ! ("" )(!" &: 'C !"( !" ** =! "" !"/!" <(: 'C !" ( )<" 0"D +)! )!C "=! !"": !("" )" + ""< +?"!* ?! )! ?!*:/<)C !"!")<"0"0= " ! "( ) "!0D +)! )!C "=! !"" =! ) =&!+<: ' " ) 0 !?"<* '!(==!")&<+"").)==!.""!? *'C &! (!! " =(!! " & !)<* =="( =" ("" ) "!& ""* " )(<((!"= !: !("" ) )! )==)+"/"!0 !()*O ")=&!+<. ":' ")0<&C !"")(!(* "()
12345613777 851298 "!0 ) 'C !"( '(0" "" . >7M ) "0"( != (</! C" !" ) ?!< (!! . 26 P< " 0" !( (""= ) !?: ! "" * ' !)! " !"!" "0"( != ) ""+ !" ) "(: $ C !" 0 ) '(? ) )!/! ! ) !0! !=)!)!() ""("" !&&"!?O "" "" ""!"")="")* !") "0": ""&"0!==" "()!"="" ) (*&! *' ?"" 0!&&" 0! )(!<!: )(&" ) ) ) < )!( !"" . )(&! 2,,9: !" ("" !(!0( " " ) '""( ) + ""< )! )" <" "" * ) '& ) !@" ) '0!: )"="!0!'&) "?< +?"!** 0"J"! )(!(0"!)& !":
>: ! !" )'C ) $# ( G$!0 () !(< ) '!80)"(I! ;;;;;;;;;;(0(C*" !&)! !") # "(C<&)'"0"(?&" ) >7M 0 "" =" 0"D ) 0" !( (""=)!?" !"8.8=C ) !")?!< (!!.26P< " "!0C!):"!/&!CC !"*(*'C !" 0" ! )'C! """ . "( 0)": 0" ("( ! "" "( ) "!0 ) 37M ) '"0"( ?&" (!& !"0"() "(:
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
12345613777 861298 "0"( *' !"" . "!0! . 0"!: #J ) )! =" '"")!.)")!)":
27: ! )( ) 32 @ 3773 ' !=( "" !"" . '!( "= *' !("" "" "( ) "!0 ) 37M ) "0"(?&""*' 0"! !)!8.>7M(0""==!" !)" !")?!<C ":
22: !!!!)23N"3773'!(!!"!"")(" "))( .'"!)'!""/!)'0)"("&)!" . '!))'C !"()!?"<*" +?"!*: C *( * '"0"( ) ""+ *' C!R" . ("&" ? "! ("""0"(!)*' 0" C!!!))!: '" !(=(!( ! !" ) () "!"" ! ;;;;;;;;;; * '"" &)'C!!**"0"(: (@!""") ("" ) "( "" 0 ) =&!+< !)" """ !**"0"(: ) ! !(<!!" 0" !"*" ! "Q? "" * ("" ) ==!" ?+* " * "!0 ""+< ! <0"!: )0"J"!)( !!"=" !/"" ==!")0"'<!:$()"!"")0"J!"!"( !@!)'==(:
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
24: ) *)330&!3773!!"""(!("") # " !"())!!: =="""+
12345613777 891298 "!0" ! ) <!) != . '("&" ? "! )0" =="! ) "!0C 0 ) ! !) ""+! ) 0"! " ) !!"' !"! ?!=!(*"*("")"( !""" &" : = ' '0" " " ) ! !")!;;;;;;;;;;3/()"!""*""*( ) ) =&!+< ("" ) =!(*" " 0)" * !0" & 'C" )' <<!0" !<!0 ) ("" ) "(: 0"!("(C!!"0"(:
25: &!0")29)(&!3773' " "" *'C !() !(0)29"&!3773:
26: )" ) 2! N" 3774 ("( "! !& ) ( 0 )=")"!'!<"@)!:
29: !!!!)390&!3774 !&)( ( !*" $# ( !" )==(!" ((" ! )(!" ! !&=()(!)!G8 !/ S I)"!&"=! )!C:
2-: !( .!!!()"=!(!!*0"D 8 "!"!) !"(0"!" !(!&) !&)"( +?"!* !"! + "F ) <( )( !0 # : 8 '<" )' ==" ! ! ?!*<!0 C "( ! '!<)"": 8 !")'"(<!"*!"=: 8 !=""!())!""!0A)" ) !") =: 8 !"/!?!*))!()!&D !+)! )!C !*!( )"!"": 8 !() !())0+ "F"&(0"D + 0" ) ( ) )'<<!0" '==" )!" ) ! ( ?<" "&: "!& &@"= ) !? G"!& ""*")(<((!"=I(""!?O"" """'0" ?<( )!")!/!(: 8 0!< "! )! )(!" " !"" &!0(D '!( )*"! 0!=!?O)( R""))(?&" !": 8 (<" )'" )! C !"(!"* !"" 0<D ! '<"))!"?" !"*""" !") ! : "!& "=! )!C )! ("" )== " !! )".!< !"!C)!":
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
2-: !( )3-!3775!;;;;;;;;;;=!(!!* 0": $ "" !("" "!"! ) !"( 0 "!" !(!&)A'C"" )!&)"( +?"!*A'!( !("" )=="?!*! ! !")'"(<!"(0" !=" "!( ) ) !"/! ?!* ) ) !( )!&)!() !())0+ "F"& (0"A '+ 0" ) )0!< "! )! )(!" " !"" &!0( )'(<" )'" )! C !"(!"* !"" 0< )'& ) )) ) ) " "!/ )("!"0 " 'C !" &: ! "! "!0" ) <!) )0!<"!=!"=! ! """!!"") '/: + 0" (<" '(<" ) !) ?) <!( 0!" +? "": = )<!( ) "!& "=! )!C("".(0!:
2>: !!!!)60!3775' !"()"!") !(()"(!"!:
12345613777 8>1298 2,: ! !!! ) 33 0! 3775 !!" 0( *' + 0" ) "!/ !"")==(!"!!( )! ;;;;;;;;;;)$#(" ) ! ;;;;;;;;;; ()8"!"": . ')" ) !;;;;;;;;;;*'.'!))'C !" +?"!*:
37: ! !) ) 4 3775 !& ) ( !@"( )) )')" ) ! ;;;;;;;;;; ! " ) )) ) !!" ) '!))'C !" +?"!*"<!)(.@<!:
- )
2: <0 ! '!<" @)! GI ("( )=( " ""( )/2!N"3774 !&")! ()6 @<)" !()""08 !()"6 (""29@<! G!":2":!"69 I:
$".'")'(")29@<! ! !&=()(! 3- @0! 3775 G S 247 279I !) <0 ) "( 24 =(0!! ) " "!"! !<" !""" !& " ) ! ) (<! ! . "! @< ""! ) '""")'(")0C@<!:
$"""!!!))!" & !&=()(!)!!J")2! @"3775=!(*) ""!"!"""" !""(""=!)!!L")!"=()(!G!!J"2:2>413775I:
<")*")'""""() !& ") ! )(!( * !(" ) "!& 0" J"! !0=!)(!<"!))!"=()(!"'!!'!": 6- :
2. =!(".'!":4:4)) ""!"!"!)" 0"'"!(0<!)" )")0" " ) !! " ("( "! )'== !& " ) ! """"*!""""/!)'!8 0)"( G=: !" 69 I: $ (" ! @<! ) )' / " ("&:
4: !&)("""!*!!"!@"()=!" )((<C"!0&.=!=!("C!":9,)=()(! ! '!80)"( ) 2, @ 2,6, G I " >5 ) =()(! ! '!80"!00")37)(&!2,59G $I:
5: =()(!! !"<((!))!")!)9"&! 3777G I""!(0<!2!@0!3774""!L()="
12345613777 8,1298 ) &! ) " ) ) ) '!80)"(: (<"0<!@*'42)(&!3773)!""=)("!" ' /: ==")' !/@! !)(<" &) ?<")!/<))!"!"*(""0<!!)!(" ) '("" ) =" * )" J"! !(( @!)*" * ) (* @!)*G S23659-):2A239299):5&I="!* '"!"( ) !! " J"! ( . !! ) )! )' !()! ) !! ) )!" )"!"= ("" ! ! C * " !)" @*' " ) )( )"!"0 "< G S 232 499):2&I:) ") !""()!"!0& @*'42)(&!3773:
6: '!!'<"))("!!)<!()'0)"()!!"" (?(")!".) !"")'!80)"(:
9: C "! ) T!": 5 T0)"( " )" ) "( ) < !(( !" ) < )!( * !(" )T """ . "( ?+*" !0")T=!"(<(")T))T )":
T!( )!" . !" "/! T " 0) . 99 314M . )8!"T"0).67M.*!")!"T"0) .57MG!":3>:2 I: (&0)"()57M 0!)!".)8!"G!":3>:2& I:
$ @! !) ) !& =()(! ) ! G8 !/ S I '&@" ) '! '" '""" . "( A " "F" (*(**)(""' "()!(!< !"!0C<&G)' !"!0C?&" !"=I: " )'0)"( " " @!)* &( ! ) ((" "" (* * =) =!(" 0 "C ) ' "( =" " * )("! ()A " (* (* ) ' "( =" *' !" )'(0! G S27637-":A279>>A2273-6A 2,>2 :235):2I:
! 0!!)<!()'0)"(')"!"G@<'+ !!I&))"*()(0"")'"! (" )0" =!!: "Q? ) () " . !"! @<" ! '("" ) "( " . )*! ) * ! " ! * "0"( '!( " & ) "!0!: "! )( () """ ((" " ! )("!! * "!0C " ! !&"C<!)'!(G S236392):5A226245): 3A225425):4A27626>):2I:
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
12345613777 8221298 "" " !!"" ) '/ =" * ) " "!/ )("!"0 " & 'C !" * '(<" ) !) ?) <!( 0!" +? "" G#$# $"=! $"U!<D !?"8)8[ +?"!?] "?" $ $ 2,,, :2":"276":A$3777 :266):3I:
! @< '(!" "= (!"= ) )' C !" () "Q? ) 'C !" ("" !((" ) ""! ( . ) " ) @" = ) '(!! ! "()C)'("")=")(:$@! !) """! !)'(!"!)'C !"@)!="*8"") "!)" *' !8C !" !)( ! "!& =! ) /! 0": "! !* )'"! (" (""" ) "!! " . ""! (!" )" !" ) )()" ) 'C !" " C! "! !("")0!<")))!! !@<& "!" ("!=!)'0C !"() G S22>3,7):2&A22343":"!(=(!I:
*! !!0! !&")'! !"()* " )("!" '" * " "<C !"" " =" '&@" )' (") =( * ! !" =) ! ) C " *' ! (<" )(!" " C !( *' " ("( ("& ))! G/I*)! ")"C"()" ! "=* )'C !""&"0(G S233 297):2"!(=(!I: '((")("!" !0! !&" '" ! '!<)+) !0)(<"=! )' ! !" )' C !" & " & " G S 233 297 ): 2A # 0)"V"&< )! &<"!? =0!?!< :3,-":A# =)O?<"?"< )!$ $ $4312,>> :443":I:
" (<!) # < * 'C !" )" J"! =)( ! )"" /" " ) )<" !( J"! " <!Q . ) 0" ) "( " !"! ) !( C?"0 " (*0* C *" ( G# 'C !" () $D "="8 C C< ) *"( "W $ $ 2,,, : 4- " :I: J % C *'C !")"J"! /"*" C="!"."C!( C*" (: )" J"! !(?& " " "!?! ) " ) )!" G % !X!"<)?"!)!$?0!"V)< 2,,, : 69-":I:
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
-: '!! !!()"!"")!!"! ;;;;;;;;;; "(* "" !("" "("")"!0)"0"( ) "( 0! !"! ) ?!< ! ) !"! < !)G=: ! !")24!2,,-I: )")2>@0!2,,> () !("(!( !(" . 0! * !!" 0" 0<! )'"! !)! "0"( <! ==!": ' ) "< )'&!0" != =="( ) @ . @" 2,,, C !" != " (<" (0( "( ) "!0 ) '!( . >7M G!)" ) >7MI !/ (!) ) !("!L" . '==!" ) *"! "" " ) "" 0"D ) !" ) ?!< !) &"( !" "0"( : "0"( &("")' (!"!! ! !?0!/!.'("&0!/!<!:
-&: 3772 !!" ("( . C !" () !) !: =" '&@" )' C !?"<* " +?"!: '!( ")&<!!)")""!?( &! (!! " =(!!: /! <((! " =) )!C ?!* * " ! @*'. 27 ! '(? <* ) )!: " != !(0( " " )! ) * "+ ) )! '<": ' " ) 0 !?"<* !!" ==! ) &<!!)")""!?*)&! (!!" =(!!: !)<! ? ) "" """ "" (0))"!&""*)(!(0!0")!*) "!& )(<((!"= "?" &! =(!!: !!" !("))!)==)+"/"!0.'C
12345613777 8241298 * !( ) 26 " ) =&!+< )!C . ": )<" (0*( !! " ) =&!+< ! ) 'C") ")"!F "=")')!)(!( "!)"&*C !"!"" "F")<")+)! )!C "=! !"" )<" !< * ) =&!+<: " . "" +?"!* 'C !" +?"! C *!!" !("+ "F)<()( !0 "!0(.'))"C' (""" !"!"(!")(!" & "" )!/! " !"/!" <(: !(" + ""< +?"!* ?! )! ?!* '" !* 'C !" +?"! !"" )<" ) +)! )!C "=! !"":=!!!*0"DE'C !"(! )"!/=""&0! "()!" 0!*"()0 "& ) '(*&! *' "!0( @!)'?K: ' " ) 0 <&/<)C !")/!* "()"!0)!!" '(/0.>7M)"0"( !=(</!C" !")?!< (!! . 26P< " 0" !( (""= ) !?: ! "" * ' !)! " !"!" "0"( != ) ""+ !L") "(:
=""")'&!)""!*""C !" 0! !&" ) @! !) ) S : ==" =) ! )"" /"="'&@")'(")=(!" " !"""" " ) " ) !!" " ) )<" !( ! & )' / )("(: " ! " '!( =" '&@" )' C +?"!* !* "/! ) "!& "=! )!C:
C !") # !"<")'!J!" "()"!0)!!"*L"! !=) :
-:=")/!C!"!&"=!)!C)""""" !!" 0! )'0)"( ) '!80)"(: '<" )'C!)==(!"!"/!)(<<( !@! !)) S *"("( $# ( " 0 () "!"" ) !!" !;;;;;;;;;;:
())$#("""(*)<!()<!0"()'==" ) !!" " =& "" !(" "!"! ) !"( 0 "!" !(!&) !&)"( +?"!* !"! + "F ) < )( !0 G!"/! "" "! """ +" 0! ) ) ) '!80)"(I: '==" ?!*! !"!0?<!0G!"/!=0!)')I '+ !" )'"(<!" : !!" "!"" ) &
12345613777 8251298 ""0="()"!"=! !)"@!A " & "!( " 0" =" ! = ! G!"/! "" "! """ +" 0! ) ) ) '!8 0)"(I:C" !=""!())!""!0"= * !" ) " G!"/! "" "! """ +" 0! ) ) ) '!80)"(I: !!" !(" (<"!"/!?!*))!()!&*" +)! )!CA + )" ! ( ) )'<<!0" <!'==")!) !(?<""& G!"/! =0! )' )I: "!& &@"= ) !? G"!& ""* " )(<((!"=I " ! ?O "" G!"/! "" "! """+"0!)))'!80)"(I"'" ?<( )!" )!/! (: C" ) )0!< "! )! )(!" " !"" &!0( * !!" )* ! 0! =! ?O )( " )(?& !" G!"/! "" "! """ +" 0! ) ) ) '!8 0)"(I: )! " !("" ) !"(!"* !"" 0< G!"/! "" "! """ +" 0! ) ) ) '!80)"(I "?" !"*" "" !" ) ! " " )("!"0 " <!( )" " C !" ) # !"" "( ) "!0 ) >7M ) "0"( ) ""+:
!(" !& ) ( "" * !"/! !"" =" ) "!& "=! )!C """ . "( +"0!)))'!80)"(=")(=".0! !&)"( +?"!* " """ +?"!* + " !" )'"(<!": "!"!&&@"=)!?"!" C"))0!<"!)!)(!"" !""&!0( * ! !("" ) !"/! (<"=: )!! " )'! & &!C * !"/! "" =0! )' ) ) '!80)"(:
) ! ;;;;;;;;;; )==/!" )'! (!(" ) '"")())$#( *)!! "(<" *''C" )!&)"( +?"!*(0" !=""!() ) * '(<" ) !) ?) <!( 0!" +? "": )'(0" *" . <!0"( ) "!& "=!)!C: !0?)" !")'"(<!"" ""(<"!"/!?!*))!()!& )!( ) ! ( ) ) 0 + "F "& (0"""* """""" &)"!0!:
12345613777 8261298 $" )" .J)!""!*") C !" )( )" "" ! ) =" * () "!"" " <((!"))". !)! !" ! ""!) !" ) = * '" . )!! " ) =" *' ' "@! '&@"0"((!<)(*'" !)'J"! " &. )!!: '"! !" () '" (" !?"< (" +?"! ! * !" "!& "=! )!C '"!0" )' C !" +?"! " (! @! !)) S :
+)""!0))==(!"!"/!C(*"!& "=!)!C)"""""!!"' 0!)) ) '!80)"(: )<!( )'0)"( " ) " "" )!/! ' )!" . !"" '" ') " . )):
!! +)!0!*)C !" ")C !" # !!" !("!""!&0"0!) ))'!80)"( "()"!0)>7M) != ) ""+ * !! )!" . )<!( )'0)"( ) 37M '0!")!".!":
=)!("" "0C !" +?"!*@"= :
==" ')"!" @< =)" ! !(" ) !0=! !0"<"C* )0" !()! )'== " 0 * !" =" !("" )<!( ) 0!& !( )(!" " * )'"! ! !&"! !!" )=! "" !(" " != )')"!! )'"! !0 G !(" " ( ) !0A Y! !X"<0!=?! )! $O0!?!< : 323 Z 567A YUO1%V! !X"<0!=?! ) !X"<!?" =< ) ) 3 (): : 4, Z 222 " : 22- Z 437A +< )0!X"<!?" =< 3 (): : 3-5A =: S 233 59, ):5233334):4237&33,):3&22,455):4" !(=(!I: " /!) !()! 0 )!")'J"! ") '!":3,:3 ":G$3772Z27 :3>):5&I@! !) !) ' ! ) '!": 5 ": ("" "@! 0& G S 235 ,5 ):5&233293):2)"'!!J""(I:
0)* !(/)=!")""!*!!=)()"J"! !@"(:
12345613777 8291298 ) 4 ) - -)- -
/181 9 :11 1 5" $&'
81
2: (!!!!0&A 81
3:@"")))'C !" +?"!*"(A 8 4: @""!!A 5: "* !()!"<!""A 6: =! !" ) *' 0" =!! !! "! !(" !!J" ) )( ) 47 @! )/ "=" ! !)( )!( !& =()(! ) ! $?XO!?=* 9 9775 "! C !: )( " J"! !<(: (! )"D I )*! C""*)(!!")(!&"!" ))( ""*(A &I C ! ! * "= " 0! ))! "" "! )(A I !"! <"! ) ! !("": $ (! "" "! ((" ((!( ""! I &I " I 8) !&=()(!)! !! "!!"/!!!!*' )0!)(!!!!0&:(!)!!"!!+ ) !0 * !" @" * )( ""*( " '0 ) *("(C ()(!!"G!":243279"27>I: <!==!D !()"D !! $ &$ !("!8@!"D S!()(!* $
=!) !("!!J"""=(C !"*'.'===()(! )! !<!==
12345613777