ATAS/623/2005 · Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

ATAS/623/2005 · Settlement Agreement Validity Challenged Due to Alleged Misrepresentation in Property Valuation (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The petitioner challenged the validity of a settlement agreement concerning the distribution of proceeds from the sale of jointly owned property, arguing that the agreement was voidable due to material misrepresentations made by the other party regarding the property's valuation and potential sale price, which prevented meaningful negotiation. The court reasoned that the trial court correctly found that the moving party failed to establish the requisite elements of fraudulent inducement because the alleged misrepresentations were either matters of opinion or based on publicly available market data, meaning the petitioner failed to demonstrate justifiable reliance on false statements of fact that proximately caused the injury, thereby affirming the enforceability of the settlement agreement.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Settlement Agreement Validity Challenged Due to Alleged Misrepresentation in Property Valuation: The court reasoned that the trial court correctly found that the moving party failed to establish the requisite elements of fraudulent inducement because the alleged misrepresentations were either matters of opinion or based on publicly available market data, meaning the petitioner failed to demonstrate justifiable reliance on false statements of fact that proximately caused the injury, thereby affirming the enforceability of the settlement agreement.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA

pourparlers transactionnels validité du contrat consentement et validité au fond épuration de l'état des charges estimation immobilière valeur litigieuse

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision governs the allocation of costs and is cited in the final order concerning costs.

Généré par l'IA

A/4138/2006

Settlement Agreement Validity Challenge: Duress and Misrepresentation Claims Denied

A/1810/2003

Settlement Agreement Validity Dispute

A/1727/2007

Settlement Agreement Validity Challenge Over Fraud Allegations

A/1597/2003

Settlement Agreement Validity: Duress and Fraud in Property Dispute

A/2516/2007

Settlement Agreement Validity Upheld Despite Misrepresentation Claims

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision governs the allocation of costs and is cited in the final order concerning costs.

Texte complet

!"#

$$%!

& !$'&() *(!+() % &$(*% +*)%

*, -

!"## $ %&!! ( "'('")(*+!,'(--./( '(--0

(

% ! %% %%% 1 %% % (0' 1 %!230(((4!5667

<7846<

%( .!

4# =<"> (?! ' 4@59! ( (( -, 0((' (/.! -, (/( - "A00( /0(. ( -, (/(-,("3"#((A/B!0-(A# 4@C@ /-''('--(+D-('(('!((-( - 0+(A# "> (E' 00 -F( - -( "> - '('G %# #!-((-E-(-0((/->FE 4@@4# (! '(' "H -0((/ & (0" "( - '(' I %# #->0--'0H4@@4#

7# -(-C-'0H4@@4!('('E(0-,AE-(- (#H&((-'(3'"(.!-'3- (! - '( 0'('.! /( - H! - -! - - /'0A3!--"3D/'0A3!-,J('0('/'-/'0 -(!--J-F0H-(!(-,(AA3!.,J( -.>0(=""(-,3K"((E(->E=<"> *?! - 79 FE 4@@L?# ( (> 0H /( ( 0(" "'(.-'>(!E0HH0(H(0(0''H< M ( - ((( - /( "'# '(' E " E - "D3A-*-(H-0'0!-"H>0- ((! - ( -,J'( =/# (/( - * - 47 0 4@@L?# J0"D3A.('('//('&,-. '('(('."(--//('"(<(0(.'-!H. 0-''!"0((("&,E"(-,(E('"/ - 0N0 E .,('0(! '(( "/ ,E'( '=/#""(-4-'0H4@@7(4@O(4@@L?#

L# ( '(' 0 H''/ -, ( (> -,E-(' " ,22 , %% < =<"> ?! " -' -4@F(4@@:!E//(->4-'0H4@@7#('((H' (J -,E-(' - 96P# % ""( - ,22 - 4C FE4@@:!'-"((,'(("EAH!,'((-(''(((H( -'/(/"((#&"-0"('((-51;66/# " 0 / 4L! - :1666 /# " 0 / 4L J. ,F(( 46P 3// -,// - ,- - 41L661666 /#! ( - 91;66 /# " 0 " . '((-E-('#

:# -'-404@@5!% ! %% , % =<">% ?0( H''/ -,(-,E-('-466P E //( 4 "(0H 4@@; . -, -0(' " ((( & ,('A('-;C!5P#

8494:8766; <L846< ;# "'-'E-((((H(&0( F.,&(D0"'E-7664#

5# % ""( 0'- - "/ ! "'( (3"'- ( 0'- 3/ - E - . ( "D. -,(3"'- ( - 3A - ,"" 0( - * - 7L FE 7667! ( H E 7C (E( 3A -" ,-( - 4@@4! ( , " " "- (E -"# % '(( - (' ( ((! ( "(' - (E"("N(0''#

9# 4 FE 766;! ( ( % /( '-"('! " (( 0((-C1:6:/#"0",'766;#

C# -'-74/'E766;!, /0(.,"'-(& 'E - -( & ( 0(/ . -'( - E /( F., ( " /0 & '('# , "B 0 " - "0( - ( & "( - 4 0 766; (( . 0 "E((,//("/&'E(#(-- ., (0(&% -0(.'(("E#

@# ( - : 0 766; J"(/ (( ( (E('(/('A0(((">0"(H(/( "'4@@;&766L<766:#

(-J"(/(-">-.(Q

# (''-,'4@@;'('&"H('0(' -0- $ % =<">%?D("H(- "(( - E! E( - "(! -,-' ( - "F(! ""0( - -0 - A( /0(. ( - 0+(A# -! ((EEL3"F =(43(53? " -C66/#"0# 7666!3(''('$$ % . "(E('/0(..,"(-(/-%-(( ( ( . /( "( - ''0( - /(# /-' 'A0( '('00H>-7L<7;!-((,(.(-( '(' % ," - A' - 00H# % E "/(E'"'('%#

H# ("'-("-(!&E"'-E-A' "(( I! -"H-,-(! -0-( "0( - C16661666 /#! -" 4@@@# J "'- "'(('(-0-", I-,"(("% -,("("(((E-,.#

8494:8766; <:846< # , I 0-(' -'((E "E' -( ""( (! @ F( 766L! . ( ( R " /0! (E & " (0" E 3(>3A'"0"(-'('$$ % =S?!-( -'E""0( ( ' ( 'J ( 3// -,// (> 0"(( =S?# '('%"")(00"E(# ( 3(0(E0HH. 'A(-"'-.(E("(E( (>"-'(("3D.(/T#

-# - - "'- E "-( - ( - -! J"(0'-'('//('""/ 45-'0H 7667# ,'E( "D3A. ( ="A 46 - ""(? (0(A/(/-"'"E!-(H-0'0& ((0(('A-!--0EH!.,/'30(- /(J'(E#"(-"(0"(HED-0"(< (0(.#'''H,("J#(H-0'0!- ,((( ( (0( ((( "HH0( A( -, -00A ''H =/# "A 4L?# '. "D3A. ((( -E-,(0(0M''HU,J"(F(- "D3A "( =/# "A 45?# ,J"( (( "(''--(E-,--L6P(F(,""'(/( " , =/# "A 4@?# (0(0 M ( -0(' " "> -# ,'E( 0( 'E- "( - -'/(! ,J"( (.-'"", ( '(("""'=/#"A L7?#

46# -' - : 0 766;! % ! -, "(! ""0' ( - ( 0(/ ., ,D ( " - "( - A! ""0( ,//( "/ -, 'E( ""(! ( -,( "(! -0-' ((( - 0(((""B-"4"(0H4@@;!(5CL17@7/#

44# ( /( ""( (( & -'- , .,& -' - % ! ( "'H0( - -J & ((( - ,//( "/#

47# % - -' ""( -( -( - 46 0 766; /0(((-,//("/!0(/.,('N(-% "0( -(!-0V-'-""-(-E( N( /0' "'- ((( - "(( .( - 'E' /(# ! % '(( /-' & ( ,//( "/ .((A(-E(-.0(-(& -"0""((-,#

4L# -7L0766;!((&,(--' .' (! /(! & ((( - ,//( "/ 0J ,0

8494:8766; <;846< H.,(-(.(-,E-('-(N(E'"-'- "'--,""(# ">E""'/(!(J".. "" H"( (( - ( . - "(( - % ! " - (( /> "' ( " 0D - H( . - C66 /# " 0! ., - 3A 0"H " " - :1666 /# " 0# -E - ( ,- "E-,("H.#!-'-"""")( -,0H''#""-('('//('-0>00 J0 - ''0( - - ( H -,/0( D' ", I!-((""'.("-(#% "3 - " ,E /0' ., (E( 00 (( E 00 -( - '(' $$ % -" 7664 ( -,E '' -EH((--# E'(('.E(&J., ("'E(,-(!% (.,,D"-,E-('# ,(H.E-('E(-,--L991;66/# E ( (E(' 0' - /( ,"( :; & 56 3 " 0# (E -'0 ( & 5 3 " F 0 A''0( L 3 0D"F5F"0(EC63"0!" -C66/#"04L/,#,A(&-E#""(- -'((E '(' ((' E >! ( "'- "' ((' (( H ,( " ,3 " -' & "(# , /EH - "'--E(N("0"("% #0N0." % ( J(( ( -//'( ''0( "(0J! ""'(' 2<E! ( ., -'(( - '('! . (((-''0('H&0N0-E'3'('- % #

4:# 0">"-("(/A""(-,J"(0"(H '(H " %2 & ,((( - FA (( - H ( - !L40766;# H(!,J"((((.(,B 00 - $$ % ! '(' % D( "B - 3 - $$ % # 0(( ,( " '(' ( ,E( " & N( 00.' & , "., ,( " '(' . " (# , '(' H/' E' -0- " $$ % # ( 'A0(""."((.3(--J-'"(0(-'(' $G ("N(//('"'('G % &. H( (! 0(( - 3// -,// H-A'(' & 41L661666 /# ,'(( " '(! A - 4C71666 /# /E - ( H-3//-,//'(('(!E0(-,(0((-& ((( '(( EH E ! ,A0(( "F(' - 3// -,//&-;66,666/#!'A-3//''"7-'"(0( .(!(//(E0("-(!'.-."("(- 46P 3// -,// ( ' "("( - 4L61666 /#

8494:8766; <5846< 000"4@@7!'E-"('/>-G % & E!(((-'"0(-0((H-A'('-41L661666/#("E.' A0((-'0'(!0N0'E#

4;# '" - 7: F 766;! % -> . ( ( "'(- & (( "E & "( - E0( - "(( -,!((.,(00(,J(-,0"(((E('- (( /0(. ( - -( - /( ., J " '(' $$ % # "'E,-(A("//00( ( " N( " 0"(# ! 00 ( ( ""'( - " H 00H ( -,''0( - /(! ( "(H -,N( 0 AA ( -E( "0(( - " J -//(' />"A>#((-"-((/> -'(#% (F(-#

45# H-'-'0"(-0-(!.,(( -(-;F(766;#

(( ! '(' -.' . "H'0(. /- (E & ""-((&-0--((('(((0("- ">-% !-,(((-(-"'-"'# <('(' F(! ( 0H( (F N( & "3 -,.N( "'0U "(-(,&F#""(--0(.E( '('-,".(-'0H766:'('-#0-( - (""',J"(0"(H.-(/(!(-.' .,0"'0(-,J"(E('('('- HE-#""(- -'((E"E' '('-&-0--, I# ,D "-""( 0'-J . 0((( F-,3 (E & ,'(( - ('-(.'((E'&,'"."/0'-# "( - % ,"" ""( - -'((E "E' . .. ('0AA H(! 0-( - % ! "<-E( A-0!(.,"-(&,-#0-(-(" "( -.' . D0H. - C66 /# " 0 -' - '(( /-% !(.,-,--41L66/#"0"(! 0J00!N(-'AA'#0-(-% -.'.''0(- /('A'"(!("("(&-//'('('( H00H,'(("(('#

% .!'(' A-'&FA!(((-,//("/!. HF(-(A#

49# " - ; F( 766;! 00.' " & % ! 0-( - ((&"'."><EHJ-,-(-('0"-(& ,-,'(("-('0AA"<-E(A-00"

8494:8766; <9846< -"><EHJ/A(-,(-'F&-("-(&,-( -('0--"'-E"-(-E( H( E-#

%( $+!

4# AE,A(F-=?'('0-/'((('!-> 4O(766L! H(-!0"'-;FA! -("'-((E<"'-(!;""'((45FA=(#4(# (;5 ?#

%(&,(-,'(-45FA!" H/'-' 79FE766:= 24L6465?!- AE-"('!4L/'E! -"(((A("0((( H(- - 'A & ( FA ((! ! - ,((( - ,'(-EJFA#

7# /0'0( & 1(# ;5 # 4 (# 3# ; ! H ( - )((.-((("'E&,(#;5 -/'-'"(A''--(--5(H 7666 = ? . ( (E & /'-' ,<-( - 7604@C4= ?#

L# ( (' EA 4 FE 766L! ()( 0-/( - 0H -"( 'A - -0 - # % "0('!"(-E.-(1"".-(N((3'&0> -"".>A""H(EA00(V /(F-.0(-'(0(("-(= 24L67L6-#4#4U LL;-#4#7U 247@:-#4#7U 2479:59-#4!4754L5 -#:H('/'?#>A-"'-.(&1"".( 'E->F-('EA= 2449@L-#5H!447L56 -#:U 4@@CWL9"#L45-#LH?# ,"".- -,">#

:# %,(#56#4 !-(N(-'"'-L6FE( (/( - -' F(( & # 0(> -,<-(! ((/ ,(# 465 "'E(! -'A(! -' - - ( 0 (-'""("(("((-,#

>A("-(EH"--'/# ,">!,A( -,-'-(!.!""(-,(#5L-AE "'--0((E= ?!"(/,HF(-,--'-46 F# ,">!-''('"('!-0N0.-(-/0!- (.(EH#

8494:8766; <C846< ;# .((A(.0(-(((-,//("/#

(( "'- ( 0' & -0- "E =/# )( G! '- -0((E! "# :6: ( '/'! '-# % 2?! ( (! " '.(!-0"'(-"'-(-30H=(#74# 4 ?# "-(! - 0 V! ,">! -' 0(( / "'((A!,A-,-'/ "(H->-, --'-((F!(-,-!-&(("'F-#

5# ,(# ;; - /'-' "'- -0((E = ?! (E & ,//( "/-!"'E(.(Q R4 //("/# %/"("(("'!-'-,(('/' "( "'E ., 'E( , " -,//( "/U ,((' - !"'-(,,A(-,>A!0N0-(">-'"K(- # L ,(('-"'-("(((,//("/& . ,((' /' ,E( ('U -0- - ((( - ,//( "/((('-'#TU

(!,(#55 "'E(.(Q R4 %/ -"( 'A (! //( "/ & 0 . ,((' . " -' ((.' ,( -' ,J'( H(( # (/! . ('N( "H "E' "'"-'( ,D ""! F-( - "(! -0- - "( -( ('N( ( AE0(0'!(((,//("/#T#

(( - ,//( "/ "( E "' - ('N( "'!(,//("/-(N(>A!"'E(.,(('- (0-E(/(0"=/#"#('!"#:6;<:65('/'?#1"> F"-(E&1(#;;#4 !"H('-(1//("/ 1("H-'&-(.1J(!-"(! -(((&/(J"(.F(/(((0#0H H"(K(&1(('""'&((!""(-1(#;; !-1J0 0(/."(/E-1J'(00'-(--'10"(( J . "E( N( E.' & 1"" - ( (# 1((' -""(-1(H('-1""'(# A''!/- 1'((-/((.1'(--!//(-AE(A( ""'0(# "'-(&"'-('N("'(&1J0- 0(/ . 0(( " ( 1J'( 00'-( - -'! "( "- -'( "'E 1 - (AU /( "-( .1 /( -( =/# 2 44@ ;69 -# :U W!

8494:8766; <@846< X(AE/3 - %YE3A! # :65 "#4@6 ! 3X8W8W! Z//(3 Y3( - (YE/A3( - -! E# ! # ;#9#L#L "# ::L! W[Y8*\! X(AE/3 - X(A3("/A - -! 7 '-#! # 5;6 "# 7LL! ( DA! -EX(A3("/A! 7 '-#! "# 7::?# ! 1((' "( ( ,//( "/ . .1 - E( " / = 2 449 4@4 -# 7H ( '/'U E 2 - 7 0 7666! 9758@@3?#

9# ,">!E(-(0"(-''0(E(Q

• J0 (.,E(-/-( H&". (/-'!(."'-('(("((( ""( - -'((E -0-' " , I " ( -0- "0( ( ('# ''0( 0'- E - -, 0'(-,'((-(' -(! .,(0' " -0! H(# (!,J"(0"(H(E(((. "(( ( '(' -' & # ( ,(( - ( ,E0( - "'- "' -'0(( "(<N( (! 0 ,'((! ( ( E( - H E - "0 ''0( -( -"#

• ('N(-% (""'Q,("(('.( - ''0( - /( (( & /( //( " / /! '3'(! & -0-0H0((.(0("-(-E(% "'!,'0(-(0"# !"0A0(-,(0' -(N('('!''0(-/(-(-"(-(& ((<&!E-"'-('N(.,E(-/!(! /( .! E J<! ( "( ( - . EE "-( "'-#

• ('N(-((.(&J"'Q('A'((('. E0((->&C66/#"0#

• -A0(-% (0H'A0(&/JQ(J(--. <'((/-'&(,//("/R.((A(- E ( - . 0 ( -( & - " 0" "(( -,T# ( '((! //(! H''/ -, ( . % ""0! & 3A " -,'(H . (( "" ( F(/'# 00"-V((0"!0('-(0"!('(' -'-'('/!(-0-("- "((#

C# . "'>-! H - ((( - ,//( "/# E0( - "(( -E N( " F.,& -( /-#

8494:8766; <46846< (! . H(( A - ! -( & - -'" . ( /J' ,">&71666/#

]]]

$ *% +!. )% !$'&() *(!+() % &$(*% +*)% /00 10

230 4 / )5 0 4# 'EH# 0 7# ,-0(#

L# -(((-,//("/#

:# -0 % "0( -, -0(' /E - -71666/# ;# /0 "( - ., "E( /0 ( "'( N( - -' - L6 F -> (/( " " 00-' -' H /'-' - ! %3XY3/. 5! 566: ! ( J0"# -' "( N( "A'# 0'0 -(Q ? -. J(0(.-'(-'H(("--' ((.'U H? J" " . 0(/ (0 "E -0- (( ( -'U ? "( A( - "'((# % 0'0 (( " ( ''0( '0'' (( ? H? ( ? <-! H/'-'-""(0(>., -E-'EH#0'0-0(0D - "E! . ( F(! . -' ((.' ( ,E"" - .'('J"'-'(=(#4L7!465(46C?# A// '-(Q % H%

"/0-"'(N(((/'J"(.,&,///'-' -('"H."A//

8494:8766;

Settlement Agreement Validity Challenged Due to Alleged Misrepresentation in Property Valuation

Synthèse Legislator

Regeste Legislator

Mots-clés

Dispositions légales citées

Décisions connexes

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Texte complet