Appeal of Financial Obligation Judgment
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe case involves a dispute over financial obligations or rights where the appellant sought to overturn a judgment concerning several distinct monetary amounts referenced by specific dates or identifiers. The court upheld the lower court's decision, reasoning that the appellant failed to demonstrate sufficient error in the original ruling regarding the specific disputed sums, thereby affirming the established financial liabilities or entitlements without finding basis to modify the trial court's calculations or interpretation of the underlying facts or agreements.
Regeste Legislator
Généré par l'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Appeal of Financial Obligation Judgment: The court upheld the lower court's decision, reasoning that the appellant failed to demonstrate sufficient error in the original ruling regarding the specific disputed sums, thereby affirming the established financial liabilities or entitlements without finding basis to modify the trial court's calculations or interpretation of the underlying facts or agreements.
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IACited in the final order to regulate court costs.
Texte complet
"##$%"#&&$ "%'#"#&&(
))
* )* *)
+, - . #/ 0 #&&(
1 2222222222 !" ########## $$!
!$
33 4 $%&'%'&() &!&"+ *(
!
',0'
3
1 &$ ##########2!&$&!34"56+($&$,//1!%+&%$ %2&%"&!&+!+($!6($%.6+($&$,//176+($&$,//-
, ,18(&$,//-266&$+5&%9"!:;9$+2&9!&!% 9"! % ########## %* , %+"<$ ,//, !! %+&& ! !$+6$
- ,."$,//- &!5(&%34"5: ;$% %+&& %"%! = ########## $"<$"! % 6$ ->7,/0/ $$9%! ? &%"&!+ 9$@ = !$! !$ , ! -1 %+"<$ ,//, &!=%+&&%2&9!&!%9"!$%9$2 !!%+&&2 96&!2<8!%299&!&9$2&!+$+
7 11 8&! ,//- 2$+ %"%+ = $"& % "!! % 6$ ->7,/0/
. $ %+&& % 1- A! ,//- 266& ! % 2"9& : ; !& $'34"5%+$+&$$(<%"%%$"&9$+&!+"!&6 B2$9!&!9%+&%-/8$%2$! 7 7%2$%$ 9$!&5++$%%$&!%$&%119!"<$,///: ;
) ,CA!,//-2&!+$+2!99+=%+&&%2 %1-A!,//- 9(&! 9 $"<$$ "" %"%+ $ & $(&! "!! "%2D9&++$%6$ 1>-./ '
0 17("<$,//-5$9$+"!&%2 $8!+299&!&% ##########
E 1C ("<$ ,//- ########## $$ 9$* % $&< ! %$&: F;=2!$%%+&&$99&!&%17 ("<$,//-
C )8(&$,//72 !$"& F%&$%9&*
1/ ,. "& ,//7 F !% 9$!& 2$+ %+$+ B2& +!&! = 2D9&++$%9&6&8(&$,//- (&!9$&!$%&("!& %%+&&%,."$,//-$'&+!&!$$&(+3G9$!$B &'"H" 2(&! 9 % %"&& 6&? %+& 1. 8& ,//7 +!+ 6&?+ = 2 9$+(!$+?"%%+&&
11 78&,//72 %+$+"&!&$%+&&%17("<$,//-
,,-.,//- '-0' )
1 ;&5(&$2$5&!&8%&&&$:;+!+"%&6&+!&!&!+ %* 1$ A! ,//- $&< ! % $ & :$! 1 ! $ ;
$$H!%-/"$,//79%! $&<%"&&!$!&6:&'9$* ; !!+%266&&!+%2$! 1! $&%+$!B F(&! +!+$++(&!&%2$! 1-1% !&!!&5(&' ! '
<;I$!%!!$B!!&$&!&$!$&<%+ ?"!&6&(!J
'6&5$9%%&9&!&6%2$$H! $%&9&!&6%285"! 9!B+$&$2!$&!+%385+!"!&6 2!$&!+%3 85+ 2+!% = ?'& B % "$ K %&9&!&6 L $(& ?9$+"! ! K & $99$!! = B!& &!&5& : I C) ,C.M N99 $+& % %$&! %"&&!$!&6 7*" +%&!& 1CC1 9 ,7E M D<3&% %$&!8%&&&$9$&(+&1CE19 -1-! ;
'>!$&!+%385+(!B&B2&&!B9$"LB !$&<9(&!?"&$:6 N999 &! 9 ,.1; $&99$O!29* %!? B %(&! ! "H" 9(&! = 2& %2 $$ &!$8!+ 9$ (&!& % %$&! 9&!&B !$ $$H!+ % & %2 !! 6&?! %!%2+!&%85$ F!$4$!&!!&&!+% &&!&!!!!8$&%&!&
' & &!&!!& $&! H!$ %+$+ F 2! 9$& 99&!&%'&!<:6 'I$@& <$!%!!$3! %$ F3P&G ( 1CC1 9 10E ! 7-/; (&! $9 % $($ B2!$&<%&!$*55++$%25&$($!99$!&&*$"! $B +B % 2!& <($$&! !! $+5&" 8$&%&B : I 11, -1-; ! "&6!"! && %* $ B &%+$! !9&B % 2$$H! % $(&! = &$ 2?&! %2 8$&%&!& B&6!&%9&1$A!,//-%+8=!%!85!&!&$&&B 8599+!!+!+$+5&*$"!+
; F?"&%266&"9+!M(2$$H!% %-/"$,//7 &!8B2=?&!&+5"!=(+$&6&$6$"&!+=2$! 1-1 ! %&2&!&!!
F!8$&%&!&%"&&!$!&(9+&B2!$&!% %"&9$!&&$%$& L&%$99$B2$! .0 % & 6+%+$ $ 9$!& 5++$ % %$&! % $ & ' ' !$+ (&5$ 1$ 8(&$ ,//- 3B ! &!&! !$&< %
,,-.,//- '70' $ B& !! &! &B $ $$ % %"& % $ & !! %&9&!& +5 6+%+$ <&5 ! = $5$9$ !! !!&? % $ & "H" !&! !!&?8B=$+9$!&=*(!$%&($""&&!% $$! 2!&&9$$+9%$=2?&59+9$&6+%+$ B+5&!$5(&$++ F
F2$! 1-1 1 ! Q&+!<&!%!$&<?9$"!9$85$ !! &(& ! 9+M $*5 "<$ 2$5&!& 8$&%&!&!"9+!R $%$+!&% 1C01%&9&!& !&!!&+!+"9+!+9$&+,&<+""&!JQ!$&< %"&&!$!&6!&!&!+9$!!$$$$%%$&!%"&&!$!&6% K&9$+(&!R
!&!!&2&!$9$*!"H"9$&&9B&$%&&$ $*5 %2&!$9$+!!& 9$"!!! 85 % %+55$ %2 %&9&!& ! J %$&$ 9! $$&$ = &!$9$+!!& &!!+$ 3&!$&B !++5&BL!+"!&B%$" 85%($9$!&$9$&$&!&$"!% !?! &$ % & % $$H! % -/ "$ ,//7 &%+$+ B !?! % 2$! 1-1 , ! &&! 9 % 9 9$ %2!$ !$&<? !!! $ $$ % %$&! %"&&!$!&6M & &!$9$+!+ Q !$&<R ""&5&6&! Q!$&<R $2$! 1-1 , ! 9$+&B !$&< %"&&!$!&6 ! &!&!+ Q% K & 9$+(&!R 2! %&$ B +&$"! $! % !!&? %"&&!$!&6 $*( %2!$ 8$&%&!& &&2&!$9$+!!&&!!+$9$"!=%$B !$"QR%&!H!$B&6&+5$""!&"!%2$!&&%+!$"&+
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
,,-.,//- '.0' * 1$ 8(&$ ,/// +!+ "& <++6& %2 5++$ % "9+! ! && %( 8$&%&!& %"&&!$!&( 9+$&$ % %$&! "" :$! .) ; ( "&!& % ""&& % $$ 9+&+!+?9$+"!$+66&$"+: 1CC09 C7-/; !&!!&&!+% 8$&%&!&2%98"&+!+$"&&9$ I&9$ I (&!9%%&!&B&$&!"9H3++5&!$BB + 9 !$% % 6&$ "9+! "!&*$ %2$ & 8B=%+(=""&&%$$=8$&%&!&%"&&!$!&( 9+& F2$$
F&2%(&!&($2&!$9$+!!&% %$$H!%-/"$,//7 "! F "& +5"! !! !$ ""&& % $$ 9+&L"9$&$!!3+ &'"H"$&!&!&!!& 2"&6!"!9+!+<!(&+9$+5&!$
( % B& 9$+*% $+!& % F 99&!& % ! 6$"= !&!!&5(&
2+!& % 85 $ L! 9$ &$ +!+ + 9$ $&< 6+%+$%$$H!%,08(&$,//7$% &5(&%9!+ 1- 6+($&$ ,//7 %&9&!& !$&!&$ 9$"!!! F % &+5$ $ = !$& 85 !&!&$ % 2!!! % 2+!& % (? $
, !$8!+!"9!&%(!8$&%&!&"9+!!$$!$(< :$! .) 1! 3&66$E%&$>$5&!&8%&&&$%,,("<$ 1C71'!)/ ;
- ; 2$! - 9$+(&!B2+!%%2<&5!&% $!&!$ !6&?+9$ %+&& : 1; 2$$ &%&B 9&<&&!+ %2 $"& % %+&&$!&!!&: ,; 2$$%+&%%%+&&%$$= $!&!!& $B2& ! "&6! B %&!& %2 $"& ! $+& : -;
<; ?!$"%2$! 7 $!&!!&!&*$9$!&%9$!!& +&%A"!"&$@%<6&9!H!$?&5+&2&!+$+ !$(%&!!&%&66&&: 1; !%+!$"&!9$99$+&$2&L &!!& %&66&& ""! K %+&& % $!&!!& ! ?+!&$ : ,; !$&!+?B9$!!&!+!+($+($!%2$! ,/ %%&9&!&%&9+&9(!&(B$6&!B2 $&!"&%&!!&%&66&&: -; %"%%$"&%&!H!$ 9$+!+9$+$&! %&!H!$"!&(+"95+%9&*+&$! %+9+ 9 !$% -/ 8$ = "9!$ % 2!$+ 6$ % %+&& % $!&!!& : 7; $"&6&!2<8!%2%+&&: .;
,,-.,//- ')0' 7 29*$$!29$9!+%+&%-/8$9$+&!+%*$B %"% % $"& %+9+ 11 8&! ,//- = &! % %+&& % ,. "$,//-!"&6!"!!$%&( F25&!%!&6&!&%%+&& % ,. "$ ,//- $$! $&! &(B$ (<"! 6&! B2& 9$& & !$%&("! %* $ B 2%$ B2& &'"H" ""&B+ = 2!$&!+ & ! 99< : I 11C ECM F % 1$ 8& ,//7 10)E,//-; && %+&& !&6&+ ,. "$ ,//- 9$ $""%++!+$@9$$$!%"&$%=2+3+% %+&%5$%%08$!!!$+6$-/8$9!$%&!"9!! %6+$&%UB1)"&,//- %+&%-/8$$$&(&!&&=+3+ 1) 8& ,//- %"% % $"& %+9+ 11 8&! ,//- ! % &$$(<
. 2$! .- 9$+(&!B2$$9!$(&$$%+&&6$""! 9+6$$B2!"&6!"!$$+!B$$!&6&!& $(H!&"9$!!<
9!%"%$&%"%%$"&%118&!,//-2$&!9%A H!$&%+$+9$2 ""%"%%$&%+$!&%%+&& % $!&!!& %* $ B !! !$&!+ 2 9 ?"&+ & %&!& %2 $"& +!&! "&6!"! $+& "" 9$+(&! 2$! - - ! $ "H" B $$! %! & 2! 9 !!+ B2& +!&! % < 6& 9$(&!%9&6&8(&$,//-%9$!!&%2D9&++$
9%! $&< % + 9! $%$ = 2 % 6&$ 2%"&&!$!& L! 6!+ % $$ = !$$ "!&*$ $ ! %"%%$&%+$!&: I11C70C;
+B$$9!B2H!$$8!+
,,-.,//- '00'
) 3 )* *)
56171 8 911 1 4! '+# :
71
1 +$$$$(<
71
, $8!!
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
,,-.,//-