Enforceability of Restrictive Covenants Against Subsequent Purchaser
Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe court considered whether certain restrictive covenants in a property instrument, prohibiting the use of the land for specific commercial activities, were enforceable against a later purchaser. The initial covenant imposed restrictions related to the sale of liquor, certain businesses, and the establishment of specific types of commercial operations, explicitly benefitting neighboring parcels owned by the original covenantor. The court reasoned that since the restrictive covenant was clearly set forth in the chain of title, the subsequent purchaser was deemed to have constructive notice, establishing that the restriction "ran with the land" and was enforceable as a negative easement against the current owner despite the lack of specific, formal reciprocal benefit language applicable to all lots in the development, thus upholding the injunction sought by the beneficiaries of the covenant.
Regeste Legislator
Généré par l'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Enforceability of Restrictive Covenants Against Subsequent Purchaser: The initial covenant imposed restrictions related to the sale of liquor, certain businesses, and the establishment of specific types of commercial operations, explicitly benefitting neighboring parcels owned by the original covenantor. The court reasoned that since the restrictive covenant was clearly set forth in the chain of title, the subsequent purchaser was deemed to have constructive notice, establishing that the restriction "ran with the land" and was enforceable as a negative easement against the current owner despite the lack of specific, formal reciprocal benefit language applicable to all lots in the development, thus upholding the injunction sought by the beneficiaries of the covenant.
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IAApplied to regulate the costs of the appeal proceedings.
Texte complet
!"#$!"%%& !'((!"%%&
) *)+ + ,+ )+ ,*
&- ./ 0 $ "%%&
1 2222222222
) 3 )+ * * + !! + +,- " # $ "%&' ( ) *
/')0/
+ 4*
"! ( + 12222222222 -".$3 44++-5+,6+ 7+/ # 89 +: # ; <+= + 6 + 6 ,6+ 6;+6 6#+" >?+ "..0!
'! '@, '%%@ ; -4+ # ?+ 5+6- + 6;+6 6 A + ;+4 , ;B < +- 6 '0 C '%%' , 6 A+ 6 +D 6 6 #+ ?+ D +D # -+ A 6 - + < - +!
@! 6,6 6 + ; - + D#+A- '0 >+ '%%@ ? + - ;-?-, , # , + # 8 ? + 6 += A;+;=++ 6;+6 6 +!-=, 6- - #? + 4+ -, + # 86< = +5 <+ E+?+ F - #+ A + A;+ ?+ 6->5 +6 ,<< + G AA -! , , 6;-?-, 4,,?+ - -# - !
$! + ; -4+ # ?+ 5+ #+6 + A;+?+ 6 - 3 C '%%@5< = + # # 5 +# - 6; A+6 +D66#+F -6 ,=+!
&! + 60 < '%%@ + 4-6;+ ?+ # - , +4A6- + 6;+6 - + 6+? 6 A;;- + # , 6 -+ # ?6-A !
H! '' ?,< '%%$ ; -+?+ -+5 6 6-++ 4 , > 6 46# 6 F =;+6 6'0 C '%%'!
0! 6-++ 6 . 6-,< '%%$ + +6- - A -, + - + 6+? 68 A; -A+ + #?+6 /,6+ 6 6-+ + < - + -# - ? + # - # + + D# +,- # ?+ # , > +# 6! ++ +6- -A ; - ?+ 4 ,- 6,6 6 +6- + 4 6; , +8 !
3! + 6'%6-,< '%%$ ; -4 ,- ## + + 5 6-++ D#+A A;+ ;?+ + 6 6 + 6 # + F = 6 ;+6 ? # A; + + 5 > 6 > I ,#J! ?+ > +# 6 + - # + ;- + # ##+< 5 ! # -+- A 4 + 6 -# + 6 6 -;- + -?-5'.%4 !
.! 6-++ ## + + 6 "' >?+ '%%& + 4+ ,- 4 6; , +8 # =, + - + ! + <+6++
)'.$)'%%& /@)0/ 4+ ? + A6- + 6;+6 - + + 6+?6, E+;- + ## +<6;## # ?6+6+ - -+ ;-?-, ?# , +# ? !
"%! # - & 4-? + '%%& ; - 6-++ +,#++ , 5 + 5# +F =64 +6 + , 6 6 -! # 6 =, 6-? ##- # --6,, + # -+- A # 8;B -6 ,= F6#+6+=?+D +D +?+ D + 6< F, 6 A+6 +D6;?+ 6D 4 + +,++,8 !;- + 6@% C '%%'FK ,-6+/6 + A+ ?+ # -6-5 -# + # + + # +6< 666 -+ G+A! # + +,- A ; 6+? ;?+ # 6 -AA 5;- <+, 64+ !
""! -# 6 '' 4-? + '%%& ;+ +,- > 6 4 6 , +46->5+? A-! ?-# #A ;?+ ## -# -++ # A ++;?+ 6,6-A"$, +# 8 46; 6"0 < '%%@6-++ 4 ,! ++ +6- - A +?+ #4+ ? + 66-+ + < 6- 6 6 A;+- + > 6;F+4 64+ !
"'! "., '%%& # + -6 +
"@! ;+ +,-4+ 6,B,66#+A63? +'%%&!
+ ,*
"! +=? + ; =+ + >6+++ 7:- -, 6+4+- + + - 68 " C '%%@ +< 6 + ,# -6&>= 6 # -+6 ?+/# -+6 &##- "H>= 7 !" ! &H :!
*+ 5; + 6;- + 6"H>= # +<4-6- '0>?+ '%%$7 L"@%"%H: 6 +=? +6 # - "@4-? + 6+# + + + + = # , +< 6 + 6 +-= 5 + >= + + 6 ; 6 ;- + 6 ?D>= !
'! 4 ,-, 5 M ! &H ! " ! F! $ +< 6 + N + +A6 + # -?5; !&H 6 +4-6- # +=-- 66 + 6 +6H < '%%%7 :A+ +?5 +4-6- ; /,6+6"3, "..$7 (:!
)'.$)'%%& /$)0/ * ,#- # >= 66;#8 ++- <+!
@! > -66-+ 4 ,# + # + ?<7 !&H :!
$! * # # ,+ + A + 6 ? + + ;+ +,- - + ; ? 6 6 6 6-++ 4 ,!
? 6; !$.!" ; 6 + 6 # - + 6-++ A+ # 6# + - +> + +,# ?A ;+ - -; #6; 6! 6-++ 6 +? +6+A ? +6 B , +?- +4 # +8 , 6 + D6,66# +! +4+ + + -=+8 6; 6-++ 6 + N # ->6+ # ;+ - -7!':! # + - +> + A+ #?+- 5 ; ! $. ! " + # B # -6- # -6 +,#+4+- 4 ,-, 5 ; ! &" ! " ! ;! ' 6 6+# + + # -? + A ;+ - -# 4 +D+= A;6-++ + 6!
# + +,# 6; !$.!" A , -?-! +,+ 5 + 5 AA + 6 4 7+ 1 * */1 ,, '%%@ !$. F!3:!
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
-=+ ;# #6- ,+-6 +6A6-+6-++ 4 , # B D+=- ##+ + 6 ; ! &" ! " ! 6 ?D# -# + A +4-6- ?+ # # -64+D 6-+6; 7LL "..$ .'3:! L+, -=+ #6 - 5 ;+ 6 + 6;6-++4 , , + A;6-+6;?+ - # 6+
)'.$)'%%& /&)0/ 5# +A > +# 6, +8 7LL"...$'&.:! ?+ 68 6 6- ,+ 6-+ 4 + 6 + 6 ! * > +# 6 6##+ + 6;+ +4-6- ; 6,6+ 6;+6 6"@>+".""7 ( : +,+ 6 ,##- + 6;?+ -# 8 +4+ + 66-++ 4 ,! 4 + + ; - # - - # ,6 + # 4+ 6-+ +6- <, # !* 6- ,+ # 6 -66-+ + 8 +? 9;+6+ + 66 + 6;D+= 6-++ 4 ,O +6 , +8 # ;+ - - # +?, # - + # ,6 + # 4+ O ,#D+ -66 ,+ # ++ A + 6? + + # -66-++ +<O ,# , 6; + A + 6 ? + + + + , +?- 6-++ 4 , 71 * #!+ ! !&" F!"@:!
; D+=- 6-++ 4 , +K , + 6,+ # 8 ? + - - +4 ,- # ;+ +,- # + 6 0 < '%%@ 6 6 +8 6 4 6 # + ! ?+ 4 + 6 ? A ;+ +,- ; #+6+A-6 ,,+ + A; -?+ 6 + 6;D+= 6-++ 4 ,! #6 4 , +?- ; # # ++8 , ,#D 6, EA + # 5? + +4+ 6;? + , 6 A+ 6 +D 6 #+ ?+ D +D + +6 ! ?+ -=, 6# 6 +6- + A ; # F ,, 6 + ;- + # # # - - # ,6 + # 4+ ! ,# 6 + +<6- 6 ;?+ A; 6-+ 6;D, 6 -4D+ 6; - ; 44+ + B 6-#-!
-A + G +6 +6- A < ;<6;6-++ 4 , 46;+ +,-60 < '%%@A+4 6F >=- -# 8? + - - ,,+A- ! 6- A+/+;- + #F<++ -5D+= 6-++ 4 , #-6-+6;!
&! 4 + # ++# =-- 6 6 + 6 + ;6,++ + # +6- 6-++ 4 ,, #- 4 6 F >=- A + ->6+++ ; ## -A 4 6 5 6+ + A; + 6 - A +4+ + ?B +,# < 7 L "'H '$ +6! $< "'' @H. +6! @:! # ++# > 6;F+4 ,, -# ; !&@!' !
# B # -6-5 +6- + 6,6 6; 44+!;G++# 6+,+ ,# /656A +6- + D71 * #! + ! ! &@ F! 'H:! 4 + ; ; # 6 # -6 5 +6- + A66-++ 6-#66+< ## -+ + !;G44 #6 + 5 +6- + 71 * #!+ ! !&@F!'':! + +
)'.$)'%%& /H)0/ ; ; #, +8 6,66 +6- + 6-++ G +? # # B -! # + B +A, ;+ - + -, +8 ?+ 4-# + +6- + 71 * #!+ ! ! &@F!'3:!
- 6A+# -86A ; #6 + 6 , 6-++ 6 / -, +8 6;+ +,-6? ; + -6 !
H! ?6A+# -86 > -!
)'.$)'%%& /0)0/
, *4 *)+ + ,+ )+ ,*
5.161 7 811 1 9 :;" ,<
61
"! - ?<O
61
'! > O
@! + A# -6 = + O
$! 4 , # + 6 A; #? 4 , # - B 6 6-+ 6 @% > 68 +4+ + # #+ ,,6- 6 - +< 4-6- 6 *FP+K F 4A+ H H%%$ + D,#+ ! 6-+ # B # =-! ,-, + 6 + 9 : +6+A D , A6-++ 6-+ < + + #66-++ A-O <: D# # A , +4 + +, # ? + 6,6 6-++ O : # += 6 # - ! *+ ,-, + + # + --, -,- - : <: : +/6 +<4-6- 6 # # , +8 A;+ 6? 6- + ?<!,-, + 6 , + , G 6 # ? A+ > + ++ A 6-++ A- ;? ## 6 A- -D#-6+- 7 !"@' "%H "%3:!
= 44+8 9 -+6 9 QR (G (
#+ 4 ,6# - B +4+-D# +++A;5;44+4-6- 6 -#<+A# = 44
)'.$)'%%&