Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/310/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/310/2004 Généré par l'IA

Tax Liability and Penalty Affirmation on Investment Transaction Substance

Numéro de cause ATAS/310/2004
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The court considered appeals involving tax liabilities and penalties arising from investment transactions, specifically addressing the validity of tax court findings regarding the substance of those transactions, particularly concerning debt instruments and ownership rights. The court reasoned that the established factual findings regarding the economic reality and purpose of the transactions, which supported the lower court's conclusion that the purported debt was not genuine and thus the claimed deductions and credits were invalid, were supported by substantial evidence and were not clearly erroneous, thereby affirming the assessments of deficiencies and penalties.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Tax Liability and Penalty Affirmation on Investment Transaction Substance: The court reasoned that the established factual findings regarding the economic reality and purpose of the transactions, which supported the lower court's conclusion that the purported debt was not genuine and thus the claimed deductions and credits were invalid, were supported by substantial evidence and were not clearly erroneous, thereby affirming the assessments of deficiencies and penalties.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
assujettissement à l'impôt placement de capitaux validité de la taxation fiscale responsabilité du conseiller en placements appréciation des preuves procès fiscal

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Imposed the costs of the federal proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/1476/2001
Tax Treatment of Financial Transactions and Debt Instruments
A/2272/2005
Tax Assessment and Penalty Dispute over Financing Transactions
A/867/2007
Tax Liability Affirmation and Appeal Challenge
A/3864/2006
Affirmation of Financial Liability Finding Based on Statutory Interpretation
A/686/2006
Tax Assessment and Penalty Affirmation

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Imposed the costs of the federal proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

    "#$%&"%&&' "'#&"%&&(

))*

+ )+   +)   

(  %&&(

,-  . /

  

0 )1111111111   !"  #  $ %  &' ( () # *# ' # ( (## 

 

22    3+) 4  ( + ,-% ./ # #'

                 !

0 12340

 2

37 !# 8888888888%  #  9# '  3,::%  ;'  *# ( / <)& 35  = 3,,-% (  > ) #  ' ' /'   /# %  )&# # >  7   =#  *  > (; ' 9 (  (#?+ *' 9?7

17  (  ( 3: /= 3,,5% &'  (''  (( (   # ( &0#/#(# '  / (& ''( # (  @ *#7

67 A '(# #  %   8888888888%  ' =#    (  ( 5 ('= 3,,5 > &  # ( &#   ( &0#/#(# ' B#0 . & C7   (#9 #)'  ( ? ( *' 9?%     ?# # .  9   9 ( *' 9?  &= # (& /#   ( ( #( # ( *' 9? ## )&    #D # .  /9  0'(# ( *' 9?  *  > (;

' 97 A  # ' #  ## '   ( /# (#  35  = 3,,-%   (' #(' #'7  / ' # ' # '/   ('= ( &' 3,,,7

E7    # '(## ( 1 ('= 3,,,%   8888888888  /'

) &'  (  ' (   # ' #   ##7 #0#  /#  ;  *# )# ' #  # / &#( % #  ( /7  ' # (  # '   ( /#%  (## # ( ( % (   #/# '  '( #% ##  # # #%  '/#   9  > #(%  @ # # (  ( 9 %  # # > 9;% #    ( ?9%   7

F7 &'  ' ' # >  ; # '(#%     (  AG  A %   )&0#( %    88888888887 A   (&; # ( 36 ('= 3,,,% &' /# ' ' /# # (& *  (#?+# > (; ' 9 ( *' 9?% ( &'/ #% . 9  0'(# /# ' ' (### /   ( ( #( #% + '# '% (  # %  (' # #09% #  ( ? ( *+ ( *  ;#  "  ?9 ( 7 &'  (  # &' #    =##'7 &; #' ' # #= ( (   #/# ' ( /% #%  / ( &'/ #   */=% & /# /#9  #  #  9#/ ( & #/# ' *# (   (

2351421446

0 62340

# ( </# 14447   # )&. &= # (  '# (& '0 + ?. ) & # '/ ('*## #/  # ' ( /# (  *# ( /  <9 (& '/  #/#(# '7   *# &;H ##  # # #%  (  #(  (  # # (=   '#   ( ('  #  (  ( ?9%  # ' ( /# # . % .  +9 *#7

:7   (;#.  # '(## ( - <# 1443%   8888888888  *#' )   # ' #  ## '   ( /#   ) /% # )&    #/# '    # # #  (= ' # /#9= > # 7

-7 &'   '   9 (&#  # *#    (&# '9 # *# ( &0#/#(# ' ( 1: *'/#  1- # 14437  ;  *#     # ' ( /#  #. B( ( 344I   # C (   #/# ' '9.  # # ## #% (  ' # (&/# (&# B?9#% #C% (&#(09##% (   > &' =#  ( / ( ?#7   *'  ) #/  J K &'/ # *# ( # ' '#( ( !# 8888888888  )&  % #  ## (  > =#   (  (  ## '#) %  # ( &# #    ( &' )#  #*       # ( # ( &'/ # *# ;' ' > A  L B*7  A  (   (&# '9 # *# ( 3E <# 1443C7

57  (  ( 3-  1E </# 1441% &'  ' ' # >  ; # '(#% (#     8888888888% '##  M!$  ?#9#%  ( ( & 7  ! (  '# (& '+ ?. ' # # /  ('= </# 1441  # ' # (  N      # ' ( /#   (   #/# ' ( '7 ( % &## ' ( /#  / ' # <  7

,7 &'  ' ' # >  ( ; # '(#% (#     8888888888% '##   ?#9#  ?'(#)% 9#  ( ( &  O%  =## ' #/# ( # = ( &#( 7  &'   %  #  # =#  =##'    # ' #  #) 9'#7 # &; # (  8888888888%   # ' # > @ ( (   #/# ' *# > 344I (  # # #0 # B*7 ; # (  8888888888 ( 3- <# 1441C7

2351421446

0 E2340

347  '(# # ( &0#/#(# ' (   (&; A! '  #  # (  88888888887  # ' ( /# ( &'

&'/# > F4I ( & #/# ' ?=#   > 344I (   #/# ' ( '% #0#%   ( ?9 '9# (  ( 34 > 3F P#%     ( #  ( '?% /    ( # # #  (= B (&; ( A! ' ( 16  = 1441C7

337  (  ( 11  = 1441%  (#/## ( '(  # *# ( &0#/#(# '  '(' >  # ( / /  . #/#(# '  %    =%    ; (&#/#(# ' ( 35%6EI7

317  ('## ( 15 /= 1441% &   *' & # (  *#7   % # ## ) &' ' #   > (   #/# '  #/ > # % ( ' >  '  (  '%  /# =# (& / * #  (& ' ( * #7 A ((% &' /#  *# =''*## ( /# (  ( &0 #/#(# '7

367  # ( 36 </# 1446% !# 8888888888  *' # #     ('## . ( & %  > & # (  (  *# /# > #/  * #  /# ( =% ' ' (  ( = (& ?9?% ( 9#  ( ( #  *H#    9#% ## )&> & # (& #(# '

<#. (  (' (  7   *# /# )&# /#  '  +?9 )# /#  )  # ' (&(  # ' # #    )&# #    (;  )'#  * #  /# ( = ' ' (  ( = (& ?9?% ( 9#  ( ( #  *H#    9#7 &; 8888888888 /# '9  #' )&  *# (/# @  /#9'7  /# (&# ('<> )#  = " # ( #  ( ;   ( 9 #* #) G(  ;% ## ) (  # ( /#9 # #  7 *#% # *# #(' )  (9' (&#/#(# '% '     ( # (&#/#( )&# # = #  * # *#% # /# (# > (  (  *#7

3E7  # ( 14 </# 1446% &   #   # # >  ##   (    #. (&0#/#(# '  =< (  ' 7

2351421446

0 F2340

3F7  ('## ( , /# 1446% &    +' > &'     #. (&#/#(# ' ( 3  = 3,,5  63  1444% #  (#0  ( 3 /# 1444  64 <# 14417  ('## &  ' '   '7

3:7   '/# ( 15 /# 1446% &   *# /# )  (#   (  / *#  &/# ) # & #  >   '

 "#    ( 9# (= ( 14I /# (    #/# ' ;#9#=7 %  ; (&#/#(# ' (  &'/# > 35%6EI% ; ##  & # (  (  7  " %   "  (  '(  # *#% &' ' #  # ' ( /#  #. (   #/# ' '9.  # # ## # (  ' # (&/# (&# B?9#% #C% (&#(09##% (   > &' =#  ( / ( ?#7  ;  *# /#    /' ) &'  ' #   # ' #   '#  #/  * # ( /# ( =  ( &#* #)7  ('## ( &  ' # ( < #*#'    (/# @  < '7 *#% &' # %  ((% =''*## (& #(   7

3-7   '#) ( 64 <# 1446%    '9' &/# <# ;'

(&   #/# ' )  ( /   '(  * # '#*#)7  &' # (.     (&;   #/# '  #/  /# #/#  * # (') 7   %  ' # '   "  (  '(  # *# &' # #= )&. &?./ (& 9 ( * #7   % #  # ' (  '# (    #7

 )

37  /#  '= ( '# )  # 9/#  &9# # <(### ( 11 /= 3,E3 BC  ' ' (#*#'  )& #=   (  #  ' ' # # ' (.  3 Q 1446%     #  #)%        #  #/ >  # *'('  &0#/#(# '

( 3, <# 3,F, B  R *7  7 3%  7   F:% 7 3%  7 % ?# 1 C7 *' > & 7 6% 7 6 (  # ( 3E /= 1441 (#*#  %  '  /#9  3 Q 1446%  '  % # (#   36 </# 1446 

2351421446

0 :2340

(  (/  ##   (    #. (&0 #/#(# '%  ' ' # (&#  #=   (  #7

17  #= ( '       )  % # < ' (  *  ('# '9;%  /= >  *% *' ;  7 :,    5E (  # *'('  &0/##  /#/  ( 14 ('= 3,E: B AC     ( # ( ('# ( % ( -. < / S)  -. < . S) ##/ % '/  & 7 5, (  # 9/#   '( (##  #/ ( 31  = 3,5F7

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

E7  &%   # #9#  ) # ( & # (  *#% &' &+    '  ('## ( &  #  +     #. (&#/#(# ' ( 3  = 3,,5  63  1444% #  (#0   ( 3 /# 1444  64 <# 14417   %  # ' ( /# (# @    #. >  # ( 3 <# 1441% (   #/# ' ( '%  )#  *#'     '(#;   ; # *#  '(#7

  %   '(# #  %   8888888888% &' '   # '   ( /# (   #/# '    # # #  (= % > #  B # '(## ( - <# 1443C7 &; 8888888888  # ) > # ) &; #' '   # '   (  *# &;H ##  # # #  (  #(  (  # # (= %  '#   ( ('  #  (  ( ?9% # (# &; # (  8888888888 ( 36 ('= 3,,,  .  +9 *#7     #/# '  )&#(0?9% #(0#0'##%

2351421446

0 -2340

#(0?## %  ;7  '(#0# ( &0#/#(# ' (   (&; A! '  #  # (  88888888887

 ; ;  *#% #     # ' ( /#  #. B( ( 344 I   #0 C (   #/# ' '9.  # # ## #% (  ' # (&/# (&# B?9#% #C% (&#(0 9##% (   > &' =#  ( / ( ?# B A  (   (&# '9 # *# ( 3E <# 1443C7  (#  '#' ) &'

/(#)# ( #. '# ''  * #  #  * # ( =  (&#* #)%  )&# & /#   # ' #  7

F7  /  ( & 7 3- 7 3  % &' > (#   (  / *# #  #/#(# ' ( '#    #  # ' ( 9#  ##%    /#=% @  /9('  '#' ( #.  =7  (#    ) &' # #/#(  ' (& #/#(# ' ##  B 7 5 7 3 3. ?  C7  ' ' #/#(   ( & 7 3-  % # )# &  #*  '( '% & #/# '  #/ ;' <)0> &'   #= ;#9#=   &'   )  #  # (  *  (  9/# ' ( & #  >   '7  # ## *#;'

  <#(  /# (# >   (    (## # (  # ' ( 9# ( 14 I /# B M 31E  334 #(7 1=   '*'C7

?D  '  #*%  (9' (&#/#(# ' (# @  (' #'   = (& # ( /7  %  / ( /# ) &#/#( # = #  ;H & #/# ' )&  #=  ( ( #% . ;' # '/  (  ( '(  #     (& #  # ')##=' ( ?' ( /#%  '  / )&# #  = # &# &' #  #/#( B 7 15 7 1  C7  # ( / & %  .9 9''%  ?# # ;  ) #=     (  (;

/    *  & / & %  (#'   (   ; (&#/#(# '7    T  /  / @  ?#' ;  % # (#/ @   #' (&.  ''   (    ##% . )# &      / ;# #/ ## = 7  '( >  # ( /% # /# (     (  # ( (# >    R  / /   #/#(# ' (#/ @  (' #'   >  @    (#*# # (  /  #= (&#*  (# >    / <)&  T  ('##  ( (#/ @  #    B M 31,  111  315  3-EC7

2351421446

0 52340

:7 &# #'  *#;'  (## # (  # ' ( 9# > 35 I B< (&  # (   ( - /= 1441C7 '( >  # ( /% # & *('

  /  #/#(# ' ( F6U:31 *7    / (&#/#( ( E6U-,3 *7    # )  (9' (&#/#(# ' # ( (# > (  (  *#  ##   * #  /# ( =7

 /# (.  ( '( >  # ( /% &  &;#)   ) = #     # /  . #/#(# '7  ('= ( (# >    (   # #   = 3,,57 & (   ' )#  &' ( '*'   # ( /7

  / / #/#(# '% # +  # (  '*'  ) ##  &+% ( 64 /= 3,,5%  )   # 99'  3,,5 EU444 *7  #7   '   = 3,,5 (  (;#. ' ( /#% # #  (# %   / #  #/  # ( /#   ?N %     *'%  F4 I ( #  = % > #  ( 36. #7  ') %  / / #/#(# ' )&# =     3,,5 &'./ > E444 *7 V 31 W 1U444 *7 B36. #C% # > F4U444 *7  &+   # (&<  >     =#% )# &  ' ' /'  )#  *#9 (&#     #(#/#( (  # # ( &'7

  # (&#/#(% # *  '*' ; # ;) / ' (  3,,5  ?   (  #/# ' #  '' # #/ (    #/'% > /# EU1:5 *7  # B# *'(' (    # #)% )@       ( # 3,,5% 3% 7 1F% #/ ( )#*# # EC%    ( *# )    > @ (&;   #/# ' #  '' # #/  )  (&/# (&#% (&#(09##% (   > &' =#  ( / ( ?#7   # =   ((#' #   (& ?# ( /# ( E4 ?% # (& (' ?=((# #*'# >  +  (   #  3,,5 BE3%, ? R  /# '#) 3,,,25 ; 7 1-% = ,71C%    (# @   ' > EUE-4 *7% # > F6U:E4 *7  7

( %   <#( ( #= *'(' ( %    (&#/#( =  %   '?' %  '(#  * # ( @?   >   ( &#/#(%   ;  # ##  # #'  ?(#% > &S9% >   ## '% >   '9# ( # ( '<   ;

(& #7  &+   *#  # (&' ( ('( # (# #   ? ( *     #(' #% # # /#  N ( '( >  '/ # 9= (   (  *    / (&#/#(%  

2351421446

0 ,2340

 ( &= ( #  (   7  <#( &(  ( ('( # 9= '# > 1F I B M 31:  -5 #(7 FC7

 &%    '   = 3,::7    =''*# (&  # # (&' =# ( +  (& ;'# *# )#  A# (# 3,,37   '   ##  # #' > &S9  >   '9# (& # # ( '<7  *# ) & #  >   ' &=#9 > '/#   /;

( B (  ( ?9 '9# (  ( 34 > 3F P#C% (  # # #0#% /    ( # # #  (= % < #*#  =  ;# ( 3F I B*7 '9 M  =#' ( 11 ('= 1446%  X  54-241C7    (   '( # ( 3F I%  /  . #/#(# ' &'./ > EFUF,E *7

 # ( / (' #  /  . #/#(# ' (# ## >  #  ; (&#/#(# ' ( 5%531 I BF4U444 *7 0 EFUF,E *7C V 344 J F4U444 *7 Y 5%531 IC )# &/  (# > (  (  *#7

-7  / (  )# '.(%  %  *('% (# @  < '7

2351421446

0 342340

)  2  )+   +)   

5060   7  800 0  3! #,% 

  60 

37 '   /= R

 60

17  <  R

67 # )  '(  9 #  R

E7 *   # (  )U / *     ' @ (  ('# ( 64 < (.   #*# #  # (' ('  #= *'(' ( % A?Z#D?*)# :% :44E   %  # ;#7  ('#   @  9'7  '# (# J C #(#) ;  ) ('##   ('# = #  #   (  ('##  )'R =C ;  )  #* #  # /# ((     ('##R C    #9    (  '  7 A#  '#   #   # ''  '''    C =C  C #0(%  #= *'(' (         #.    )U# (/ (' #/=7  '# (   #   + ( /% )#  <# % ## )  ('##  )'  U/ ( )   ' ' ;'(#'   B 7 361% 34:  345 C7

 9#. J  '#(  J

+ A '# ! 

 ' #0<#  J M'('#)  A 

 # * ( ' @   #*#' ;  # ## )U> U# *'(' (  #   9

2351421446