Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/388/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/388/2006 Généré par l'IA

Contractual Right of First Refusal Waiver via Failure to Meet Condition Precedent

Numéro de cause ATAS/388/2006
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The appellant challenged a judgment that affirmed a prior ruling against them, stemming from a dispute over the enforcement of a contract provision related to the right of first refusal on the sale of property. The central issue was whether the appellee properly waived their right of first refusal by failing to meet a condition precedent—specifically, timely providing necessary documentation regarding financing arrangements as stipulated in the agreement. The court reasoned that the express contractual provision required the right holder to satisfy the documentation requirement within a specified timeframe to exercise the right, and because the appellant failed to provide this documentation timely, their purported exercise of the right was ineffective, thereby upholding the validity of the subsequent sale to a third party.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Right of First Refusal Waiver via Failure to Meet Condition Precedent: The central issue was whether the appellee properly waived their right of first refusal by failing to meet a condition precedent—specifically, timely providing necessary documentation regarding financing arrangements as stipulated in the agreement. The court reasoned that the express contractual provision required the right holder to satisfy the documentation requirement within a specified timeframe to exercise the right, and because the appellant failed to provide this documentation timely, their purported exercise of the right was ineffective, thereby upholding the validity of the subsequent sale to a third party.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
renonciation au droit validité du contrat droit à la propriété voie d'exécution droit de reprise de la possession preuve insuffisante d'aggravation médicale

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the final order regarding the allocation of procedural costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/1767/2002
Contractual Condition Precedent Dispute
A/29/2007
Surety Agreement Waiver of Condition Precedent
A/4295/2005
Contract Enforceability Despite Alleged Unmet Condition Precedent
A/532/2005
Breach of Contract - Conditions Precedent
A/4051/2007
Waiver of Condition Precedent by Non-Cooperation

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the final order regarding the allocation of procedural costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

               "#$%"&''$ "())"&''$

!!

* !+* ,  *! ,+

- . (  % / &''$ 



 !"""#$  % !&'( ' )#("!!""*#(+('" , 

!('

% -    &!''#"("! #/' '&'#)!.!/!'$ 0)'&'#)!. "!'"'# 

                ! 

   75147  

*  0+

""89)"'5663 '":(!' !" *   &"( "'";# !('   %%%  %   * %%  % %     !( $  !("!  (( '"<'  )'(*'(*")""(#!&<($!&('=!(!:'566>)"( /'"(#&?

'#&!24/#)'"'5663 %@%%- 7A"'&'"%%% %   * %%  % %     7  /"( ''A' A (( '"<' *#("( &  "("(("!&'#)!."''&'")# !'(A&"(#&!'#/' /""(#/(*&<?

*&'#"#A*A"(#'"# ')"( #(# '# &!'  &'#)!. &'!/"! &'<  %  -         %   %  % %   ,   - %B C"7&'<D % E $?

 %@%% -  *( :("(# $ *" ''  %  ! !"#(# ;#'(/!("!?

 %@%% -   &'!&!#  &' !" *#!!"  &'!#'   !"#''  89)"'5663!"'";#!(' % ('A"'("/"("! !&'("#/'?

  A(  /!  %@%% -  &'<  !) F  !"' *'7 ")""(#  *'#  *( #'# "&!# $ ''  !)'('  *")""(# !/!'#(  !('( *'7)" !(")  5> &(:' 288> (  '<;(G(?

*!$A!"('.#'H"($'!"*!:9( ?

*  &'#"# A  '"' "' %   ' #("(  =2*22=/'I  '

2 9)"' 5665 C"' !!'!#  J>*38=/'IE ? A  '( *")""(# *#)"( $ J6K  ('"((  :  *(7$7"'  !'<((  &!'  '  $ 5L*JJ=/'I &' # C!( 24*>JJ/'I56 !  &'#)!. &'!/"!E? A  '( */( *")" *#)"( &!'  &'( $ LK  ('"((  :  !"(  &!' */(   '  $ 4*3L8/'I C!( >*63L/'I86 !  &'#)!. &'!/"!E ? A  '!"( F '( *")""(# ( */( *")" #M!"( $ *#M#'!"(F""(#9!'"<' !"(=!(!:'566J?A'( "(";"'"(&(#$*#)!("!&'"F(A''#';'('"( )'#)4K*"(#'G(<89)"'5663 (?



123415663  7>147   *"(''!;# '  &!"(  )!"' "  )"( "" !:( ("/("!   '  &' !''"'  > ' 5663   /"( ''A' A  !  '"<' (((("!#(:"&'-  % (2J/#)'"'566> !(( '(*")""(#!&#("')'"(*#)'$>6*28J/'I("  '( */( *")" $ 3*6>8/'I ? A  &' "'    # A  ''#';  '( &!'(( "(#'G( $ &'("'  53 9)"' 5664  (   &'"<' "(')("!&'<#/'?

*"/!'#   &!"("!   '  %@%% -  &' !''"'  2J'5663 /"(''A'A *&'( *(((("!2J/#)'"'566>*#("(& !("((")'!"(!*!:";("!(A *('&'( ('"((:#("(#;  "' %A&'!'#)'"( &')!"'!'*#&'" !"#'("! *(7$7"''(A*(&'!"(*#)#(!;:   *&< *# 5665 C'( A  ('"((   :   ' #("(  =2*22=/'IE ? A*/"  *;"(  "(#'G(  %@%% -  *( #'# "&!#  &' ;"  &"F  $  !'' <  5L 9)"' 5664  (  '#&("!&'"<'(('!"'?

 &' !''"'  5L ' 5663   '  &'" (  /"( A  #/'&("()''"(#'G(!'(!"'$!&('5L9)"'5664( *( #'# &'G(    "'!(  $ &(' A  &'(("! *")""(# !"(  $ !&('   ')  *"&"(#  (')" !(   ( $ *!'";"*")""(#?

&!''& #A('":(('#&*"(  !";(A"%@%%- )"(!#"($'(!&#("' *")""(#$'#539)"'5664 &'!#'*'"(&"*G('?

,+!  !,+

!";)!"'N!';"("!9"""'CE#(#!"/"#("("(# <  2' !O( 566>   '": (!  ' !"  !&!#  4 9;  !(&'#"(()"7&'#"( 4&&#((239;'C'(I2(I'( 43 E?

 "($N("!N#("!239;' &' '":/##' 5=9)"'566JC -2>6263E ' !";)!"!&(# 2>/#)'"'  "&!"("!('"(!"'';(&'((( '":(!'!"  "#;'  ' $ ('!" 9; ("("'     N(((  N#("!  !)F9;'?

*F('N'(I=>I2 MA(!#"; '":A"!+(  '"<' "( (!   !((("! !&&!( "("(("!  &'#)!.  &!.'(.('!"(?



123415663  7J147   *$ <)   )'(  N'(I 43  I 2 (I :   N(  '": (!  ' !" A" !+(  "( "A  !((("! '(") $  &'#)!. &'!/"! !&&!( "("(("!  &'#)!.  &!.' ( .( '!"( .!&'"")!' ""ANF&'#(("!'&!:""(#C'(I>>2$ >>2   !" /##'  >6 ' 2822 !&#((  ! ")" " P!  !:";("!? Q? '(I 45  43 I 2 ( =>   !" /##'  54 9" 28L5 '  &'#)!. &'!/"!  )""  ')")( ( ")""(#? '(I 2J5  ! ")" "26#:'286=E?

!&#('("!('" '":#(<!'#(:"?

 &'"' !N'(I=>I> /!'("<;!!""" #/'!"NF&!"(("!AN'##(#;;#?

  < !' AN" N( & !((# A  '  (')"# $ <)   !&#('("!!" '":#!"(#;(G('"?

*"!)"(&'"' *!'('&'(" '("/"'&'("#/'    )( G(' "'";# !(' %  -        %  % % % ,   - %B   "$?

*"!)"("(&''(*;;(#/'*!''$ ''(*")""(#5L*JJ=/'I&'#C!(24*>JJ/'I56! &'#)!.&'!/"!E!'("*'(*/(*")"4*3L8/'IC!( >*63L/'I86 !  &'#)!. &'!/"!E  #M#(  = !(!:' 566J  ) "(#'G(4K<5L9)"'5664?

   )"( ""  !:9( &"A  '  ""A# )!"' !:(("/("!?

  ' A" !:("( ;"    '!"(  ':!'(   /'" ( #&""AF!("' G!'A&'!#'(!:9(  &!'((AM<&'!<9("/"(C -2264=!"I5?  28L8&I>2L!"I5:E?

((N&<<!'A#/'A"#$?

*" !)"( ! *!'  #& $  '  A '!( /"F# $ -'I2*666I7?



123415663  74147   !  ,+0  !+* ,  *! ,+



123   4  5   67 #$& ,8

2I #''):I

5I '(*;;(#/'*!''$  '( *")""(#  5L*JJ=/'I &' # C!( 24*>JJ/'I56 !  &'#)!. &'!/"!E  !'(" * '( */( *")"  4*3L8/'I C!(>*63L/'I86!&'#)!.&'!/"!E #M#(=!(!:'566J  )"(#'G(4K<5L9)"'5664?

>I *.!((A:!"I

JI !#/'$)''$'!2*666/'I$("(' #&I

4I /!'&'("AN&)(/!'''!'!('&'#(''G(  #"  >6 9!' <  !("/"("! &' &" '!# '#  '": /##'' %MR"S'M!/A"3 366J  ('!"F&"'I  #"  &( G(' &'!!;#I  #!"' !"(D E ""A' F(( A #""!  '!'( #"' !:("'  " ( &   #""! ((A#? :E F&!'&!'A!("/"("&!)!"''((('#""!?E&!'('  ";(' !   ! '&'#((I %"  #!"'  !("( &  ('!" ##( ##'# ! ((' E :E ( E "7   '": /##'  '  &!'' & (''  ("<' '  '!' AN" )' #'' "''):I #!"''!'("!'!'!.&') A"'!(9!"(  "" A  #""! ((A# ( N)!&&  A   #(# F&#"#  '!'(C'(I2>5 263(26LEI  ;'//"<'  '#"(D       "-- T'"% T

!&"!/!'&'#(''G((!("/"#F&'("""AN$N//"/##' '!"&';'//



123415663