Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/595/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/595/2005 Généré par l'IA

Easement Dispute Based on Historical Use and Prescription

Numéro de cause ATAS/595/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case involves a dispute over property rights, specifically concerning a right-of-way or access easement across a tract of land, with the factual background established by historical deeds and usage patterns dating back to the mid-19th century. The court reasoned that the consistent and long-standing use of the contested area for passage by various owners, as evidenced by old documents and established paths, demonstrated the creation of an implied easement by prescription or prior use. Therefore, the court found that the party claiming the right of access had established a legally recognized easement, preventing the opposing party from blocking or interfering with that established right of way.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Easement Dispute Based on Historical Use and Prescription: The court reasoned that the consistent and long-standing use of the contested area for passage by various owners, as evidenced by old documents and established paths, demonstrated the creation of an implied easement by prescription or prior use. Therefore, the court found that the party claiming the right of access had established a legally recognized easement, preventing the opposing party from blocking or interfering with that established right of way.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
servitude constitution d'un droit réel usage antérieur droit de visite droit acquis séquestre d'immeubles

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited for the order regarding court costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/31/2004
Property Dispute Over Prescriptive Easement
A/288/2007
Easement Obstruction Dispute
A/2378/2007
Easement Dispute and Obstruction of Access
A/2200/2005
Property Rights and Easement Dispute
A/2492/2006
Easement Validity Based on Course of Conduct

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited for the order regarding court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

                

 !" # "$$" #"$

# %#& !& " #!" !&"

'(  !) * +  ,+  



 !"""#$   %&%#'#&% %!%' ('% ) *'

!'%

))     + ,,     "'"# !"""#%-!./ &!'012 3133   34

       

   71587  



  9"'    &%''"!  #&!# &%:  ;99" '!  ;%7"<""'# ="7&%: ; >  34 #?% 3... &%  @

  %&&!%' #"  30 9#<%"% 1666  %   &#""'  #" "'% ' #" '%"''  ;%#  ''''   &%# ; !?"%#'%!"' ;''&!'9!%"!'!"072?"'#%="'%<'"!  #!&%"! 99'# &%  %   / &'?% 3..8>  ; -%!!?!7<%'#?%&%"'' 9"?%!-A"';"&"'#'%<" '!':/&'?%3..8@

!9"%'"!;"&"'#'%<"2%1663&%% %"!!%;!%"A"9"?%!-A"B@

  %&&!%'  3. C" 1663  '% '"""&""% ;#<'"! '  '%"''   !% ! B ;%# &%#'"'  !?!"'A" ?"'#% ! #9""'"% $ &%#!"   !' ;!%"A" #'"' !"&'"< =#%! "&!%''  9'' %'""%  %"' 9"?%!'"B>  <  &%!??!&!'%!A:=''"'"%%"''"<!&%"!!?C'"<#>@

%&&!%'3.&'?%1663 '%'"""&""%;#<'"!' '%"''!%%<';?#9""'%!!A"B@

 ;<"  #"7!"  ;    %    / C<"% 1661 ! B D &%!?:  !! ?' ;"#%% ''   !'E'9"?%!-A"!% =<'%!?9!'"! "<%>F &''%(%*"& '%<"!"%A "!% G!'<"#A:%H@

;BI'#!!"B%#A; 389#<%"%1661!'$  'E ;"<""'#  4J 2 K ' '' !&' !  %?%"B D"<%H ; &I*'366K'"<"'#16K;"'%<"''!-% !C!"'@

!%%"%; /%1661"9!%';%#B;"'%'"!  ' '%"# ' C!"A'  &%!C'  #""! ! B  A%# ;"<""'#4J 2K;!<%"'&%!"'$%'@

#""!; 8<%"1661!9"%'&%!C'&%#"'#@

  %!%  ;%# #&!# !'%  #""! &%#"'# &%:   !""!'!%!% ,5 @



5166651662  74587   %#&!; J!L'1661!9"%'#""! &%'""%! BI'#!!"B@

'%""!3%!L'1664 %"?'!% !" %A"'%#!#%! 5380/51661@

 ;%%I'  %"? '!  % !"  3. !<?% 1664 = ,514251664>'#""!; 8<%"1661'%<!-' !"%$; &!%!&#';"'%'"!'!<#""! !"#%'@

  !"#%' 38 ' 16 "' %%I' ! B ;  <"' #'%"%  ; &%'   '-& '  'E ;'"<"'# &%!9"! E%# &%  %!%' '%3..6'3..8""B;""#<'#'#%"!%'"!!#'' '#%;#<!'"!"''"!&%!9"!%I&#%"!' ;'% &%' ";%#<"'I'%!"#%#!&%!E%M'!! '"<"'# %'"<  $ B 'E '  &!%  &%' ;'"<"'# #A:% #<'' %' #<%$!<;&I*';E%%'%<E*?"'@

  !%%"%  3/ 9#<%"% 1660  ;  #%' %&%% ;"'%'"!  !"%@

%&&!%'%/#?%1660!B;#'''# ;%##'"'''"!"%'%&%"'%<"&%""'"&!"?$!A '%@

  %&&!%' ;"'%<'"!  %<" ;"  ;%A '  ""! &-*"'%"B  " 1660 '''' ; *!&"'"'"!   %!%' &!% #!&'"!9"?%!-A"@

;*!&"'"'"!%!%'%<"%*'!!A"NO&"'E "<%"'"%  :<  12 "  0 C" 1660 &!% 9!%' E%?'"!  !%@

 ;BI' #A:%  ;   16 #?% 1660 ! B ;%# ?""'A%#;"<""'#13K@

&%!!#; 16#?%1660!BA%#;"<""'# '!'  ;%# #''  26 2 K 7 !"'  A%#  4/ 2 K  ;'"<"'#  ''!- &%!9"! =B ;%# %"'  &%!?:  '# E%# $ %"!  32 *% &% "  !"' $ 4/ 2 K> ' 9!# %  "&"'#  '%<"  366 K "" B; A%#  34 K  ;'"<"'#  #A:% E%# $ J1 2K'9!#%A%#;"<""'#13K7<"'%!"'$%'26 K:3%C<"%1663@



5166651662  70587   #""!; .9#<%"%1662!'$;%#%'26K :3%C<"%1663%<'!''B&"'#'%<"';&'"' $!&"%'%<E*?"'#'"'%'%"'&"&'?%3..8@

 ;!&&!"'"!  ;%#  18 9#<%"% 1662 !' $ ;!'%!" ; %' '":% ;"<""'#  !'''   &%'""%   'E ;"<""'#  13 K  ;BI'#!!"B%#A:!%B;"#'"'"9#%"%$"4J 2K &%##'"@

#""!%!&&!"'"!; 1/"1662&%!!M'BP

3F D;!&&!"'"!9!%#189#<%"%1662'%C'#''B;  <%' ; %' '":%  ;%7"<""'# < 99' %#'%!'"9'&!%;<"%@ 1F  ' !''# B  "7%' %<" $   ; #'#  ":%&%#'%#<!"#%'"'#"7@ 4F #""!.9#<%"%1662!'%!-'$"7%' ;"<""'#'#@ 0F   ' %<!-# $ ;  &!% "  Q<% ; E&%'" #" &%"""&""% "" B '!' '% ' ;"'%'"! B" &!%%"';<#%%!%'"'#"%@ 2F  "7%' <%# $  C!% $   % &&%"#  &%"% C!%  E": !" B" "<%  !'"9"'"!   &%#' #""!=%'F88?"F1'F>@ JF  ' "' B; #<' %!% "%"A# !'%  &%#' #""! % !&&!"'"!;%&;99'&"9H@

!'"<'"!"'#""! !B;"'%'"!#"!"% ' "% '  E&%'" #" ' #"% &!% #<% "  '%!? !'!9!%!!%E'"<"'@

%!%;%#$;!'%''%":%#""!9!%#&%<'  %"? '!  % !" ' !' &%#?' $  %'"''"!;99'&"9%!%@

  %#&!  ;   3J C" 1662 $    %'"''"!  ;99' &"9!'%C'7"@

''  %!"' B  !" A<!" % ;!%A"'"! C"""% =>  #'# !"9"# '  "'"'#  :  3% !L' 1664   %"? '!  % !" !&!#2CA !'&%#"''<"7&%#"' 2&&#'' 3JCA%=%'F3'F%'2J >@

 "' $ ;'"!  ;#'"!  3J CA %  &%  %"? 9##%1/C<"%1660= )34636J> % !"A<!"!&'# 



5166651662  72587   34 9#<%"% "&!"'"!'%"'!"%%A'&%''' %"?'! % !"  "#A%  % $ '%!" CA '"'"%     ;''';#'"!!<ECA%@

 %"?#'""!&#''&!%CA%;&:@

;"'%C'#  '& '" !'%  #""! "'"A"  %!% ' %<? =%'F2JF3'F*F3'%'FJ6!"9##%%&%'"A##%%!"' %!"J!'!?%1666R >@

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

+A"'%'%"'&%+""'%'"!+99'&"9$!&&!"'"!! $%!%!%'"''"!+99'&"9 +'%#<"A%  '+%!%&%'"A##%%!"'%!"= > + %" *A# $  C%"&%   '":% =%%I' &%#"'# F7,F  10 9#<%"% 1660>F  +&%:  C%"&%   &!"?""'#  %'"%% +99' &"9  %!%+'&?!%!#$!"'"!B+"E"' &%'""%  "%!''!'$9"'E&'"!B"C'"9"'''%F ;""!? ?"&'O'$+'!%"'#&&#$''% &&"'"!+%'F22 +E"%" !'"9B"&%'9<%+E#'"!"#"'#""!+&!%'' %EB"&<'I'%"<!B#$+&&"!'"!!'%"%F +'!%"'# "&! %  &!"' + %'" "?%'# +&&%#"'"!F ; A##%    9!% % +#''  9"' ' B+" %#'  !"%   99'%  !A "<'"A'"!&&#'"%F ;&%!#'$&#"'#%I'&%# 



5166651662  7J587    &%#<""! % +"  "'"A  9! &<' #A' I'% &%"  !"#%'"!@B;"9'&'B+9'!'F &%"%  +'!%"'#%"'%'"%%+99'&"9%!%!%B++&%"! !<"'&!%9"%= )31088F!"FJ 33/3.3!"F1?' %#9#%>F &%""&+&&"B"'#A'%+%'F./ F 1  , ='%  <"A% CB+ 43 #?% 1661@ ) 336  0J>  &&"?&%!A"$+%7"<""'#<%'+%'F83 =?%!A#&%  >@

; ;&:  ;  "<!B $ ;&&"  &%!!#  %'%"'  ;99' &"9%!% 9"'B;"'%'"!#"!"%'"%@

;$ '#A%  %"? #!''B&":#" !"% '''';E"';!?"%#'%!"' ;''&!'79!%"!'!" 072?"'#%';9"?%!-A"@

  #"7!"  ;  "7I  %<#  3% C<"% 1661 B  &%!?:  !! &!<"' '%(%  *"&  ;'"<"'# &%!9"!'G!'';'"<"'##A:%@

;$  "'  '' &&%#"'"!  ;   !%!#  BI' #!!"B  "<';&&%#"'"!!#"7!"B'%':%"<"' 99'"!@

;  #""!8<%"1661%!%':%"<"' 99'"!%!%':!%B;"#<#A%#;"<""'#7"  9!' %  &%!&% BI' #!!"B %  #A  38 9#<%"% 1661 B%%"<"'$!"!B;A%#;"<""'#4J 2K#'"'%#"#@

 "'  %!%  ;%# = 5380/51661>   %"? '!  %!"#3.!<?%1664#""!; 8<%" 1661 '!'%<!-'&!%"'%'"!!&#'"%@

;$ ' #A%   %B#%'  ;   !< BI' #!!"B '  #'%"'"!  ;E"' ! ! ; '"<"'# %'"<   %!%'   %"?  # ;' ?!%# $ %<!-%   &!% !<   A%# ;"<""'# $;E"!'!'"'%'"!#"%B'"!%':% "<"'99'"!@

;!#B "'%':%"<"'#'#"&% %"?# !CA'3.!<?%1664@

"; '"'!''% "<"'%!%"%!'%"'CA'@

CA'''%#9!%@



5166651662  7/587   ; %"':!%%<"%%''B'"!@

;!#B;%A'; <"'$&&%"%%'!'"9B "<'"A'"!#"!"<'!%I'%99'# !"'I'%%C'#@

  A%# ;"<""'#  26 2 K # &% ;   16 #?% 1660 &&%('  '!   %#"#  ;  ;"<!B'  %%%   %'"<' $ ;'"<"'# %'"<  ;%# ! $ ;BI' #!!"B %  #A@

;!#B &%#<""!%;""'"A9!<%"' !'!9"%%!";!'%!";"7%';"<""'#$%!%'@

 ;"'#%I'   %!%' $ ;E#'"! "#"'   #""! . 9#<%"% 1662&&%('""&%#&!#%'@

; <   B" &%#:   %"?  # %'"'% ;99' &"9  %!% '":%B#""!%!&&!"'"!7B&&%";!'%!" "7%' 7;'%%&9!%''B%&%#'&%!#%@

;#"2!L'1662%9"E#$; &!%%#&!%%!%@

;"C'"9";!%#&$%!%' B"!?'"'A"F



5166651662  78587  

 !" $ &" %#& !& " #!" !&"

+

-./0/   1  2// /  3 4' &56

  0/ P

3F #%%!%%<?@

* P

1F '"';99'&"9%!%@

4F )"E#"2!L'1662$; &!%%#&!%%!%@

0F !$%!%'""'#9%F266F7$*%A;"'"#@

2F 9!%  &%'"   B; &<' 9!%% %!% !'%  &%#' %%I'   #"  36 C!% :  !'"9"'"! &% &" %!# %#  %"? 9##%  %  ,*V"G%*!9B" J  J660     '%!" E&"%F  #"  &' I'% &%!!A#F  #!"% !"'P > ""B% E''B#""!%!%'#"%!?'"%"'&#""! ''B#@ ?> E&!% &!% B !'"9 " '" &!<!"% % '' '% #""!@ > &!%'%  "A'% !   ! %&%#''F ,"  #!"%  !'"' &  '%!" ##' ##%# ! ''% > ?> ' > "7   %"?9##%%&!%%&'%%'":%%%!%B;" <%#%%"%%<?F#!"%%!%'"!%!%!-  &%<  B" %!' C!"'  "" B  #""! ''B# ' ;<!&&  B#'#E&#"#%!%'=%'F341 36J'368>F  A%99":%P  &%#"'P   -, #%" 

!&"!9!%&%#'%%I''!'"9"#E&%'"""B;$;99"9##% %!"&%A%99



5166651662