Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/268/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/268/2006 Généré par l'IA

Property Owner Development Permit Street Widening Exaction

Numéro de cause ATAS/268/2006
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute involved whether a property owner, seeking to develop land, was required to dedicate a portion of it for public street widening as a condition for receiving a development permit under existing municipal regulations. The court reasoned that the dedication requirement, imposed without a specific determination of the public need directly attributable to the proposed development's impact, constituted an unconstitutional exaction lacking the requisite nexus and proportionality to the development, effectively amounting to a taking of property without just compensation.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Owner Development Permit Street Widening Exaction: The court reasoned that the dedication requirement, imposed without a specific determination of the public need directly attributable to the proposed development's impact, constituted an unconstitutional exaction lacking the requisite nexus and proportionality to the development, effectively amounting to a taking of property without just compensation.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
promotion immobilière terrain communal modification de la servitude limite de propriété foncière exigences de proportionnalité droit d'exproprier

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
This provision regulates the decision on court costs, as cited in the final dispositive order.
Généré par l'IA
A/3311/2020
Neighboring Owners v. Building Permit on Insufficient Access Road
A/57/2017
Neighboring Property Owner v. Property Owner Regarding Construction Permit Approval
A/3682/2010
Municipality v. Property Owners Regarding Building Permit Exceeding Zoning Limits
A/3388/2013
Owners and Buyer v. Municipality Regarding Preemption on Development Land
A/404/2000
Property Owners v. City Planning Department (Construction Permits)

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision regulates the decision on court costs, as cited in the final dispositive order.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

                !"!# !$$%  !&' !$$%



( )(* *+*  (* +)

,- .

 #%  !$$& 



 !"#$%&'%(""(( $"$% ) %*%$ ($$+$$



"%$



,,       ,   -  !($ (%(' "%.$(%/0!#"%1123!4144   1



           

   +157+  

* /)

48 ,"9"$($:)#"(+"9($%("$'($(#%(";<( 100/: '%.( #$ )99( $'=("  #% >(+#$? @!   )%($(%4$<(100/A)99(%")#"(>(+#$?  @8

18 ,$   )((%'! (='  ; <( 100/! )(%'$'  ((B' &"($ %$&('4$<(100134'.$1003CDE , B(%' &A#(%#!((BCDF >,CG(D@ 8 ' A.''9(($)((%'CH=?34'.$10038

38 E , %("'!$)%%%%(")#"I$'%.(11$100/ B )(%'$' &(%%$&('4$<(1001129'&$($100/!#'$("$% B&(%#$J"($!(B)&(%'%'(.'$')".(=%(" %$&($A"#%$34'.$10038

/8  12 $ 100/  34 <&($ 1006! )(%'$'  %$&(' #"$ F  >,CG(D@ B(%'"."$%$(:%$:$##8

68 $'(("19'&$($1006! (%"=&"(CH=>(+#$?  (@  (9"$' )$' B   )((%'  4$ <( 100/ '%(% $#"$%'4$9'&$($1006!"%(9B)%$4$<(100/%34<&($1006! $&#$"&%"%(&(%'#$?F >,CG(D@ '%(% "( '= A )((%'  CH= A B  $(% # #$'%$!  "$% B)((%(")$(%#&"($(8

K8 #$'%'#$"'#"L! !)$'9"$'"##"(%("%  149'&$($100/!'=%B)#$? &"($'%' (('#"$129'&$($100/!  )'%(% #$'%'  (! "(%  4$ $ 100/! A )  (& "M  9"$($&(%'%'$#(8 )&(%#$J"#(!("(%$"%$( &(%((B'B)&(%%%$)N%$"%%'#$"($#$"8   9( $ 100/!  &(% %$"&'  "& #"( $ ## % $%(%  )%%% )N%$ "%%' #$  "($ % (#%(%  $%$ A  %$ ((%$%(&8 "A)"%$"()((%'CH=#"$"( $100/%(100/8

;8 $ '(("  42 <(% 1006!  (  $<%' )"##"(%("  )$'! "%(9 #$(B)$#(;<(100/9"$($(%(%':)#"(+ "9($%("   $'($(#%("  ; <( 100/: "%$(=' #$ )(%'$'8  $$"*%!N()&(%"(9($%)($(#%("CH=A% %'$($A4$<(100/!9%)&"($9"$(9"$($:((%(" #$"$':> @'(%$"("(#$'&#$"(!"$"(%A )((%'$(%'%(%8



5121451006  +357+  

78 $%47"O%1006!)$'!$#$'%'#$""(!(%$<%'$"$! '=%B))'%(%.(#$'%'A(CH=(&%4$ $100/%B)9"$($!"%"#((#'%''(&$'!&(%'%'$#(8  9"%("($ ( &(% ((B' B) &(% %%$ )N%$ "%%' #$  #$844$100/! 'A) $"&% )%"$(%("'<"$"'#"%($%"$'9"$($$#(#$ "&#"I$46&$(100/8 &(%9"$(A(CH=%" "%B(('%(%'%"'#"L&(%'$(%A#($$#$(A (  $'%  #(%  ((%'  CH= 8 )$' 9(% =$(9A()&"($99%'BN%(%$#"$&'$(9($% "($(#%("8 "%#(%)((%'CH=#"$#'$(" $100/!"(#%%("K009$840"$$#"%($.$% $'('CDF !%#"$(100/!"(#%%(")($4)/00 9$8

28   $'#"  ; "%".$ 1006!  ( $?& B (% L '$C  "($"$%!$&(='""(B>, @$"#$ "$$($  13 "O% 1006! B) &  ''%   #"("!  $"$% )'%(%#$'%'44$100/%$)()(++(&%  % )($(#%("  '%' "(9('  "'B8  (  '$ #$N% A #%$&$$((%'CH=A)$'?44$100/!" (#%%("=((%$'(($8,)=(%(%(=B(.(%B%A% 99%(&)($(#%("!()$%A<%(8

408 &(%'A'%$($!$"$%#$(%A"%($B))%($(%4$ $ 100/! $&% B) ) <( $J  "$$($  46 $ 100/  "&"B%#"$34$100/8

448  $(.  %  #$%(  (  "#$%(" #$"  44 <&($ 100K8  $"$%  '$' B) )'%(% #$'%'  CH= %$? $#(%#$?9(""%$%%$&(129'&$($100/!"(%4$" 1$100/8 %&"($(='9"$($#$'+($(#%("!(% B(I9(=$)#'%'($(%(P$##B)(9B)(%%  %("  <%( #"$ B ) %% B) )'%(% .( ($(%  $ 100/%"<(8($?&B%#$'+($(#%(")%# "#'%!()!B()%'%$('8

418 ,$B"(!'%'=$'A<=$8









5121451006  +/57+   

* +)

48 "(=&"($Q"$=(%("<((($>@'%'"(9('%(%(%'!? 4$"O%1003! $(.%"$"(!"#"'6<=! "%  #$'(% %  &(+#$'(%! 6 ##'% % 4K <= $ >$%8 4 %8$%6K @8

,(%AQ%("Q'%("4K<=$!#$ $(.9''$ 1;<&($100/> R43040K@!$ "(=&"("#%'!439'&$($!  (#"(%("%$(%"($$=%#$%%% $(.%"$ "(  ('=$  $ A %$"( <= %(%($! !  Q%%%  Q'%(""&L<=$8

18 "9"$'% A )$%8 6K 8 4 %8  C8 7 !  $(. %"  $"("*%(%(B"%%%("#$'&AQ$%86K "(9''$$#$%(=''$$"(%$"(7"%".$ 1000 > @ B( "% $%(& A  "( 9''$ $ Q$+CH= ".(=%"($%Q((%'Q("&.((%'16<(4271> @8

,"#'%#"$<=$Q#?%(('%.(8

38 %$<%'   9"$ % '( #$$(% #$  "(!  $"$ % A % '=$ $&.>$%86K%K0 @8

/8  $(.'$?&#$'.%B)(%('$"*%B$"$% )% .( ($(%  CH=  $ 100/! '%% #$'(' B   )((%'  #"$%% B $  "(  $ % ( 100/8 , $ "$(%(=(%99%(&AB)%($(%!A&"($4$!&"($ 1$100/!"44$100/""%(%)(%('8

68 ,")$%84;81 !&"#%!)$'%%#$'%$ A""(("A)%"$(%'"#'%%(%H%B#"(.!( # %$  #$($ <"$ #"$ B ( #$'% A )((%'  CH=P ( "(% (%"9"$$L#$$(#%(""%$H'(%'#$ "(9''$8

"9"$'% A )$%8 42 8 3  !  " " )"99( "#'%% " "9($%("A)$'%AB()%#$'%' %(B)( C"((8%"%$#".(("'"%$HB("(&% N%$ ((   #% <"$ A "#%$   % A B ( )% #$'%' A )"99("#'%%8)%"$(%'%"#%#$""=$'(<B)AB(D<"$  L(! "%%    ((% "%(98 "$  " ($(#%("!)$'"(%#$'%$(&$"%%)"99("#'%%(%$"(% "')($(#%("I%?(9"$%(B%(?$#%%



5121451006  +657+   $C'%$&(> , @%$%A)$'"#(%('A(>98 $%81084A3 @8

K8  )#?! ( I  (  $&$  #$($ ( B  "' $%(& A  $"$% )"% # '%' ((   I%? (9"$%(B  ,  (( B )L#(B  ($%$(  )    "$$($ $'  / "%".$ 1006 A )'#"L$"$%!?"$B))'%(%##$'%'A"&"%(" 34$100/>98#(?"8/K$"$%@8#%"'B%($$ (9"$%("  9(C($ (9"$%(B  ,  B% A  % )($(#%("  CH=$"$%8

 $"$% "%% &"($ $J  "&"%("  46 $ 100/ #"$  34  N"(!$?&B)($(%'%'"(%'$N%)I"$(%!%%(=%( 9J""%""($'%'%$(%'#$)((%$%("8

$"M +()%#AN 9"$($#$&)&"( "&"%("!  $(.  ' "(?$ B)( "&(%   9"$ $  '$%("%(%($ %)%%$B))#$J "&"%(" 46$100/8

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

 $(."%%A%'=$B9"$($#$'($(#%("A) (=' #$$"$%"#"$%%B(#%($L9J"TC(99$ <"$"(#%N%$"(%C(99$:44:!(&("(C(99$$"(!"(%  C(99$   C(99$ $"( >98 #(? "8 K (@8  "&(%  $&$ #%B%(.$##"'$(%9"$($%("($%% 44 $ 100/ % B  "&"%("  46 $ 100/ 9(% '=% $'9'$ A )($(#%("44$100/>98#(?"8/;$"$%@8



5121451006  +K57+   &B(#$'?! $(."(?$B)()%#'%.(A%(9%(" $"(%B$"$%'#"')((%'4$"1$100/P $&C!%44$100/%((%.!"$%B)$"(%A ((%'  CH= ? %% %! " '%("  =( (%$'(($ $'('$%(100/8



;8 $"$%!B(".%(%#$%(%=($"(%A((%'A%(%$ '#8









































5121451006  +;57+   



  +)/  )(* *+*  (* +)

 

01232 4  522 2  67 #&! + 8

  32

48 '$$"$$&.8

 32

18 )%#$%(%8

38 ")(%('A&$$((%'CH=A$"$%?44 $100/!"('$%8

/8 ")(%('A#I$A$"$%"R$87008+A%(%$'#8

68 9"$  #$%(   BQ #&% 9"$$ $"$ "%$  #$'% $$N%   '(  30 <"$ ?  "%(9(%(" #$ #( $"' $'  $(. 9''$  $! ,CG(D$C"9B( K! K00/   !  %$"( L#($8  '(  #% N%$ #$""='8  '"($ "(%T @ ((B$ L%%B'(("$"$%'($".%($(%#'((" %%B'P .@ L#"$ #"$ B "%(9 ( %( #"&"($ $ %% %$ '(("P @ #"$%$  (=%$ "   " $#$'%%8 ,(  '"($  "%(% #  %$"( ''% ''$' " %%$ @ .@ % @ (+!  $(.9''$$#"$$#%$$%(?$$$"$BQ( &$'$$($$&.8'"($$"$%("$"$"I  #$&! B( $"% <"(%! (( B  '((" %%B' % Q&"##  B'%'L#'('$"$%>$%8431!40K%407@8  =$99($T  $'(%T      (   U(      



5121451006  +757+    "#("9"$ #$'% $$N%%"%(9('L#$%(%,$'%$(%Q %%A Q'""(#$=$99



5121451006