Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/24/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/24/2007 Généré par l'IA

Effect of Prior Judgments on Current Liabilities

Numéro de cause ATAS/24/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case involves disputes over various obligations and liabilities related to prior legal matters, potentially concerning judgments or settlements from different years, with the court addressing cross-references and potentially challenging the application of prior findings or settlements to the current claims. The court's reasoning involves examining the scope and effect of earlier judicial determinations, referencing specific numerical identifiers and dates of prior proceedings, to assess whether the current claims are barred, satisfied, or otherwise impacted by those prior actions, ultimately affirming or denying relief based on the legal effect of those established records.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Effect of Prior Judgments on Current Liabilities: The court's reasoning involves examining the scope and effect of earlier judicial determinations, referencing specific numerical identifiers and dates of prior proceedings, to assess whether the current claims are barred, satisfied, or otherwise impacted by those prior actions, ultimately affirming or denying relief based on the legal effect of those established records.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
effets de l'arrêt gestion de sinistres action en constatation de responsabilité procédures connexes concours de responsabilités calcul des dommages-intérêts

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in order 1 for the allocation of court costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/1785/2006
Interpretation of Prior Judgments and Damages Calculation
A/364/2005
Disputes Over Prior Judgment Allocations and Liabilities
A/1886/2007
Preclusive Effect of Prior Judgments
A/4391/2005
Application of Res Judicata to Prior Judgments
A/1066/2006
Finality of Prior Judgments in Subsequent Litigation

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in order 1 for the allocation of court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



               !"#$%!&''( !&#!&''%

))

* )*   *)   

+,-  (  .' /0 &''( 



 !"""#  $  % !&'( '!'( )#("!!""*#(+(',  $"''

!('

--     * ..    ' "("# /!01    

               

   $528$  

 1

9:   ;"$&'< = *'#>  #  9075  '"#  "&?#  *#! @?("<' A"B !"A C <)   B'# ! '"' &!"  (")"(#D'$D#'(E#F D(''900GC5663: ('('#."566G:

5:  58 E#)'"' 566G   ':   '@(!!D   ')# H *'# )"(   '"! * "  @('I  #)"(' (! #("'  ) &!'(  @'D&GJ"! )(("!K!(&'!!D#!EB"!'@":.! #("'(;')>#("(!('$""H#:

3: 98'566G *'##&!#&'(("! '"!* &!/'(@'"(J/!(;"@('I>B"((AE!'((<5669AL !@"("('(!)&'!E"!:

4: 4)'"566G *'#'&"AH("!"'')(C#('"'((( *'#A  ""H( H "  #("(  K! (#  B''"(  (")"(# *M!!DC966N&'A&"!(K!"E""'A(A<H&!"KA:

G: 1)'"566G ' ''&&!'(#" H" "D!("H"@('I&"5663: ""H)!"')*'# 5(9G&(K'5663(98E#)'"'566G:!'H*"*)"(')566G  "( K" ( *)"( &  &"(:  *)"( & E"( *''O(  (')":   &!)"(&'#&!'H("!"'!'('#"'("!&'!E"!' "!""(&P&("("&!)"("'H#("')&!'( @'D&GJ"! )&!"("!EB"!'@"()(')" "(#("(!('$""H#:

7: 51"566G ' '("E"#H*'##("("&"(# (')"C966N<5&(K'5663:

1:  9G &(K' 566G  *EE" (!  *'$")""(# ;"$&'< = * >  ('"  !"'  .')" #" '#D"!  " '! ;"$ &'<=.>&!'B'@(!!D"H:

8:  7 ' 5667   ':   #"    ("# H  ' *!'' &'!E"! *#("( & Q("E"# ' " *(")"(#  ') ( EE(")(!('$""H#'"!*(("(C(#  D#'( ( D("!*@?( '('( ""*(&!('$""H#'!R '&(""(("!E!("!!#&'&#""(:*'#  E!'("! &'!E"! (  B&#'" &'!E"! !&("K ) ""(("!E!("!#'"(&'' :



2340125667  $328$   0: '#""!54)'"5667 * 'Q(#'*!'"(("! &'!E"!   E!( ' *)"  .:  */ )"( &  !('$ ""("!C'&'"*(")"(#D#'('('("!:

96:  9G " 5667  *'#  E"( !&&!"("! C (( #""!:  #("( "!"'  &' H* &!/' "( *DD' ! D#'( )  ""(("! E!("! H* '!('"(: *(")"(#  D#'( * #(K"( A('A"&"H"(D'(")"(#&@/"HH"#("("!&("K)! #(( (#: &!( "'('"* D' & D)!"'"(!&("K " " #("( "!"' H*  !K(" :  E!'("! *M!!D " &'(('"(&'!('(')"':

99: ' #""!  54 !S( 5667  *   'Q(# *!&&!"("!:  '  )"(!"D#*"#H("!&'!E"!'):*'#"&!"("" *&"(#(')"("<'&!(#D' !.*)"(')#: '"' *'##("("("("'* - !'()"(B'# (T@ ""('(") #D<'   (")"(# (#'"':  (")"(#   ('!'"#("(""B"D"K:*'#*#("(!&")"(*)"( &'!"(C'*!''&'!E"!:

95: 5G&(K'5667 *'#'!'!('(('"<'#""!&'< '"K(!'!"!(C!("! C*!('!"  ' *!'"(("! &'!E"!  M!!D" !  ')!"  !"' C * &!'!)"('("!: &!)"(&B''#("' '('("!(*@?('"(&!)"(&'#('C&!(""('("E @?(B:

93:  36 !)K' 5667   '!'(  ('"  ! !#   '&&!'( #"  '   58 !)K' 5667: "$" '<) H *'# !EE'*""E(!"''@(" .&!/'(@'"( J/!(: &(&)!"'*(")"(##"((&!'(@'D&GJ"!  (("!K!(&'!!D# &!"("!EB"!'@":(')" '('("!(*@?('";')">(!#!"#:*'#*(!&# D("!'('(("!*@?(E!'("!#!@?("<': *#("( (!Q!'  &("( ('&'" )  "" *&!/#: *'# E""( ! (!(  (T@: . E!'("!  !''&! ! & C  * '""('("E*@?('": &(!&&!('C&!( D' C!"H* "&'((E"'E!'("!#H")(: ) E!'("!&!"H*&!''"('!(')": H" ("&!"KC)!('$""("!#":*'#*K"!&'"  &"H &' $O    #K(#  E!'("! *M!!D:  )'"( O(' !(&'* (()!":

94: 8#K'5667 * !'Q('!':



2340125667  $428$   9G: .'H!" #(#D'#CQD':

 )

9: !"D)!"'U!'D"("!Q"""';>#(#!"E"#("("(# < 9'!S(5663  '"K(!'!" !&!#GQD  !(  &'#"( (  )"$&'#"(  G &&#( ( 97 QD ' ;'(:9(:'(G7 >:

."(CU("!U#("!97QD' &' '"KE##' 51Q)"'5664; -936967> ' !"D)!"!&(# 93E#)'"'   "&!"("!('"(!"''D(&'((( '"K(!' !"  "#D'  ' C ('!" QD ("("'     U(((  U#("!!)BQD':

5: !E!'#( C *'(: G7  : 9 (:  @: 5    '"K (!  '!"!+("("H!((("!&'#)CU'(" G7   !" E##' '  &'(" D##'  '!"(  ' !"  7 !(!K'5666; >H"!('(")C!"'U'$")""(#90Q" 90G0; >:

.!&#(&!'QD'U&<(""#(K":

3:  ('#)"D'9'Q)"'5663 (&&"K*&<:

4: ('Q(#(&(" '!'(')K;'(:76 >:

G: *!KQ("("D&!'(''!"('!'(C''(:

7: ( '#&(# "&"(#  (')" (!( &'(  (!( ! &'("   U&("(  U'#C!&"'&'!E"!!!!"U(")"(#(')"H"&( '"!K( O(' B"D#  "  " (( &'( '#( U (("( C  (# &@/"H  ( ! &/@"H:   U"&"(#  (')"  !D '#  U(")"(# H" &( O(' B"D#  " &( " ')' U (' &'!E"! ! U (' !" U(")"(# ;'(: 7  >: ( '#&(# "&"(#  D" (!( ""("!UK!U&'("&!"K""(#D"U'#' '@#(')"#H""K'#!!"U(")"(# "((""("!'#( U(("(C(#&@/"H (!&/@"H(HU&'"(&'< ('"(( (  '  '#&(("! B"D"K ;'(: 1  >: ( '#&(# ")""(#U"&"(#D"(!(!&'("H"(&'##&'(! !D'#;'(:8:9 >:

1: .! *'(: 8 : 9     '# ")" ! # U ")""(# ;'(: 8  > ""( !( '!"( B '  '#&(("! #"' H" !(  ('C'#(K"' C"("'!C#"!'''&"(#D"!'&"(# U!&"''(')B@K"( HU""(!!B'#(")"(#'(")



2340125667  $G28$   &'#K: '!"((#('"#E!("!(!('#U(")"(#&'!KK:  '  '#&(("! !&'(  ' *!'' &'!E"! !"( *!'"(("! &'!E"!   E!'("! &'!E"! ""("   '( &'!E"!(')"&(:

.! *'(: 9G    *'# H ! ")""(# ' "EE""  @!"B U &'!E"! ! UB'"  ! (")"(# (#'"'  '!"( C U!'"(("! &'!E"!:

*'(: 91   &'#)!"( H U'#  '!"(  '(   !) &'!E"!"!")""(#'(('#"'(H&"(#D" &( ""  ! (!( )'"K  O(' "( ! #"!'# ;: 9>:  '##("!   O &'!E"! ( ""#  '( ;: 5>:  Q'"&'(H*(''((Q("E"#(" &"(#D"(""#56N)"'!; -954968>:

8: @P  '# ("E   D'# *")""(# !"( O(' #)# '  K * !&'"!  '): !'    ') H *'# '"( & !K("' *" *#("( & ")" ( !&'# ) " H*" &!''"( !K("'  B'V( *(")"(# H" &( '"!K( O(' B"D#  " &'<  ('"(( (  '  '#&(("!  '  '@#  (')" #H""K'#:  !&'"!  ')*EE( '<D!'""' @"EE'("B((H&!"K !((B')( !E'!((* )*(' "EE#' &'(((  '  (B *")""(# ;#(@! D##'  !&'"!  ')L -936348!":3:4 95836!":9 964937!":5( 5KL QH* 39 #K' 5665= '(: 58 : 5  L  9' Q)"'  39 #K' 5663='(:9:9 !''#("!)*'(:97 L&"9'Q)"'5664= '(: 58 : 5    !''#("! ) *'(: 97  >: !' &'!#' C  !&'"!  ')  " !)"(   &'  !(   "  '!"( C  '(L  ') ) (  ")""(# !")( O(' #('"# &' '&&!'( C  O !( (  !"E"("!   ') &("K *"E'  '!"( C  '(  ') QH* !( !R  #""! ( ' !")(O('&'"!&(; -950553!":4:9 958914>:

 ') *")" !"( O(' #)# )( (!(  E!("!   "(("! &'!E"! !'<(  *"(#'#:  *K * ') EE(")( '#"# "/"'#E#''B!#(("("H (H*'#(( HO('('('"'*EE"E##'(("("H; -957  17 !": 3K2 ( KK>:  '  H  "' '!'((  (("("H !")( O(' '#"(  #&  *K  "'!( &'! ( &'!E"!   &'(""' ;""(("! "#  @"&  TD  #  ')"  ("!"(#2(#D!'" *(!'"("!  #Q!' ( (B *!&("!>('#(*#)("!""(&!)!"'*&&'#"("!: #("!D!KB"5GN'"'(("("H&'(("'



2340125667  $728$   !&(  "EE#'( ##( H" &)( "E'  ') * (")"(# '(");E: -95718!":G>:

 ')   &'! )"  #('"  #(K"(  D'#   )'"K&'#&!#'(H*'"(EE(")(&'#"'!( #('"( "  #("(  K! (# ; - 950  554 !": 4:3:9 (  '#E#'>:  !"( O(' #)#  "<' " !'<( H &!"K " K" H*" !)"(   '<D D##'    '#E#''  '"' "' H *'#  !K( )(*(("(C(#:

0: &&'(#)("(#'#;&'B&" *"( *"&"(#  (')"  *")""(#  *(("( C *"(#D'"(# &@/"H ! (> &&!( *"('("!E"(*!''#":' &!'&!)!"'#(K"''!"(*'#C &'(("! *""('("!!QDK!"!(H#" !"( " E!'"': *&&'#"("!  !# #" ')O( ""  "&!'( *((&D'!(B(:Q'"&'!&'#"#(T@ #" &'B&!'*#)("!*")""(#!*(("(C*"(#D'"(#  !!'*B""(#('('*#)#("(( ')!D; -9559G8!":9K('#E#'L.  &')'!"('!" "=#D*@!'W'"$!K'( . WX W$T 5666 &:578>:

 *'$")""(#  *"('("!  E"( *!'' #"  E! '  '&&!'(#"('"((("#C*EE"*'$")""(# B&'(" #""#&(*"("(("!*' B&'("H#&' ('*!K')("!#"* ; -95391G> B&'("&'!"( &'&'("""HB&'("#"!'!#&'QD&'"<' !  '"<' "( ;. 9001  &: 398 !": 3KL     &'!#' ""('(")  '$")""(#  (@< -'"K!'D 9000  &: 945>: !'  *#)("!  *")""(#   (T@  #" !"( C &!'('  QD( ' *#(((#(C""H'H'(&!'H(")"(#*'#( "&K(')"': !(' !##"!("((##((" &!'#('"'H(')B!&(!'  '"!K( B"D'*'# ; -95G579!":4('#E#'>:

H"!')'&'!K(*'&&!'(#" H"(#('"( *( H  &!"( "("D"B "( E"( *!KQ( * #( "'!("#  H  '&&!'(E!'B!&( H*"&'#D(!"#'("!  &"( B&'"# &'  &'! B"#  H*" "( #(# #(K"  &" !"*< H'"&("!!(B(#"(*&&'#"("! "(("!#"!"("'(E"H!"!*B&'(!"( S( !(")#:  '(  *##( #('"( &!'  )' &'!K( *("*!'"D"!/&')"#"D("!!'&&!'(!! B&'("  " K ( K" ! !( ; - 95G  3G5 !": 3  955  976 !":9('#E#'>: 

2340125667  $128$   .*D"(   )' &'!K(  '&&!'( #(K" &'  #" ('"((   QD&((!"(("'!&(E"(H !*B&#'" #"('"((( D##'(" !( C&''&'("&!'!&("('"! '("!!E"H"*"(C'"': "" Q'"&'!'& &!"B!((("!E"(&'&#""(H*C*&&'#"("!*"&"(# (')"&'#"E"; -95G3G3!":3K2('#E#'  900G &:44L 9088&:G64!":5>

96: *&< '&&!'(' 58E#)'"'566G 1)'"566G( 58!)K'5667((((H'!'(&(&B''"#("' ') "(')"'('("!(*@?('";')">&&H* #("')&!'(@'D&GJ"! (("!K!(&'!!D#(EB"! '@"!(')""(:

 !(''"! ( !  '<) *"("#   '!'( &( B'' C &" (& (!( (')" H" '&(  ""(("! ("!#  !"(  &'(""'  (")"(# ""('(") ( H  H*  #QC B'# (' 908G ( 9081  !  ''" )"( H* &'!"(:  )  !"#'("! H" ")( " *(&#"'#('"'"*(")"(#D#'(*'('((!' B"D"K:

99: !)"(""'D'#*")""(#:

 '!'( */( & B'#  (")"(#  D#'(  '('(  ." &" 9006  " !)"(   E!'  &!' E"B'  "'  ")""(#  '  "''#((*HO(."'('('"'; ..>5664 ( '#E#'&!'D'#*")""(# ' /((((# "&"(#(')"<&(K'5663:."*!!"<' EV!'D H "&?!K(#C*#!@?("<'<)!'!"(") H"E"("! 5 !"( !''&!( C  A(')" "#&( ( ('< H"E"#A   ') !  (K 9 .. 5664 &!'  (")"(#  *@?('" (  '('("!  &!'  E ; ")  H"E"("! 5> (  4*359 E': &' !": .*D"(  ') *")"  " !)"(  *''O(' C 3*803 E': !"(  ') (("("H &!'  E B'V(  (")"(# "& ( '#&#("(")  5664;")H"E"("!4>:D'#*")""(#'#((!&'"! B')(0N:O"*!&'!<CK(((96N'  ') *")"  !(( B" ""K  *&< !&( (  Q TD   '!'(    ("!"(# " (   H"E"("! &'!E"!   ') *")" '"(  3*G63 E': 16  H  !&'#  ')  ")""(#  4*359 E': K!("( C  D'# *")""(#  98 0 N  "EE"(&!'!)'"''!"(C'*!''&'!E"!:

95: )H"&'#< '!'&(H*O(''Q(#:



2340125667  $828$  

)  1  )*   *)   



23454 ,, 6  744  4   8 9 .(& :

  54 ,

9: #''!'')K:

 54

5: 'Q((:

3: *#!( E"B#C566E': ("C@'D'!'(:

4: E!'  &'("   HU &)( E!'' '!' !('  &'#( ''O(   #"  36 Q!' <  !("E"("! &'<  '"K E##' ;.@I"P'@!EH"7 7664  > &')!"'!'("<''!"( &K" !E!'#(B'(:85!"E##'' '"KE##'91 Q" 566G ; ->L  #!"'  '!' !"( ""H'  !"!  !("E ( !/&')(&!'('"D(''!'(!!("'L"!"( O(' '#  '"K E##' &' )!" &!( ! &' )!" #('!"H B !"("!  *'(: 45  -:  &'#( ''O( (  &"<  &!"!  '!'( ")!H#!!/&') !")(O('Q!"(C*)!" D'EE"<'  &'#"(   /. #'" 

!&"!E!'&'#(''O((!("E"#B&'("""HUCUEE"E##' '!"&'D'EE



2340125667