Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/297/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/297/2007 Généré par l'IA

Constitutional Challenge to Gross Receipts Tax Based on Interstate Commerce Burden

Numéro de cause ATAS/297/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A party challenged a statutory assessment imposed on their business, asserting the assessment was unconstitutional as applied because it was imposed on gross receipts rather than net profits, which resulted in an unconstitutional burden on interstate commerce by taxing revenue earned outside the taxing jurisdiction. The court reasoned that the assessment was a valid, nondiscriminatory gross receipts tax, which is permissible under federal statute if fairly apportioned to in-state activity, and that the taxing scheme satisfied this requirement by using a formula that accounted for the portion of business activity attributable to the taxing jurisdiction, thereby validating the assessment against the constitutional challenge.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Constitutional Challenge to Gross Receipts Tax Based on Interstate Commerce Burden: The court reasoned that the assessment was a valid, nondiscriminatory gross receipts tax, which is permissible under federal statute if fairly apportioned to in-state activity, and that the taxing scheme satisfied this requirement by using a formula that accounted for the portion of business activity attributable to the taxing jurisdiction, thereby validating the assessment against the constitutional challenge.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
taxations fiscales juridiction constitutionnelle condition légale vie de l'entreprise comptes de l'État fardeau de la preuve du contribuable

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in order (1) regarding the imposition of court costs against the appellant.
Art. 64 LTF
Cited in order (1) regarding the granting of legal aid to the appellant.
Généré par l'IA
A/606/2007
Tax Statute Validity Challenge
A/3246/2006
Tax Assessment Challenge Regarding Statutory Constitutionality
A/58/2004
Taxpayer Business Expense Deductibility Dispute
A/2350/2005
Taxation Challenge to State Fee as Unconstitutional Tonnage Duty
A/1538/2007
Sales Tax on Stored Goods Versus Interstate Commerce

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in order (1) regarding the imposition of court costs against the appellant.

Art. 64 LTF

Cited in order (1) regarding the granting of legal aid to the appellant.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



               "#$%%"&''( )"&*+"&''+

)

 ) , ,),  ,  

-.  &  &' . &''+ 



 !"#$!%&'(   

"# !"#$!()&)'  !* #"

+

,  -  ! . " # &'!  /+  %0&1!%''% 2  

*     3    *      2   2 2  2 222 2     -     22  4   ! + " "$:" 5%'! /+&)!%(0& 2626  &  22      3   42        2   7  8!  " +9 %)! %&'%   

              !

  &;0  

, / )

%> ?@#+"&1#&''=!(A#5#B" B"/#A+  /$  ". " "#  ! $  %C=1! +   !$%C=0!#$"+"1'"$#B%CC)>

&> 25::="?@#+/$+$! B"/#A+"$  /+@ / #+$ " . " /$.D /: E / 5 "$/9"+#@>

1> ?@#+"".+"."$:+:%=#&''=+$+$+#"4::  B"$&1#&''=/9$+"/+@>

)>  B"$+$"/+#"+++"/$.D! /+/$+++"$:"/+"##E #++ " .  " /+ E "+  #@! + +  1' "$#B%CC)+%=#&''=>

0> .+@+" B"$+/#"4$+BE+F

"# F

 "#" + ::$ /A "  *     3    *     2   2 2  2 222 2     -     22  4   > 2 . /A " ++ +++ " /$.D  $+$ +A#+ E "+  #@ + ++ //++"B/@>2"*    3   *   2  22  2222 2    -     22  4     " %1 ? + ) /+#B&''=!/++E/"+#@/"#"+ ")%4)C(:>)0!+$G+#/%=#&''=>

 F

"#"+::$/A",  -  >2./A " ++ +++ " /$.D ++ / /++ " B /@!  E "9 /++ E  #@! 4 " <411< :> %0! 4+ " &4(&< :> 2   " ,  -   " %< ?+ &''=!  /++""#"!+$G+#/%=#&''=!+"0%4)=%>C'>

=> "#+!E:#""+$G+%=#&''= /++ " "#"  #@! + $+$ +# 9 /+  "+ " ( "$#B&''=>?"+"E$E4H"$:+"4B.+"4%< "$#B&''=!G++"++B>

    ;%<00;&''= 1;0  

(> +$$/5"%)"$#B&''="# $@$E96 $/9 .+ +.$ / "4+ #/D! +##+ I ! 

3 +J >$E+! B/4++"  ! +$  #/+ "." "  H   + @. " #/+ 76/A  8 + E+$  #/D D :@+>

<>  + "  K E  /A "  22         3     42        2   76/A  8 $++B$$:"4/++"B/@ " (4'(( :> &0! E  ""+$  #++ " 0%4)=) :> C' #+$ 6 ">

C> /"0#&''( B##E$"K9 /+  E  . /++ " B /@ H /+@!   :9$  ."$%=#&''(/"$+#+E4H"$:+"4B.+" 44+"/+G++"++B>

%'> 4B"4B?+""$:9$!$+$@"$H?@>

,  )

%> 4+>&0":$"$B/@"/$.D/:! .!..++."+$"%("$#B%CC17*8!+$.@ %?.&'''!A@/$""".>E?++ /"L"/++"+H/+@7+>%&&+%&1 " .6 8! ?@""".#/$++"4+>(1>%":$"$ /$.D /: " &0 ? %C<& 78! + H A.  B +""/%M+&''1!"+!/AE4::  $+$+#7+>%)& 8!9$+"4::/+@B" $" $/++"$+#$/?@"".>

&> 24+>&&*7.+.@"/%?.&'''8! " ".!  /++ " + E "+  #@ + /+@$ :#$#+ 9+>%&&!%&1!%)%+%)& N+>1H0 *4//E+ /@#++H+:$7>%8>5E?+!/++" +H/+@/"H"::$+/++"+!@#+$ " . " B /@ 9++ $.+#+  ##+ " ".! +  /++"+!@#+$"."B/@9++$.+#+ ##+""#@7:>+>&)*8>!?+ H  /++ " + + H 4. " B /@ 9++  ##+ " 

    ;%<00;&''= );0  

 " #@  +$G+ "  ##+ " ". 7 * %&<  &1'N *%&C)))8>

 L/A!  ?@ " /#A +  "$  /+@ / #+$ " /++ " + E "+  #@ /  "#">  "+ /+++!"L/+!"#@!1'"$#B%CC)!"L+/+ %=#&''=!"+HE?@#+"".+".9$+>

1>  !+><"4" :$"$B/@" /$.D /:! .! ..+ + ."+$ 78 + %& " 4" :$"$   /$.D /:! .! ..+ + ."+$7&8!+9"4+$G+//BH/++"+E.+ #@+")O?E41%"$#B&''&+1!&0O&''1!&!&0O&'') +&!0O"A%?.&''0>$E++$G+""#" ## " &4(&< :> /+ ++ ## H )4'<% :> <0  %= # &''=! +  " <411<:>%0H##"%&4)11:>%'7:>+B9"+$G+#/$# 9/+8>

)> 2  "#+ /"+!  /++ E /"+  #@ /  "#" + " 0<401C :> %0! "+  .+ " "$"  /++  #@.+$G+%=#&''=7)4'<%:><0P%&4)11:>%'8"+E /++ H /+@ + " )&4'&) :> &'>  /++ E / "#   + " )%4)C( :> )0N  +$G+ + "$?H $+$ $ /  +++"/$.D"$:"> "#""+H96$/ #++"&%4'%&:>&'7)&4'&):>&'F&8+6"+H6H#++ " &'4()< :> (' 7)%4)C( :> )0 F &8! " + E L+  "#" E "+ H  "#"#++"&=1:>)'>

0> :#$#+ H  ?/"! "/  ? "$+#+ /  /+@ ?E4##+"+:+"/++"+""#!?+ ".$B$$:"++/++"+H"+$G+#/+ #++"6> +$G++$+9###$@4+>%& "4"/$.D/:.!..++."+$ " %< . %C<) 7 &8    +9 $@#+!  6 + /$

7 */B$1=;'&"%<?+&''18

=>  $##+   /K!  /$" $++ @++ 7+> (1 > &  + <C->%"/$""#++."%&/+#B%C<08>

QQQ



    ;%<00;&''= 0;0  

  ) /  ) , ,),  ,  



01232.. 4   52 2  2  6! #(& 7

%> .+  22         3     42        2   H +:$! " #/+ "   !  ##"&=1:>)'H*   3   *    2  22  2222 2  -    22 4   :.""#2 !E" +$G+ #/+   " "$+! "A  %= # &''= ?E4 ##+"+:+>

&> LD"#++E"B>

1> +E/$"+@++>

)> :#  /+ "  E4 /.+ :#  +  /$+ G+ "  "$ " 1' ? "A  +:+ / / ##"$ "$  B :$"$ " ! 25RS5:E =! ='')   !  + 9#/>  "$  /+ G+ /@$>  #$# "+ F 8 "E 9+#+ E "$  + "$ B+   + / "  "$++E$NB89//E#+:+#/."#"++ +"$N8/+@+"/$++>2#$#  ++ /  + $$#+ $#$$  ++ 8 B8 + 8 6"!  B:$"$"//+#+AE4 "."$.B>#$#"#+#D " /.! E + ?+!  E  "$ ++E$ + 4.// " E$+$9/$"$+7+>%1&!%'=+%'<8>  @::A  $"+F     3T J B2 

/:#"/$+G+++:$9/+ELHL:::$"$ "/@::

    ;%<00;&''=