Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/43/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/43/2004 Généré par l'IA

Arbitration Clause Validity and Unconscionability Finding

Numéro de cause ATAS/43/2004
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The court reviewed a claim concerning the validity of a contract provision that mandated arbitration for any dispute arising from the agreement, which the challenging party argued was unconscionable due to its one-sided application and the context of the transaction. The court determined that while certain aspects of the provision, such as one-sided fee shifting, might be substantively unconscionable, the challenger failed to demonstrate procedural unconscionability because they had the opportunity to negotiate or reject the terms. Ultimately, the court upheld the arbitration clause, reasoning that because the agreement was the result of a bargained-for exchange and the challenger did not prove sufficient procedural defects, the agreement to arbitrate was enforceable, though it severed or modified certain provisions deemed substantively oppressive.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Arbitration Clause Validity and Unconscionability Finding: The court determined that while certain aspects of the provision, such as one-sided fee shifting, might be substantively unconscionable, the challenger failed to demonstrate procedural unconscionability because they had the opportunity to negotiate or reject the terms. Ultimately, the court upheld the arbitration clause, reasoning that because the agreement was the result of a bargained-for exchange and the challenger did not prove sufficient procedural defects, the agreement to arbitrate was enforceable, though it severed or modified certain provisions deemed substantively oppressive.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
validité de clause compromissoire partie au contrat vice de procédure nullité du contrat arbitrabilité objet du litige

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive to rule on the cost of the appeal proceedings.
Art. 64 LTF
Cited in the dispositive to rule on the request for legal aid.
Généré par l'IA
A/13/2007
Arbitration Clause Validity and Scope Dispute
A/3647/2007
Contract Arbitration Clause Enforceability and Unconscionability Finding
A/1092/2005
Enforceability of Arbitration Clause Upheld Despite Unconscionability Claim
A/1860/2005
Arbitration Clause Enforceability Based on Unconscionability Claim
A/2377/2004
Arbitration Clause Enforceability Due to Alleged Unconscionability

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to rule on the cost of the appeal proceedings.

Art. 64 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to rule on the request for legal aid.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

    &'()*&+,,+-+- !&./&+,,.

0!

 ! "1 "!"1   "   1 

$  / 23 +,,.

+4   

  

  56666666666

78$



99  "!"1  1:" - ";1  !      !" # $%

 

           !! "" #$ $% & '()&

" 9 !

*+ ,- .//////////0 1 2  %1 *!"*0  -12  -$  3 40 2 51%-  *!!*0 *!!6  *!!7 8  259  ::1 125 51 *!!*+

'+  *!)7 # *!!*0 ;2  %12  <12 =-5 2  > ;> # *??@0 51 # A?@    9 1$ 2 ;1%12+

$ 5-> *!!*0   2   51 :2  1%12 1% 9 41  =5   -2:    40   %1 # 1  7 B 5 -1 %1  ;51   -1+

3+ =122 44 51  4 = 1 &->1  51 *!)'0   5:2 51 0   1 5  0 --  41  C2+

5$  91$- :0 =2 # D  2 # ::  41  51 5 =1   EB -2:$0   ;2 - 2+

6+    *! 42%1 *!!)0   112 =1 =    1   1+

F  55 -21 2>1  'A -1 *!!) 5   //////////0 -21&10 ;122 44  &->:1 B1<  1-5 1 &->1  6?@   D 1%  ->9 1-  5B 1B251 51 *!))+  -21  5212 < =2  2   51 21 > 51 *!!70 -1 <=1 911 2-1  1512  %1  A?@ 51  * %1 *!!"+

A+ 41 =2>1  :2 =1%112  ,- .//////////0   =-51-   %9 -2: <   1%12 5410 ;441   ;&1%112 G1&5$  H  522 #  <I 2-1<   -2:    6 > *!!!+

  1  55 ;<I 2>1  *! > *!!! < ;2 5%1 44  1%12 2:$  144120 -1 <; %1  41 1 5  %9 1 0   5   510  51  1: -120  5 ;B 1-1 25 3  6 J1+ & 3()&

     <I0   22 <= > 20  1 %1->>- %12 # 1  ! B 5 -1  <= 1 -2   -2:+

=<I1  5212 K

LF =20  1 -- B:  511  1   +   :I2   1 -1 C=1 2 <= 5%1 # %  4  3   14412 55L+

;1%112  ;2      EB -2:$  11 22 4192 # '?0'@ +

7+  <I  22 -522 5  : # =1 -2:   =>%1 41  =&1%112 G1&5$  H <1 = 22  6  " 2-> '???+

=1   :0  -21&1   0   //////////0  K

L  =2%1   1  -2:0  =% 5 5 -  2%1  4B 1-11  =-51  -%-+  0   B-  %1  412 5  -> 5+    25211  1 1%12 551  +

  2%1 < =1 B11  44 ,- .////////// &11<  1%12  11 <  -%- 2522  1   491    --  1%12 # > 5+  51    51   4 552-1   1:  -5   14412   1%12 5 0  --  41> 2%55- :2212   -+

 0  1%12 2:$ 5% I 442  14412 -   1 :11   C2 M  51 5   1442 %90 5- 11  %11  511   :   -5GNH+  %  =1-51 < ,- .//////////  22 4- 142 5  55   1442 B250 <1 -> 1 %1 12 =2%1  44 41   5 ::% 5  5>$- B11+ $  ,- .////////// :1     51 5 5   41 -0 -1 1 5 1  +L & 6()&

"+ 41  1 -5  >%1 -120 =  0   5C  211  *? 5-> '??*0 2C2    :2 =1%112  ,- .//////////  4192 1&1 # 63@+

)+   <1  =1%12 5410 1 = 5 22  =1512  %1 1  :10 =  12 <0   1:- -219   510 =2 5%1 %1 # A?@   51 -5   1%12 =-5 2  >+

!+ $ 0 5 211  7 2-> '??*0 =   42 =    1%112 # =2+  440 =441  1-20  4   21  =122 &-I-0 <  5 5 #  >1 # ;51  =259 ;2%1 # ''0A@    =-51-  EB -2:$ # ""0A@+ -5  = 9 =1%112  63@  =1%12  -2: 52  ""0 A@  1%12  =20 =   2 <  9 :>  =1%112 21  3303'@0 9 1441 5 %1 1 #  +

*?+ ,- .//////////      *) C%1 '??'   211  = +   41 %1 <  1  2:10 <= 51   1%12 -2:$ 21 C 1-51> # 5  A?@0  -I- <= 1%12 541 # 5  A?@0   1  5 -5   41 5 =  1%-  -5 2  -2:  # =1%12 541+    #  < =    % 211 -  9 =1%112  A?@  -11--+

+   52%1  *! - '??'0 =    #  C  +

*'+   22- 51  1  510   <  >10   51 O  1 P  52 I+

"  !

*+  1 :%1  =:11 C111  '' %-> *!6* GH  22 -1412   1>     22 112 $  * D '??30   1 1<0 --   1 1% #  1 422  = 1%112  *! C1 *!A! G H+    $  22 -1 =441  52 1>0 4-2- # =+ 3 + 3  & A()&

1511 11  *6 %-> '??' -141  1  =:11 C111 GH0 <1  -52 5 C:   =5$+

'+  1 422   51 :22  1   1  7 > '??' G H  2  %1:  * C%1 '??30 Q  -1411  -> 1511 2:   -1  = 1%112+   =5$  2-1 2:1 5  1511      %1: C<= 3* 2-> '??'0  2:  5115  <  $: 551>    %1:  -- M  41 C11<- 2-1   51 G R *'"  67" 1+*H+  0  C: 5521  2:12  211 <20  $: :220 =5$ =2  41 91  -- M  211 11:1  22  G R *'*  377 1+* >H+

3+ 4-2- 9 1 7!   1 422  = 1%112  *!

C1 *!A! G H  )6  = %11  %1%  '? 2-> *!67 G FH0     '??'0  122 5%0   3? C $  14110 1C    211  = +  211 <1 = 5 41 =>C =  4-2  -5 1 5  4  B C:20   <  C:  5   -1$    14+   <1   5510 =>%10  5:1   11  210  + '? # '6   1 422   52 -111%  '?

2-> *!7) G H   551> #  52 %  12    G *!!' 5+ 3!A 1+ '*H+

110 4-2- #   0  21 4192  C   5  *)

2->  * C%1 11%-+

C2  *) C%1 '??'   211  =   7 2-> '??*0     %> #  4-+

6+ 9 -  =+ 6 +*  0 =1%112  2411 --  1-11   512  :1 5-   : 20 <1 2 ; 1 #  2 5B 1<  -0 5% = 141-12 :210 = -1  = 1+

 %  =+ ') +  0 =2GH  1 #   1$ =1&  1%1 # 770'(3@  -10 #  -1& =1&  1%1 # A?@  -1  # S   =1&  1%1 # 6?@  -1+ & 7()&

4-2- # =+ ') +'  0  %  =2%1  =1%112 = 50 1 %1  -5  %  %1 < =1%1 51 >1  9T  1%12 <= 5 1>-   1  % <=1 1 5 >1  1%112+

=+ '"  0 < # 10 51 < =1%112  5 <1 =9 5 =1%12 1%    =+ A +*    1-2  41  =-5IB- =-51  %9 B>1  =1%12    -2:  =21  4+

  =1%12 # -5 510 1  1  419 =1%112 5  5 5 -51  %  =+ ') +'    ;1%112 5  5 2 9 %9 B>1 5 -51  1%12  =+ '"   G-2B -19 4+ + '" >1 + *  H+

$ 0 1 %1  2-1 52>-  5  =1%12 1%    =-51-   %9 B>1 %    :2 =1%112 =5$  B15  =2  442  B  1%12 2 G *!)7 5+ '66 H+

A+  =5$0 =1%112 1 I 2%2   -2B -19 21+  440 1 1  55 <=%  I -10   %11 # -5 51 G''0A@H  =51   -1  1 = 51   -5 9 1%12 -2:$ G""0A@H+

 5:  5 ;  ;951<   -1$ 1% K

F1 ; 1$ <; 5    1%12 # -5 -5 %1 :22- 6? B 5 -1  <   -511  7  ! B  %1 -1114 B>-10  521  5 -1 ; <   -50 1  1%12 541  ;  ''0A @ G :H+

  <1   9 =1%112  ?@      1 1%12 5410   52 <0   1 #  20  1 %12 # "A@  *??@+  2:1  5 21>   - M0 %1-0   = :$ %12 5  7 B 5 -1  =51   259 51 *!!*  0 5  1  % 5+  Q0  %1 2C# 52 5  51 # -5 51 %  1   4+  55Q <0 -$  1 4  & "()&

C G  1  2  *!!7H0 ,- .////////// =1 1- 5 :-2  9 =1%12+

 10 11 < ; 2  -21&10     512  %1 21  A?@ K  51 44  5>$- '? B  %1  > 5 -1  0  4110  7 B B>1  %1  ;51   259+

= 11 # C 1 < =  = 5  =1%112   5+

7+ 9 41 ;2>1  9 =1%112 -11>     =-51-  %9 B>10 =   522 #  <I 2-1<   -2: <1  22 -522 5  :   1   +

  <1   521  1442 1%12 -2:$0 4    <0 1 0 1 <I  22 2>1  4-12  11%    11  =1%1120 =1-5 GB+ 3?!?  G  H    C15 422+  5110    <I0 1  22 D- 522 #  1411  2%1  %9 -2: 5 242 9 " 5 11<2  B144 3?!A  0  419  1-5 51%  5 0   4B 2-120 -5   2   8 =-5IB- >1 5 B< 5  22 4192  41  21  =122   >%1 41  5+

10 5  1 9 >%1 4-2 5   0 =   2C2  9 =1%112  ,- .////////// 111-   =91   EB -2:$+

 20  %  121 <1 52$0  1> 1$ < ;1-1  -5IB- >1 5 =2   1%12 B>10  <;  22 442 5 ;-1110  1 I 11<2  < 1 -5IB-  22 - 4192 # 63@0 =M  :2 =1%112  3303'@   <1     -2:+  %1  2<0  9 :> =1%112 11< %1 I -10 % => =1%112    5 541+

"+ 0  :2 ;1%112 =% 5 1 #   0   <0 - 420   1 I C2+

UUUU & )()&

   ! 9

1 ! "1 "!"1   "   1 

$

  28 

*+ -  +

$ 28

'+  C+

3+ 1 <  52  :1+

6+ 4-  51   <= 5% 4-    52 I   21  3? C $  1411 5 51 --2 2  1> 422  0 FBV1WB4<1 70 7??6   0  1 9-51+  21  5 I 5:2+  -2-1 1 K H 11< 9- <= 211   21 >1  1  5   211 <28 >H 95 5 < -14 1 1- 5%1 -   2118 H 5  1:     52+ F1  -2-1  1 5  1 22- 2-22   H >H  H 1&0  1> 422    5 5   -1$    <=1 % 2 1%>+  -2-1   -1   -   5%0 <1  C10 11 <  211 <2  =%55  <   22 95212   G+ *3'0 *?7  *?) H+

 :441 K  21 K

1  F > F

 21&C1 K 9   

 51 4-  52 I  1412 9 51 11 <=# =441 422   1 5  :44