Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/275/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/275/2004 Généré par l'IA

Admissibility of Expert Financial Testimony Upheld

Numéro de cause ATAS/275/2004
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A litigant challenged the admissibility of expert testimony presented by the opposing party in a dispute concerning a financial instrument, arguing that the expert's methodology was flawed and the testimony lacked the necessary foundation. The court upheld the decision to admit the testimony, reasoning that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in determining the expert's testimony, while perhaps subject to criticism regarding its methodology, met the foundational requirements for reliability and was helpful to the trier of fact, as the opposing party was afforded a full opportunity to cross-examine the expert regarding the methods used.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

; LOI FÉDÉRALE SUR LA PRÉVOYANCE PROFESSIONNELLE ; PARTAGE(SENS GÉNÉRAL) ; INTÉRÊT(FRUIT CIVIL) ; DIVORCE ; JUGEMENT DE DIVORCE ; AVOIR DE VIEILLESSE | LPP.73.1; CC.142; CC.148; LFLP.52a

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
témoin-expert dépositions des parties instrument financier preuves crédibles décision motivée rapport d'estimation par expert

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the final order regarding the imposition of court costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/1516/2001
Expert Testimony Admissibility Challenge Affirmed
A/2983/2007
Expert Testimony Admissibility and Evidentiary Challenges
A/1602/2006
Expert Testimony Admissibility in Property Valuation Dispute
A/2201/2007
Expert Testimony Admissibility in Commercial Contract Interpretation
A/1871/2006
Expert Testimony Admissibility Challenge

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the final order regarding the imposition of court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

    $%&&'$'(()  $'*&$'((+

,

- !-    - !

 '% . '((+

+/  0 1

     23333333333  3333333333   ! "  #$  %& ' '(  &" '""



4 23333333333   ! )( * $  %& ' '( " &" '"" '

 

5 !  ! 6   7-    6 " ' % +,$ +-++    -



!8 -! !  9- -  ! '&4' *.  //-$ 0120 3 *

           !

"# ) -5,)

 5!

+6  78 ' -,  -11-$  ,9 .: ' ": ' "9 "  '  &:"(    ' 9;  &  '" " ' "8   &  ++ " +<=0  !' >??????????$ & ??????????$  !" >??????????6

-6 #  ."44 - ' '"" "4 ' 78 &" &$  ": ' "9 "   '&   8  " "& ' ;" ' &;@ 4" ("  !" >?????????? '  "8 9 '  A' " ' ": 8 '  (   ' 9;  '  A' "  ";  ' % ;" "6 !' >??????????$ ("  & ' ;"& '  & "B $  %   " & ' &;@6

C6  78  4" %:7 '%  D   '  " E   "   "     "" ' '";$ " %     &    '   ": " '%  " "" (  4 '    ": '""  "4    8 ' ;" 6   " (  ;"  %;"  & &  "&6

26   '  "$ '  F ' +C '&: -11-$  4"&  4 '    ": &     8 ' ;" 6  ": ' "9 "   "(&  78  &" &  ": ' &  '  ' -- G -11C6

/6  (F  ' ": ' &$  ": ' "9 "   "'"(& (  '"; ' &B & " '; '&4"" "4  B& "  0 " -11-6

=6  +C  : -11C$ !" >??????????  '" " '    " ' &;@ '     ' % ;" " H7'%." "I #" #"& & '%    "J F &  C+ '&: +<<<6

,6  " ' -+  : -11C$ !" >??????????    &  '  '

0 " -11-  4" ;" (  ;" D  8 '"; %F   7 K   "  4"&$  '& " &" $  "  " ' '";$ "  ++ '&: -1116

06  ": ' &  " &  " "  " '&4'   " ' "

"(     ' ;"  ("   & '  ) C5,)

"8$ "    ++ " +<=0   0 " -11-$  '  '& " ( D  '  ' % &  4 ' '";6

<6 #  " '  A' " ' ": 8 '  (   ' 9; ' C+  : -11C$    " (" '  "8   & %&9; D 46 ,/L1<C$0/  0 " -11-6   &"& (   B&"$    8&& F &   ' 78 $ " '   & $  -,  -11-6

+16 % "I #" #"& & '%    "  & :" D %  " ' ": 'B    "$ %     " ' ": 8  + '&: -111$ " A6 ,1L2/-  %   0 " -11-$ " A6 0/L<,=6)) 6

++6  '   & & " B  "  '  ' -1 ;: -11C6  B)

&B  "4 &  '&' ( D  '  '% &  4 ' '";  !' >??????????   D % " '%" &F  D ;     " '  " '9  + 4&;" -11C6

+-6  '" '  "  '  "  & & 8'&   ": ' &6 !" >?????????? % '&& '%'   '  ' 0 " -11-  % &  4 ' '";$  ( !' >?????????? %   & D 7 "6   " &  ;. '  " ;" D % " '%" &F $  D ("  B)&B % &6

+C6  (F  ' ":$ !' >??????????  "(&  '& '   ' ": 8 ; 9 '  ( "44" H& <+= +<C6=,$ "8 :" +00J     & & 8'& D 786 ) 25,)

 !

+6 L 6 -/ '  " 4&'&   ": 8 '  &;@ 4" ;""$ ;";   ";"'" & ' +, '&: +<<C HAJ$  &  ;"8  + 7;" -111$ 98  &'   ' '";6   ' '&' ' 7"      " '  " D  8   ' '"; H 6 +--  +-C J$  78 ' " ' '"; &    ' L 6 ,C 6 + '  "

4&'&   &;@ 4" ;""$ ;";   ";"'" & ' -/ 7" +<0- HJ$ " D 9;  ":   '  " '"  + G -11C$ '" $ 9 ( L44" "  & & " H 6 +2- J$ B&  'L44"   8   : '  & ' & " " '& "&   78 ' '";6

-6 # L 6 -- A H;   ;"8 '"  + 7;" -111J$   ' '";$    " '  " (" '  "8   8& 4& B  6 +--$ +-C$ +2+  +2- ' ' ";" " H J E   6 C D / A L"(  8"    D 4& H6 +J6  .( 7" $    " '  " D  8 ' D  '"44&      " '  "$ 8 & ' ;" ' ": 8 B"  &;    ' '";$     " '  "$ 8 & ' ;" ' ": 8 B"  &;    '  " ' "8 H46  6 -2 AJ6   $  7  D    " '  "  D L;" ' ": 8 B"    '  " ' "8  " &F  '   ' '"; H A +-0  -C1E A +-<  222J6

C6  ;" ' '& "  '  D (   8 '    " ' ": 8 '" F  44 &6

B  ' % 6 +2- "& -  C $  78 ' '"; 49 '%44" %44"  78 &    "9 '  '9 % &  4 '  '&""  ";   8  " " "(    '  ' '";6  %9$  ,9 .: ' ": ' "9 "   "'"(& (  '"; ' &B & " '; '&4"" "4  B& "  0 " -11-6  $   ) )" & & 4& 9 '   '  "6   "   " '     "" ' '";$ " " '  8  " "& ' %;"  ' ''  4; '  ''6  "' '  D  &8' (  &8"  4&'&  "&& '  "   &4 ' '"

' '";$  (%  & & ' &  -= 7" +<<0$ ' '"" " &' M  '&N '%   ' % &  4 ' 78 ( '   ' " " H 6 +20 "& + J6  %" '9  ) /5,)

(  78 ' ": ' "9 "    &  4   " $ "" ( %   &   '  " '  F ' +C '&: -11- H46 &8  6 2=/ " 6   E   ### 5  5O 5# *! $  " '  " ' &' ";" 8;"$ 6 2 '  6 2=/  J6 ""

(  9;  ' "$    " '  " (" '  &' ' '";  " '   8$  ;" ' &;@  " D P  E  ."B &8" "4 %   &(   ' 8 &' H .  # $  ; '" ' '";   '"    "9 4"$ "   A# ) * $ &'6$  %"  ; '"

' '";$ $ +<<<$ 6 =0J6  &($  ;" ' &;@ '"; F   8& D  '  D  (  '";  '; '&4"" "4$ "   0 "

-11-6

26 #  '  '" $    " (" '  "8   '' 9 '  A' " ' ": 8 '    %&9; D 46 ,/L1<C$0/   9 ' % "I #" #"& & '%    " D 46 0/L<,=6 ""$  '' '" D  B)&     '  "; 46 C,L/2=$<1  46 2-L<006

/6  ''  D % " '%" &F      " '  " D 4&6

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

 " "  " ' &;@ '&4' ;  &( ' " &F   " D  ''$ '9  0 " -11-6

 &' &  8 " $ "    Q '%& " & '%"'" & H 6 0=* 6 +  J6

RRR    !5  !-    - !

 :4;4   <  =44 4  9# %>' 

+6 ;"   A' " ' ": 8 '  (   ' 9; D 4&$ '   ' !" >??????????$   ' 46 C,L/2=$<1 9 '  ( "44"  4; '   ' ": 8 & <+= +<C6=, ;   ' !' >?????????? E

-6 %";"  D ;$   '    $ ' " &F   "  B '& "&   ' "'& $ '9  0 " -11- 7(L  ' 4 E

C6 %@ '   ( ' :" E

26 ;"  % "I #" #"& & '%    " D 4&$ '   ' !" >??????????$   ' 46 2-L<00 9 '  ( "44"  4; '   ' ": 8 & <+= +<C6=, ;   ' !' >?????????? E

/6 %";"  D ;$   '    $ ' " &F   "  B '& "&   ' "'& $ '9  0 " -11- 7(%  ' 4 E

=6 %@ '   ( ' :" E

,6 " (%" %  Q '%& $ " & '%"'" & E ) ,5,)

06 4   " '  (L ; 4     & F '  '&" ' C1 7 '9   "4" "  " '& '&  ": 4&'& ' $ #.S"I.4(" =$ =112   $  " B"6  '&"   F  8&6  &" '" M J "'"( B  ( '&""   '&" : "  "   '  '&""  (&E :J B  (  "4 "  " ;" ''     '&""E J    "8    '  &  6 #"  &"   "   " &&  &&&    J :J  J ")'$  ": 4&'& '         "9    (L" '; '& ";:6  &" '   "   @ ' ;$ ("  7" $ "" (  '&""  (&  L; ' (   & & B&'"&   H 6 +C-$ +1=  +10 J6

 844"M  &"'  M

T"'   !  "  

 " 4 ' & F   "4"& B  "   844