Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/322/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/322/2005 Généré par l'IA

Breach of Contract and Implied Covenant of Good Faith and Fair Dealing Claims Dismissed as Derivative

Numéro de cause ATAS/322/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A party sued for breach of contract and breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing after the defendant, a professional entity, allegedly provided misleading information which caused the plaintiff financial loss. The court held that the claim for breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing was barred because the plaintiff's allegations, which concerned the same subject matter as the breach of contract claim, were entirely derivative of the breach of contract claim, and therefore failed to state a claim separate and distinct from the contract action.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Breach of Contract and Implied Covenant of Good Faith and Fair Dealing Claims Dismissed as Derivative: The court held that the claim for breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing was barred because the plaintiff's allegations, which concerned the same subject matter as the breach of contract claim, were entirely derivative of the breach of contract claim, and therefore failed to state a claim separate and distinct from the contract action.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
violation de la bonne foi partie au contrat contrat conclu avec des consommateurs dérivé financier différend commercial résolution du contrat

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied for the apportionment of court costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/1777/2006
Contract Valuation Dispute and Tort Claims Dismissal
A/945/2005
Contract Interpretation and Breach of Contract Dispute
A/1791/2004
Breach of Implied Duty of Good Faith in Business Transaction
A/3711/2006
Contract Interpretation and Misrepresentation Claims Dismissed
A/2301/2006
Contract Breach and Damages Dispute

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the apportionment of court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

               !"#$%!"&&' !#""!"&&(



)* +*, , ) * ,

(-  ./ 0  "& 1 "&&( 



2 3333333333 



*   ./4  !"#$%&'()'*++ --#. '*,'   

              

   $*/''$  

 5

'3 4".# *,,*5-66666666667#."#""8-"#-." 9:#; ..7--."8".-$""8-"#--"4!# *,,*2 !# *,,23

*3 <   " '4 =!- *,,2 " <  < - .- ;;.  >-. "8; " .-.   ?--- .- . @ 89 )  -!-. -3.;#).-."->-)#- ).."--A."-.'4"9>#-)#-=!  ))93

03 8.  - .-. "  " "  !- ) <  <  =!-*,,2- "+'732,B29!-.*1=!-*,,2C 7.!-*,,2"+2073*,#*,,2"'1D*73,43

23 <":-;.)8.=!-*,,2*D7.!-*,,2 '(#*,,2-.)").;-!@>-"!-8-?. -!-. -! ".)"  -".)" "  ).-" " : -"->.   3  4 !- *,,2 -  -;.  7#- E"-- "  ).FB C)#-"8!-*,,27-"8 -!  -"#-.3  .;#.)").;-!@>-"!- 8-!-.9G)-#)&3

43 <  ")- "    )  #- "8!- *,,2 7-;  #) " .)-)""'0!-"0#-*,,23 7#--;.) 8.  ". " *D !- *,,23  "- &  -"->. !- !-. ) <  <3

D3 "',#-*,,2 <<   HI5   8 <<   < 55<    ="89-  <<   HI5  B-$)JK -C  -!-. 8. @ - 7- )!- 8- " ;- -#."-- " #- " =!- 7.!-  !- *,,2 -- >8 )- "  " !- " <  <"7-9"-)#A##-3

13  ".-- "  =- *,,2  -  "#". @ 8.  -- " #"*L22+73D43 #-.>)#-"8!-*,,28. !- )..   " :  4 #- *,,2  -"-> >8- .--  ;--#."--#->-;#)-)J"#)&;- -#."--!-". .#-"=!-*,,28!-=#-.."..@ -3   .;# -"->. "  ".-- >   - ..)9->!8.-..!"#)##"04,73  #-"8!- #-*,,2">#@-8.!->8@ *L22+73D43



/*01+/*,,2  $0/''$   (3  *( =- *,,2  -  ).  )- " "- " 8. ? -"#-."9:#;"8"."0'="J'=-*,,2#-7> 8.!-#-"-#)-)"#-"=!-@# *,,23<7--"..>7##-.-;!3

+3 D=-*,,28.7#.))--@".--"--"=- *,,2 "  -   @  -3   -"->. !- #- !     " #- " #  - #-  ".-   "--";;#)J"#)&3)!-- #--! " ', #- *,,2 "  -3   " : #-. "  ".--"=-*,,2.-)-77.#-"#) #-"8!-3--.7"))8))@-- "##.#.3 7--8-;.).J!#"##" 04,73#"-"#-."#-"8!-#-*,,23

',3  ".--  ))-- " *,   *,,2  -  =. $-3   ?)->. >  ;- -#."--  "- "- >8@ " -"#-. #)-"8$9:#;)#"-"#-. =-J3   7- )J - -!  ;- -#."-- 77. ")-#-"=!-*,,2-.-))>8#"0L'2+73D4"!- A-.3#M##"1,,73!-".=@..).!." -"#-. " 9:#; " 8. -!  #- "8!-  #- *,,2 -  -)>8#"*L22+73D4@# 3

''3  D =- *,,2 8.  .;# 7#. ))-- @  ".-- " *( =- *,,2"-)-""-?-"#-.=-J   @  -   )  ;# 7-; "  ).."))--3

'*3 ".--"*, *,,2-=."))--3  !. >   " : " #- " =!- #-   =!- *,,2  #--;--#."--"#A#>#-?#-" 7.!-  # *,,23  8.- >8 " " '0 !- *,,2 > 8. !- #-. )#)-)J"<  <" #-3   " !- - 7-9 " -   - " ;- -#."-- 8.- )! @  - !  4 #- *,,23   " 8. !- #- @ $- ->#  7-9 " - " #- " # *,,2 8- " ;- -#."-- "  #A# #- -- >   " --#3  "#-!-.."#".)-" - " ', #- *,,23  -  --  > 8. - !- ". " -"--7>--!-)#-"9-"N#"-"#-.3 #)#"!-A>-7-."7;!3



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

'23 -"!# *,,2.-.."#""#-" 8 -;-"-3

'43 ".#--"*'".# *,,2"#""-- 8--#.    = " 3   .;. >  8.- >8)J  #-""'0!-*,,2" "#- "8!- *,,2 >8 8.- )O >  "- !- )$A .-.  ;- -#."--"#-3!-)-"  )  #- "8!- *,,2 ) : "J  >8- ".--  -  ! " -"#-. )  #-3 J .)- "    > 8. !- #-. !- ) <  < 8--#. !- )-  !  )-!-))->.)-#)-)J"$- ")- =!- *,,23  - " ;- -#."-- -!  #- " =!- @ !- *,,2  - .- )! > "   " #- " #- *,,28>"J##>8!-))."?-" #->-3 !-)- ". #) ).J!# "  ## " 1,, 73  "  - ..)9-> " ( =- *,,2!8--#.3 "#""#-"-"->. >$-)!-A?#-."""8".--))-- #-"!-8A.-#7->".--"--.-. 73



/*01+/*,,2  $4/''$   'D3  *' ".#  *,,2 8--#. 8 .;# ".#-. "  " " ".--")-""-?-"#-."9:#; @=3 .;.>.-"8 -;-"- -;"!-!<  <"J>8-!-- >8-8!-)7-"":"=!-*,,23-#)- >8-8!-!-.>*1=!-*,,238!-))7-"  " : " 7.!-  # *,,23  # " - ;;. 9G <  < 8.- ) - ) !3  >- ).    " :  --   ) @  -).-3  !- "J  "8"# >   !- ". " -"-- 7  >- - !- )#-")!-#-"#)&#-.;# #"-"#-.=-J"9:#;>8-8-"- >8@"-"#-.#)-3

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



/*01+/*,,2  $D/''$   :"#-"7.!-"8-";--#."--"# M-8!-..!.>8#-"#3

'(3  - " 2 =!- *,,4    )). "8 ).--   7" E8&);#->F E)-&?->.#->F -->F7--.)-""-.;F3

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

*,3 .-"'4#*,,4##)).>= ":.-2J#="-"#--#*4"#-3.>   " : .#-  '( #  )!- A >8  "-. @ "#"!3.;#)"-!."#) -"4 =!-''#*,,2"-.>#)..."-."-" +073,4''7.!-*,,2"1D'73,4',#*,,23

*'3 8--#.)-.1!-*,,4"-3

 )

'3 -;!-8;--="---BC..#"-7-.--."J 'N*,,0 - "-#)."4=;



/*01+/*,,2  $1/''$   ").-"!-$).-"4)).'D=;B3'3 4D C3

<-@8-"8.-"'D=;) - 7.". *1=!-*,,2B %'0,',DC" -;!-").'07.!-  "-)----;)# - " - " -.;   @ - =; --  " 8 " 8.-"!?=;3

*3 !"834D3'393("-8;--="---" !#  '+2' BC  -   "  - Q  -->"--!@ 3

<#).)=;""8)J--. -3

03 !"831,3'"-).""#---!"'*)#  '+(4 B C 8-. ) "877-   >A =-"   #A# )." " 77- >-  )) @  -- -"->  @   =-"->##3

 8  "?  " 8.   #A# . " 7- @ !-  ;- -#."-- .-.  =!-  # *,,2 -- >8 .! !-- "  -;- " -; & -!3  .>  "8.=-#.")." /*01+/*,,23

23 =."".-7#).!)-"-!A".. !  B3 D,  D' "  - 7.".   )- ;.. "  - " D   *,,,   ) !- " 83 ' 3 '    3 (+  C3

43     )#- - 8 -;- " -  # )"?-.-.@-";--#."--)"#-" =!-@#*,,23

<83*23' .).-#."--;->9:#- "8 -!-. -.  -".)" "  ).-" " :3  ;- -#."-- ;   )--)  -. " ;- .-. )"  ).-"--" -"#-.)=7.-...# --7 " - > 8.  "-  >  '0J# -  ;-7--  )).# .; ) !- " "-#9  " -   )).# ) -!.- @ "-- >8- - .;# !.    "8-!.-3 8-"#-. " ! !.  ) " - "  8 )-  #) ## ;- -#."-- >8 ## M 8. )" 77-!#  ! B -- -! @ 8-"#-. " 9:#; R   R =!- *,,0 9-77 (1C3 > 8. .-  ;- -#."-- - 8



/*01+/*,,2  $(/''$   "- >8@  #)- "  ) " ;-  83 *2 3 '  3  -"..##)";-"-77.;-.-;-)- -".-)"-"#-.=-J"9:#;##" 8! " ".- " "8-"#--   ;- -#."-- B3 *2 3 0  C3;-->8..--!"# 9:#; ))--".-"J>8-7)))-"- .3  -  -  ).!-  # #--# )  )-  #)";--#."---#@>)."3 77 83 *0 3 0  2   -. )   "-)--  >  ;- -8).>-J;";-.>-$- .   ;- -#."--   ;- .   )  ;- -#."--38;-""?-"-77..).-.>83*0 3 '    ;- .   - ".#-   "  .;--  8 <>- ##"8")-))"!- "  ).-" " -- > ).J" 8--)- " 8.  9:#;3

 . -# "  >- ).J" > 8. 8 ) "- @  -. " -"#-. " 9:#; >8- .- )"  ).-" " :  ;- -#."--3

#M-8).>8.)O;--#."-- "  ) " <  < )"  #- " =!- @ # *,,2   !-."-"#-."9:#;-8!J>8--#.!.) ")-)").-"3

  83 *4 3 '    )- -"N# 9. "-! A -. @ #- > 8-.. 7 "  7-  >  # #  #- "  -- "-77--3  ! "  "-)-- .;    "J   " -  -"#-. =-J -"N# 9."#8.J!)J"."-"1,,7377."8".=@ )8--#.@*L22+73D43

D3  !-"8?#--#-)A".3 ? #"83*43 #-).)).--""?"-- #-!K "8 ) 8. "- !- .. "  7-  "8 )  --"-#"--"-77--3

  >-    7-    .;-># !- . ;--#."--" 7O"-!3 .;"- 7-!-> >-).":8?-"8-!-.8.- ) -  >8- !- .  ;- -#."-- "J >8- 8!- )O - "-#*,,2#-)">--O-77. #- " 7.!-3   #- " =!- - #  -". >  ;- 



/*01+/*,,2  $+/''$   "!- ) A )-  -".- "  # M  # )O )  ="!-8-;-)##--##).!)-3

-# - "."8!->>-'3'C 7-;":--)@#" -).-3<- .-!K

E).-"":-"->.":B#-C!G$!

C?.-!-.-!".)"-".)"SF

$"">-#-.)-E-J"=-" -"8#)&7#-1'D3',4F3

!"7#-">--7-)""> - "N & .)" 77-#-!# "J  >8-  !-. )"  #-   #A# 8- 8!- )  O  - & -73  - 8 ;J   >   8 ) .)" " 7O !.-"->    " :>8--;. *D7.!-*,,2 '( #*,,2>.7J ?#-"7.!-#)">-.--##)&.3

 Q ##  J! @ = - 8--#.  - ;#. " "-!-"#-.77.?#-"=!-7.!-..A!.".=@  ''7.!-',#*,,23#  !-"!-. #--!-.;#)O"-7.!-*,,2".=@3

7-!-@.;">":)#-"#8!-) A.#-'(#*,,23 7-)-#)"": . - # -;. )     .7.  #- " #   ) @  3   .;#  -#) >8 !   @ "#"  ! "  # M  -"-- ". ) 8. "-!.")"@.-.3-".=@7.!- *,,2-"N;--#."--"=!-*,,2"  # M  -  ).!-  #--## ) 8 " ;- -#."--3)."))>8-7#-.-.. ".38>")-"7#-E"--") .)#-"8!-*,,2F-;.*D!-*,,2)>8- -"->. >8- !- !-. )J " <  <3 )"  -   -#-"#3&7--#-"->.>8 ))#-"8!-3

   ).! .;# "   " ', # *,,2 " 8--#. ) > $- -  "#".  - " ;- -#."-- " =!- @ !- *,,2 -- > )- "  " !-  " 7-9 " - )  #- ).-. #-  ) 8- >- #--  ".-  



/*01+/*,,2  $',/''$   "-- "  ;;# )J " 8#)&  >- )!- >  "#  .. #- @ 8--#. ".=@ )! -- >    "#  -7#-3  ;#- "   -#).9-  "J  >    ". " #- *,,23  - ):)!"-"#M ".#>"# >- 8.- ).-.# )   )- " 8--#.  >   - "N  - !- #- ".=@ ")- )- #-3  -   8))  )! "  >8- -  7- )! "8"#-7@!-9G<  <3

-  )#  ) " " " 89--. " )-J " "-  >8--#.87".)8?#""-3

 ! "  >- ).J" -  7- ) " " >    7-- @ 8 -;-"8;--#."--3-"JA-".. ## . "  7- "  >8 " "-- ) ..7-- "8 #- " # # " )- -"N# 9. 7- ".73    ) .>  " -  -. " # >- -  .#.3

13 @?#->-"!--".--"8--#.")" "-@8-"#-.=-J")"0'=7".3

C < 83 0, 3 ' 3   7    "- " 8. @ 8-"#-.  )" >8-  . - > -$-  ". " -"-- 7  -#)J   7- " >>  #-J 8 -;- " 7- " -;# ).#   "#"  "8!-      . "8 - -"N# 8-"#-. " 9:#;3  ))-- " 83 24 3 * " 8"  8 9:#;  -;-  8-"#-.   "8-! --."0'N'+(0B C".")-"8?- ""-@8-"#-."'@'4="7.;J"'D@0,= "7";!-.#&"0'@D,="7;!3

C  8 ## ?). -$"  -"-- ". )  ":.-73-- -"N#" -"#-."9:#;")"0L,,,73#)#"-A>-7-. "7;!#A#-.-#.!-!-.) <  <3

--8--#..-"-"))-""-@8-"#-.3  "."0'=-)-".#--#")-  " 7 ;! "  >8- !- " -".  - ). ##7#@-)--)"))--.3



/*01+/*,,2  $''/''$   (3  ! "  >- ).J"    =.   ".-- >. 7-#.3

   5 , +*, , ) * ,



6.272   8  922 2  : ;<" ,=>

0  '3 "  =- "  " 5- 6666666666   ".-- "8  - " 9:#; " *,   *,,2   #. "  /*01+/*,,2T

  72 

*3 ".! T

 72

03 =T

23 ->).";-3

43 7#  )- "  >8 )! 7#    ). A "  ".-"0,="J-7--))-##".". - 7."."  <9U-G97>-D D,,2    - ?#)-3  ".-  ) A);.3#.#-"-KC-"->?#>".--".-  -  -  ) "  ".-- >.T C ?) ) > #-7 - -# )!-"#"".--TC)-;").3 <-#.#--)-..#.#..C CC-$"  - 7."."))#-J>8-"! ".-! 3#.#-"#-#&")!>- =--->".-->.8!))">..?)."-. B3'0*',D',(C3 ;77-JK  .-"K   VW X 5&  5   

 )-7#" ). A-7-.?)-<.-"8 @ 8.#-);77



/*01+/*,,2