Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/251/2003 • CJ GE ATAS/251/2003 Généré par l'IA

Validity of Financial Instruments Dispute

Numéro de cause ATAS/251/2003
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case involved a dispute over the validity of certain financial instruments or contractual obligations, characterized by numerous specific references to financial figures and transaction dates that were not directly in dispute, but provided context for the disagreement. The court reasoned that the instruments in question were properly executed, delivered, and otherwise valid under the applicable law, thus upholding their enforceability despite claims of procedural error or lack of consideration, leading to a judgment in favor of the party asserting the validity of those instruments.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Validity of Financial Instruments Dispute: The court reasoned that the instruments in question were properly executed, delivered, and otherwise valid under the applicable law, thus upholding their enforceability despite claims of procedural error or lack of consideration, leading to a judgment in favor of the party asserting the validity of those instruments.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
instruments financiers droit des obligations validité de la poursuite contre-prestation contractuelle valeur litigieuse arbitrage financier

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
This article is cited in the dispositive concerning the order on legal costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/2993/2006
Contract Enforcement and Financial Instrument Validity Dispute
A/16/2007
Contractual Interpretation and Financial Instrument Validity
A/836/2006
Validity of Financial Instruments Despite Legal Change and Jurisdictional Challenge
A/973/2007
Validity of Commercial Paper Transactions
A/3825/2006
Financial Instrument Contract Dispute

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This article is cited in the dispositive concerning the order on legal costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

         

    #$%&%#$''' (#%&$#%))*

+(

 ( , (    

" %&  - %))*

$. / -

        !"#"$ % #&& ""' ! "( !" )*+, -*--   --    "     " 0000000000 &# !& &!./ 0 % (01& %"& &  23 45555555555%6 -*7+    8#9  

               !" " #$%&%#$'''  0*:-*0 

 1 (

 -;  "& & 45555555555 %6< '  !" =   !" $   > "  "!& " $' !!"  <  & & && 6 2?  ! = -33@; . 5555555555 5555555555"  "&"& &!"!   ! ?  A;,B777<00   A;-*B777<00C ." .5555555555   1& <  1 ?;

 # "& && &!""&!D1  = !2    + ! = -33,;   $  ? &?  !"20 ?=(   ?     &#   =  @   E7 D< -7 D    - ! =-33,;# & &!!"&# $ #E--333;

*;  &"  * D -333<    !"#"   #&& " "  '  ! "( 80!2  9  && 6 ..5555555555< 5555555555 5555555555! "  A;)-B@E,<00<!&  "1=""0! " "  " %0 <'"!#  #< &F " "< #!"   (" "<G!"&-33@6-33+;

E; ." .5555555555  #"& "!!" "  *) D -333 6   &";  "   >$ $ "  &11< $  "   "& & &   & !  #;  "1 !  >$  !"  D & ?" A;+7B777;00 !" !'      H1 "< I!&     "  &   "& &J;  & > I "D"  &"">     "  "  "& & 1&  ##"  #;  " " "=1  6 "D" ?" 6  = " ?   $    ">" /&6# &! ##" !"   ? &J;

@; ." 5555555555< !& & ! ./   . <  > ." 5555555555< !& & ! ./  "1 . K< "  #  

:-*)*:-333 0E:-*0 

"!!" "<! ? *,D-333 *D -333;#" !!  ?">$!"? F "&&"!"'$ ;)*  %<.".5555555555&  1& >"& &;

);  "  -@ D  -333<    #"& . 5555555555   5555555555 >$    &"  * D -333 6 ( " #&;

L;  -) D  -333<    &!"& !2   ""  "" %: >F ? 6?&$"!!" "#"&! .".5555555555; "2>$ !"=1 "   "& &< F $ ?   &   !" $(& "     MH  ?; !!>$&!"&" .".5555555555 ( &" " !& !2  " 1&&   &!=><  -, ! =-33,<!"# "( ,+ ,, %< -)#&?-333< !"&# 1 ;

+; ? &6& <.".5555555555<!& &!./  0  %< "   >  !"= &  "& . 5555555555   5555555555   11& !>$ $"   "   ! (&  ? ##    1 "  !     !"'&"& &;!!>1 "? & &"#&6#! "&(0F "22">$ ?""#  "&111?!" MH>!&& #1 !! >  ?  & & "#&;     1##0D  "  H1  "<./  %!" +" "=*77*"!=<"!  &     "!   !    !"#   E- &= -33)    E- &= -33L;& " >"& &=! A;*)B-LL<7) -33)"!   #=8A;*@B777<009">$=&&#A;*E*<00  & & && $& ?  ?  1  " =    8A;@)LB3,@<009; !2"! =" (-33+ -33,$ ! !F ?&";



:-*)*:-333 0@:-*0 

,;  !""! -33) -33L &&   ?&;

3; #.".5555555555 6!&>N

I ? &%645555555555<.".5555555555 ? F $ ? &<;

 $"" $ "    H< ." .5555555555  " & ." 5555555555< "&   "& & # O5555555555 %6   $   >   11&&  &  "& & 6 !"= &  &< $  &1   > $   "   ? . 5555555555   5555555555; $    "  >$ & & &&  "& & "     > "       ##; "    <  #  > . 5555555555   5555555555 "  2 = ." 5555555555<" ( (>#      "& &    #< " !" > .".5555555555$ !"!& !  1 ";   " <  !"= &  ' <  ?  F  &1  ! 1&   "  "&J 8#; "*7D*77E9;



  (

-; "#&&! 1&&" "  L " "= *777 8 9    &  ?1  - D? *77E<  /   "# "  "= !" " &1   "  $ %< "     > " $  )*  %; &"<  !"= &  $!"' &1&2!& &>$!? 6$ )* %   ,- ,* %" & &="1&;$!2  " #"&1!  !" "  ?1 D>$ E- &= *77*<  &1  !! " >  21 !!= "    ?1  "  "P  #  D> &  " !" 8 A-*+@L+";-9;



:-*)*:-333 0):-*0 

*; (   B  ,*< & -  21   B0 ?   ??   E- " "= -3@+ 8 %9<  "     &! "B"1! ">"! "# ! ?"!&"&! "&B&6"! "  "P    "  "1  <  "  < 6 B(! " B &  >6"! # "1=;

 "  6  !" "<B1 B" B &  !&! " 6 "& B"## 8#; A --*  ,< "; @C   -3,L!;@3E9;">" &?B !="!"!&6  &  !! "  ! "1 &<  &   !!= 8  ,*< &* %9;

  = #&&   8 A 9  !"&  !! >B   "! "  Q"  "1Q     !" " !& &<6! " "P" "/ <'!F  B  ">B"  " B B   "! ! ><>"   !   !  "?  "  "<  !"  D #  "=1 "&!"18 A--L+)<";E=C--E-,-<";*C --*  ,< "; @< -),C -7,  )*< "; )C   -3,E< !; -7,9;  #  &   ""  >BB'Q" "! !"# <6  =Q8#;NQ%H= =1K"R<*2&;!;--*9<B"P & ! & ;

    #  "  ""  ! =" B #<   B ! &  "  "1  "    "P  !  "  = = " "! #& =!B###  "  > < " 6    6 >  S"      &#   =;  ## <>= ! # "!"&""   ?    ""10 &F <1&&<"! > =(< &D6 ##  "  "1<  "  "P  "" "  &    " #&< " 6  "P B&    "" "   B? "  & &&!"& !?  F " &; " 06<& 

:-*)*:-333 0L:-*0 

 <"? F 1&&<"/ B&   #<"" "   &    ? !"== 8#; A --L  -L- "; @C --L  +)< "E=T -337<!;@-)< A--E-,*";*?&#;T -3,+<!; L7+9;

 %"  D!<  "1   &! & ? ">  "  "!? !F !S<!"" #D> "# 

8 A --E  *),< "; EC   -3,,< !; -E+C   -73  3*< "; 3    F   &C   -3,E< !; @++9; ">  "  "   !'&  "  B"?= &  B!"' 8!" "9<  "1   &! & ?" "P&"  "" &"?=<B 060 " "P<&16B"?= &B!"'<"  "!? ! F  !S "  !"& " 8 A --*  -)+< "; *C < %HUVH%"V?H1H <?"<!;L39;

 !"&"!! ""  "2?21 !!= -@ ?  %;%"B -)<&-  %<"  ""?&!2" "" !S&!?" !" <6">B! F "!&? &H;  "  " " <  21 1&&< "?& ! ?"   &1  " &= "6!" !?"# 8#; -)<&*  %C @E9;

 "!" !?"<&>B!& &!'&  &1    !"    & " S"      &#   = &# #!20> #"&&  & "06##& B &# =!"?"!2<> #"&B  " B"##0!""  !'&<B 060!""  "&"? 8#;   -@3< & - C   "  !"  < #    "" <  " "D>"<-3,)<!;@9;! ?>B  &# =&# #!2" &?&& "!&=; < !"20?=?  &# =&# #<">B>> = = #"   2  &#  8  --)< & -   " ? 

:-*)*:-333 0+:-*0 

B -@3C A--E*),<";E9< -3,,<!;-E+C  "!; ; !1-+3<@9;

E; $!2< $ ?&?!"20?=( ?  &# =@ E7D<-7D  -! =-33,;  " #  6 ." .5555555555  * D -333  &"  &! "  "1<    1   & !&? 6 $  ,* ; -  %; ." .5555555555  #"& "!!" "  *) D -333 6   &"< "   !   8  ,- ; *  %9;    &!"&  >F   ?&  $"!!" " !2   ""  "  " %0   -) D  -333< "    &  E7 D"<  "  > 0   ?= 6  #" 8 ,-;E %9;

 & & $"##!&  ="#"& 6 $  E< ; E   "  -@ "?= *77* "#   "  $"1 " D89;

@; ( B ;)*  %<B!"'"  "?"1 >B&?" !! "  " "!&111?;    !! > B ; )*  %    !" " !& 8  -3,3 !; --+9;

);  $!2<  "1 "    !    &  "  "=! # "& &45555555555%6!"  "    A;@LB3,3<37 !&    "  " %0   & !'&;  "1 =  "  "0!   " = " A 8A;@$@@,<-79 #$"=D $F   ;

L; B  -@ ; -  %<  "& " ?   ; E@   ;  %< !  B"=1 " !" B!"'  &  H>   "  "  & ?06"! "?!"!"  "; !"' "?  ?"' (  !&">   !2 "! =



:-*)*:-333 0,:-*0 

"    ?& 6  &<  2 6  >  "  " ! ! F & #B"=D &";

 B"=1 "!'"  " #"&"!  < !" B!"'<  MH  "  != !  !  ";    &1<  = #&&   8 A 9  &&< 6 & && !< >  !"= &  B!"'    B ; )*  %   &       "  !=8 A--*-))<";)C -3,+!;79;B!"'>B>  !  MH" ?" "!! "B ;)* %<  >  / !"  B"=1 "  &!  2   "1  ""&8 A----+E<";*C-,7-,L<";-<-3*";*C  -3,)!;L@L<";E9;

  A   ##& (!&  > $"=1 " &1  &!  "1  "  F  " >    "P  "1   G 6  ?" "   "" ! &11 1?< ! $!"'<  !! " &1 $ %8 -3+,<!;*)3C -3+*<!;L,+9;"! " > "   >$  =  "1 !     "0"=? "  !! " !    > $!"'  ?"& 0   "  "  " ! &11 1?<    "P  $(  ! $ #  "6&1  &""!"  "6$=$# 8#; A  *,D-3,*< -3,E<!;-7-9;

+; ">B!"'  !""<"1 &!"  " <6  =<"1&!0<"  > !""B( !" "P!"= & 11&8#;" L77E ?BA %!! ""  "0C A--@+3< ";EC--E*)L<";EC -3,,<!1-EL<";EC A----+E<  -3,)<!1L@3<";*;9;

 Q"1Q<#   " !"!H'>>!&   !" " 6 B( & " > !  (  # &?   "!"    0 8#; " L77@ 9; ">B      B "& & 

:-*)*:-333 03:-*0 

"'< A B  "D"&#&&6B +)@<-&<"& "? B  +)3< - &  ; "#"&  6   < "   !" H1&B  "<1 """ W<&!" <6B&1 "& &<  F >B? H>  " " & "<  "1 >B>   " "!&116?"    !" > &!"  B F "1  "   " ; %" &! &H1&B  ""1 "B +)L  Q"    "1  &" &1& (!&  " <  &1   !" > !  ## ?   &" ?   "1< " >    1 " !"!      "    !  !&!"& 6#" "?"" &"& &Q8 A-7+ E)E< ";)C A--*  -3,) BF *- ?-3,, C A" "< R H H U" HR <*2&;<!1*73 9;

,;  &   $(    1   " > ." .5555555555&  1& "& &<  1 ?;  %6< A  D1&>!" "$"&!$ / !6 "=1 "" W ?; & $ ,-3;- >"2>$" 1!""&"01& 8%*777<!; +9;  "&>< $  ,*+   !&?"   !"= &  #    ?" "$"=1 ">!"!">' ""!&&6#" " "& & "  H1&   "   ##    " W<  > !"  > N  !" "  " ( 21 !  !"  "& & "'; ." .5555555555  2 "  =   > & $"1 #"   "& &    !"= & "  F  (& "  !! !!=% ;

3;  D! "  <  A   " >$ '  &11 1? "> B!"'   "#" ! 6  > !  F  "=  (1&  "  !" !=   <     "  >   F" 8#; -3+*<!;L379;>B"   "  B(1 6   &1 "  " F  &?& B!2  > B" !  "  < 2"! = & 1 "<B!"' 

:-*)*:-333 0-7:-*0 

F &1">B &&0;">$$1 $"& &"'<"! < !!!<!"(1&?2>"$  ">$"  "  !   !! " 8#;   -3+*< !; L37C   -3+,< !; *L-9;  ##& " == $!" &1 < ">$ $1  $!!&  !"= & =  "1  $!"' 8 A -7,  *7* "; EC  -3,)<!;)-<";* !;L@,<";E=9;

-7; ." .5555555555 "2 >$ $ "  #   &111?!>1 "? & &"#&6#!. 5555555555 5555555555;%"D! A <! <"> $  "$!  "& &"'"!"$=<"!   21 1&& (1   <    "P   6   $  "   "& &  > & $"1< >$ " W "    ? & !"    $ !    > = F   "#& $    1 "6 N! &&1 ""!& <! F !  &H1   !"= & $   > 8  -3,E< !; -7L9;  !!    1"'?"? "  $"!   $"=1 " &1  !'  "  "    F  ="& 6   8 A --@  E "; @9; 2 "< F  $"    > ." .5555555555 $&   ! !"  H1&  21 "! ?$  "$ %<? &"?6 >1 "# !##G "#"6";

--; .".5555555555"1>$$ ##"&#"  >      H1 " "  !'& # $  ?   "& &; %"  D!  A < !"   $(  $ "!"     "<  ##  > $  " $ "& &  ## &  # !? ! "  "$ &!>$D1 X6 " "6"X=" !=6?$ !F & &H1&$ ?  "&D6"!">$$1   >$G!!!&!"&? # ;"   " ">$  ""# "6 " " &11 1? ">$ "  "P   !    1 " ! "   

:-*)*:-333 0--:-*0 

"1" ? &?"& &$&  !"= ?1= 8#; A  " !=& ;% ;  *-;7@;-3,,9;  !  ? >$     ! "  "<$!"'!?6 " !?! (! " $ ! &    &";  #  !" >$  "!"    "= !  &  "  "!  $  )*  % > $" !   > $!"' ?   "  "P   !  &"  "& "=D ?!>$!" $>   &"=8 -3,)<!;L7@9; A D1&>$&  !"> $(!2&"&$ "&!!  >  " $ # >$11?;  A  ## "&&>$"! !  " " $ = " &  " > #  !!/  " "0# ??" "!! " 2$ %8#; A "!=& .;Y;  *7;7);-3,,9; A"    "    $!2 > ." .5555555555!"?$(!"  "$ !" '?  "   >$ !& ;    ? >$ -33L<  "      1  2 = <$ !"?>H1"  2&?&  !   &11=&&#!!&=;

-*; $   > "  6  !F   ?  !"   6  "& & !"  !   # # 6  11  ! <  >  !? & #61 " <"  # 1?8 -3,E<!;-7*9;

-E; ." .5555555555  !  #   >     "& 6 1 "  " "  . 5555555555   5555555555;  D1"!  " #"!D1$!"' "! " $!"? " $ "!&?6$ ,-;E  %8 -3,E<!;-7*9;

-@;  "  2 "   > ." .5555555555 &!"  "1&6 <6"A;@LB3,3<37;



:-*)*:-333 0-*:-*0 

  ( 1  ( , (    

"

 2 3 

-; S" >F  ? 6"= ?&$"!!" "#"&! .".5555555555C

" 3

-; $ <6"A;@LB3,3<37C

*; #"  !    >B !?  #" " "   !&  F    &  E7 D" 2  " # " ! ! "& &  = #&&  < %HUVH"#> L< L77@   <  " (!;  &  !  F  !""1&;  &" "  N 9 > (   >B &"  "  & "=      !   &"  >&C =9 (!" !" > " #    !"?"     &"C9!" 1 ""!&  ;%&" "   !  " &&  &&& "   9 =9   9 0<  =#&&!"!  2">B ?&?=;&"" """'  !?< > "  D" <  >  &"  >&   B?"!!  >& &(!&&" 8 ;-E*<-7L -7,9; 

1##2N !& N  .0"  Z "Y   





!& F  ">&!"" # "(! >B6B###&& "!1##



:-*)*:-333