Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/317/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/317/2005 Généré par l'IA

Contractual Unconscionability and Limitation of Liability

Numéro de cause ATAS/317/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A dispute arose regarding the enforceability of certain provisions within a contract, specifically challenging the validity of various clauses by alleging that they were either unconscionable or violated public policy, focusing on limitations on remedies and liability waivers. The court reasoned that while some contractual provisions appeared commercially reasonable under the circumstances present at the time of contracting, others, particularly those severely limiting remedies for a party's breach or those seeking to waive liability for gross negligence, were unenforceable because they were both procedurally and substantively unconscionable, violating a fundamental commitment to fairness in contractual dealings.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Unconscionability and Limitation of Liability: The court reasoned that while some contractual provisions appeared commercially reasonable under the circumstances present at the time of contracting, others, particularly those severely limiting remedies for a party's breach or those seeking to waive liability for gross negligence, were unenforceable because they were both procedurally and substantively unconscionable, violating a fundamental commitment to fairness in contractual dealings.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
responsabilité contractuelle validité du contrat négligence grave clause compromissoire contrat bilatéral imparfait notion de marché public

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
This article governs the allocation of judicial costs, which is explicitly ordered in the dispositive section (order 2).
Généré par l'IA
A/2637/2004
Contractual Limitation of Liability Enforceability
A/4452/2006
Contractual Limitation of Liability Enforcement
A/3421/2007
Contractual Limitation of Liability Enforcement
A/2410/2006
Contract Enforceability and Unconscionability Dispute
C/29701/2002
Contractual Limitation of Liability Enforcement

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This article governs the allocation of judicial costs, which is explicitly ordered in the dispositive section (order 2).

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

               $%&'($&($)  $'%*$+&&,



- .- ! /  -! /!

+0  12   %3 4 +&&, 



 5555555555  

 65555555555  & 

 !"#$%&'"&! !())))))))))* +,-



& 

! ! / 7/  !/  /+  6! & " ./012345



                 ! "#

   %781%  

 -  )

  &! ! ()))))))))) *  %93  &! !-  ! !    '  " &66 "  & " 34  :;<= 4 &66 >   &9 &+ #&' &+  "!4&996 +  4  " 6 !   &' "  "&6 " #,&6    " #&' & "# 9?  ..+  ,&6 &    96  " 9&?  9 9 & " "  9  99&  2# 4 !"!9&@!9&! !?

 "3 :;<=+ A& B))))))))))   ! ! "6  %4%9!" +   A& )))))))))) "6  %! + & "$ 4 '  & 4 2 "$?  "3 :;;=+ A& B))))))))))    "4 "6  %9!"    A& )))))))))) " + !'6  4 ' & 42"$?

  &! !  ! ! ,,! "3  ! & 93 "          *    A *  %93  - 9& & 9& !?

, "&! !! !9&&!9C'6 " >"963    :7 "!6> 7DD:?     9&"  "  ,  9&  6&  "71E:7;,51D?#" "7D&46>7DD7#!  "&& & ! !9>!+ +F:C47DDF+G ""!, ">93 , "6&  "!?

 9 "!& " ! " 7F & &> 7DDF+    !6!  !9 & " &"&66'2AB))))))))))+))))))))))  ))))))))))+9& &  & 9  *8 8 8 + "# 9 +   9&  &  & H 69@!+& 1E;0D,5D0+"# 9 ?

 A& B))))))))))  ,  &99& &  "  " 71 &46> 7DDF+ 9 E 6!""AA +A& )))))))))), &99& &"  "70&46> A&))))))))))" "7<&46>5

9"!&&99& &":047DD1+"6#&99& &" A& ))))))))))+  + #'  " A& ))))))))))+  "!! #&99& &4>&6/6#9  "4?

#C !&99& &"AB)))))))))) ))))))))))?

99!9!":167DD1+AB)))))))))) ))))))))))&  && "!&?



  %F81%     &  , $ &  & *% % %  &  ! !   &   8:DFI8D1  8:DF;8D1+ $ ,$&  & H& 8:DF187DD1  8:DF=8D1?

"!9&":0C7DD1+& C "&?

 9 &"& " 7: C 7DD1+  >  C&    * &   8:DFI8D1?

 9 /  "  " I C  7DD1  >  C&    H &   8:DF18D1+   9"   C#2 "&  & " #,, 8:DFI8D1?

9/ "77,!47DD0J 8:DFI87DD1+C&"#."!, ,  $! &+  > " !  !  "!&  &99& & " :0 4 7DD1+ &  !  #&99& & " A& )))))))))) !   4> 9&  "  "4 !+ C !  & " A& ))))))))))+ "      & "!&!9 &""&66'"7F& &>7DDF   ,&+ "6  & " A& B))))))))))   !  "!&  !9 &""&66'4 ! !& ,!7F& &>7DDF5

KKK

!/  /

&'4&#&' &C"-! !6&",!   !+ "3 :&L 7DDF+ > &"&+&69&!"0 C'+ "&   9!"     4%9!" + 0 99!    :I C'   5: - 0I -?

  >+        + &M  " &   & 9!4 2 # F<"& && &,6+":6:;;I,5 5 0I!7 --?

&69! 9&C'""#93 ! >?

#$ 6 " #  FD ! F "  &  &   & & ,6 H-+# 07 *#999&'2# &!9 & " "&66'   ! 9   "#& & ,6 2 #&  "# 69&@?

 9&  ,$ & "     " !   " 4 &6 2 & > &  6 3 "#& & ,6+ &  "! 6   "!& 9 9  &'+   $! ,  C"+ &69!    6 3 "# *   FD !: H-?



  %181%   #&4 &!"#99"9& ,"6 3 * 9!  '+9&  & > &"#& &,6?

9&!" '  5 KKK  ! / )  .- ! /  -! /!  819   :  ;   <# %=+ />?

  9 

:5 !&4>5

 9

75 "!&&99& &":047DD15

F5 &  #&99& &"A&)))))))))) 4>9&" "4 !5

15 C &"A&))))))))))5

05  &"!&!9 &""&66'"7F& &> 7DDF ,&5

I5 "6 &"A&B))))))))))5

=5   "!&  !9 & " "&66' & ,!  7F & &> 7DDF 2 A&B))))))))))5

<5 !>& 9 " &  &&5

;5  9&!" '  5   ',,N  !" N    * >>&      &9&,&6"9! /  & ,!$9 9',,