Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/315/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/315/2005 Généré par l'IA

Appeal Regarding Denial of Statutory Interest and Punitive Damages Following Contract Judgment

Numéro de cause ATAS/315/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case involves multiple appeals concerning the denial of various relief requests, including statutory demands for interest and punitive damages, following a contractual dispute that resulted in a judgment for the appellant. The lower courts systematically denied these requests, leading to the appeals. The appellate court reasoned that the trial court correctly denied the request for statutory interest because the underlying judgment, being unliquidated until determined at trial, did not qualify for the statutory post-verdict interest, and the contractual provision for interest was unenforceable under governing law. Furthermore, the court upheld the denial of punitive damages because the appellant failed to demonstrate the requisite willful or malicious conduct justifying such an award, and the evidence did not support the finding of independent tortious injury necessary for punitive damages in this context.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Appeal Regarding Denial of Statutory Interest and Punitive Damages Following Contract Judgment: The lower courts systematically denied these requests, leading to the appeals. The appellate court reasoned that the trial court correctly denied the request for statutory interest because the underlying judgment, being unliquidated until determined at trial, did not qualify for the statutory post-verdict interest, and the contractual provision for interest was unenforceable under governing law. Furthermore, the court upheld the denial of punitive damages because the appellant failed to demonstrate the requisite willful or malicious conduct justifying such an award, and the evidence did not support the finding of independent tortious injury necessary for punitive damages in this context.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
dommages-intérêts contractuels intérêt moratoire légal action en constatation saisie de salaire perte de l'intérêt digne de protection péremption en droit commercial

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The court applied this article regarding the costs of the federal proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/649/2006
Appeal of Denial of Statutory Relief
AC/3634/2021
Legal Aid Denial for Unsubstantiated Contract Damages Claim
AC/1704/2018
Legal Aid Denial for Appeal Lacking Substantive Challenge to Contract and Misappropriation Findings
C/16468/2019
Appealability of Order Focusing on Preliminary Contract Question
A/3813/2006
Contractual Damages Multiplier Appeal

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court applied this article regarding the costs of the federal proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

               $%&''$()  $*%&$)((&



+  ,+ ! -  +! -! 

).  /0   %1 2 )((& 



 3333333333 



-44 ! ! -  5+!6 7   ''() !"#$%&

           ! "#

   0/*10  

 4

+2 3' 4444444444 5'06%  7 )  +"8,  '9' :';' 6< '&'&'' )('2 :)=9 '))&''( :'  >/+ )(?/...2)$@6 ?'))6)$:>A6' (2 6%6)'+-=  ( ' 6)'  >)('6);' ;> < (6'2  $ 6  ?  '6'))6')B'/8<)&'/..+2

/2  )6) (  6' :0'&' ')  +#6(?/..+&':' :' 'C@'&'6 44444444446)''D3E() ''2

F2   66  ++ )(? /..+  6'' ';'C  ! ( 60('C '0))? & >)('0! ( ( ;> )C' ? :)C''?>!6' 66' '2:'6')  &'  '%   ) ' )(') :) ''   6' G'&()&)&)C66>!'C6!>'C')$  ?  (6(H2  () ' %&  <<  ?  :');'''& :)C''? G? :>()' 6  ) :;'  :;'&') &'0$0&'   ; '' C  ? 'H26)'&' )6'(''C 4444444444;D3E))6>;6>')(!;6>'2

82  6)''  )?'  66 $ :'  : DD       : BB  0    5'06%  7    F =' /../2  ';'  G('( I' ))? )&%H2 :'6')  &'   6':' G6 ''(6!>0;'C 6'  &' )' : 6 6'?2  ''  ?'') $ :J6' :)6'6'6??  :'&';' '(H2 J( <';''&66)2

,2  J(  )) <<)  /+ &(? /../ 6   3!'(   6!>;  6!>;  DB2   (( 'K G:J( 6!>;'C()&'  J60  '; << ))? : )' $  (' <00'K ? '(6   <J'?'') (    6;((' ? ( ))  :'>'?'''(?')&%?';?)&%  :<<'' '25L7  '&') '   & = :>' '(6'?25L7 B  6 ;''<  '' (? = :>' ' )6'? :()''H2

-2  )''  /F M/../ :   ('    ?))<' :  :'&' ')'%? : ;) :'&' ') +..NG&<<+



*+,--*./  0F*10   M /../H2 ' 6 )''  /F 6(? /../ :   <'J)  )?  ' $    + )(? /..+ ' ) C:' :;' : ( '  ; )? : () '0' +-?/../2

#2     +# ? /../  ) J ((''     (6)     6'  )6    ' )@' :'&' ')6(2

12 )6 +F=&'/..F: = 2'' G('<HC:':;' :( ' ; ):) )  ?')&' 6':' ()'': & ?CG)((H2

"2 ))(' '? )+M/..F&( '<'' ';&':;''= '''2

+.2 6' /6(?/..F '?C' : 6& :&'   )'' :M/../C':66@66))6 :   +1 6(? /..F  )'' ! )) '<') 6  '   (6'(6(666''(62

++2 6' /F<)&'/.., '? ): )J4444444444  4444444444J<' &''J:'$))'?'') ')&'?$:)6C 66'=$()'' 6)='2

+/2  '  /1 <)&' /..,   4444444444 () ' ;))'  )6 C6)() )(()') 666$'C:'6)' )(?/..+2B6'  ' &'; ? :)C''? ? ()(' '<<') '')$') :;'2&J( 6!>;'C')'6C' ?6!>'C2:)  &'?2

+F2 ' +.(/.., 4444444444;)6 G&' '(H '   66 C :)  ) )' '' C  6') &'6&'6@()') :('% : C  ''  ?'') >('  C'  :)6'6' 6??2  ))(('= :J(6!>;'C<<)&(? /../ G :J6'  '  ('( '0))?   )<'''<H2

+82  '?(''J6'/F(/..,& )' /.&'6 )(''2



*+,--*./  08*10   +,2  6'  F+ ( /.., :   )6  C: &  )6  () ' ';)')'G('<HC:) )  &'@C'<') ?'26' ++&'/..,' 'C)(''2B C')); )$=;2

 -

+2 ';&':;''= '''57))( '<')'') %  + M /..F  '?    ' (6)  ,=; 6)' &'06)' ,66)+-=; 52+2,- 72

B'$:' :)' +-=;6 '?<) ) /#=&'/..85 D+F.+.-7  ';&' 6)+F<)&'  '6'''';6( '?  '  ');   $ ' =; ''   :  :)' &J=;2

/2 <()( $ :' F ') F  '6'' ''   '  +8 &(?/../( '<' ' '&:) &';   ' 6)')  6  &  ((''     ('% :0'&' ')  )) (' :<<'  B C'   ' 'C   (6'' 6)& 6 :' +-/   6)  +F <)&'/..82(6)  '? ) %)?'6> 6)'';2

F2  '   6' ;))  '   ' 5'06%  7 )&';+=&'/..FO) (?( '<''   (' :0'&' ')2 :6% (<');'6 '6''  &'; =C: F+ )(? /../  );   6''6  C  =;   ' : 6 $ 6   ' )'  ( '<''  ' :) <'6)'$  )('  )'''';'5 D+/#8-#' 2++/+F1-' 2+?P<2);( '6''''21/2+ 726)'';)C J(')$('%  '6'' '<) ):0'&' ')  +"='+"-+5'06% 7&';=C:F+ )(?/../2

82 )6) <( )''(6)6'&?52-"  18 '<) ):0&''&'& /. )(? +"8- &';=C:F+ )(?/../5'06%K B72  <<6& '<''  )'' /FM/../:6 @ 66) 6 : P : 6   )''  /F 6(? /../  )) )  )'2



*+,--*./  0,*10   ,2  C' '';'   6'  )6  :&  ' $   :'&' ')2

-2 & :'82/ :'&' '))6)& %C:6     ;&') 66 $ &' ' J 6'   ' )'2  (( ' @ )(') ?='&( :6% :)  )P  < J <' : 6 :'(62   )6   6'''   $C6' ))C' Q' 6 6)'(&((R:)66 66('%<' C:'$)6&' '$ 6' :5 D+/- " ' 2 /? ++1  1/ ' 2 FP B +""1  S " 62 F- ' 2/*72

B:;'  '$& :'&' ')'((R '0' 6  ' <()( $ :' /" 2 +   ' % C :)6)'6') ;' ? 8.N('57 % C:'6))(!'6') &' 8.N('6  )'6'?5?7('6A+=C'' 'J0>''%('&' :)52/"2+ 75 D+/-"' 2/? @')72

B:;'   '''   J >!6>% (')  ='6  <) )  '(6   ('%  : <<')  <'  )26)((('K

:' :@ 6''6 +. )(?+"#+5 D"#/88 2/7 '? <) )   5'06% D 7  <'  !>%   ='6 )'2 0'%A6)'%6(  ''; & &' J);)6&'? :'/"2+  5''C6&'  ' '6 '? <) ) :(6' :'2/" 72

 :?   ' :'&' ') 6( 6)66' :J' : )  ) 6>!'C  ( <<'(( ?'') 6 ' 6)&' C :'6')  ;' :) ' &'(??( $   6)'  ( :'&')C6') ;'6'6@)?''%(  (?6 ( ) 6'5&262J2 D +"-/662/8- F,FF,#P +"-F662//,F-#P D +"-F662/#"/"./",P +"-8 62F"872

'  D   6)')  '  G?'')H  ! <'   6 :')&'?'')2''J6)C:'&' ')6(:)' )C' : 6&'  ( &  &'(? 6) (' :J' : '$)?6'?'') '6')?( )%'(')&'? $ '('6??(6')



*+,--*./  0-*10   ;' :('% ? (<<'6&' '$ (;) :)&( ) 6'2  D J6'C)C )'&')?'') :) )6>!'C(PC:'<'  ('< 6' () 'PC:J'; ?'') 66' 6 J )6' )('C  :' )P C: ) ;( ?'')  6&' @ )6) 6( C C: 6&'  ( C:' )' '( ')&'?P C   ''  6( C''C6)'  :'&') )('6:66''   PC6)C:;' 6I;)'<<''C:)  )?6'?'')<M')&'?=C:$<' 6)' 6 C:6' (:66'' &'+ :'/"2+ 5&2 D +"-8662+.1+#FP+"-,662+F./#./#1P +"-,662FFF8F+P  +"--62/,172

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

!>%(( D :<'() @)''!'6')  ;' 6( C :' $  )  ;( ?'')  '( ')&'?  C:  6??(   $ ) '  6')  ;'  :) & << 6(   ( C' ='<' :' : :0'&' ')5 D+++/+' 2/?P +"1" 62/1/' 2+72



*+,--*./  0#*10   #2 :6%'!' : (& C'6)% C<< : '&' ') 6(    :2 /" 2 + 2   2   &' C ' ?  ' <<' ' $ :'    (6)   '6  C <'(  () ' '2 '0'   C')  6 6  )('C:);)) 2 &><   C  ('( I' ))? )&% ';'C) 6  ;;))) ?((;''<C')) %('  ='/../C'<') ?'')  )<'''<2;))((6)''  <'()  )  <'2  &   ?   <<   6') '      <(' ' 66O '( C :'6')  &'  6 )C  ;' )'  % :'   6' ( '<''2

 )C '$ 6 <</+ )(?/...2  )'' ) (2

12 6) ;'C:':66T :)(('<'J)  )6521"E 72

UUU



*+,--*./  01*10  

  ! - 4   ,+ ! -  +! -! 



8/9   :  ;   5# %') -<=

  9 

+2 )&?2

 9

/2 : (2

F2  )'' /F6(?/../2

82 'C '$ 6 <</+ )(?/...2

,2 'C6) ;'2

-2 <(  6'   C: 6& <(    6) @   )'  F. = %  '<'' 6 6' (( )  )  '? <) )   B>V'W><C' - -..8     ' J(6'2  )'  6 @ 6;)2  ()(' 'K 7 ' 'C J(C )'' )'?''6  )'' C)P ?7 J6 6 C ('< ' '( 6&' (    )''P 7 6  ';     6)2 B'  ()('  ' 6  ' ))( )())   7 ?7  7 '0   '?<) ) 66('%C:' & )'&?2()(' ('(!  6& C'  =' '' C  )'' C)  :&66  C))J6) ')52+F/+.-+.172  ;<<'K  )' K   '' ??'         

6'<( 6)@'<')J6'''C:$:<<'<) ) '6;<<



*+,--*./