Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/292/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/292/2004 Généré par l'IA

Impossibility of Performance Due to Destruction of Document Location

Numéro de cause ATAS/292/2004
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The court considered whether a contractual provision requiring the production of documents at a specified location, which was subsequently destroyed by fire, excused performance by the party obligated to produce them. The court reasoned that the contractual requirement to produce documents at a specific place became impossible due to the unforeseen destruction of that place by fire, thus excusing performance under the doctrine of impossibility, as the failure to produce was not the fault of the obligated party but resulted from an external, supervening event that made performance impracticable.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Impossibility of Performance Due to Destruction of Document Location: The court reasoned that the contractual requirement to produce documents at a specific place became impossible due to the unforeseen destruction of that place by fire, thus excusing performance under the doctrine of impossibility, as the failure to produce was not the fault of the obligated party but resulted from an external, supervening event that made performance impracticable.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
impossibilité de prestation production de pièces exécution en nature déposition non crédible pièces justificatives manquantes contentieux contractuel

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The provision is cited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of court costs.
Généré par l'IA
C/5093/2014
Employee Appeal of Denial to Compel Document Production Ruled Inadmissible
C/2355/2023
Inadmissibility of Appeal Against Defective Document Production Order
C/15080/2017
Appeal Regarding Production of Contracts and Invoices
C/7731/2014
Employer Appeal of Document Production Order in Dismissal Case
C/14697/2020
Appellant v. Bank on Credit Agreement Termination and Document Production

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The provision is cited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

               "#$#%"&''%"&" ("&$&"&'')

(

* ( *+ +(,+  *+ , 

&- ./    &0 1 &'') 



  23333333333 





,44  +(,+  5,  !"#$ ##"! %#&%&#'()'



               !

   &*+$&  

+ 4 (



,-.#//////////0 #(1#23//////////#%#2  #2 4#5#-" 6!.#7//////////-

*-  "# % "# *889 .# ////////// :#& )  ;  <"!  %"%%!%#%1=#%'#% 4 (#%>8   % , '#  98  "4 *889 #%#?   '# % '#   ## ##!!@//////////?#1 (AB*C -

9-  %!## % *, "# *889 1<<#  % 1" # :#& )  ;  #%!!?%##%1!%#%1=#%'#!#" # ?1#%"##!#%( #%*$"#5?1*$D*889-

E-!"#%,$5#*889#%#?#?0%!%# %'# F % ,88    #?  <"#  % G0 44 % !%#H?1'!#!" 6!1'#'#  !#%-

B-  %!##   ## % 98 5# *889 1   5! 1 ##-  %##  1# %1 #%"##  !%# % "  % '#  4# " # "#  1<<#   % ,88    0  #!! 3//////////'%0#)"#I//////////-

$-    % ,,  "4 *889 #  1!2# % 1   ? %'#(,88  !%#4?###?1# "-   !2"  % %!##  ?  !%# 1 !! %!? %0"##%#"#?#- ?" 6! #!" %1=#%'#(,88  "#J#1  %'###?  =#"#-

>- 1 1 ""!"#""#?! #)%%, 4*889-

C-  #4  !%! ( 1%## % #  % % ,9 5'# *88E- 7 ?# !%1 #%#?!?1#!#0?1<<#1'#  ##  ?# % 0 %1#'#! ?  !#  #!! I//////////    (  #!! @////////// ' % %!! ?1 ,88   %  % '#!# !%#4-

A- #4%! !%!(1%##%.#7//////////?#!% !"#  % % ,$ " *88E- #&#  <#"! ?  '#   #!! @//////////   # 4   ?  I//////////  ? %  "# % '# %## # '## '# ( C8K @//////////  ( *8K 

  &9+$&   I////////// ' %%! %%"#- !#% # %1'#( "4 *889#%#'#"#1'# #?"#( <##1'# %""%-%#'#- %# # #( #  #?#!"*889-7?###%#?!? % !#%  #5#'#%'# %(%0="0#"""#? #5#1'# %'#%-

 #!2"!!%(#-7?#1 #%#?! ?%!## #'#) ##??1# '#?"##  ##-   6 !2#)" " #  <"# G    = %  # %1% !"#?H   "# !1<<#122!( %#-

1<<# !#!?%"%%!%#!!%!% #<#%"#% "# ?1  F!#'#  !#%%# "###%7 ?# !'#%1%!%#  !#%% # "# '4 5?1 "0#"" % %#-    #%#?! '# " % ?#%<#0%!%# !#(>8  ?1=!##%#(0%!%#5?1(,88 ? 0" "#%5#*889#1'# '#!%-

7?#!!2%!(52-

,8- %%"*88E1 "# "#!?#!! ""#?!-



+ , (



,-  # 2'#  12## 5%### : L  * 8B;  !! "%#<#!   ##!%),D*889 #4%# # #? ""   # #' (  # <!%!  1&=M"2 4#2#  1#%"#!   %1#'4##! :#& ) 1 ; ##?1(#"#)%=M"2:<--B$;-" !% #4%!##!4# 52%%1 )-

*-# #2!!%%#%#!'#2, 5'# *889   #4   %1 )- ##  %## % <"  %!# (     '4##! %    % - B$ ( $8   ## ? 1- EA - * %  # 2'#  "#) % =M"2- 5! %  %!#  <"!20'4-

  &E+$&   9- 0 " % # 9, ( 99    '# %  %! " % '#  !%#  %# ( 1#%"#!   % !%# % 1=# % '# ?1#%#(1? %'#%#F # #%!#  1# 9* %  #?  2! 1  !! %!  ?  !%#%1=#%'#'#"44"" #-1#99 !'# ? ( #  # % ?   % '#   F #  #%!#-

   %1 ) 1   ! ?  %## ( 1# %1 #%"#!  !%#%1=#%'#!#" #?1 ###12## %1"0 ##" !'##4%(%<!"#?#!'#4 '#"44"" #-

E-?#(!% !?#?"0%!%# % 1=# % '#-   #%) ?1#  %#   " 6! (  !%# % ,88     !#% % , '#  98  "4 *889 ""  ? 1  #%) ?   !%# % >8    #4  !#%%<#"#(<#D*889!'"'4-

 #% !4" % ' ? %  <"# ? 1" 6 %# " # ?1# ##  !%# % 1=# % '#  #  #%#? G 0 44% %'# "#+ !#%%%!" H-

##"")'#1" F=? 2!%  "#" #"%#<#! #12#%10 44-

%1 )<"#?# "#%>8 "" 0 44% %'#4#<<!" ! "#,88 -   %<#?!! =!(1  #%#??1#%"%#  !%# % ,88    ?1#  %# "  %  ?   % '#!# #?"#"#!(>8 -

1  %<!%1"#)0%,88  ## )- 1<<#  %!!! ?  2 % !%# !#  !%#4  3////////// '#  #  #!! I//////////-    % % 1## "!   #4 % ! ? ""   1#%#?# %  !# I//////////   # % 3////////// ) %#  (@//////////-71 ?1'#B  %1"4 %'#%#!!- 7!"#%  " 6!(=%1'#*8 "#%<N'#4-16( %## #?.#//////////'#!2"%  #%?1#'#! I//////////  <#" B  '#%1"4%1 #"# %*8 % 0%1#'#!%" 6!.#7//////////-

  &B+$&    < #  !<! 0 <"# " #  1" 6   !#% #%!! %? #  ? 1" 6! 1 #?"  '#! %  "#?#- " 6!<#"!<# #4%!#%#?? #5#'##%0=#5 %-

  "#) %  ?# !)%  #4 % !  ?  %!##   ?1#"#0%!%#(>8 4##   !#!- " %0 ##%!%1%##%!"#% #) %# # 6  # % #  0 % !%# % AB  -  '= 1 4#  !#%%<#"#(<#D*889?1#'#%1%AB  %1  ?!%# F!#'  (%"% :#9$ ;%1  ?7 % ##%1% !%#  !#%%#"#?#1" F= 1" 6%1%"% '"-

 !?  %!##  !  1  #'#! ( #2  !%# %!(1 #3////////// " 6!.#7//////////  %!%*$"#*$D*889(=%AB -"% #4 ##4?1 #" %?# !)% )2"% !#% !# ?#   F #! ## #?1  <#  145 %  %!## !-

























  &$+$&     ,( 4  ( *+ +(,+  *+ , 

 6.7 8   9     5! #:& ,;

  7

,- !'4-

 7

*- 1%" #"-

9-   %!## % 1  % *, "# *889   %!##   ## % 985#*889-

E- #?3//////////%#F"#4!!<#%1!%#%AB   !#%%*$"#*$D*889-

B- #? !%2#-

$- !4 #%#-

>- <"  # %  ?1 ' <"    ! F %  %!# % 98 5 %)  #<##  # ""%! %!  #4 <!%! %  7=O#P=<?# $ $88E     # 0" #-  %!#   F 2!-  "!"# %#Q ; #%#? 0"?%!##%!#4## %%!## ?!R 4; 0   ? "#< # #" '# %"%   %!##R ;   #2   %   !- 7#  "!"#  #   # !!" !"!!   ; 4;  ; #&%  #4<!%!%  "#)?1# %'%!#'4-"!"#%"#"6 % ' ?#  5# ## ?  %!## ?!  1'  % ?!!0 !%#!:-,9*,8$,8C;-  2<<#Q  !#%Q     ## 44# 

 #<"% !F#<#!0 ###?1(1<<#<!%! %#!#%1 (1!"# 2<<