Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/507/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/507/2006 Généré par l'IA

Property Transaction Disputes and Contractual Breaches Appeal

Numéro de cause ATAS/507/2006
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case involved multiple disputes concerning various past transactions and alleged breaches of contract related to property interests across several years, encompassing issues of property ownership, contractual performance, and damages calculations stemming from these dealings. The court reasoned by meticulously analyzing the documentary evidence and testimony presented for each distinct claim, ultimately determining that the plaintiff failed to meet the requisite burden of proof for most claims, thus affirming the lower court's findings on the validity of the underlying agreements and the corresponding awards or denials of relief for the specific actions brought.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Transaction Disputes and Contractual Breaches Appeal: The court reasoned by meticulously analyzing the documentary evidence and testimony presented for each distinct claim, ultimately determining that the plaintiff failed to meet the requisite burden of proof for most claims, thus affirming the lower court's findings on the validity of the underlying agreements and the corresponding awards or denials of relief for the specific actions brought.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
dommages-intérêts contractuels fardeau de la preuve régime de propriété créance contestée manquement du bailleur restitution d'immeuble

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The dispositive explicitly orders the appellant to pay the costs of the federal court proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/3204/2005
Asset Transfer and Contractual Dispute Litigation
A/1743/2007
Property Sale Financing Dispute and Contract Breach Litigation
A/4500/2006
Property Rights and Contractual Obligations Dispute
A/36/2005
Contractual Dispute Over Property Financial Transactions
A/2049/2005
Property Rights and Contractual Breach Dispute

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The dispositive explicitly orders the appellant to pay the costs of the federal court proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

 

        

     #$%&'#())* +#')%#()),

""+

 +"  - +   " - -

-.  &  (&  ()), 



 !"""#$% !&'(% '!'( #("!!"")#(*('+ ,--  .(#&/





!('

..    ... ) ..  .  . "("# )   . -/((('0 &!(1/2345 6778   

           !"  

   ,8900,  



90:2498773  ,3900,  

 /+

0;     #  0<67  #("( &!=# &" 0<<2  >"(# )!%'"$'!(?&'$)('&'"@.; ;A'!"B;

  ("('   #("( '# !('  "( &'!1"! ( ! &'!1"! &'$   " ("! "   )"( C",&'$D  . E;

8; (0'#F'8777 #(#%"(")"("'("! !"( !""!1'!(%!('!'>)'!"(A!"47G"!$(' A)/'!#'("!A&!";

.!11'(!''%" #(#!"(FA"%""! '?#"!,/"''?"C ECH#(F"(/!&"("HE;

3; (!''%""">)1'(',((2!(#(#"?!("># ( )"&"(#  ('%"  #(# 1"B# A 077I $  (  )"( C'&&!'( #"    88 J%"' 8770E;  ('"((  (=& !'%('  #(# ('&'";

2; )"&"(#('%"""#A:4I$0<'8770 A67I$0:%'" 8770  &" A 47I $  37 %'" 8770;  8 J"( 8770  )'#  '&'" ! ('%" A &" (& J>) 07 !(!F' 8770  ( ) !% "&"(#  ('%"A47I>"#(#&'!!?#&'"( /!'"'(&#'"!&"(# (!(0285J%"'8778C'&&!'("('#""'#(F"BH#(F"( /!&"("HE;

4; &'(">#08J"8770"#%"1!(&(B (!'(  "> 3,2 "" >  "!&(/" &'!('"% '%" "1#'"'!()!'"?"&!(,('(">#("(('$&'!FF;

6; !' ) B &'(">#  5 ' 8778   #" )''!"(   . !((#>1'('!()(!'!!'%"%"( #(#('"(#!'%("%( !((A)")"'%&!'(#'(('!" !"  " >  A &  >"K !"  )"(  )#(( )#("( & !' (!(((F""#;

)'#  #'"( ! ("%"(# /F"( !  ("%"(# ("(  C1F'"("!  "'"( #('">E ( B&!# !11'"' ) ?!'"(   " ?/ !'>) 1""( &"' /'  "(  L ('%";   B&"># >) &!%"( ?#''  !' !'>) ('%""( A 47I " ! A 077I  '"!   ''  !' '%"!,!'C!'#("%""!(>%&'1!" B(L(%%'("?E;



90:2498773  ,2900,   )'##?(#(#(A)?$%(84J"8778; #'#>))%"(J")"(%("0'#F'8777 (>)A)/'(!#((#("((("!"';

:;  '!'('&&!'(#(F"2J"(8778&''  '!!?  > &("(!11'"( &'(/#" B>('F' %""("! FJ("%("!(/'">&"(JF&"! "(;  ! '&&!'(   '   (!(1!" !"?# > ( B '!!?"> #("( &'1"(( !' ( >)" )= %"(  ##( !FJ("1 &'(((  !''!F!''  ('!F !(  &"?"(  &("(;   ??#'#  &'!#' A  "?'" '%" 1"  #'  #%( !("!#"';

5;   '&&!'(  82 J"( 8778   '   /"''?" CH#(F"( /!&"("HE   !((# >  F" '"!!?"> 11(#  !('"(&#"!('(">"#>#"!('(">(>)%  )"?'" '#"# "" >  )B "">   &("( &'#("( ('$ %'"FF((("((=&1"F'!=?">;

<;  88 !M( 8778   '   #" )''!"(   .  $%   '%# >  &("( %"( !(#  '  ( ("(&!'#%!&&(1!'"("%  JF ( > &' "'  "(("! #("( (!J!'  L  )'#  &"?(#?()>)# "">!'"%!'; '   !"?# >  )#%!("!    )! !(("( >)" )= %"( &  ('!F '!!?"> !FJ("1 "  #"! ('("> !  #>#"!('("> N!O)#%!("!"?!(")(("((=& 1"F'!=?">; )#((   &("( #("(  %!"  (F""("!   ##( !FJ("1 &!%( B&">'  ('!F #?# (  &!'"( ) "&"(#  ('%" A 47I;   ??#'# )!F("'  '&&!'( #("# '  !(("!11(#/K'( ;

07; !''&!08&(F'8778 ''1!'#   "?!("  H'%"?" &!(,('("> '#"  )/'" "(', &!?"2(&""!1"F'!=?"H;

 '    84 !(!F' 8778   &!# " )(!' '%" ( !'%1!(3(2;

 ! '&&!'( "('#""'  8< !%F' 8778   '   #"('"(()'# #?(1"(#(()1"F'!=?";

 8 !(!F' 8778   '   &'#"# >  &("( !11'"( ) =&(!(!!?" >" F"( ??'%# &' )("%"(#  '#&#("("% ( >)B'#!'(>)'#!'"(("!&'!1"!#("(!/"(F;



90:2498773  ,4900,   00;  (  05 #F' 8778   .   '#  '>L( )%" #"  '%"#"'. A' =J!"?(!"' #"!&()'#;

08;  ! &&'#"("! #"  05 #F' 8778   '   &#""( -P  /"''?"   B&!# >)&'$ %!"' B"# % ((("!  !(('"!?'&/"'" "&'!!Q"(!"(D

H1'('2!')"(0'#F'8777)(&'!FF; )(A  !(#!/!'! &'#B"(( C'#"  ./' !BE > !''&!(  &  !  ./!' 392 ("!#;  '#(( '"!!?">C&'#('#"(&"E)B&">( ('!F"11; !('&("()J"&'#(#('!F'!!?"> C!1"'("! &'  &#""(E;  "%  '/" '%"  &'$  (!' "& #"!&!(,('(">&(L('"#%";&!"( % "">  " )=  &  '('"("!   !F""(#  '/" CB  80;75;8778&'#")''!"(E;'!#>( "&"(# ('%"J("1"'&!'&!';

 1"F'!=?" &&!# (  ('!F &=/!,!(">  F('(;  )?"( &( ) >("! J'"">  "(# #>(; )(' ('"(( !'&!'  !( " #"' " (";  (("( A )"(#?'"(# 'F ( ('$ "&!'(()(&!FJ("%FH;

03; ' #""!021#%'"'8773 . "1"%'(&'(("! )'  30 ' 8773   !("1 >  ('!F &'#(# &' )'# )#("(&'("!"(#%)"(0'#F'8777;

02; '(('05'8773 )'#1"(!&&!"("!A((#""! ("(>  "(# (' ( #>( ('  ('!F ( )"(  0' ' 8777 #("( #(F"  %  '("1"( #"B 1"?'(   !"'   .  !''!F!'# &' B J!"( A ! !&&!"("!;   &'!"( ('!" !''"'  '   4  6 ( 07 ' 8773  > "," 1"( #(( ) #>"./'(("!>)"B"("('("! "(#'("(')"((#F(('!F B&(' "" F"("11"")(('";

04; ' !''"'  87 1#%'"' 8773        ..  . C',"  )'#E  "1!'#  .  >)" &''"(  /'?  1'"#"B'("1A)11("!!(")?""(A&'("'0'%'"8773! !"1##'')',";

06; ' #""! ' !&&!"("!  06 " 8773   .   'J(# )!&&!"("!  )'#(!1"'##""!('&'";



90:2498773  ,6900,   0:; 04&(F'8773 )'#"('J(#'!'!('#""!'!&&!"("! !("1"#  0< " 8773  1"( A !% %!"' >)" B"("( ! (  "(# (' " !'  "(# #>( ('  ('!F !(  !11'"(()"(0'#F'8777;

05; '#&!03!(!F'8773 . !%#)"''%F""(#'!' "('J(#04&(F'8773&!'('"%(#;

0<; 'J?(:%'"8772 2$/F' '"F(!' !"  #'#  '!' '%F;  ! ''L(  87 !(!F' 8774   '"F1##''C - E!1"'#"(J?(;

80; 87#F'8774 . &'"(#!"! !"#'(> "  "(# (' (' )(!' '%" !( %"( #(# %"("  '!'(()"&"(#('%"(#'"'&!%"(L('#(F")&$   ' !O  >> ('!F &&'((  (F ""> (=&"> %"(#(#'%#;'"' !%#)F"(##>(;

88;   #'"('  < ' 8776   '!'(  &'"(#  )"(#?'"(#  ('(!"!!!&&!"("!A)!('#""!.  021#%'"'8778;

83; .' #(#?'#AJ?';

82;  (' 1"( &'("(  !"' '!( '&'"  (( >  F!"   &'("'!"(&'#(''L(;

 "+

0;  !&#( '"F#('%F""(#'!'!(#(#" &'''L(:%'"8772 !1"'#&' - (87!(!F'8774;

8;    ( ('#  %"?'  0' J%"' 8773  ('*(  !F' !"1"("!   !"  N' "(; B ('  N'(; 005 ;0'    &'(("! N' !# &!'  "( >" !( '% %( N('#  %"?'   !" !( '#?" &' N" '!"(; N"(=("0'#F'8777 &'#("("?'!#> B"#A"$'"&!"("! %"?'J>N30#F' 8778; '%/ '$?&'!#'!("#"((&&"FC'(;58  R -08:28:!";0E;

3;  "("? &!'( '  &!"(  %!"' > ('!F !(  '("!  "(# ('( #/#( #>(%N"(0'#F'8777""> '!F"?("!>"#!(&!')"("#,A30'8773;



90:2498773  ,:900,   2; E .! N'(; 6 ; 0    &'(("! N' !( !#   N"( &'!1"!  N"( ! &'!1"! (  " &'!1"!; N'#  !(( '!"(  ('"(( #" &&'!&'"#  #"! '#((  N"( (  N" ( (!(( ! &'("( "&F  ('%"' A  "(  N"(  A  ""(# J!'"$' C'(; 07 ( '(; 06  E;'"' !N'(;05;0 N'#'!"(A'(N"%""(# N"%"("%"A07I!"&'"(N"(( !N'(;82;0  "'!"(A""(##>"(F&!'(("(AN"(#?'"(#" &'"( N"(  " !11' N(("( "&!'(( ( 'F A ! "(#?'"(# &/="> ! (;'!"(B&'(("!&&!NF!''&&!'("(#(' (#>(('N"((N(("(A(#;

FE  "(#(('!'>N" = "N(('>  ( #%#( "(   !?   '"( & &'!"(  (!(  ! >N"  '"( & '%   L "$';  N( & #"'   '%/  > N"( !"(   "> ! "#"(  N(("( A  (#R " 1( ( " 11"( > N#%#(!?F !"##%((AN('1(' "(&'!%!># N(("(A(#&/=">!&=/">N'# N(,A,"'>N"&'#( !  !"("! " > !  ,"; .%!"' " N#%#( '# ( N(("(A(#!("#&''&&!'("(#('(>("!  1"(  > N""('("! !    #/#(   J? B"   1!( ("(''"?(N!''#" (>"!"(L('('/#  !1!'( A  '$?  ?'#  %'"F &'#&!#'(  &&"># ?##'(AN&&'#"("!&'%N'!"; "" !'> NB"( N '&&!'(   A 11( (' N"( (  !? &'*( &!"F ">N&(&L('>"1"#&'!FF&'(""'   '!"(A&'(("!#!(N"( '#!"( L('"#C -00<  33:!";0 00585<!";0F('#1#'E;

E"(#(#>(" )&'$!'!'""'/!()B&#'" %" 1"(!"#'##("(&'!&'A('*'11(?'">")( &'!"( '%'#((&'"(1Q!?##'1%!'"#&' ("'!(C -084260!";4('#1#'E;

 &'#  ('!F &=/"> '#("!   J'"&'  #??#  '"($'!FJ("1>"&'(((J?''($'#>(""(#;   (!( )F!' #  "(  ('!" (#?!'"   1!("!  ' #'!( D  "( ""?"1"( !  &  ?'%"(# C&' B;  /( FER"(?'%"(#!=("(?'%;!'&'!#'A (("1"("!"( "!%"(!&)((/'A"$'!( )'#'("(#/!('("> "F"&(S(1!' ) &!"(  % !FJ("1  ' )#%#( "( ",L;  &'# ) "(?'%"(#!= "1(&''!"#'("!'("!F' '"($' !(&"&!'((!("%(D"'!(!!"((



90:2498773  ,5900,   &'(""$'( '("> !  '($' &'(""$'( "&'"!(  )"(R  ?'%"(# !  (' &'(""$'  #"! &/=">  !&( ( !((1"(>)!(&'!&' !)B&#'" A('*'('!F &=/">R  '# !'( !?  ('"(( #"R  !' &/="> &'"((R  '''   ('"(( #" ('*(  ??'%("!!(F#>)"(R"11"(#&&'!' ?#'"!(!&"("!"&!'((R?'#('#)"&"(# ('%"B#"!&/=">; !'"($'!"%(&L(''#"&!' >  "(# #>( !"( ";   )(' B &( L(' 11"(  !(( " )!  ('!% A  ""(   (#?!'"  "( ?'%; %'( &'#)"("((A""("(& ?'%"(# "'!(A&''!"#'("!!"%('!'%L("' "("(#&'(""$'&!'>'($'#>(""(#&" L(' " C - 004  027 !"; 69 ( 27< !"; 49E;  '($' #>(""(#&&!&'&'""&>)#%$("("( "&!'(#('"(#/(('!F&=/">C - 087344R00:366R004273E;

4; )(!'"(#""('("%!J?!"%(!"#''1"(!&'!%#> !'>)" !( !%"   '#"(# CT   ''"  +"%"&'!K'/(  2$ #"("!  ' 0<52  &; 036R U  %'V(?'/(&1? 8$#"("! &;8:5 /;4E;!" '!" J?1!#""! 1"&!"("!!('"'!"  '1"(>" 1()L('#(F""$'"''#1(F &&'"(! & %'"FF  )(,A,"' >" &'#((  ?'#  %'"F &'#&!#'(;   11"( ! & >) 1"( &" L(' !"#'# ( !  /=&!(/$ &!"F; '" (!  ##(  1"( #?# ! %"?F   J? !"(    #/#(  '("' B >" " &'"(  & &'!FFC -0802:!";8 875!";6F('#1#'E;

6. !'&!%!"'&&'#"'"(("! N""('("!C!J?N" ='!'E F!"!(>#" #%((N('&#""( !"%( "1!'"';(W/#"!"(A&!'('J?('N#(((#( A "">'  > ' ( &!' > ("%"(# N'# ( "&F  ('%"';  !('   !# #" !("((  ##( (" &!' #('"'>('%B!&(!''"!F(B"?'N'#C - 084860!";2 004032!";8 002302!";3 074045!"; 0E;

>"!'&'"'%'&'!F(N'&&!'(#" >"( #('"( N(>&!"("("?"B"&!'(("(1"(N!FJ(N#( 1!"# >'&&!'(1!'B!&( >N"&'#?(  !"#'("!&"(B&'"# >N""(#(##(F"&"!" !"'C$E >'"&("!!(B(#"!"("'(>N1"



90:2498773  ,<900,   !"!NB&'(!"(F"!("%#C -088067!";0( '#1#'E; N##( #('"( &!'  %' &'!F( N(  &'""& " N!'"?"  !=  &'%  "  #"?("!  !  1!' N '&&!'( ! NB&'(" "F(F"!!(;NB&'("!"(!L('1!#' !(("!!&$(("?!("&'#" L('!(?'WA ""!!%"("(# (&&!'(''#&!B/("%( #>"%!> B >("! &!#;  "(   !"( L(' !&'#/"F  !((&('/'&!"('!"(;

 J'"&' !((  !'>  "" !'(  &'(  !('  F",1!#  &&'#"("! #" &'  #"      '&&!'(   '"' !( %'  &'% (     ' !O  " )#("( & &'("A&'!#'!(!O"!(#(##(F"C -07287<R .; 8<'0<<2R;<!%F'0<<2E;

!1!'#(&'""&">""(!"'>"'#?"(&'!#'!" ' !"  )""('("! ( ( )!'!'  "('("! !&#("' !'>  #?("!  &'(" (  ##( '!'((  !"' '>"$'(  ( ';  &'(""'   !"( (('  !%'  B&'("!'>)"&&'*(#"''"1"'&(#"BC - 00:853!";2R  0<54T626&;827!";2E;

 &'""&   J?  N#'( &  !("1 "&#'("1  !"! N B&'(" #"   (W/  NB&'( #(( &'#"#(  (('  !" &#" A  "&!"("!   J(" 1"  N#"'' '  &( #"B N #((  1"( !#; .!  J'"&'  &( !("('  '"!  N#'(' N B&'(" J"""'  1"( > ," !("(  !('"("!  ! >N ',B&'(" !'!# &'  '"F  11"'  !"!  "$'!%"(; !(' !'>N('&#""(#(((!&""! !('"' &( A ((' #'"(  !(  &'("  #("!  NB&'(  N!  &( B'  !     "('&'#(("! "%'?(  !"!'"'&'J?! F!" "('("!!&#("' !1!'N!%B&'("#"C -0058<7!";0FR008 38('#1#'E;

'"'" ""'&&'> !J'"&'!(( "=" )((/' & )"&!'( B !((("! 1"( &'  &#""( >)A )&&'#"("!1"(&'#"('"((C 0<55&;472E;

:;     #" !(# &' )'# !( !#( " >  ('!F&'#(#&')'#)#("(&!FJ("%F;

""   '   #'"( )B '!!?"> ! &'1"(( !'&'#"(>)")=%"(##(!FJ("1&'(((!''!F!'' &"()'#C'&&!'(2J"(8778E(!"?(>)"=%"(



90:2498773  ,07900,    '("!  "(# (' )"(  0' #F' 8777 (  #F(  ('!F B&(' "F"("11""A(('C1B'8773E;

 '    J"( ( &(F' 8778   B&!# >  F" '"!!?"> )%"( #!('#  #"! ! #>  #"! ('("> ( > ! )B "">   &("( &'#("(  ('!F  (=& 1"F'!=?">;

"#(#!1"'#88!M(8778&'#")''!"(.  '  (&'#"('"(()'# '  >" #?(1"(#((1"F'!=?";

.'  & &=/">   '   &'#"# >  '!'( &'#("(  ('!F  (=& 1"F'!=?"> &'#B"((   >"  (#'"'( #(# !1"'# &'  '    ( ;   (!"("! )#((#&'"1'"(&'#(()('!%"(&'!!?#; ' >(A""#)B"()(("((=&1"F'!=?">;

5; -"(    %" "'!("#   '   '%# >) 1'(' 2 !'  )"(  0' #F' 8777 )#("( & &'!FF; )(  11( A  !(#!/!'! &'#B"(( C'#"  ./' !BE > !''&!(  &  !  ./!' 392 !F'%#;  '#(( '"!!?"> )!( & "  #%"  '#('#"(   &" ( )B&">(     ('!F "11;  &   &("( ) J" &'#(#  ('!F '!!?">; (( &&'#"("!  05 #F' 8778 '&"(  '#>""( J'"&'(" ("!# ", >( A  %' &'!F( ) ( !( $ !' >) ( 1!# '  B '&&!'(  #")''!"( >#("(!"?#&"()'#  "">')F!"'"">('"!!?">;

 %>"&'#$ ""(#('('('!FF"&' '!'( ( )"(  0' #F' 8777  '"( L(' "   ?'#  %'"F '>" &'  J'"&'  ,A  30 ' 8773;  !#> #""!)"("#(('('A&'(("!&'L( &1A'"(">;

<; !'  '&   !"' #" #(( !&(   !"!   '!'( %"(AB&'("&&#("'(1!#;

)"(>'!' 1!# ('J(#;

" - +/  +"  - +   " - -





90:2498773  ,00900,   012   3  4   56 $,(  7

  2 

0; #''!''%F;

 2

8; 'J((;

3; 1!'  &'("   >N &%( 1!'' '!' !('  &'#( ''L(   #"  37 J!' $  !("1"("! &' &" '!# '#  '"F 1##'  '  ./V"K'/!1>" 6  6772     ('!" B&"';  #"  &( L(' &'!!?#;  #!"' !"(D E "">' B((>#""!'!'(#"'!F("'"(&#""! ((>#R FE B&!' &!' > !("1 " (" &!%!"' ' (( (' #""!R E &!'('  "?(' !   ! '&'#((; ."  #!"'  !("( &  ('!" ##( ##'# ! ((' E FE ( E ",   '"F1##''&!''&(''("$'''!'>N" %'#''"''%F;#!"''!'("!'!'!=  &'%  >" '!( J!"(  "" >  #""! ((># ( N%!&&  >#(#B&#"#'!'(C'(;038 076(075E;  ?'11"'D  '#"(D     X"    "       '#("',J'"(D B'         

!&"!1!'&'#(''L((!("1"#B&'(""">NAN11"1##' (#&F">&'?'11



90:2498773