Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/477/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/477/2005 Généré par l'IA

Statutory Assessment Retroactivity and Due Process Challenge

Numéro de cause ATAS/477/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A party challenged the imposition of a statutory assessment, arguing that the relevant statute, which included a retroactive effective date, violated constitutional principles of due process and retroactively impaired vested rights, as the assessment was levied on activities that occurred before the law's enactment. The court held that the assessment was permissible because it constituted a retroactive tax or fee, which is generally constitutional if it serves a public purpose and is not arbitrary or oppressive, finding that the assessment was rationally related to the public interest in regulating the industry and therefore satisfied due process, and noting that the retroactive application did not unconstitutionally impair vested rights because no vested right existed to be free from such prospective, regulatory fees.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statutory Assessment Retroactivity and Due Process Challenge: The court held that the assessment was permissible because it constituted a retroactive tax or fee, which is generally constitutional if it serves a public purpose and is not arbitrary or oppressive, finding that the assessment was rationally related to the public interest in regulating the industry and therefore satisfied due process, and noting that the retroactive application did not unconstitutionally impair vested rights because no vested right existed to be free from such prospective, regulatory fees.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
prétention légale rétroactivité de la loi taxations fiscales droits acquis date de début du droit motifs d'intérêt public

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
This provision governs the imposition of court costs, which is ordered in the final disposition.
Généré par l'IA
A/3612/2007
Tax Statute Retroactivity Challenge
A/2064/2007
Assessment Challenge Regarding Due Process
A/2809/2007
Tax Amendment Retroactivity and Vested Rights Challenge
A/1289/2004
Statutory Amendment Retroactivity and Vested Rights in Cost Recovery
A/3246/2006
Tax Assessment Challenge Regarding Statutory Constitutionality

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision governs the imposition of court costs, which is ordered in the final disposition.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

   

#$%&'#(&&% )#%#(&&+

)

! )! ,)"  !, ",

$-./   0$  (&&+

  

 1111111111   !" ! #$"! %!  #   !!" & "' '(  )" '

"!

, ,)" 2"  ,3"  ")  ! ' #"*!" +, - .%

            !" 

3 2/4 3

 4)

05 #! 67777777777  )") 88) '.  0! ! 2,,,  (") ' 8!' ' ! 39::! ' #! 7777777777 !  )") ;7777777777 6 5  "!" '") ' 20 ')*! 0444 !)%<"  !  *!" ' 4=>,, :!5 "!? : & ! 1, 9! ! 5

 ' "!"  )") )"* %  )") @7777777777 6-!  0! :)%!!

2,,2 A "! '( B C  "!%!?  (") ' 9::!38!' ' ! 5  !)"

"!" !' ::"  0! D%! 2,,2 !  '!) :A ' 0>  "

D(&-  : D%! 2,,>5  !   !))'" "!" ' "!%  % "! )") "  ""  "! ' " "!" ")!!5 "! !  ' * " ' EF 0,=,,,5,, *!" G02 A !

)H ! ' 9!! ' 1, 9! !  GIJ3'  !H K5 ! %" ' 20 %*! 2,,2  !' %" " )") 8) !

&!) "  )") ;77777777776 " !  #! 7777777777 "

'! 7777777777 B

3 #! 67777777777  "  !)" '  "!" ' "!% %  )") @7777777777 6-! !  >0 "*! 2,,2

3  ! ! <) D(&- : "*! 2,,25  %!" ! ::")  2L %*! 2,,2

3 ! ' ' ""  " <  ! ' ' % " "! )%" !)"" :.! !"% -  "!" ' "!% ;77777777776  %!!   ' +L=,,, :!5  !.8" ! ::")   "!'  >, %*! 2,,25

6 &A"!" ' !8"! ' ! :8!" '  '! #! '!

7777777777  )") '"!"!3 !)'" ' > %! 2,,,  22 %*! 2,,0 '!"! ' 0+  2,,0  0, D" 2,,2  '"!"! -  "!

' 22 %*! 2,,0 '  )") ;77777777776 M (  )") @7777777777 6-!  ! )38)!" #! N7777777777 " ! ) #!

#77777777775

25 ! !!! ' 21 ! 2,,> #! '! 7777777777 !  ! - 3"O" '  )") @7777777777 6-!  "") (  ' 'P - &!) &%"  )") %!) & A " !    ' "  'A ")  !! %!"  0+ %! 2,,>  - 9( : '   '!! )""

!)% !  >0 ')*! 2,,>5

#! 67777777777  :" :" ":! -  )") ;77777777776 " !  #! 7777777777  '" ' <!  '" ' Q

/0+,1/2,,+

3 >/4 3

D" 2,,> !  "" ' +L=,,, :!5  ')'" ' 0,=,,, :!5 %!)  2> ')*! 2,,25  '" ' <! &  )") :! ) '& "5

#! 67777777777  !(  "" '  !"  01  "*! 2,,>5

! D8" ' 0, %*! 2,,>  !* ' !.! "  !)

 :" '  )") ;7777777777 6 5

&")!)  !'" '  '! '  :"  !) ' ! !  "" ' >1=401 :!5 1L5 &:: ' :"  )!") '" !'" C '. ! (  :9 '  "  "!" !'" "   ' @7777777777 6-! K5

>5 &")!)  ') )  Q D%! 2,,+  '' %" - &"! '& '")   '&%*")  !. '   " 8% ' 9R8 G3 !.  H5

+5 ! ') ' 02 D%! 2,,+    !D")  '' ')!"   (  "!" ' "!%  (  :9 ' ! %" )") )"* !

 )") @7777777777 6-!5

L5 &")!) ! !)") ! #$"! %!  #   :!)  "  0Q :)%!! 2,,+5  A ( %! '. ! 2,,, "!%)  (") ' 8!' ' ! 39::! ' #! 7777777777 !  )") ;7777777777 6 5  D" ( * (& ' "!" " )")   0! :)%!! 2,,2 %  )") @7777777777 6-!   ") - A!! "!""  O "%") ' 8!' ' ! 39::! ' #! 7777777777 M ( ! %" ' 20 %*! 2,,2  )") ;77777777776  ! !  88" !": -  "!" ' "!% M (  2> ')*! 2,,2   !S  "" ' 0,=,,, :!5 '  )") ;77777777776  " !  #! 77777777775  8 (  )") ;77777777776 &  :! ) '& "  '" ' <! ' Q D" 2,,>5  '.! '. ! O"! !)! ! ' !!)!) ' ! " "! !"" ')" ' "!" ' "!% '  )")

;77777777776 "  '  )") @7777777777 6-!5  " - &"! '& '")   ' &!"5 L0 5 0 "5  '  :)')! ' 2L D 04Q2 !

&!39R8 *8"! " &'")   '&%*") G3 !.  H  )") ;77777777776 )""  :"5

15 ! ') !  " ' 0! D 2,,+    :!)  ') '

02 D%! 2,,+5    ::" ')!) ( &")!)  )'"  ' !) %!  )") ;77777777776 ( &)""    <!5   - " )8!' ! ) ( "  "!"   0! :)%!! 2,,2 ""  :9 ' ! ' ! - "*! 2,,2 %" )") )"* !  )")

@7777777777 6-! " (  21 ! 2,,> &" ! "" )") ( &A  !. ' &")!) ' !"!' ! '  " ' ' 'P5

/0+,1/2,,+

3 +/4 3

T5 &")!)  "!D") !! "! '" ') !  "  2 D"

2,,+5  "" (  ') ' &:: ' :" '&)!"!  !) !'" '  :" '  )") ;77777777776  !" !      !* ' ) " :!  '!! (& "' ( (&  "

""! "" ') C  !)9* K !  % '& "  """ ' &)"" ' "5  ! !9 )8" -   '&%! !  ')!"  !!! ' 21 ! 2,,> !  ! ( & <!

!"  )") @7777777777 6-! "   )") ;77777777776  )8"

( C #! 7777777777 & D ' ) ' '! '!" '&88!  )") @7777777777 6-! " ( '. !  !!!  )") )"*  '!" "

%!**" - & ' !8 "!) ' "" )") K5  ::! !

! ( * (  :9 ' ! " )") )"*   '  )")

@7777777777 6-!  %"  !)") )") !))!) ! #! 77777777775  !.% )8" (  !) !.% * ' !)"" ' !  ) 2,,, " 2,,0 ) '!" (  )""  <) ' ;77777777776  "!" ' 20 ')*! 04445  D" : ( (' * O  %" )")

:!" 88) ' 0! :)%!!  >0 "*! 2,,2 !  )")

@7777777777 6-!  "%") &%"  !)") *  ':" !

! !" -  )!' '!" (  )""  <) '  )") ;7777777777

6 5

Q5 %") -  ')"!!      !D" ' !!5

45  !* ' )  9") "'!   !" !  !"5   ' &!) &  '" :!)  20 :)%!! 2,,L ( 3 &)""

")  '5

0,5 8" !  !. '   #  '  "  !. ' (  'A )") )"" ::)  !!" :8! !  """" ' !  ' ;77777777776 ' 0! ! 2,,,  >0 D%! 2,,0 " !

 ' @7777777777 6-! ' 0! :)%!! 2,,0  >0 "*! 2,,25

005 "'  (") ' ")  04 %! 2,,L !  !* ' ) #!

7777777777  A () ( @7777777777 6-! " ;77777777776  !""  O 8!   (& < " "": ' 9'8 ::"5   :!) (  !!" %" )") 88) ! O"! -   !% " ( &"%") ' 3 &%" *  ':"  !.   ' "!" ' 0! :)%!!5   ! !)) (  %" ' 20 %*! 2,,2 %" )") )"* -  '' ' !!" 3O (" ! ( ;7777777777 6-!   %!"  !)8.!"  !5   '" ')!!

(  !!" )"" !") !) ' @7777777777 6-! ;77777777776 &"!%" ( ! <!  ' ' ! 'P5     ')!"

(&C  " "" - :" '! ( #! 67777777777  )") 88) !  8!  '" :" !" ;77777777776  ;7777777777 @7777777777 6-! K5

/0+,1/2,,+

3 L/4 3

025   )!  !. (O" ' 0T  2,,L  !!" 8 ( &'" ' ")  ! ' :!! (  "!:!" ' ! !" ' "!%

- @7777777777 6-! &%" )") ( :!5  '.! (&  :"  &!!O"!

- & ! !)) !  "!" ' "!% ' 0! :)%!! 2,,2  !"! (&  "!%) '  :" ! ;77777777776 ' :)%!! 2,,, - : "*! 2,,25

0>5 &") (" -  !" '  "5  D" ( O  !

 * & '""" ( ;77777777776 )"" '% & <! % ::" !)"!":  '" ' &!"5 L2 5 0    !"  ! 5 &'") !  '&%*")  !!"  ::" O"! %!) !   ' %*! 2,,2  :" ' ;77777777776 <" )") !)  0, %*! 2,,25  !!"  !!"    !)"'! - ' '") !  "!?. ! ' ) 2,,, " 2,,0 (&  !! '"  - ' !"" ' !  ("! '!!  ' ! !" ' "!%5 "  "!?. ! ' &) 2,,2  &"  !)% !  "!"

' "!% ' 0! :)%!! 2,,25 : &!"5 L2 5 0   "  %!"! ' ! - Q=4,, :!5

0+5  )!"! " )") "! A !"  04  2,,L "    )") 8!')

- D8!5

 ")

05   8% ! &!8" D'! GH  )") ':) "  "") '.  0! P" 2,,>  !* " ' !   ) ' L D8 '"  !)'" "  %3 !)'" L  )" " 01 D8 ! G!"5 0 "5 ! " L1 H5

6" - &" ' &)" ' 01 D8 ! !  !* :)')!  2T D%! 2,,+ G F 0>,  0,1H  !'  8%  ' ")  0> :)%!!  ' " "!"! !8" !"""  !* " ' !  ' )8!  ! - "! D8 ""!  ' &""" ' &)" ' %A D8 !5

25 :!)" - =!"5 L1  5 0 "5  95 Q   !* " ' !  $"  " ( ' """ !)% - &!"5 L1  ( " !"% -   :)')! ! &!39R8 *8"! " &'")   '&%*") ' 2L D 04Q2 " - &!"5 +4 5 > '   "  ".! ' 9R8 ' 00 %*! 04Q>  ".! ' !"" "  )"!5 6  )" ! D8! '  '& . "  )"*5

/0+,1/2,,+

3 1/4 3

>5 A "! ' &!"5 L0 5 0    "!%! D""  " ' "" ( "  !% '&  <! %* D" -  !)'! '&A)" :!)  6   <" ' "!%!  6 " '!" -  '") ! %*") !(& !)'! ' :" " 88) "! !  <! " (& " -  "3- ' !) ' ! %!  G"5 H5

+5  & . &")  !D")  '' '&'")   '&%*")

!)")  Q D%! 2,,+ !  !!"  ": ( 3  )'"  ' !) %!  )") ;77777777776  '"  :"  )") !)  0, %*! 2,,>5   ')!) (   <! )"" @7777777777 6-!5

L5  "8 !" '. ! !  (" ' %! ( ' ;77777777776  ' @7777777777 6-! )"" & <! ' !!"5

15  " '& <! ! ! - & 6 & ( - &!39R8 G:5 6 U 0,>2H5  !"  &!"5 2   " " ' <! ' "" ' &!39R8 & <! ( '" <! ' ""  %!" ' &!"5 02  6 G:5 )8" !"5 00  H5 " ')!)   <!

 ( %!  "!%!  !))!"   ' &!"5 L 5 2  6 M  &8" '& !) " ( " O"! !%!) !(  ! " <) !

&!'! '& "! G 044, 5 0+0 M  04QT 5 >2H5  ".! 6  " '& <! "  " " ( & (  :!)" "!  !" &A" '& "!" ' "!%   ' !"5 >04 " 5   '& ! !" ' !% ' '!" * G3   "! ' !" 0 - 01 '   :)')! ! &!3% " !%%" " + '5 !"5 02H5

6  D! !' ' !* :)')! ' ! ! ' "" *8V  '.!   <! " ' :!  ') " " ' <!

 ""  ( %!  ! ')"!" -   <)5  &"  )! (  ! *8"!" !)  "!%  ! !" ' !%  '&88" %  !   "%") ' ! (  %!  !5  ::" (& ') ' " ' " ' % ' &) '&"! ! " '  ' &!8" '  ! (  "!%5 6 &!) "  O "  " !  O "%")  ! !" ' ') ' " ' *!'" - &)8!' ' ! ! &*8" ' :! ' ') " " ' <!  "" * - & <! (   ""   )'" "   )"!" % &!) G 04QT 5 >0 '5 2*H5

T5  & .  !!"  "!%)  8!' ' ! 39::! ' #!

7777777777 '.  !! "!" - %! '.  0! ! 2,,, "  D(& >0 "*! 2,,25 &"%") (&  ') <)  !. ' #! 7777777777 & *  ':" '!" "" "" )!'5

/0+,1/2,,+

3 T/4 3

 !! "!" ' 20 ')*! 0444  )") 8) ! #! 7777777777 !  )") ;77777777776   '  '" ' 0! :)%!! 2,,2 ! #! #7777777777 !  )") @7777777777 6-!5 " -  %" ' 20 %*! 2,,2  & )") ! #! 7777777777 " 7777777777 !  )") ;7777777777 6 5

  !" ' """" ' !  '!) -   '  " 6 (  !!"  )") ')!) ! ;77777777776 ' 0! ! 2,,,  >0 D%! 2,,0 " ! @7777777777 6-! ' 0! :)%!! 2,,0  >0 "*! 2,,2 " :!)" A 'A "!"5

 " %! "": (  'A )")  !" "!. )"!"" ) - " 8 (& !!%" - #! 7777777777 ' %!! '!""  !!"  ! O !( 3 "!%" ! @7777777777 6-!   "!"   0! :)%!! 2,,2 )"" ! ) - " )8!' ( #! 7777777777 &%" D A!)  %!   ' "" )")5   ! ! )!"  !!"  21 ! 2,,> !  ! - 3"O" ' @7777777777 6-!    %"  ! ( !   ")   ' "" )") G:5 !.3%!* '&(O" ' 04 %! 2,,LH5

 "!:!" ' ! !" ' "!% ' ;77777777776 - @7777777777 6-!  0! :)%!! 2,,2 &!"  )") ( :!   !!" "  !! '!"  -  !)") ' :"5  %"  !  ' ! ! ( ;77777777776  ! !  '"" ! ' @7777777777 6-! %!  !!" !  %" ' 20 %*! 2,,25

 (" ' %! ( )") " & <! ' !!" " ( (&  " !"! %!" '  ! W  '!!  !!"  !)") !)"'!

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

/0+,1/2,,+

3 Q/4 3

 "!?. ! &"  !)% !  "!" ' 0! :)%!! 2,,2 ( :A  !  ' * - 0,=,,, :!5 *!" G02 A ! )H5

F! '. ! " ' ""! (  !!"  "  !)"'! - &'") !  '&%*")5   !! '"3 O"! !D")5

/0+,1/2,,+

3 4/4 3

 , ")4  )! ,)"  !, ",



5.6   7  8   9: $'( ";

  6 

05 )!  !! !%*5

 6

25  !D""5

>5 " (  !)'! " 8!""5

+5 :!  !" '  (& %" :!! !! "!  !)" !!O" '  ') ' >, D! '.  ":" !  !') '!)  !* :)')! ' ! 69I?!9:( 1 1,,+     "! A !5  ')  " O"! !8)5  )! '" B H '(! A"" ( ')  !!" ')! *"!   "  '  ') ""()M *H A ! ! ( ":  " %! ''! "" "! ')M H !"!

 8"!   '  ! !)""5 6  )!  ""   "! ))" ))!)  ""! H *H " H 3'  !* :)')! ' !  !!  "!!  ".! !  !! (& '%! ')!!

!!%*5  )! ' !! "! !  < ' !% ( !" D"  (  ') ""() " &%  ' (   )")

A )')  !!" G!"5 0>2 0,1 " 0,Q H5

 8!::.!B  !)'" B

#!3  X ! Y   

   :! ' !)" !!O" " ":) A !" "  6!)"!" '& "" - &) !  8!:: 

/0+,1/2,,+