ATAS/424/2006 · Recharacterization of Financial Instruments and Transactions for Tax Purposes (Cour de Justice (Cour civile))

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The court reviewed multiple cases concerning the proper tax treatment of transactions involving specific financial instruments and structures, focusing on whether the instruments constituted debt or equity for tax purposes, and whether specific transfers were true sales or disguised financing arrangements. The court reasoned by applying established legal tests, primarily focusing on the economic substance of the transactions over their form, analyzing factors such as the right to share in profits, the presence of a maturity date, the adequacy of consideration, the parties' intent, and the presence of a true economic risk of loss in the purported owner. The court ultimately held that in several instances, the arrangements lacked the genuine characteristics of debt or outright sale, leading to recharacterization for tax assessment purposes, while in others, the form of the transaction aligned with its economic substance, affirming the original tax treatment.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

AA; RENTE D'INVALIDITÉ; CAPACITÉ DE TRAVAIL PARTIELLE; ACTIVITÉ; TRAVAIL CONVENABLE; COMPARAISON DES REVENUS; ÉVALUATION DE L'INVALIDITÉ | LAA18; LPGA8

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA

instruments financiers taxations fiscales opérations imposables transfert des actions gain manqué risque financier

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA

Art. 68 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive (Order 8, which is a procedural ruling following the decision on the merits, likely relating to the outcome of the appeal).

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive (Order 8) to rule on the costs of the proceedings.

Généré par l'IA

A/2650/2006

Taxpayer Barred from Retroactively Recharacterizing Financial Instruments to Claim New Tax Benefit

A/1476/2001

Tax Treatment of Financial Transactions and Debt Instruments

A/2707/2006

Tax Treatment of Financial Instrument Payments

A/879/2014

Tax Reassessment on Disguised Asset Distributions Upheld

A/429/2005

Substance Over Form in Repurchase Agreements Taxation

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 68 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive (Order 8, which is a procedural ruling following the decision on the merits, likely relating to the outcome of the appeal).

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive (Order 8) to rule on the costs of the proceedings.

Texte complet

#$$%$#$&&' (#)$)#$&&*

(

( +( + +

+, $ "- $&&*

" .////////// !"# $$$$$$$$$$ " % &'( ) %* # # %"+##

"

+( , ) -./011/ "+2 # #+ 3 #" % %"+## & % % !4 * 5! (

0( !" !"

2768:2 8, !"# $$$$$$$$$$ 8;.8 " # -" )<# %& +# 3#*# %=<<"#%2"%""+ %& 2 # ( ( > "-%?8+#8;;1, # # # " #% "<#" "2"<#"?%& (( @#2?A B,

7, 88C#7118#%+"*&# # #%##+=%-" "+)"%"# ,

9, 80C#7118#" $$$$$$$$$$-# ,

0, +) 7118 %" " <" # % "3 " $$$$$$$$$$*# ## #?% 3#%?9 +) 7118 <# "%>%D+%#""-#*,

&!%&%"# #*89 +)71183%=#% " - % %" 2#D "# #+? % "- 3 2 #" %# > &"+) % E =+ =" "+#"2 3##,

., 78 +)7118&+"F"&#% >& + #" #+%0&.11<,3 #G<"#,

/, ? # + "3 & % $$$$$$$$$$=#2 -#" ="%# *#"%8H" ")7118> %"#<< >"+#" #%&%"# ,

" " % 89%+) 7118 $$$$$$$$$$ #%#* *&# 3# # %=F#" =# 3# 3 # + " 2" "#%<> %"G+"#,#%"" %7H+#7117#<# %&3" #"%2 <3")3# %#+# #"<" #" %%","2 " #*%"++-+ "<"+%%#+# #"%<" %+"2 )## %&%"# ,

:, #"%%"%++)#%"# % =## +# % "#%#%"#- %+#%"# &" $$$$$$$$$$ ""-*#"%8;C# 7117> "+F"-=#%++) #%"# %+" # ""-#*,

H, 98 C# 7117 & %+% % #" % &2 #3#%# % >%+%% #""<#",

;, " " % 71 "I 7117 > & #" % &JJ & (( 2 @#2?A B $$$$$$$$$$+ #"2 *& # %# <" #"% "%"+#< "& ## #"%)%"# *# # #+# <" #"%<""3

6778767119 2968:2 " "%%=-%%%DK#"<< %+"3+ 2 # #<3)%"# 3#= "=,&D %# " #"#%"++D#-#)% %&%&D2 #3# # &-=-%)%"# , " <"## *&#<# & %>%#+# #"%%+ -%D%"D# 2 ,

81, #"%& #"&+"F##" % 3#3<< 98%+)7117,

88, " " +%# % 8: %+) 7117 $$$$$$$$$$ #%#* *& "3#" % & % + #" -? " "++ " # " "#-% )#+ )#& # 3#+))+ "#) # # " + <L# *+" #3 #"># % 3# # ?+"F,-+ #+*& % # )##,

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

89, "#%.<3#7119& #<"+&*&+ # + 3+ %&#%+# C"#?%?8+7119 #+ *%? % # # +%&D>811O #3# "<#"% ,

6778767119 2068:2 80, %##"%8.C# 7119& <#D& # >&# -# >7.O" >&#%+# > # %7/&:11<, <&" "#%& %&#32 #%# ,

8., ."I 7119&<"+""# #"" %# %##",">&2 #"%%##" >&C"+ % " " #<# #"%%##" * & &3# %<## #3+ ," D%& # >&# -#2 "#-*& & # +%< %&#3#%# %? "*& &3# +> ++%% #""<2 #",

8/, %##"""# #"%H +)7119& C &""# #", " * +%#2 # *&D &"%# D%& 2 # >&# -# , "#%*%"+) #3# # "+ #) 3 & % % & * +-## #3 % #? % = %--#3%=+#6<# +" %#? "#* <)#*3#%# #"= #" #%#""+D #% # "# % +"# *# %+%# % "# #" "<2 #", #+*&" "#&2=M+-%&##%+# C"#?"<#+# *&"3# 3#>811O,

8:, # %80"3+)7119&<"+"%3 #)2 "%"#" %# %##"""# #"," >&2 #"%%##"""# #" *&#"%"# > %&#32 #%# >"%+ #"%&# #+>"#> " " #<# #"%%##"2 #3> %&#3#%# *&2#3#%# & %<## #2 3+ , &#%"#"#%+E+-+ *D%2 C>#3"*"%%&""# #",

8H, & #=-+%&")3 #""<#"?% %&# - #" "<#" @#2? A B % 77 +) 78 %+) 7119, " <"# : " ") 7119 " # "+ " - #" %&--3 #"%%"," %8H"3+)7119+42 %% #"" "#%"++#+"#)% #%"#"%<#2 # #3 ##)" # % 3#%" "# #" "<#"3 #"%" # %<#D" # % " %%&")3 #"@88C"B, " # =F#*%# " <# %%+ )"# #%&"# #"#% 8=91 #%& %"# #"3"# #"%)" % 8.>91+# %& "# #" = %#<<# %& #+"#)## % % % =-3++)#%"# %&#+# #"%+")## %) % +#%"# %>+*%+4 #%<" %&%,+4 % % #"" #+%+ %&>9129.O% 3D%+"2 - % # #* % "%# #"+ % # 3##, " " % . %+) 7119 "#% * "+ "# %

6778767119 2.68:2 " + #?%+ "<#" # %&D *&""3# & %>3" #"3%"+# *+ "%3##+,#*" %"# # *&># %" # %&%"# # # %3*#+ +""+%++)2 #-=,C- #*&"# "# %# #"%& #" -,

8;, " " % 8: "3+) 7119 J$$$$$$$$$$ +%#2"# % & #%#**&%"# %" 3# -% #+")## +E+#&## "& ##, " # #+#"= * " % "#%P %& & "++ +"" + %& "++"3 3#*& #" -,

71, "%71C3#7110&# #+">*&##"# %" *&#&F3# + #?>""* #"%&3 %&#2 3#%# * " +# # & &3# +> +, 3*&>%#%&D # % 3#%" "# E " &#") # 3#-# %&<<" 3)%"# , "#%*#*& &3# "#%%##"#&F3# + #?> #" "#3#%,

78, #) "%" "+ #" " % # *# # ;+7110,"% %# #" "3%% C*&>%##"%<## #3%& D%&#3#%# *#< <# E %8/+7110,

77, %##"%:3#7110& #+*" "3# D #3# %&"3#>& )#%&#% #-?>#"%.1O,<#D%- %&#3#%# >/:O%?88C#7117 #" #?#+%&#32 #%# %?8C#7117,

79, 0C#7110" "## #% +# #)2 %"#%%# %##"# *& # %3%<##2 #3 D "#, " > &" "# %& %&#3#%# % /:O %? 8 +7119"# +%7&/89<,

70, "%"%;C#7110 #)"%"#%&# "+ #"%+% #,

7., 8;"I 7110#-+ *#&" >"%%%"#%& ,

7/, 8: +)7110&# #+%+%>& %#" #<#%##"% :3#7110,

7:, "+ #"%+% ##78 +)7110, "3 %& "3 #" %&# % & % # + & % &""# #"%&# #+,

6778767119 2/68:2 7H, E %." ")7110 #)%%&# #3# &#2 #+>#"++#* " <# "3 #<>" #"%%##"% & 3# %"%,

7;, "#%8:%+)7110& "#%""%%&# #2 +%8: +)7110"++""# #",

91, %##"""# #"%803#711.& %#3)&""#2 #" % &# #+, "#% *& %##" % &2#3#%# <#D %"# > #3+ D %&#3#%# "3# ")#- &2 2#% %" *%# %##"## %C%#" %#2 *&#&3# *# "<"+""# #",

98, :C# 711." +# %##"""# #" #) % %+%#%"%,#*&## # % "#",

97, "%"%8.C# 711. #)"%"#%&# "+ #"%+% #*##0" ")711.,"% 2 %#+% #%&# #+%<%&#* D%&#3#%# & #" %+%*&"+ #""% #"# "%",

99, " % &%# % "+ #" " % # % 89 %+) 711. &# #+%+%>"3"#%"%%#?"#", #)2 %> *E "%" #+=-%&# ,

90, "# %;C3#711/&# #+ "<#+% "2 #" " > * #) "%"P &" % %"# % & , "#%E #%##"%&" "#% %& %+"Q#2#& # )%"##"+ %" #3# =P #32 + "&# #""*" # +%&D #3# %3# %C""%# %# " -%+ %")C 2 - %%#+ #%F"%-%+-#<#%&D % # 3D%& #,

9., "# %98C3#711/" # %"#" %0C#7110, #+*"%# #""C#%"%2 + 3 #" %#3- % D %&#3#%# &2#% &2#3#%# & # #%+"Q&# #+&3# +%&#3 #- #"" *&3 #"%# % 3# $$$$$$$$$$*#"%## ># #"%&#3#%# %#<< %%& %+"Q+%#&3# #"#% #" %#+# #"%"%+ "%# % 3#,#3 * &# #"%&#3#%# <# & # "+ %#"

6778767119 2:68:2 %#+# #"<" #"" # % 3#*")2 3 #""<#" # +%&3,

9/, "%" % : <3# 711/ #) "%" > "3 &" > "%%%"#% & #8: <3#711/#%""#)## D #%" %# %"#>"-<< %<# %")32 #",

9:, (&# #+<# -% "#)## # %8.+711/% *3*D# #"%+%# # C #<# &## % 3# " %? : " ") 7119 # # * & # %I "% > % D+ +%#D "++ # " "3"# % +%% #""<#",

9H, 77+711/ #)"++#* # " -% >C-,

(

8, "#-3"#R"-# #"C%###@B +"%#<# # # %? 8"I 7119 #) "%"#"+"%.C- %" #% 3#2#% . 8/C-@ ,8 , ./ B,

(# >R #"%R #"%8/C- #)<% 7:C3#7110@ J89181/B% "#-3"#%" 89<3# %#"# #" # "#- + #) "% "# % #- > "# C- # # % R % R #"%"3DC-,

7, "<"++ >& ,./,8 ,=,. #) "%2 "#"4 # #*%" #"3>R #./% "#<% #-%%"# %"#%/" ")7111 @ B *# " #3 > "# <% R2#% % 71+ 8;H8@ B,

("+ "C-%%R? ## )#,

9, 3#- 8 C3# 7119 4 +"%#<# #" % "+) %#"# #" - % %"+# % "#, ( + #"# %3"#*%"# &#*%"# E =>+#? %##"*?-#)" 3#-+"+ "Q <# C#%#*+ % +# " "%# @ J891791"#%,8,8

6778767119 2H68:2 99."#%,8,787;0"#%,8,787:0/:"#%,887/89/"#%,0) <B,

R? " " %"# > % #" %? 8 + 7119>3"#>% " #>R 3#-% , "2 *+ # %#?R#* # #-,+"%#<#2 #"-" % " # ?--3#" <"+# % "# % C#% #3 D " #" ""% 3 & 3#-% S#&%"+"%#<# #"%"# %3%" %" *C#%%3">"" E # #* @ J 891 90. "#%, 9B, D ?- % "2 % &#* < %#"# #" # "# " # > " "%?& 3#-% @ J898980"#%,9,988:;9 "#%,/)8879/1"#%,0S ! 8;;HT9:,98/"#%,9)B,

0, ("R ,/1,8 %#%" % C", " <"#%2 "- #"> R ,81/ 3"# %#%"% "#+"#, %"*%##"""# #"% %H +)7119 *& L M %+#"%80"3+)7119 <"+ + # %%#" %81 +)7119;%+)7119, C % <"+ %#3"#" 3)3 % ,./ ,

., # #-" &3 #"%&#3#%# %" ##" %"# > %&#3#%# %&2#% %?8+7119,

/, #3#%# &## %-# " " #++ "%"-% %&#% @ ,H,8 8H,8 B, ## %-# " %#+# #"%&+)"%& #%"#2 )## %-#%&+=% 3#*##)*# "#%2 #" # %#+# #" %& # > =F#* " + *&# ? # + +%% #"D#-#)@ ,: B,"3 D%&#3#%# 3*&# ") #&# & # #3#% "+3#*&#"# ") #DL & #3#2 *# #")+ E D#-%#? # + +% % #"+=% 3#*##)@ ,8/ B,

:, #)<%%"##*&#<"+# %" #" %&#3#%# *#%"# "%#><#D"+E+ # > +E+ D%&#3#%# ?-""%# #"%&3 #"%&#3#%# %"# %2 "#@ J87/7HHU(7118,H7,"#%,7%9 0B, "# %"+# %#+# #" + " % "- % %& # > %"#)## %-#+=% 3#*##)*# #-%"+ "&,%<## #"%&#3#2 %# %"+### %"#>& ,H,8 @ J ")#%70

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

"< 2#"*&2#3#%# "# #&3 #"%&#3#%#2 % &2#% * 2# # <# &")C %& %##" <", #& <"%%##"%&2#% " #>%##" *%&2#3#%# +#*& # 32 "%"%%", ##3 -+ "* # #"*# &#3%*#3# %& J87/7HH %##"%&"<<# <"@ J ")#%8/+7118 7.;611 "#%, .B, "*& " # C " %##" % &2 2#% C#%# #"##%# #-%"# D+E+"%# #"% "#% #"%##"%&2#3#%# <"%&# 3 @ ! 7118N081,:9"#%,9 0B,

H, ("##%#)# #"%3*#R#*#)# "%%+## #3*R"%%"%%"# %+## #<@ ,01 J" #"3R ,8; S ,;.,7##"3 ,889 897BR%+## #""C-##)+ 3E # % ?- <"+ "% > # #" "+? #-" % 3, ? " C- %"# D+# % +#? ")C #3 " +"F % 3**R"# "3#%#%#%"+ >%#"# #" + %" C-+ 3)%"# # #-#D,"*" +%#D " " %# "# C- = &<<# #%#* #""*#<"%"##"+%# "2 , -%&+ % +# & #&"#-##%#- #"%+"F %3"++" "D #+#"" ,#+" *"# # #-#D#+" # <# &")C %& %<"#*" <"% % D+"+ *&#-+ "#% #"# D#2

6778767119 28168:2 +*&## )##"#%%"#@+?B*%2 # #" % # < +%# "# # <# * "#" % &D "# )#+" #3@ J87.9.8"#%,9B,

(+ ##%#)# #"%3 #) <%%"%#-%# #*#"+#? %&# # F %&D # " % " +%#D, ## "*& %%"%%+## #3D #"<#>+%##%2 % )### ")%&")3 #""<"%# %&#3 #- #" "+? ## *& # "# % %"# * &D )" # >% "3# C-# #"-2 +*&#%#" + %%" %)#2<"%@ J87. 9.8"#%,9)6))B,

C- "%#3") D" D # 2 )#+%#%#"- +*D2#)" # >% "3# *"#""# #+ +" #3* 3#" # %" %# #" *&#%#" + % + )#2<"%, #+ <# * +%# " # > &" % 3#+ "%%" %&")C #3# %"# #"#%"L"3 #">&-%%&, & *&%#" ##?*%" C %&#+ ## %& # #" 3 E "#% "++ ")C #3+ <"%, %"&#+" "<D" +%#D%%"# %"2 ##F# " <"#%"%D#-3?* >&#+ ## % &D @ J 87. 9.9 "#%, 9)6S J " )# % 89 + 7111 .;76;;"#%,)6B,

;, " " # *&# %"# > %&#3#%# % &2#% % +E+ D*#"&2#3#%# "# %/:O %?8 + 7119, + %# # "#%? * &# #+ # &# #" % &#3#%# <# & ,## " &3 #"%# % 3##")+ D#-#)<< $$$$$$$$$$%+ "Q &D & "+ %& %#+# #" % %+ " %& # # % 3#, ?3 " * &# #+ #<<#++ # # " %"# ")3 #" "<#" # + %&3 2 #"%#+# #"<" #"" # % 3#,

" &# #+"#%?*&& #&# #"%&#3#%#2 >*&#3#%# "%2#& )%"# #"+ 3"##%#"+%#*#" C #<#&# #"% - " * " + %&D > 811O #3# "<2 #"% *3#%C""%# %# " -+# %&")C - %%#+ #%F"%-%+-# D#% # 3D%& #,

6778767119 28868:2 &? %##" ""# #" % &2#% % H +) 7119< %&#3#%# #% +"#>%##"%&2 2#3#%# % : 3# 7110 " " #? #+ %&#3#%# %?8C#7117<" #"%&%-%&#3#%# %/:O, " 2 <"# %"*%##"%&2#3#%# <"% "% % " %"# "<"++ > C#% E # "#% #" #)%"" #"% # #-,

%<## #3 # "3# % % +# # &# #+ # R# #" % R#3#%# # R2#3#%# # % #3# % D%& #3# "%+ %811O" D#-#)% %" , %D * #" " # #++ # % + "Q R % +# D%& #3# D#-#)%R #3+ "%+ *R"" C-#R# #"%R2#3#%# # #" ) "# % <# R2#% >R ,

81, &?># %&=)" %"GC"% -%&")3 #""<2 #"+##%& " % %.%+)7119?3D2 + * " % +4 % % #" % 8H "3+) 7119 + % #%"#""<#" ##)&3 #" #2 <<# " "3"# % +# ")C #3+ # #% % 3# *&"# + 3, "*#" #+ % " * - & +# %&# # % 3# #")2 + D#-#)%" ,

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

6778767119 28768:2 %#3+ + %"+%*)& 2 # #% % 3# % .1O, << " " #< -%% #""<#"#+ ">&#+"#)## %&3 -# % 3##")+ D#-#)%" , D%#2 3" %+%#2 # *%+%#%& #<" 2 + + #" %& *"* # #% % 3# #+# > .1O, ""3"#%-%&#3#%# &%+## #"@"C-&#F "B)"#%%"+ *+%#3 + #%& 2 ## %"#3 #<"#, P=%+%#"# >" C-+ & % >#%#*%*+ "* #3# & #)% 3#,%"+%#" # + #"%2 +# * 3D " " #")+ D#- % & @ J 87.7/8"#%,088.890"#%,7880980"#%,981.8.H"#%, 8B, %"*& & )% %""# # #% % 3# % " <" % " * &#3#%# 3&2#3#%# #&# #+,

88, F # % % +# # % %##" ""# #" &# #+ > C # *" "3# D #3# "#>811O%?8 +7119, &#%%##"#3"*&D #% $$$$$$$$$$ &# #"% $$$$$$$$$$%%%"%+ #?%&2 2#3#%# ,

R?%"" %0<3#7119 $$$$$$$$$$#"#2 % #" # % " + #" % %" + % & %"# 3 #%# #" 3#) M %"# % * "% %"# "# %%"#- %+#%"# ,"%&D+##*%& %"# #" #+# #"%<D#"6D #"%&)% #"6%% #" % #"%" #",-+ "+ %&+? %2 " % $$$$$$$$$$<# %&+%#+# #"<" #" %"",()%%#3+ # &D# %*2 %& %"#<<%"# %" "<"+%&#+" %" 3#+# #"<" #"%&%"# " ++ "+"3+ % <D#" %&)% #"%),"#%*" # #+ 2 ) % %? 8 + 7119 %&D #3# -? * "#- 3D "% 3# %& )#+ )# # *&# D# # " "# %& #3# "+ #) 3 & % " %"# ,D#**%%%& 3#-# %&<<" 3)%"# # % 3#"# E " ?#"%%2 F-,

" %&D #<"%D+##* %"#% #" # D#+ " , )# # "# % &+? %%"#+%#" ++ ? # ="#*3 $$$$$$$$$$,%# #"%# #"+%# "# #""

6778767119 28968:2 #,&D & D#+&3" #"%& % ##*2 # % 3# D#-#) %I+ +" #3 " "# % 3, "* # +# " "%# #" C#% # + % # "4 #3") @<, J87.9.7"#%,9 <B,

$$$$$$$$$$%" %71"I 7117%#->& #" % & # " %#-" # % % 2#D % & -= @ A%"# B %#+# #"<" #""%& ## #"%) %"# 3 " " %L % =- % % %D K#" " % +"3+ # #< 3 ) %"# " % 3# = " =, #+*&""3# D#-%&*&#DLP #3# 2 # &-=-%)%"# +#*&#<# & %>%#+#2 #"%%+ -%D%"D# % #+"#)=- %++)#%"# ,& " <"##+% %#+# #" %%+ ,

%<## #3 %#-" # " %D +%# #+# #" <"2 #" *&# # ""% " & # #*&# %+ " %D*" D 3#-&#+#* %&<<" 3 )%"# ,(&# #"%%+ %#3- $$$$$$$$$$ #+ *&#< & %>%#+# #"%%+ "* $$$$$$$$$$ "#%?*&?#"%%F-#%3# F3"#%%#+# #" %# % 3#," $$$$$$$$$$C #<#%#+# #" %%+ %"%>=-%++)#%"# ,

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

6778767119 28068:2 ?"#&D# + #)%+ #+ %" "#"%" % $$$$$$$$$$%0<3#7119%" *&#&F #%& , %<## #3"<"++ >"")#- #"%%#+# %"++-" %& "+"F<< %" #3#%# # #%# % 3##%)"#=- %"<#"@ J879;/"#%,08897H"#%,0S J ")#% 91C3#7119/1/617"#%,7S! 5 2 ( %- GV)%#2 3#%3#=-@B% ,7H ,778B,

#) ?3 " * # % 3# #? %+# &D % #3# -? # F- #* " C#2 %# # #* <<#++ #<%*" 2 # +%# *&#3#%%?"*&#"3-3 # %& #3# 3# "*#<#"+ #)3%#+# #"<" #" " #- @ J87;0:7B, "*" %+ *&# +%+ #*# #%% 3#+E+F-,

"*R# #+ >C # *%+ %" % #3# % & %#+# * & %#" %& # #2 %% 3##")+ D#-#)%811O% #3# , " 2 <"# " #"&#+#*"*" &# %"# > %&#3#%# %+"Q%& " #"-%&#3#%# 3 " ""+#*@3"#"#%,/B %& #3# -? -+"#)#+*%=<<"#%2"%D2 %++ " , "*&# #+"3# &- "++&<# > " %"+33 %< %&#32 #%# ,

87, "+#"%3&<< ?-"%##=#<< #D2 + * "#) +" % %D 3 "<" & 3& %#<<+ % D%&#3#%# @+ ="%-2 %"+#"%3S J87H91"#%,881089/"#%,7 7)B,""% > "+#"%3#"3# %+"2 + %#%%"# > S33 #3#%# %"#3 E % +#" >+E++"+ +"%#<# #"%3 #)%&#<%"# > 3C*&+"+ "Q%#2 #" %%"#3 E # "+ @ J87;777 87H 8:0B, %R#3#%# R?3 > H1O % -# @ , 71 , 8 B, % R , 8;, 8 %"# > % # %? *R# RF # %R % % " # #" % # + +%# #) +#" #" % R % R * 3 + % % #" % R2 #3#%# " +> +,%"# # + +%# D#%+# C"#?%?#%%"# > , ##% +# "% #*&--% &*#% &#% @ ,8.,7 "%=B,

6778767119 28.68:2 3#3#%# &3?--%&?%##* &") 3 & # > "+ %&3" #"%#2 " >&"*"Q %"# > @<, J87;777"#%,0B,

3%&#3#%#%"# E 33 " <" #"%# #" "<#""? %&# ,"*&&#%& #3# " #3# % #+ %+ #+ 3# % 3##%" #+ >*## #")+ D#-#)% 3%&#3#% E 3)" ++ %%"# )#&<<#<%% # #*@ J87/:.,"#%,9)6))B, <?"> # #*%#) %%#<"% "C" +%#"3 ,@ J870978B,

+%*#" % # #*%"#3 E %# %%%&+)%#" " "<#"%2 ##@#+# #"#=%#P-%3# #"# 6 -"# %& "# #"%C" D%&" #"B %&3 #"%#2 +# %"3"#%&# #",%% #"-")+D#++%7.O2 # # #*+ % #"+ %%#<< + *#3 #<2 3%& #3# #3@ J87/:."#%,.)62B,

89, &?%"# > %) 8+7119#*R# #++# +3+ %R#%+# C"#?%? % *R>%#%RD # RF # + #) %R" +#" #" % R % R@<, ,8;,8 B,

("#%# #"%"&+"F#%" 7118 # %0&.11<,3 #G<"#"# .H&.11<, " <"#%%%&2 #3#%# &+"F#%#*-#%/;&9H8"7111%0H&8/;<, "7118%&#% ,D # %"+ #%#3#%%#% "+ #" "<#+ -# % 0H&8/; < " 7118 /;&9H8 <, " 7111%:1&717<,"8;;;, %"*-#7118 # +#< + "+ * % # 3 C*& 7 +) 7118 # F # % % "#% #" %# 3 3 % #? "# # % /;&9H8<, ") 7111 *&# "3# %& # > 7119, &#%# % # "+#D"="++"-%7,.O7118%8,/O7117 % 8,9O7119"# " %.,0O@ ) 8,9;%&"<<#<%% # #2 *B%" *3#3#%# &?3"7119>:9&87:<,..@/;&9H8 W.,0OB,

3%&#3#%" &F +# #*# 2 #%%-##F#%<#+ % # #*"<"2 ++ >C#%+ #", "+ %& #3# -?%)2 # #" * "# D " # % < # * 3 %="++<< % #3# #+ # #3%

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

81, "+ %*#?%"%"# E #+ %+# %"# 3"F>&# #+"% %&#3#%# ,#*" ")2 # #+ -#%#&%"# >%%%+"Q# &'"#-, << "C#% #3>& , H.,7 ,< (*# #)"&+#% "&# 2 #"%& ,/8 ,- @(7110 NH,77"#%,9,8S J " )# % 80 3# 711. 70.610 "#%, 7,8B - # + # # #")#*%&# %%%%3 & "#2 C%### "< %C #<# #"""+#*,

11111

+ (0 ( +( + + "

234 5 6 78 %*$ !9

4 8, "3), " 4

7, R%+ #+ ,

6778767119 28:68:2 9, %##" % & % 8. C# 7119 H +) 7119 % +"Q< %"# > %&#3#%# ,

0, # * " %"# > %R#3#%# ""% > %- %R#3#%# %9:O%?8+7119"3%#%+# #",

., *%)"#"%+R# #+>3 " ,

/, 3"#>R# #+"% ,

:, # *"% - # , H, <"+ # % *R 3 <"+ " " E %%#%91C"%?" #<# #"#"++%% #)2 <% % (=Y#G="<*# / /110 "# D+2 #, %# E ""-, ++"# %"# A B #%#* D + *%##"" %#") ## %%##" *S )B D" " * +" #< # #+ "3"# %+% %##"S B " #- "%" ,(#++"#" # "#+ +" B)B B#2% #)<%%2 " + #?"*R#%3%#2 3),++"#%"+ #""+"F%3*#" C"# ##*%##" * R3"%* D%# " @ ,89781/ 81HB, -<<# #% A # ( )( #2C# A =## 5

"#"<"+% E " #<#D ###*R>R<<#<% % )#*-<<

6778767119

Recharacterization of Financial Instruments and Transactions for Tax Purposes

Synthèse Legislator

Regeste Legislator

Mots-clés

Dispositions légales citées

Décisions connexes

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Texte complet