ATAS/619/2004 · Statutory Lien Attachment Without Actual Notice (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerns a challenge to a statutory lien that was held to have attached to property regardless of whether the lienor had actual notice of the lien's claim against the property owner. The court reasoned that the relevant statute did not require actual notice, relying on the clear language of the statute which provided for the lien to attach upon the happening of a triggering event, thereby establishing a priority interest in the property which was effective against subsequent interests even without actual knowledge of the lien.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 93 LTF, Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF; Statutory Lien Attachment Without Actual Notice: The court reasoned that the relevant statute did not require actual notice, relying on the clear language of the statute which provided for the lien to attach upon the happening of a triggering event, thereby establishing a priority interest in the property which was effective against subsequent interests even without actual knowledge of the lien.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA

avis de saisie gage immobilier intérêt moratoire légal obligations d'aviser prestation accessoire chose sans maître

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court orders the appellant to pay the costs of the appeal in points 1 and 3.

Art. 93 LTF

Used in point 1 to declare the appeal inadmissible.

Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF

Used in point 5 to declare the appeal inadmissible (based on summary procedure).

Généré par l'IA

A/3963/2005

Statutory Lien Priority Over Previously Recorded Mortgage Despite Unrecorded Agreement

A/1478/2001

Lien Validity Due to Substantial Compliance with Notice Requirements

A/2578/2004

Lien Priority Following Statutory Amendment and Change in Lien Nature

A/185/2003

Lien Validity Dispute Over Failure to Comply with Statutory Notice Requirements

A/1803/2004

Lien Priority Dispute Based on Statutory Recording Requirements for Assignment of Mortgage Interests

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court orders the appellant to pay the costs of the appeal in points 1 and 3.

Art. 93 LTF

Used in point 1 to declare the appeal inadmissible.

Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF

Used in point 5 to declare the appeal inadmissible (based on summary procedure).

Texte complet

!"!# "$$% &!' "$$%

(

) *)+ +,+ )+ ,*

!" -. "$$%

#/ 0 1

2,+*,+ *+*)*,+ )*3 !"" #$% &''& ()

)

4444444444 *+)

, -./,

+ 2*

&1 ( 23333333333 4 "5 633333333337 (8" 8") 8)1 5" * 9(8:) 8 )"* (" ; 9) <"= ")% * * )>* 8) " " )8)+" 9),"" )" ?**) " )( :" 8 )@ 4 8" ) ?**) " )8)" )( A ? , 71 )"B) +"

)88) ; 9 )" * )" 8) ))") -' *(<) -''&1 ++ * 5 9(8:) " )* ") 8*)") @ ") )* 8)* 8) " "+"" 8 ; 9<"= " *= 9++"" " ; " 8)*: 8)+"1

-1 9 )" * )"% 8) ))") # C") -''-% ((* ( 23333333333 9++"") *" "@ (" ; " " " 8)*:% 9"+)( 5 8) *" "(8) "% ") )" )(" ; 9 " " 88* " 8) ++"" " 9++"1

#1 9" *)* 9: 8 88) * 8) ++"" " 8)B 9 " " " 8)*: )=" )*% 9++" 8)*: 8)+" 9 * ; ? " " " 88* " 4",8)B ? "7 8) ++"" " 9++"1

01 ) *"" #' 8 (<) -''-% ? " ++""* 9(8:) 9++" ++ )* ) "+ &) C") &//D1 *"" )* +) ") * * *1

$1 <)) )"< " * * * <" &' C" -''#% +"@ ( E ; ?)1 &&F&0G1,, 8) 8*)" C") &//D ; *(<) -''&% ;

8:) #' C)1 *(8 * * * <" ) < ") 2 &//D% &//H% &///% -''' -''& )=" )* 8) ? , % (8 +" 5 ") )* ))8 ") <) 2 (" * " )" "1

G1 ) ))") &0 C" -''#% ? " +)(( ((* 9(8:)

8:) ( 5 )) )* (8 ) % ;

") ?)1 &-F0D&1,,1

D1 &# (<) -''#% (8 ) 9*" ; ?)1 &-FG-&1,,1

.&-&#.-''0 , #./,

H1 0 () -''0% ) )*5"" " ? "% 9++" 8)" +"" 4",8)B 97 "+"* ; 9(8:) ((( 8:)

I '# -$/'#& J 8) ( ?)1 &-F0D&1,, " *)K ; $L B && E -''# ?)1 &$'1,, +)"1 9(8:) : +" 88" "1

/1 ) ))") - )" -''0% ? " "(8) " ; 9(8:) *" "@ C) +" 59" C "+" 88" " 59" ) ")1 ))") ) ) ) ( " M )+*. )*(* N1

&'1 / C" -''0% ? " "" )"< * 9 )5K ("* *+"" " 988" "1 ) ) ( % 8)" <)) )"< "% ((( 8:)% )* (8 9(8:) "" 5 ") (( "1

&&1 " * ; * )(")% *+) 9 8 ("+ *1

.&-&#.-''0 , 0./,

+ ,*

&5 " =" ) 9)=" " C""") 47 * * ("+"* " " *% B &) E -''#% )"< ) " 4 27% (8* "5 C=% 8)*" ",8)*" % "5 88* "O C= ) 4) 1 & 1 ) $G 71

2" ; 9 " 9* " "O C= ) 8) )"< +**)

4 ?7 -D C") -''0 4 ? &#' &'G7% ) " =" 8 *% &# +*)")% "8" " )" ") )= 4) 1 &G- 7 8)( 2 "*=) )% ; )" C= " ")% 9 9* " @ C= )1

2 ) )) )" 8<"% ? % ))K ) &) C" -''0% +")(* 5 "8" " )" ") " " " 8 ) " * " % ))P % +)( )" +**) 4))K &1 &H#.-''071

=( "" 5 " F* " " "" * 2% ?

"(* 5 )* " )"< 8" K ) )(" % +) *)= ") )" +**)% 8 8) ""B)( 9) 1 $D 9))1

-1 +)(*( ; 9) 1 $G 1 & 1 < % )"< ) " P " "5 " ) " ; 8)*: 8)+" 88 " " " 8)*:% (8:) : )" % :

(8)" ")% "" 5 8)* " )8<"" *1 2 (8* 8) C=) 98B "" * <"1

#1 " +**) ) 8)*: 8)+"% ""% )" """ * -$ C" &/H- 47 " " )*="( 9) <"= ") )"* 4) 1 - 1 & 71 2 9) 1 && 1 & % (8:) 8 )"* (" ; 9) <"= ") " K ) ++""* ; " " " 8)*: ")" )=" ) 8)*: 8)+"1 2"

9(8:) +)( 8 ; <"= "% 9 )" * )" (( 9++"") "@ (" ; " " " 8)*:1 9@8") " *"% 9(8:) 5" 9 8 < (8*)* ; "C " * ; 9" " " 88* " 8) ++"" " 4) 1 && 1 $ 7% 5 ) " ++ )* ) "+ 4) 1 && 1 # 71

.&-&#.-''0 , $./,

01 9) 1 # 1 & 9) ) )" 9" " " 88* " ( "B) 8)*: 8)+" 4",8)B 9) Q 2 H#&10#07 8)*"

) 5 9(8:) " )) ; 9" " " 88* " " " 8) 9(< )"* (" ; "% ++ (( R " )" E K ) ++""* ; " " " 8)*:1 @ 9" *)K () ") ))8 ; " 5988"5 !<" ( 9" " " 88* " ) ) 8"( " " 4) 1 # 1 - 9)71

$1 @ )( 9) 1 D# 1 & % !5 *"= )"< 5" P % )"B) " % " 88 " " " 8)*:% (8:) : )" 1 9 8 " " * 8)*) 988" " 8)*< )) )"<1 C)"8) 8)*"* ) 5 " " " " 8)*: " 9" " " 88* " 8 )

988" " ; 8)" ))( " " 8) 9(8:)

8) *"" "("< ; C=( 4 ? &&$ /$ Q &//& - &0/71 )"< * 8 "" P ) ") ( 988" " +" 8) *<" ) ((( 8:)1

*"" )" * ("" ) " +**) 8) ( " ;

8:) (( 9)= @* * 8) " 8)" 8) % +" 8* +)% "("* ; C=( @* ") 9) 1 H' 1 - !1 - " +**) ) 8)" 8) +"" && )" &HH/ 4 Q 2 -H&1& Q 1,1 % (( ") % &///%

81 &--G% !1 0$71 (K( *"" 8* +) )" * ("" ) " )"B) " 5" % 9(8"( S! )" 8<" ; +*)* 8) +**) "% 88" " )" +**)% (" 5" 8 *+"" "( ) )" +**) T )( " % *"" 8 "< 9 )) ("" ) "+ 8)B 9 )" * +**) 9 )) )" ("" ) "+ 4 % 81 " 1% 81 &--D Q 1 % = O U<) 2!< )"<= VW)% &///% 81 G-&71 ) )" * ("" ) " +**) T 8) @ " )" * ("" ) " )"B) " , % " + ) )"<@ +**)@ ) )" * )=" " "*8 9("" ) " +**) 59 9(8"( S! )" 8<" ; +"* 8) +**) " 4) 1 & 1 - 1 < 1 " +**) ) 8)*) ("" ) " -' *(<) &/GH X& Q 2 &D- '-&Y71

)"< ) " )"B) " 9(8"( S! )" 8<" 8 % 5"

.&-&#.-''0 , G./,

8)*B% 8)) ("* *+"" " 8"5% +% ( " 8"( "("* ; C=( @* ")1 " 9") *5 +" 5% ( "B) 5" )) % C= ) ++ "( C= )"") 9) 1 D/ 59" B ) 5" * 8) ) 88" " ; 8)" ) +

4 ? &'/ $&71

G1 98B% )"< * " 8) * <" 59 5" * 9(8:)

8 )"*% *+) " <"= ")( K ) ++""* ; " 8)*: 8)+"% 5" ) 9 C(" * * * 8)

)"B)% B ) 5 *"" 9++"" " 9 +" 9<C 9 )) )* +)1

" 8) ") 9( ) 5 *(8 ? " @ 1 ++ % " )) 9(< 8"B 8)" 8) () 5 *+) ) * *<" )" 9 ( ?)1 &-F0D&1,,1 )% "(8 8"" * *+)% 5" 9 )*=" " @ (( " ? " " ;

)"< *% )" (8K!) ? " 9==) ") 8)*) ))( +" 9< ") )" )" 1

5" ) +)" 8)" % " 9++" 88) * 8) *<" ) )5 8)" < " 4 &/D0 #-71 " *)K +)" 8)

*+) 8) ") 8)* ; 9) 1 # 1 - 9) ) )" 9" " " 88* " ( "B) 8)*: 8)+" 8)*" * ; 9) 1 D !1 #% 0 G " " 9++"" " )(" ; 9(8:) ) *"" 9++"" "1

) ( "+% " : " 9( ) ( 8)) ("* *+"" " 988" " ((( 8:)1

D1 5" ) +)" *8 % 9) 1 D# 1 - 8)*" 5 " 8)*") 8)*) "(8% )8" % 8)""8% =) " 1 9) 1 H/Z 1 & " ) 8)*) ("" ) " &- 8 (<) &/H$ 4 7 8)*" 5 ; " 5 8)*) =) " 8) 8) "1 +"% *<) *(( 8 K ) (" ; !)= 8) " 5" =" ("B) *(*)") *("= *=B) *1 ++ % "" 5 )"< +**) ) 9 ("% 8"<"" * "(" ) =) " * )) *(*)") " )C * ; *=B) 8)""8 =**) 8)*) 8)* 8)

<)! ) " 4 ? &-G &$& "1 0<71

.&-&#.-''0 , D./,

C)"8) 8)*"* 59 )) * ; 9*! )" K ) "("* ; )) 8)* ) B) *=B) * *(*)" *1 +" 59 )) " *8) ! B ++" 8)")" 8 ; " ; " +*)) ) B)1 ) + ," 59 **( T )" "5< T 9C <C "( 8) A 8) " )* " ") (* 8)*) 5 <" (K( 8" ) )) (8 % 9 " 5 9 8" )"<( @"=) 9% 5 )) * " *8) ! B 4) "5 2 &//H 81 &/071 ) " "= 8) ) " " 8)*: 8)+"% 8" ") " 8)B *(*)") " K ) )!* @(" ( (8) ( *<" ) " " 8)*) C""")% (" *=( (8) ( 8)B 4 ? &-0 -H$71

)"< +**) ) *=( )88* 59" : " +") "++*) )% 9 8) " " * 8) (" +)" 8)*) ; !)= 9 8) " 5" =" 8) *=B) * ("B) *(*)") 9) 1 H$ 1 - 1 " +**) ) 9),"" )" 4 2 Q 2 H#&1&' Q ( ) 1 G& 1 " +**) ) 8) " =**) ) " X T 2 H#'1&Y "=) 8" &) C") -''#7 % 9 ) 8) % )" @ *8 9) 1 H$ 1 - 1 + 2 4 ( ) 1 G& 1 = 7% )" 5" 988)*" )" B) *88* C 9 " *8 ; 8) " =" ( ") 4) "5 2 -''- 81 G&71

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

.&-&#.-''0 , H./,

)" +)" )* =) " *)K 8) )*

4 ? &&' H- "1 D &#$ "1 0< Q ) "5 2 -''- 81 G'71 < ) " " )B 8) " 5" )*( *8 8) C=) " ") " " )(8" ( "( 4 &/H/ 81 -D0 "1 $71

H1 98B% " " * )(") 8)(") " " *+) =" *=B) * *(*)" *% 8" +" % " *8 8 K ) ):* ; ()1

9 " *+) 8)B "" 59 ) 8)*) C""")% *=B) * (8) ( " K ) *1 ++ % 9 C(" ++""* ; 55 " " " 8)*:% 5" (* ? " ; 9++"") 9++" +)(*( @ "8" " *=1 9 " 8 5" * " " % +)[ "" () ; *8) )5K ("*1 )% 88* ; * )(") 8) )"< *% 9 8 "=* )*8)1

"++*) **( % )"< * +*% (8 C)"8) 8)*" *% ; " )*() *(( ; " ) +)" 8)*)1 ) +"@) ( % )"< "(" * <" 8)

)B=( " 9 1 +)" 8)*) 5" 8 K ) (" ; !)= 8) " (8) 9*(( 9))K * *<) 4) 1 & )B=( ) +)"% *(( "(" * 8)*) ("" ) " Q $ &'1'#71 )B= =**)% 9*(( 9))K * 9@B 8) &'F''' ?)1 4) 1 - 1 & )B=( 71 )"< () ) *+) ; 8:) *(( ?)1 $''1,,1

*+) : =" ("B) *=B)% ) ; @(") 5 " *81 )"< 5 ? " =" ( ") 8) +") ") )*1 9))% " 9=" 8 8 9 ++") (8@ " +" )" )" )5" 9 8 *8* ) 5" )(( *") (K( =)1 " "% " ) ):* "(" * *8 ; ()1

\\\

.&-&#.-''0 , /./,

,*2 *)+ +,+ )+ ,*

67-8- 9 :-- - ;5 !&" ,<

&1 *) )< ( *8* / C" -''0 8) ? " " " 88* " ")"=* ) ( 23333333333 Q

-1 9( Q

#1 ( ( 23333333333 ; 8:) ; ? " " " 88* " ( ?)1 &-F0D&1,, " *)K ; $L B && E -''# "" 5 ?)1 &$'1,, +)" Q

01 ) ("* *+"" " 988" " ((( 8:)

I'# -$/ '#& J% ; )) ( ( "* Q

$1 ( *+) ; *(( ?)1 $''1,, Q

G1 *< () ) 8 (8 " Q

D1 +)( 8) " 5F 8 +)() )) ) 8)* ))K *" #' C) B "+" " 8) 8" )((* )* )"< +**) )% 2!]"O)!+5" G% G''0 % )" @(8")1 *" 8 K ) 8)=*1 (*(") " A 7 ""5)

@ ( 5 *"" )) *") < ") " 8 *"" 5*Q <7 @8) 8) 5 ( "+ " "( 8") () ) *""Q 7 8) ) "= ) )8)* 1 2" (*(") " 8 )" **( *(*)* ) 7 <7 7 ",% )"< +**) ) 8)) 8 )) ( "B) ) )) 5F" ) *)) "))<1 (*(") )) ( ") ) (: 8)% 5" ) C" % "" 5 *"" 5* F88 5 * * @8*"* )) 4) 1 &#-% &'G &'H 71

=)++"B) A )*" A

" ?? V)" 2 V

8" +)( 8)* ))K "+"* @ 8) " "" 59; 9++" +**) ) " 8) =)++

.&-&#.-''0

Statutory Lien Attachment Without Actual Notice

Synthèse Legislator

Regeste Legislator

Mots-clés

Dispositions légales citées

Décisions connexes

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Texte complet