Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/355/2003 • CJ GE ATAS/355/2003 Généré par l'IA

Challenge to Natural Resource Revenue Distribution Formula Upheld

Numéro de cause ATAS/355/2003
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case involves a challenge to the validity of an assessment regarding the distribution of funds derived from a natural resource extraction agreement, where the challenging party alleged that the prescribed formula resulted in an unfair distribution of revenues. The court reasoned that the agreement explicitly outlined the method for calculating and distributing the proceeds, and this method was clear, unambiguous, and was followed by the relevant authorities; thus, the court found no legal basis to overturn the established distribution formula or the resulting assessment, affirming the original calculation.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Challenge to Natural Resource Revenue Distribution Formula Upheld: The court reasoned that the agreement explicitly outlined the method for calculating and distributing the proceeds, and this method was clear, unambiguous, and was followed by the relevant authorities; thus, the court found no legal basis to overturn the established distribution formula or the resulting assessment, affirming the original calculation.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
base de calcul bénéfice ressources naturelles fixation du revenu sans invalidité créance contestée degré de la preuve

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
This provision is cited in the dispositive to order the appellant to pay the judicial costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/1410/2002
Mineral Royalty Accounting Dispute
A/2574/2006
Challenge to Calculation of Amounts Owed Affirmed
A/2846/2007
Property Proceeds Distribution Dispute
A/1363/2006
Royalty Calculation Dispute Over Natural Gas Proceeds
A/3372/2005
Royalty Distribution Contract Interpretation Dispute

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive to order the appellant to pay the judicial costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

         

    #$%&'#())*#)(# #*&&#())*

+

       

" ' ,-  ())*

(.- /- 





0- 12222222222 





   1   30  !" #$%&'( %)*



              !"   " 

   +,-.+ 

 4 



/3 #") 4444444444 5%+6'  7  6**  ")" "8%")%*"9:);""2<*(%, 23

,3 ")"**=*6"*%%",), 2!)%<>" "*%+"!%2<*(%, /,<*(%, 2!8(%6%* ">86(%?)%$**<%"8)%<"%$*%3

23 %",.), 2!"*6**)%!@6%> )) (% %(%  <)% & 8* " );)  " ))%%/$, /2 =%, ,!%(%"2)%" ;*)**6%">%A="*"%"66";3  6*@)!('!""/B$, ,3

3  "*%% " /. =% , 2!  CC        C    D#  5%+6' %7=*66%%3 $! % '(>**%*!""*%+"!"/ )%,0!, =!   )6% " 6  "%% *; %( &  6*%" " %%3 C8;% "  %$*% 6 " % " <)%!   $**<%%6"8<)%"6""A)%)%?  " (% ))  % 8@%;! )% %>) " "A )% @)3

03 "//E, 2!@6%>>8&<%"; *)**6%)6%6'"%**F4444444444C !)%& )%+)6"//B$, 2"<G&6(%*"%;!"8)%+ )6!66";3 6*@)/B$H6"% 6%'I%(3

.3  " " 0 6)$ , 2!  %  )%  %$ " *  "%))%3

B3  %$  6*"* & 8"%% " 6%  " " 1 "*)$ , 23 ;*! %%"%>*6<%>=*"/B$ , , (% ** * &   " 8@)  >   (% G  * & 8% " +%3   %"%>*  6 6(% 6"  %"*%6*%" "/$/B$% 66%%" =%6" " %$ <*"* "  % 5%+6' J 7  " "%%( " C*% "8  & 8*)% 5%+6' C 73  **;"*&=;&8%"8"%"*%$**%';3 

-/01-, 2- ,-  +2-.+ 



   /3 =*""*%<)*;@!($530.. " % <*"*   6% ;** " "% "  % " . $ ,  5 +CK2 3/713,"%;(%)%'"9:);5C,, 73

,3  % ;(%  8;%% ="%%% 5H  , 07  ** )"%<%*   %%*!"'/E, 2! %$"%! % %>! ))   % %( &  % <*"*  8+9:); $%;%  8%")%*   "8%($%%* 5%+6'  7 %%>8&%)%'"9:);5<3%0.73)6* " %$"*%%*$%6=;""86'3

23 @ ) " 83 K 3 /  ! 8*  "% & 8%")%* 9:); 6 !))!>8%)6%"%%%(&6*%""%% >8%%%$**5373

 "%% " %%  )6% > 8*  %* & % " %* L""A)%)%M53/23/ 73 86%%!>%8 6*3

6"!%$**""%%%(&6*%""%%6 >%L"%)%""*%+"5313276"6""A)%! 8*%66%&66"(%!6!86)6%"%% %(&6*%""%%M53/3/ 7!6%%%"8 <)%%!(%!6<%)6<%5373

 66%% "  =%6"! 8 % )6 6   "  6*%" *%&%$*%!")6*&8)*%%"8(%""%6:)!" =%*"!>%8""%%!%%>"="8@)5<3 J /,/ 22.H?"  "/3 ,3 /N -, ,-, /",,3 ,3 /N -/0-, /73



-/01-, 2- ,-  +-.+ 

 86'  6 " "A )% " <)%!  *! % < "'  % )6  ) " /B $ , /! = " 8@)! )% *;) " >%A="6*6%"66";&)%+)6!"//.$!%K = 5/.O ,73     " /, )%  1 = >%  ** * &  <)%!">"%?%$**"8$%;%%*&"*" %%3

 %$*>>8<<%""*%%*6 " )(% )%<3  <<! %  %@ >  =%6" <*"* %)6%  *! ))6*" %! )%<"8@%"866"(%& )%+)6 6"  6*%" " ;  "8@)3  %!  >%  ** 9*6 %$<*"*"!"<<%%$)%"%> P  * (% 6% " *" & )%+)6  (%* *;) & )%+)6! 6%%)6*"*"6"%(%*%(&)66% '3  J =;*>86%$"%))"%>8@)% *6*)%()"%%"6*%""%%"8*""  "*%+"!  >8  >8 "%%  %  "%%( 66%>* 6 8")%%%6(%?%(%38;%"8 J //,63,2B!>% @6%>))>%%O

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

-/01-, 2- ,-  +0-.+ 

6%+""*%+""R3132 5(%*;)"R? !6*%*!>%* I(%*&)66%>%(%** %! 6 % " "%(! " 99  %(%* %( & 6% )673 %% "! "  ) P  "%%( ")%%%( 6*%* *$% " ) >%   6 <) @ "%6%% *;! % RI  6 % "  66%>5 J//,B2!///,01%"3,*<*73M3  >%6*'"!")%!"*%%"*! "%(I*& %6"%")%*"&3

5 5 5



-/01-, 2- ,-  +.-.+ 

  0 4        

"

  6-

/3 *($3



" 6

,3 8")3

23 *>!"*%%"(%"%& %6("*%%"%"*3

3 %>6*";%3

03 <)  6% "  >R 6( <)    6* ? "  "*% " 2  = "'  %<%% 6 6% ))"* "*  %$ <*"* " ! C9T%A9<>% .! .    !  % @)6%3  "*%  6 ? 6;*3  )*)% "% O 7 %"%> @) >R "*%%   "*% $%  %  6 "  "*%%>*H$7@66>)%<%%)6(%")" "*%%H76%;"6*3C%)*)%  % 6  % **) *)**   7 $7  7 %+"!  %$<*"*"66)%'>R% "("*%($3)*)%")%)I " 6(! >%  =%! %% >  "*%% >*  R(66 " >**@6*"%*53/2,!/ ./ K73 

;<<%O 6*%"O  %% $$%



6%<)"6*?%<%*@6%!&R<<%<*"*" %C*%"R &R )%6;<<



-/01-, 2- ,-