ATAS/441/2007 · Statutory Construction and Regulatory Compliance Appeals (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The court addressed multiple disputes concerning the application of various statutes and regulations across several distinct factual scenarios, primarily involving regulatory compliance, liability determinations, and contract interpretation, as reflected by the numerous cited sections and subsections of the controlling law. The reasoning consistently hinged on a strict construction of the relevant statutory language, applying established precedent to determine the scope of obligations or liabilities, often resulting in the affirmation of lower court findings or the reversal where the lower body misapplied the explicit terms of the controlling legislation to the specific facts presented.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Statutory Construction and Regulatory Compliance Appeals: The reasoning consistently hinged on a strict construction of the relevant statutory language, applying established precedent to determine the scope of obligations or liabilities, often resulting in the affirmation of lower court findings or the reversal where the lower body misapplied the explicit terms of the controlling legislation to the specific facts presented.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA

interprétation et application strictes interprétation du droit interprétation du contrat champ d'application de la réglementation responsabilité objective simple invocation de motifs légaux

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for the order regarding legal aid costs.

Art. 64 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for the order regarding legal aid.

Généré par l'IA

A/1142/2004

Statutory Interpretation and Regulatory Compliance Appeals

A/1850/2006

Statutory Interpretation and Procedural Compliance in Commercial Appeals

A/4486/2006

Statutory Interpretation and Appeals on Factual Applications

A/1684/2002

Statutory Interpretation and Judicial Review of Regulatory Compliance

A/2377/2005

Statutory Interpretation and Application Appeals

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for the order regarding legal aid costs.

Art. 64 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for the order regarding legal aid.

Texte complet

'()*+',--. "'/',--0

"

" "# #

12 )

! ,) 34 ,--0

! "#$% ##$ !$ &!$'$# (#

$#

)) & + # $ ! (,-

! "# $% &! !

+3.63+

$"

67 !6,5-$8#9:$!6,,0$6,,, !$ $"(!" 6#;% #3446$$<#!"$ $7

37 * !#$ = $ /4 "$># 344/ =#! !$! % $ = $ #$ % $> $#$ $("?" " @7="!$!">#"##$#% 7

/7 60 $># 344/ #% 9"#$ %!A = B * % !#!"#$ ! ##%!A =#!C5&100734:#7

17 #$ : $ ! $ 63 !># 344/ # "! $ ! <! <= % $ "$ $ " 60 $># 344/ $ D$ <! $ #% "#9 % "#>> ! D$ #$$ #$ # 1+ 0C# $7 "# # ("$E =!$ $ :$! "# # % $ #A 8 = $7= " $!$#% !$ $$$"##! !$# !7

07 *#""#$,!>#344/## D< : $ $C +#% %9"#$ :$ =(% $" D "$A #% #$A#7 =( % $ " = $##"$ D$ #>;$ %!##$#$ #7$#% $: # $ "$AD < 8$#$!#+"$!# ##$$ % 4+ 6$ 4+ 3$ $#8"!% $ # $ 8$# 6+ 37

57 =## <!66#3441< "$ $ =% $ " #"# $#% $ <= "#!$ $ $;# #% + #D % "#$$ $$ :9 +9$ #% " $#$ 7 $$ $!$ $:$$$"$E$!#7"!# $ ! ##"#$A!#" # #7

-7 * #""#$ 36 %# 3441 & "$# $# =# =#!!$ $##F$!C!G"D7%!A =% $"#$!C=## 8#7 A % $ !$! $#8 :#$7 #D# $ # DA $ A7 % $#$ %#$ D$"# $!$ C<$ #> # <:# $ DA7 ;#F!$!C=AE" $" $! #H ! $# $$ <# "#$# $$7

27 #""#$ 32 %# 3441 # ! $! "# )##%!A $"#$ !<=#!" D $ "# $##% ## $%##I;<=:#$%# D$#$#> #$!"#" $ "#D!$

./012.3445 +/.63+ #A7 =#! % $ "#!$! $#$ #% ! $##% J %# #K7"# $ $# ## #% ;# % "$ "(AD < $ =!%$ #$ $ C %#7 $ "% $ F$# !#! < 7 = " $! $#% # $" 3,"$>#344/7

,7 ### #1 3441="(#=#! : $#$$#% %::$/6; $34417

647 * #""#$ =9"#$ &#+ $ 64 ; 3441 %!A $"# # $#AC% $"# $#600$330L.A $% $#=#!% $> # $% $,C60L.A7

667 30M$3441=#+ $$# C=#!#""#$#34 ; $3441"# <!"$$ J +"#8N K $C A" $ $ 33; 61; $3441 "#$ $! /4;# "# ""#$# ##< 9" $ "!$ #7 =# $ !;C =#!!$ $%#$ <=#$$# $: C"#$$ /6M$34417

=9 #"(AD 31 $ 30 ; 3441 % $ $#! #$ $!#!C#$ !"#%A#!$#!7"$ $$$ $+ F#$ $#$::# $%! $ $# < "% $"F$#97#$:$ D $ % %$ D! $ $D>$ $#7* "(A $# < 32; 3441<$ # #%!!$>;$ : " $7 => ::# "(A :$ "% $ " #$ #$#>$:#7 $" $<=>#%$ "# $$# !$$!"# :9 9:#7"#$ #!$$$#"$$#$ < "% $ F$# # >$ #!!7 "(A $# #$ $ " $#> "(AD8:#$# $#> %$ " $! $#% 7"# $$:$#$#C% #= $"#$=" $#!%!$ $ #AG=!"97

#$ A" $ $ ! %#! C =#! #$ : $ = " $! $#% = $ ;<= 66 M$ 34417 D$ #% D A# < $ = $ % "$ $ $> $! #$$ # % 4+ 3 "$A 0+ 5$"$ $"#$# "$!#+! "$!$ % 0+ 5!$ $#$7

*#""#$: 34; $3441=9 <!$ $ :: %"$ $">#$ ! $$D <$#:$#! $ #$ $$ : $ #7 =($ " " >$ # "$ $ : ! # C "# $ $# $$ =A" $ $ % $ !$! $##"7 = !;# =9 $ $"=! #$ =!$$$! "$ $ $ " $! $#% + #$ $ 7 >

./012.3445 +1.63+ # D < "#$$ $ " $$# !% :O >;$ % 9" $ C"# $#7=9 $:$#% #$9 ! 9"## $ :#"# $=!$$#9A# <7

637 32"$>#3441=#!#< "#$$ =#+ % $!7

6/7 # ! /4 "$># 3441 =##+ $ $# %#$ "#$$ /6 M$ 34417 : #! $$ ! /4 !>#3441#"" $ &#!7* $##+ # > !!$$! "###F$6,"$>#3440$ $#(! # $9"#$$ &#+ $> D$ #+C/6M$34417 : $ # > ! $! $# $ !<$ # $$ < # $$ # 8# $ & " $! $#% #>"# $#$#!$# $$! 7

617 36 "$># 3440 &#! : $ &>;$ & 9"#$ "# # "! $ A ##D #$A"! < C &:: $ &#+ % $! J +"#8 N K7 &9"#$ D$ <! #% D $>D A# <7 $ $# D$ #!"# # " $!$#% $ ! #$ D:%#&(# #" # $7 &!%$ $$ !$ $ ! 9 # >;$ % &> ! "#$$ &$$ $ "(A $# < >;$ %> 9"$! #$ #$ $ # # D#"A $ # # C &97 &9"#$ & " " $$! >D #$ # $#$# #7 # >;$ % "#$$ $ "$ $# < &9"#$ ! M$ " " $! $#% 7 !$ $ #$ $ "> #"##$#% #!"$ $$$!!"A $< $::#$ "A( < $ "#$$ $ AD$ " $ 7 & " $! $#% % $$A!# <$ !" !>$3440% #%$7

607 &##+ $&#!: $&>;$-:!%# #3445& 9"#$ ! $# &9"#$ ! J +"#8 N K C (7 * #""#$ $# " # #7 #A$D #7 ) "(A $# $ #D ::# #% D $>D A# <"! : <$!"A!$ 7 9"#$$"# ##%!:$#&9D!#$ "#>>7&9"#$ ! " D $#& $ $!$;#!DC"# #;# % #% $> # <!"A!$ !" $$$# $$ $$!;<&C"#!$7& $ $!##% !$ $2#647 " < $ "#: # # #$ << ;# % >D$$#$# ##;$!< $ : $# C 64 # 647 " $ "% $ F$# $!#! % # 3 A# $ $$ >$ % # 34 $7 #A !$ $ #$# $ C 64 C 60 $ 9 7 # > # $ $ C % # - # 647

./012.3445 +0.63+ # M $""# $$ $ % $! "A( < $ !$ $ $#8 $! % <$ $$ "# $IA !D8# $# D$7 " $ ;#"#$ ;#!C A!$#$ $<&% # 14 $"#;#9$# : "##$"#"##"# 9" "# % :$7 * " $ !$ $ :$ D! "!"# !7&% $ &D "#7 !$ $"#$#>!7* " #!$ $" $# <$A$7

&9#A$D <&9"#$"! $$$!<"$ $!$ $$#8 : D!!$#$ %$#!$ %C #""$ 7#A $> $$763 " $: >#(D #62$!$!#%! <"#!$# D P # < C % # A("#$ % $! C &9 # C "# 9 #A $#C#$$ $!9 $#7 #A$D $# $ ! #$# $ > $! #% $ > # D &$$ $ #D <7 &9 #D < % $ <$ !% < "% $ F$# C &# D # "#$$!# $"#&#!7$#% $ %$ $> & "#$$ # $# " $ $ $$$ >;$ %&#!&!$$ $!(##9A# <7*# ""(A <$$ $&"F$#!!7*9"#$ &(% $ " & " $! $#% D : $ % # " $ < $ "#8 "!# 9 : $ $C&!%!$ $7*#""(A < &(% $; & " $!$#% 7

657 &##+ $ "!$!64$># 3445 #""#$&9"#$ 7 #$($A! $A("$A! $" D $ &#!9"#$$#%!<" $&% $"!$!>;$ %!7!$ $ "# # "#>> <& &D'$ & #$ (# $ #" 7 #$# $ > $!> #$#% !$ $!D$$#8 #8$7: $$ $$ "#D!#A$&$ % $!"#$ % & # % $$9$&9D!#$ ("$E79"#$% $C $ !D# >#%! < &#! "% $ #$# #$ &$#$ $ < &9 <% $!$!#7

6-7 #! 31 3445& $#(!C&#!#$$ 8# " & % $!6#"$>#3441/6#34407 : $& !#! < &!$$$!&#!&!$ $! #!#$<&% $#%#! " " $! $#% &$ % $! 8 6# ;% # 3440 7

627 #! #"" $ 3,M$3445& #;$!+ 7

6,7 86#"$>#3445&#!!$!#">$#% #C644 Q "#! 7

./012.3445 +5.63+

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

367 2%>#3445& $ !!$# ###$C#;$ #>9"#$ ::$!7

337 36#344-##$$$"# # >!7"#! <& :$F$#$#8 " >$$<#!"$ $< $ :: % :#$9$F$$<7% $!D$ :: $!C#$# "$"3A#7#$#% % $ &"# &!$$&$#$IA9$<"#9"$$#>> & :$ 7 D > %$! #"## $#% " <& #! C $#% # 8 6# "$># 34457 # # $#: $<&C $& $> $# $$! $9 #<&::# $$::#$;#"A$"A> $<&!$ $A "! "#$IA!D8#7

./012.3445 +-.63+ 3/7 *#!$!D#!C;D#7

#"

67 :#!$C&#$70576$7A73 D% #=#D $ ; #33%>#6,16JK # >$# '$ $ <$$$ "#!%C&#$705 :!!# # "#$ D!!# # $ # 5 $># 3444 J K < $#$ %C :!!##=#+ % $!6,; 6,0,J K7

*"!$"#;D#="8$ !$> 7

37 $#;$!! $:#"## $"# ##$#%>J#$705 K7

/7 $ $ D &"8<$ % # ##$"#!$# % $!+C/6#34407

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

&$ &#$!D# %$"# #$ : $ # $ J $ ""# #$K $ F$# : 9! :#!$ C &#$7 22 7 6 J ) 630 16- 7 3T 6,21 "7 6/-K7 * $$ " $ " $!D " $! =" #$#%9A> $

./012.3445 +2.63+ =#!&! # ( !##<AD$""# !A!$ $$ "#$ # $ 9 "#$$ 8 <& "$ &$$# C <&! #$ $$! $ #$GD"!# T % F #<& $ AD$ !$# $ #! $# !;C $##"$ $>$<&" $ "#A $C# #7

07 $#!"$! % $!& " $!D $$"#$ "#!!"#$ D #! #!$$ & : # $! D! $ & & $ J#$7 2 7 6 $ 1 7 6 K7 $ #!"$! " $! D $$ $ &>&"#$ " > $!D &#!# #A! $#% !< >#! < $# !#$ $$ $ #!$ &$$ $C$!"A( <$$<&"# $"#8$# $$ $ # #!"$$ 9 D > J#$7 - K7 # !%# $9 & % $! #% < &#! # $ " >$ # & &!$ $ " % $ "#! % <& "## $ >$ # 9#O$ &$ % $! < "$ # >$ F$# 9 D! "#8 $# $$ $ # #!"$$ ##A!$#% !< >#!J#$765 K7

%#$&#$73276 J%$#K=#!# $C#$ $ 8#= $ % C-4Q C$# +<#$#$= $ % C 54Q C +#$= $ % C04Q C<#$ #$= $ % C14Q 7

57 #"% ##D#!& % $!& $#$ J;D& ( ##K > $ < ! !%$$ &$# "! $ %$ :# #7$IA! $C"#$#;D$ #&!$$$!$C <#<#$"#<$ % $!&#! $ ">$#% #7$#!! $ $$!!$ $ "# !$# # < $#%9 "$ # # >$ 9 D# &#! J ) 630 356 7 1 660 6/1 7 3 661 /61 7 / 640602 76K7

-7 &> D$ "#&#! #D$"# "D!!## $ # J )63,15/ 717363/3// 7/66- 3-2 7 3> 144 $ ##F$ $!T +U )U : A$ G# *>$%#$V#$D )# >#D 6,,, "7 0- 006 $ 0-3T B$>#L $"# G " AV G# A *G %# A#D#A$ $A8 B# A 6,,0"756K7;D"$":# "$#$#% <&#! :# &$ +F">:# #" !>$ " $! $#% "#!% $#<##$ $$$!& :#C"#: $D#! % $!J )64525 73"72-K7

27 *"# " >#""#! $ "#%< ="" < > "#!# $#$ %<="#!#### $ $#$ :J#$714

./012.3445 +,.63+ )##!$ %=#$76, T#$7,073 %#$766/$ 6/3K= $#$ ;D""#! >#$"#%F$# !"# #8D :# "#!$ C ""#! $ "8$ $ # D# "#%7 8 # ;D $ 9 # 8# >;$ % $ ( "#%<<= $"#%" ! # $C " $ "#$$$"#$#;D$%>## $ $ D 97#<#""#$ ! 9 $ $# $ # ;D "$ $#A# &:: # <# # "# < : # " ! $ " # $#7 $ !D# &!!$ !$# $ &$ &# D ! D$ ("#%#""#$9"#$ $7 "#$< " $ $ D 9 "#$$ $ : $ &>;$ & !$ : ! < #""#$ : # 9 "$ <& "# !D$ !#$ " $ 9"# ! <& $ !$! !$> " # J8K<# "$ $#:!#! $ #$: < &9"#$ $> $ %!J )630/06 7/K7

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

,7 /

647 &"8 # >!$ <9"#$ #$ #" $ $ # $8# ;# "#$ "# # #'$# " %#"#>$$# #$C<"#!$##$7*&D $ #""#$ # # $ $$ F$# !#! <

./012.3445 +64.63+ $$ %!7 ! #$9" <!<& : $ #: $<&! &$>;$ %>$<& $ $!#&$" #! >7 * &"" $ 8 # # !#$ ! $ ";D$%#7: #""#$ #65%>#3441 # &$ " "$ > $$# %# "#>$ & 9"#$ ::$! "# "! $ !"$ &#7 $ C #%#"# #<#""#$65%>#3441# #! $ $!# # C &9"#$ # $ < & $ ! % $! ;<&/6#34407

#$&9"#$ " %#"#>$# $F$#! ! C+ : $<&##+ $ "!"# $<$ ""!$ #7 + "#$"" A!#$$$ " " $! $#% 8 # < 9"#$ &$ " $$ $$ #A$&$ % $!"#$ %"#$ # "#: 9#! #!"$ $7 ##$ : $ % # #D$%>"#$$#$$9"#$ 7

!$$ # > ! ;D " ! # $$# R%# 9"#$ ""!$ # &$# # H $ )#< #$##$7

667 &$ " $$! &## < " $ ##$ &$ " " F$# >;$ %! # " ! 7 9 &$ $$ " !% ! $#$ <C&9"$ &# ##% #%!"# #7 # #9"#$&""$$!C&9 < >D #$ # $#$# #7 $: 9"#$ :$!$$&""#$ $$ "#$$#> $! < <$#$#"##% $"#> #J"763$6/ #""#$K7! $!$$$"# #<##$ ::# & $$ $ "(A $# <7 !%$ " $! $#% "## $ 8 # F$# < # > " $ >;$ % $$ # 8#7

9"#$ $$$"<&!%!$ $"#%<! #% +!"AD $<+ "%$"# $#"$D"!# :O !#!7 "$ > # # 9"#$ < # ;D$ " #! > & $ $! " $ !D! "# ##$7 $ !D# # "#O $ #$ 9D!#$ DD#%$ $$ $$ $$$ ::# :: C ##7 #8% < # &$#$ ##$ < $$ $!$ " $ : D! $F$ $ !" > ""#$ #$ #% $#! $#$$ #" " >C>$ ##&97 $ < >#$ &9"#$ ! $ ! #7 : $ <& $

./012.3445 +66.63+ #$! > "#$ &$#$ " $ $# > # :$# DF "#$ 8# > !D$ "$ > % #<&!# $7

$ 9 9"#$ :$ #$ !$$ " $ # "#$$&9"#$ !7 $: $# #$C<$$# 8#"#!$ ! # ## &$ " # & "#$ !< !D!7 ::$ #""#$ &9"#$ : $ < #"# # " $ &9"#$ !7 $ $# # 9"#$ ## %$ C %$ N S W 9 $ > $>$ $ $# & "#$ " $ <#!"# #" $!$#% &"#$$#$8# >;$ %$ $ &!%!$ $ &$# "#$7 # # $#> $$! C &9 < !%<$ $ :$# &" : $ 7S #""#$ &9"#$ #; $ $ 8#$ #7

# >!#8%#!D$<& "#'$"$#8%# >>< ##$::# $##% "#% $ $! 2 # !A 64 " <$ "#: # # #$ << ;# % >D $ $#$# # #;$! $ : $ C 64 # 647 ) C $ $ $! !D! C % # C $ "!# # &!A # > !$$ < ##$ $#% $"!$$!" #$$%!"# #!$ <& "#$$#$# $ < &!$ $"7

##$ D!!D$($A! $A("$A! 9 #$ $7 % $ $$: #%# < ::$ $ " "$ > $#" $!$#% $ % $!#!"$ $7

%< "#!8 % $&$$#<:#!$9 # $ ##$ "#!$ " " $! $#% "$#!>$34407

637 #$$####;$!7

6/7 ##$ >$ !$ 344 :#7 # C A#D "" $ &#$75,76> 7

#"$ " "# #

./012.3445 +63.63+ !

4 51

67 !####%>7

! 5

37 #;$$7

/7 &!$: 9!C344:#7$ CA#D##$7

17 :# "#$ <= "%$ :## ## $# "#!$ ##F$ ! /4 ;# 8 $ : $ "#8 # > :!!# J*AV G#A:< 55441 K"#% ##$ 8## $ "> :#!$9#$723 :!!## # >:!!#6- ; 3440 J )KT ! # ## $ <# $ : $ ("#%$"#$# D$###$$ #T $ F$# #! # > :!!# "# % "$ "# % !$# < 9 $ &#$7 13 )7 "#!$ ##F$ $ " 8 " ##$ %<!("#% %$F$#; $C&% 7 D#:: 8# "#! $ # H * (

" :#"#!$##F$$$ : !9"#$ <=C=:: :!!# # "#D#::

./012.3445

Statutory Construction and Regulatory Compliance Appeals

Synthèse Legislator

Regeste Legislator

Mots-clés

Dispositions légales citées

Décisions connexes

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Texte complet