Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/485/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/485/2004 Généré par l'IA

Former Director v. Corporation Regarding Defamation and Qualified Privilege

Numéro de cause ATAS/485/2004
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The appellant, a former director, sued the corporation and its officers for defamation, seeking damages after the board terminated their employment and issued press releases implying misconduct, and the trial court granted summary judgment for the defendants, reasoning that the statements were protected by a qualified privilege because they were made in good faith, without actual malice, and related to a matter of common interest among the corporation's stakeholders. The appellate court affirmed, holding that the record contained no evidence supporting a finding of actual malice, as the defendants reasonably relied on internal investigation findings, and thus the qualified privilege was not defeated, even though some statements might have been inaccurate.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Former Director v. Corporation Regarding Defamation and Qualified Privilege: The appellate court affirmed, holding that the record contained no evidence supporting a finding of actual malice, as the defendants reasonably relied on internal investigation findings, and thus the qualified privilege was not defeated, even though some statements might have been inaccurate.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
diffamation responsabilité des administrateurs privilège de responsabilité motivation sommaire bonne foi demande de récusation

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied to regulate the costs of the federal court proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
P/21755/2016
Defamation conviction upheld based on intent and lack of privilege.
C/22638/2018
Former Managing Director v. Employer: Wrongful Dismissal and Discretionary Bonus Dispute
C/20972/2015
Former Employee v. Publicly Traded Company Regarding Press Release Liability
P/21202/2020
Appellant Challenge to Dismissal of Defamation and Fraud Complaint Against Former Associates Rejected
P/21374/2017
Complainant v. Bank Director (Defamation Dismissal)

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied to regulate the costs of the federal court proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

 



   

           



       

    

 ! "#!



$! %%%%%%%%%%  !"!#$# % #$&' ( (')&& "! *+, - %'$ !&

$'(! %%%%%%%%%%   !"!#$# % #$&' ( (')&& "! **+./  %'$ ()(!

'$!

            )$ 0!(!'*12%+    (#3(!      

*+!& , $! (#!--!  . *(!&!. $!( '( /0 !& 1- . 1+!(2

 3 4 





+ ! 56)$ ( 40 '$'7! 4889   92) :)7! ( !&7 ( "!)&2! &$"!''#(&%'!(*()$*'&!;;;;;;;;;; )!&# ($("$)7!<=>+

4+ ?':&33!>(56)$"!#&$# !&7("!)&2!&$&(&@# $!)$$!  (&"'&$&3  !&7 ( # "'! @A& B(#$!)&  )'$$ @& ('&$ C$! $$!&7# 1 *() ;;;;;;;;;; 1 $&$! ( "!$6 ( %'&! ( "!#%'D"!'3&'(A!$&44E+

9+ '))&@#F"!$&4<'$'7!4889"!"&!'))(# 56)$( (&%'!$(%(#3&&$&3"$G$(&!(#)7!4889 AD$"3&$ A'75$(A""+

>+   '$ ( 56)$ ( (&%'!  ' @  "!$& #$&$ (A'!( ')$!"!&&"("!$6)&#6)$!)'((&&  '&$"!$6"!)'&$&#(%'&!)#"($)!&6"!*'&! ;;;;;;;;;; "!2  (   ??  ?    ?  ? ?? /*  !&7(#&$!"#"!$&!')"#$  %A!$+4('&!&7!"6H , I "!"&(J)!488>+

+  7$   "!$& '$ 3&$ %'&! @A 33$  ')"#$  (&$&$  )&@A&5$&3&&$@!&7$!)$&2!+*'&!;;;;;;;;;;  "'!"!$ #6&$@'#"'%&$&7!"6  '$!&!)$1 @A %&$ &(&@#  !&7 ( "!)&2! &$   @ ( "&2 (#)'$!!&$+

=+ !&7(#'!('#')"!$&'("!$& @&A$$($ (  )& 488>+  $$ '&'   ()(!  '3&!)# %'&! #$# &(#"($ $ A%'&! " '$&#+  A$ 66# 1 "!'(&!  !$&3&$ (A! ( ' F)!&  (#51 "!'(&$ (%$ A&$ ( (&%'!  $  "!& '$(@!&7!#$&!&$)'$$1"!$6!+ !'!$ A$""!#$#"!'"'!& )&A$F#$#!&!)$+

0+ ()((!&7  ???  ? ? ?? /* $!)&!$&3&$(A!(()(! 15'!98 '$'7!4889+ !#$@"!$$&'(&7!"6$(484KJ03!+0+

J+  (')$  #$# $!)& F "!$&  ($ ( 40 )&  $   6!(# 1 56!+ 9 



 

+ K!$+4 ,  $!#%&6!!5%&!4888 !26"!'#(!( (&%'!+((#'!(('5'&$!"!$$&'('!$&1"!$6! ((&%'!H!$+44$49I 56(&((&%'!')"#$$ (K!$+09+  '&$12%!&7$'(!'& ("&!'L$4889 ('&$ "!2@K33&!&#$#$!)&H!$+>4I  F#$!(K'33&"!$6!7( # (!#"!$&$&'(#$!)&#"! 56((&%'!+

4+ ?'K!$+44 , H'%$!%&6!("&!5%&!4888I  ((&%'! "!$$&'('!$&@&(!$)!&6'$"!$6# '3'!)#)$F!$+44 49 >$>4M!$+91 , K""&@$ "!'6&)'$$1$!3#!!H+I+'!:@'5'&$ "!$$&'( '!$&1"!$6!'!!"'(1(&33#!$!"!$$&'('!$& 6)$# ( %'&! ( &7! "6 F&$$ #%$)$  )')$ ( (&%'!  $  "!$$&' ( '!$&  6)$# ( %'&! ( &7! "6 F&$$ #%$)$)')$('&'()!&6H3+!$+4> , I+'!  '5'$1"!$$&'('!$&$1K%'&!(&7!"6F&$$ )')$('&'()!&6&$#!C$()')$((&%'!H, 4J498M,4<>>>I+

3.  A"2   56 ( "!)&2! &$  '$$# @  "!$& #$&$ (A'!( %  "!$6 "! )'&$&# (  "!$$&' ( &7! "6 ( ()(! $%&$)&!$&3&$(A!(&')"#$$+  AD('"(#'!(('5'&$('&"!#&$#+"($ &D &(A$!!)$&2!$(A'!('!"!$6 !"!'#(!(&%'!$ !:&%# $!#%&&'!&$1"'!$#("!$&+ "!&&"(A#'')& ("!'#(!A'""'1@!&7(#(#!&')"#$$+

+>+   ($ "!$&$ '$  (A "!$   ( )!&6   "$)7! <=>  (A$!"!$(#)7!4889 ($1@56)$((&%'!$(% F#$'&!+

?'  (')$  ('&!   "!$$&' @& "($  )!&6 "! *'&!;;;;;;;;;;$(484KJ03!+0+?'F#"'A"'$&# !  #$&$ &(#"($+  "&2  %&$ '$!(&! $$ #6$&'  (#51 !$ "!  56 ( (&%'!+ && *'&! ;;;;;;;;;; ('&$ 1 ' F #"')'$$(8A>903!+<83!+H484KJ03!+03!+N4I+

+ '3'!)#)$ 1  5!&"!(  ("&  5'! (#$!)&$ "'!  "!$6 5@K )')$ ( $!3!$ (  "!$$&' ( '!$& ' (  ()!   > 



'5'&$ (&%'!# 7##3&&&! ( $$ "!$$&'  (!'&$ 1 ( &$#!C$ ')"$'&! !  )'$$ ( &+  &$#!C$ '$ #  $F )&&)) #6 ' K!$+ 4 ( K'!(' !  "!#%'D "!'3&' %&&  !%&%$ $ &%&(&$# ( J %!& <J> H 4I ' '  $F !#6)$&!  & && $ "#!&! H, ' "7&#  9=84 ( J 5&$ 4889I+

=+ #)')$!"!O "!'#(!#$$6!$&$H!$+09+4 $ J</+ I+



PPP

   $ 3 .

        ,

&&&

45'6'*!& 7 - (8'(&' &(&'! ! -9&2 :; 1<

+ %&$ ???  ? ? ??/* 1 $!3#!! (')"$(*+;;;;;;;;;; '))(8A>903!+<83!+3!+ 3%!(*);;;;;;;;;;+

4+ %&$ ???  ? ? ??/*  1 %!!   " (  )'$$  ( &$#!C$ ')"$'&!   ( '&(#!$ (2!(#)7!48895@K)')$($!3!$+

9+ AD'()$$@(7'&+

>+ %&$*();;;;;;;;;;1'%!&!')"$("!#%'D!@$$ '))"'!!C$!%!#+

+ &$@"!'#(!$6!$&$+

=+ 3'!)  "!$& (  @K "%$ 3'!)! !'! '$!  "!#$ !!C$ (  (#& ( 98 5'! (2  '$&3&$&' "! "& !'))(# (!#  !&7 3#(#! ( !  ?:Q&R!:'3@& =  =88>    $!'& F)"&!+  (#&  "$ C$! "!''6#+  )#)'&! ('&$ N I &(&@! F$)$ @ (#&&'  !'!$ (#&! '7$&!  & $ " (  (#&&'$$@#M7IF"'!"'!@)'$&3&$&)"'%'&!()(!$$  



$!(#&&'MI"'!$!&6$!'('!"!#$$+?&)#)'&!  '$&$ "  $!'& ##)$ #)#!# ' $$! I 7I $ I &(   !&73#(#!(!"'!!"$!!)$&2!!!'!@K& (%!(#!!&!!%7+ )#)'&!(!'!)$&'!'!)'D ( "!%  @& !'$ 5'&$  && @  (#&&' $$@# $ K%'"" ( @#$#F"#(&#!'!$H!$+94 8=$8JI+



6!33&!N !#&($N

&!!& 77'&

  





'"&'3'!)("!#$!!C$$'$&3&#F"!$&&&@A1A33&3#(#! (!'&"!6!33