Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
ATAS/552/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/552/2007 Généré par l'IA

Standing to Sue After Assignment of Contractual Rights

Numéro de cause ATAS/552/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The court addressed whether a party had standing to sue for breach of contract despite not being an original signatory to the agreement, where the original signatory later assigned its rights. The court reasoned that the assignment of contractual rights effectively transferred the right to sue for breach to the assignee, allowing the current party to maintain the action, as the essential facts concerned the transfer of a legally recognized interest in the contract allowing the current party to enforce the agreement's terms against the breaching counterparty.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Standing to Sue After Assignment of Contractual Rights: The court reasoned that the assignment of contractual rights effectively transferred the right to sue for breach to the assignee, allowing the current party to maintain the action, as the essential facts concerned the transfer of a legally recognized interest in the contract allowing the current party to enforce the agreement's terms against the breaching counterparty.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
cession de contrat rétrocession de créance intérêt moratoire contractuel violation positive du contrat compétence en matière de contrats conclus par les consommateurs droit des obligations

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Généré par l'IA

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This article is cited in the dispositive concerning the costs of the proceedings.

Art. 68 al. 2 LTF

This article is cited in the dispositive concerning the costs of the proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

           ())*+(,++- #(..,(,++/

#

 #$ #     $

"01  2 ' ,, 0 ,++/            !"#$%  &'( ''( )!(   *!(+(' , ('      ('    --   * .. /    ' ( ! 012  

       !  "  #$#% ! &' ' 

   /#3"4/  

 3$#

"7   !  "152  !&!  $ 8!)' ' #665   &'9  *--     * .. /    : /&'9  ;) (<*(' *'(* )  (!79=88' '*'(>'   =(  ?   ) =8( ( !(!' '(   ? &' 9' &>=& &@ A*'(>'=' (:'(;(0&  ) !&>(  0)  &   ?     8 (    ? !& &   @ A  *! (   ( * !& 0 (   ' (7

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

 '   F(! @* ( ) (! '( ) < #6E '( ( & C  !( ( 88  <(')'@&( () (C &! ' ' =  =(@*&) ('(' 5>7&'F'C(#>7 &' F' @* !( (  ')>   (!   & (  < =?  *   C((& ( '& 7

47 *'!'& @(  '')(<!(' '(((#"F #6657  0 !' @    ) ( !(!  C (!  ?'' (  ( ) (! '( )  @ (! *&0!  ' < '   #6 / 46E  '   C 8  '7' (?'!((( ) (!&  8  ( &0'  ( &   "' !C' #6647   ! C!'!( '! ? &'((   *'/>G=7  '&& @*  (') ! < &  (& *H( "1$% < )'  "12" ( < @  *( ' ! @*  ?'!  ( ) (! < %6E  "' ' "12#  4" (C' "124 !=( < %6E   <



344563#66$  /43"4/     "')C'"1B#46&(C'"115&'I(<#6E  J  "' )'  "112  46 )C' #664 :8  (;7  ?& @ @* (') !') *I<%6E&'> ?&' :9'  80';(<#6E&'J' !(((!:'(>';7 (') ((<  <"6E&0!C'&''  =7  F( @* * & ) =! *=('  (& *( ) (!  &)(&'('& '>' <(&'') '*' ('7

57 (''=! &' *   '    @!  1   #66% @ *'(>' = (!( (&'(  9'('!8'((&K> ((( ( ) (!'!'<( ('&'8   @( ) (!&'!  '!&!( ( )(0&('(' (C'' (7

%7 ?'>(= @!(!'! !&'' '  .')  !  '!=   : /&'9 .;  ## H( #66%7   !(! '( < ( ('   =(  ) '!&'  '  & (!  (')  ?  &0'(>'   =( C (!'  ==  C (!'   ' * >'&(>  '(  (  !C(  ='(>' (' * (( &(/ 0) (   &'( ( (!' ' (  *!>'' ('>0  < => ( * &!' '(>'&(>  &/>!' & '@! < ' (   '*((&(?   8 ( <=>(  ( <' ((< ( ('   =(   '!&'  '  & (!  (')  ? *?9 &!'((&(/>!0(( *((&(/(' && =)  C' 8!' '?G(!!='0'C '(')  ' * ('C (( @ ( &'CC( !=!!'( 8    @  0C  '7

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



344563#66$  /53"4/   =  ( ( < !) ('7  &'(  >'= (   (! < "6 M=  (7( ) (!8 ('!&!( ( )  (( =( (('9  (!7 !)!='!& (!(')  *( ) (!>C ('!( '<%6E(( ) (!&(!<16E7  88(  !'! @  (')   '!( ' !( ( ('9   (! <    &0'(>')! =(&'((@* )(') '( (  (&(  ((' '(( '  >  ! @7 ' (( ( ) (! &(!  '!( '  ('  ')>  & (!  (')  ( ( 9' )  &( (   (   '(  <  ! (!  8 '  &( ( & &'!=' 'FC( 7((@!=9'&(' (N>)@@0?   '&'(')?8 7

$7 '!  #8!)' '#66$*  8'!( '*'!@ (((  !=9'  ?( ) ( !(! '(  (   * &' ?'D(  ( ) (! &'8  < 46E (  '( <  (')? >C ( &'  '((@*&'!( (& (!(') ' C(? = C ( ) (!>C (*&0!C'%6E@' *&& (  < @*?'( ) (!<46E&'&!@* *0) (!@ &&'(! @' !(((!@*= ((N> !=9' !( ('!<*@K(! @'!=9'@* &'!( (&*&K>( = 8 ( 8*& ((')? >C (@*8 (&'( 8&'((  !( ('F(!7

27 *'! '&'!(! &' +(' /'  -   8'! && ( 7  (< O)'*'(*'!&(( &'8  <*(' * /'(* )  (!7

B7 * &'!!<@K(! @'!=(2F #66$7   ' *'!  !'! @* ' ( (') ! < %6E  (( ( <  (!'&&(@*) ((') !<%6E&(A(@* )'D (7 '!(*@K(@*&'!((?* & (!<& '(')? !='"2%E7

17 ' !    "" F ( #66$ *   8 '!  (((  ?(  *'! < '   46E &' *( ) (! '( ) (  '(( &'  (')? >C (7  '&&@*'!'!?&'(( *'/>G=@  & &8)'*)(!*=('(?*( ) (!K@ 8 (  * ('   ' ( ! ' @*   ( &7 )( @   '   *'! ') (  & (!  (')  ' C( ? = C  %6E   ( ) (! >C ( *&0!  C'*&'(@*&'!( ('&&'(*@K(! @(? *&K>(  *& (  (N> !=9'  "2%E *(' &'( *   8 ( C(  ='! * )  (!  "#E  F( 8 ( & *(' &'((  7



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

""7 '!&#$&(C'#66$* 'F(''7

"#7  #$ 8!)' ' #662 +(' -   8'!  ' C  ! @*   ( *&'7

"47 ' '' '  $ ' #662 +(' ('    ,  !'! ) ' !(! (!&'*'!(&' ! ' C!C ) ' ( 8 ' F=((&)7

"57 '' '* #$&(C'#66$!(!(' <*'!( ='!<F='7

 $#

"7  =) 'P'= ( F   ':;!(! 8 !( ( (!9  "' H( #664  ' C (  '   ((( 8'!( < *'(7 %$ 7 " (7  >7 #   (  @ '  ((( &'!)<P'(7%$ 8!!''&'( =!!'' ( '    $ (C' #666 : ; @  ( '( ) <    ' P'/ )  (!  "1 F  "1%1 : ;7 . &!( &' F='   P&9(  !(C 7

#7    ( ('!  ) ='  "' F) ' #664 ('+(   8 (  != ( ) ((   ' (  *'/ )  (!7  & (  ) (&'(&'  &&& C'9=' () ='(Q  8 ( F'  @( !(' (  ( &' ( (  F=  '  8&'  &&'&&'! ''*!((8 ('! !<



344563#66$  /$3"4/   (!(' (!  '&& (  ( = : -"#15 7"7#R "$1 7"R4%$ 7"(''K( (!;7

.'8 ' C!'9)@!   ( = 0(!(!' (""F (#66$(((('!((8 (F'  @(!(' ( '(( < *! #664  &'!(  ( = ' ? ! <   9'   & (     7  ) ( @  @*    (  ')' @   & (  *( &  8 !  (  * )  (!  *    (  F' &' - 0'( )((F'*( (!7

  @  '  &'!' ( < !8(  '9= (' ( ' (' '   ('*&& ( *&& @('!')9F'' ('!) =': -""214 7$CR""#4$6 75R  "11B S42&74"$ 74C;7

47 !&!   8' ( !  &'!) &'     &'!( '' ( ')C :'(7$6 ;7

57  ( =&'('@( ) ' P'!&'!(='!P )  (! &( CP)' '' (<'(P )  (!7

%7 P )  (! (    (    & (!  =  &'!! &'(   = '! @  '!( P (( ( <  (! &>0 @  ( &')( P 8 ' (!=! (P P (:'(7B7" '(7 5 ;7P(( (<(!P(&<!(' (('&'   !'( @'Q('+ & (!(') 0( 88('& (!= P'!:0'/'=(ATC'  ) )' >'=U' >"112&7B;7

$7  )'(  P'(7 #B 7 "     ('  ) =' F@* 4" !C' #664 *'!  ' ( <  @'(  '( *  ( )  < 56E    <   /'( (?* )  (!(%6E&(<'(( 9'  /  (&!' '<$$#34E7& "'F) '#665P!>('(  P'(7 #B 7 "   * & !(!  8 !  (( @*  '  @'( (   /'( @* &'(!' *('0'(' /@'('(< (  ='! * )  (! (( ( $6E    ' @  (? )'( ' ( <  '(( 9'(&!$$#34E<26E7

27 '!)'(?P )  (!')@P'!' (&C( 'P P!( ( & ) (&'!) @P &'' (C( '?'D(P( ) (!@  &( ' C( K(' ? =!    &'9  (' (( (  '  '!&((  '  '>!  (')  !@  C'! :'(7 "$  ;7 P )  (!  '!@ P?'(&P( ) (!'( )((&( ' C( ? ='@P ('&'((!)!!'=( <P'(7"$  8(   P & (! P& ' ' (')? >C ( :'(7 #B 7 #C   



344563#66$  /23"4/   (') ='& "'F) '#665;7'@P'!?' ( ) (!'( )<(&&'( (') K(''!!'!P('&'   F (P )  (!&'((( ) (!(!)!P'(7"$  7.P  & (  (')? >C ( P )  (! ( 8 ?!  P7 #C  &' (( ( ) (!/< :'(7 #B 7 # ('     ('  ) =' &   "' F) ' #665;7

B7  ( ('&'!C 8( ? '*='(75(%  @ !(> *!)( P )  (! ) (*&& @':'(7#B ''!( )  '(7 #2  ;7  > ?   !(> *!)(   * )  (! :!(> =!!'  &'   ') !(>  ?( !(> &! 8 @; !&'(((C!!8   '&(( '(L'!?'D(( ) (! '( ) < (& &( '! ?'D(  ( ) (! '( ) < (& &'(  '!( 87

17 ' ) '    '!  ( K('  !'!   &' ?'D(  ( ) (!<& (&<(&&'( '&( )(&'!(' '&'( *( ) (!'( )&''&&'(<'!?(')?!=' ) ( *? '@8' (*'!K '(* *!( (&(( ( (!7''!(') (!= 8(( '&(  (( 8   (&'8   @(N>*!( (  <*!='8(*N=&( (&'8 8'(   & ( (&'! & ( 7.&'( @@( ((( ( K(' ('>! '  C    ((  ( @* *( !)&&! F@* ( Q *  ('(   &'   !   ' @ &' ((' *!)( (!@*'!' (?'!( ) (!'( )* ) (!(! C(! 8 @8'&'C( ''>C ((' ( ' (( =='!)' C&'!&!'(: -"#% "%6 7#""2"15 74C('!8!' (!R."112&746"  7#C"11$&7#61 7"('!8!' (!;7

"67 ' (9')' C&'!&!'(@ (=!!'(&& @!    ' (  *'   )( !=( &' *&&'! (   &')' : -"""42# "C("6%##1 4;7 ( )' C&'!&!'( = 8 @*? (*8 ((& )' CC @  C :87 - """  425;7      ' F=8!  8 & ( (' '  '8 (@ 8(*K('!(C  9' ''!8(C&&' ( & )' CC *(/</ ' @  &'!((  ='!  )' C &'!&!'(7   88 (  & @* 8 ( &  K('  !'! (   >0&(>9 & C7 '  (  !!(  8 ( !=!  ) =C  F=  (   !>!( '( ' ? @    &' (  & &'CC: -"#$4$6 7%C"#%"1% 7#('!8!';7   *? (/(/  &  ' (  '    &'  &  @



344563#66$  /B3"4/   *  ('( F=)' ((('(8)'*'!: - "#$4## 7%;7

""7 P&9P'!(') !F@*)C'#664<' 46E (#6E  ')   J ( "6E <    &' '  =7    @!@(  '')(<!(' '(((#"F #665@* C (!  ' ( ?'!  ( ) (! '( ) < #6/46E &'  ( 8

8  '7   ((8  F(! @* ) ( &')( (') ! < %6E &' I(@ ) ('! ((&(') <#6E*!( ('  !(((!7

  '  *@K( !=9' *'!  (( 8 /   '( !'! @*' ((') !<%6E *) (&88'(((*'(>'(( ='((&&'*('(  ( ? ?7

 ) (  =!!' *''  &'!8!' ? &' 9' !'(   *'! 8 ( ' @*   =' ( &(/K('  !@ F'  @  ?& ( )&)(K('/ (/8' ('!8?  (!' ': -"#"52 7#""%"54 7B;7

0((8  *C')'@'&' 9'!'( *'!) ( !F<?& @!@*) ('! ((&(') <#6E' !((  (!7  ( 9 ' (( < 8 ( )' CC @* * ( & &'   @(  ''( 8(((7 ((((( 88 (&(&< <&'(') ( @*C(!' ((') !<%6E7

*'!9=@*)' ((') '<%6E&'( 88  '8 ( @* *( !&'!   ' 7 -' ( ((8   ((' @* )C' #664 '@*  &'  (')  ' @* ) ) ( !F<  <  ' :87@K( !=9';  * &   (! *  (!  *'/>G=7  &&'(  '&  '&&'( ! ? @  &' 9' (( ( <  (! (88'*'!(')9"116@**(((8  8! & (!  (')  @*< &(' *)'  #6647   0 /(/     ((' @ *'!)' CC('! ((&(') "115&(%6E< #6E&' (! &'@*) (!(!  !&' ( 8! @7

  ) ( &' !@( P((' @    ((    !((  (! P'!' (( !<(') 'K&'&'( @*( ''K(  (')    C  @  ='! * )  (!  ( K(' !(' !   !(>  ?( < '   46E &' *( ) (! '( ) (  '(( &'  (')?>C (7

"#7 )'(P'(7#2C 7" :(') ='F@P4"!C' #664; P )  (!  '! @  P?'( @ &'( (  ( ) (!



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

"47 '&) ''='!P )  (!P  ('( :F=P 0 '';  C   ( @  !  !)((   P(' &!  ( )( 8' '7(N>!  (<&'('F=( 'P!(((!(<  @'@'(&'@( ) (!P'! ( &C(') '7('!! ( ((!!( (  &' !(' ' @ (')?  &( ' ' C( ? ='  P'! : - "#%  #$"  7 5 ""%  "45  7 # ""5  4"5  7 4 "6%"%B 7";7

@ ')'&'C(P'&&'(! @ (!(' ( P( @  & (  ( = ?  ( 8 ( PCF( P !(  '( ! @  '&&'(  8 '  ? &( @P  &' !=(   !'( & (?&' !&'&'? !@P  (!(!!(C  &     P9 @  ' &(   (?( !  ( P&&'! (  (( !  ( '(8 @  P?&'(  ( H( ( )!7  '( P!!( !(' ( &'  )' &'C( P(   P' =   0  &')    ! =(   '&&'(?&'(  C(C (: -"#%4%# 7 4"##"$6 7"('!8!';7

"57  *&9  '    !(C  &'  .  '&&'(  ## H( #66%7  '&&'( '& ( (  '!@  (   F' &' &'(((    ((' C' &  )' &'C(7  88(  '    ?& @!  @  ( ((( (<(!''((@  ((  ('+ (7. ( '(C ( )!'(@ ' C !*( 8*!'('70 '( '!@@ *(( ( <  (! &'!(! &'  ''( ('+    (    & (!  (')  (  =   %6E  *( ) (! >C (  '!( ' ( 



344563#66$  /"63"4/   16E   ( ) (! &(! !(( &'! ! @ &' (( ( ) (! &(!  '!( '('& (!(') (( 9')&( (  (  '(<! (!8 '&( (&&'!=' 'FC ( 7

'&&'(B8!)' '#665' !=(( !< %6E &  F  #664  & (!  (')    &( (7   '( F(! @*( ) (!'( )<#6E'( (& C8 (<*!) ((8  '(&(') 88( )((') !&'&( (F@/<7

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



344563#66$  /""3"4/   '@(( (&(' (8 ' CK ((  (K '( ) (*(('<') '&'((  *'7   !>!(  &(  '!('  = !8'!  *!((  (! '!   &' '! :) ' !=( 0'/' >(&'>= =' >(AU' >"112&7###;7

"$7  P&9 P   &'!! <  @K( ! @ '  !=R  '!((( )(L

')? !'(  &K>( )  (!  (!= %E 6E 6E  ((  46E "6E 4E ('( =( #6E "6E #E >(3' )' "6E 46E 4E  )3('(  #6E "6E #E )K(( . ?8( 6E 6E 6E ?('C'    8      )' "%E %6E 27%E ( "66E  "27%E

(( @K(  !(! !(C   8' (! )  ' ' ' * )  (! ( * &(* :  ;788( 88!'(( ) (!''(( !(! &!'!  (  9' @ *C '&'!( "66E !&( ( !=@ * &&'' *!= (!(' (((' '! :'( @ . "112 &7 465  7 5;7  * ( @ '@   *&9 *'!  !&   ( ) (!  *  *(' (!='  :&' ?&  *C *8( ( *(' C'   8  ! ((   ;&!'( ('&( (K('=(!*((7

P'!  ((!  &!'(   '(  (')? !=' !(C  &' P@K(7 9'88(@(?"%E*( ) (!'(<'C' @ $72'( )?( ) (!  '*(&88 ('@?46E&' * ((  ( #6E &'   ) ( *('(   )K((  )' ( & K(' !)!& @*) (7

. *) (&'!'<''( (' & (> (!&' *'! (L $7#L #6E 46E $7%L "6E #6E( $72L 4%E "%E



344563#66$  /"#3"4/    ) ' (  '( '  &K>( < >('  "$E   @  ' *& (  ( ) (! !=9'  @    8 ' ( &  '!((

8 7

0<(!=' (('@*'''*(= !& ($72 *@K(@('! (!4E:"%EL%6;@ ' (H'&' ( ) (!!=9'='!* )  (!"4E7(?*&K>(*( &  & !(! ''(( !(C    ' Q  (( (!   (? !&"66E7

"27 P!)(   (? P )  (!  0   !(>  ?( P!)(   !(' <P 8' )(L

?X:VUYW?,;

Z(') 8' &''!((@&' ) ?'D( ( ) (!'( )>'&' 7

 Z > & '('!  (( @ &' ?'D(  ( ) (! '( )  &'(7

UZ'!(') '&'?'D(( ) (!'( )<&  (&C'>'!>'&' 

,Z> &'('!!=&'(7

"B7  (? P )  (!    C( ( @  @*    ( 88 ( &' F( 8 ' *(' *@'('(*'(7#B7" 7

 '' (/ K(''F(!7







344563#66$  /"43"4/  

  4#$3  #$ #     $

'

  5 0

"7 !'''')C7

' 5 

#7 'F((7

47 *!(8 ?!<#668'7( <>'=''(7

57 8'  &'(    @P &)( 8'' '' ('  &'!( ''K(   !   46 F' 9  ( 8 (  &'9  ' C 8!!' :.>[ A'>8@ $$665  ;&') ''( 9'' ( &C 8'!(?'(7B# 8!!'' ' C8!!'"2 F  #66% : -;R  ! '  ''  (  @'    ( 8 ( 0&')(&'(' =('''(( 'R  ( K(' '!  ' C 8!!' &' )  &(  &' )  !(' @ ?  (   *'(7 5#  -7  &'!( ''K( (  & 9  &   ''( )@!0&') )(K('F (<*) 7  ='88 9'  '! (     ' /  U ' \ 

& 8'&'!(''K((( 8 !?&'(   @P<P88 8!!' ' &'='88





344563#66$