Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/228/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/228/2006 Généré par l'IA

Breach of Settlement Agreement Based on Non-Material Prior Breach

Numéro de cause ATAS/228/2006
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Frais judiciaires à la charge de l'autorité
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A party challenged the validity of a settlement agreement, alleging that the opposing party breached the agreement by failing to make required payments, which the opposing party claimed was excused by the challenging party's own prior material breach. The court determined that the challenging party's alleged breach was not material under the circumstances, as it did not substantially deprive the opposing party of the benefit of the bargain, and therefore, the opposing party was not excused from its obligations under the settlement, concluding that the opposing party was liable for breach of the settlement agreement.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Breach of Settlement Agreement Based on Non-Material Prior Breach: The court determined that the challenging party's alleged breach was not material under the circumstances, as it did not substantially deprive the opposing party of the benefit of the bargain, and therefore, the opposing party was not excused from its obligations under the settlement, concluding that the opposing party was liable for breach of the settlement agreement.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
gestion de sinistres violation positive du contrat validité de clause compromissoire consentement et validité au fond paiement des prestations litige non administratif

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
This article is cited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of judicial costs for the appeal.
Généré par l'IA
A/1482/2001
Settlement Validity and Breach Dispute in Prior Litigation
A/1883/2003
Validity of Settlement Agreement Compromising Prior Breach Claim
A/1912/2007
Settlement Agreement Validity: Failure to Disclose Non-Material Information
A/159/2006
Breach of Settlement Agreement and Modification Validity
A/760/2005
Enforceability of Settlement Agreement

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This article is cited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of judicial costs for the appeal.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

                



  !"# "$"#  " $ #

% & '

()   

 !"""#$ % &

!"& !"""#$  

!'&

((   ((( )'''&*+ !',)  #,& -./-0 1

2  %   2    (  ( ((   ( 3(  4 (  (5!        

1  ( 16  & !&&'&"77 78./   

       

  85/  

" * 

7: & ;<'   8..*   7=& )>&  &">  ?&"=& "' @ A  ?&!!#  "B!&     #     ' !"&  #    C" D#'"'&"#'7+-9:

8:  )",,& -  ;<' ?&#"'#   &">  ?&"=& "'  !&!#  ?&'<?&!"'"#B!"&?&#B!E?&!,"!C"?&) #?!F&'&"<:

G: ;<'"B!&'B#,""'",8..9'#'#'&" D!,,"  &"> '!  & !"  89 ;B"& 8..9 ?!& F#'"!?&'<:

/:  &">#!""'#?&'"!&"'"''"!?&#B!E  ?""'&?#"'"''"!#,&?&"'"!"C& !''  B!"&   ?&'" C" &'  &"<  !"' '&  7+-9'8..9:

*:  &!&'!&&"& 2  %    2    (   ( ((   ( 3(  4 (  (  8. ,#B&"& 8..9  C  ?&''"! C" ?'  &"< ?&  &D#=B$2&:8*D-/+:-*:

9: '$& '2&:77.D.*H:!!&&"& ((    (((7&,#B&"&8..9:

H:  !' !' #'# '&" F ?&'"  '  88 ,#B&"& 8..9:  ;&""'"!&""C#CD$#,'D!>&B'"!#""?&'" &&I' &"'&&''>:

-: D>D!>;'"!#","F# #'#<&#$;<&:

" $ 

7: D&':8*!",##&&">&?<?&#B!E?&!,"!  B"" &B"B''"B""'#7H#>&7++G@2A '&#B"<& 7&;B"&8... &=<?&!#&"B!&:!&C!;!"'!' ?J!&&?&''"!!&'"$?&'<&@&':788'78G ! "B"3 A  ;<""B!&!?#''D&':HG:7!",##&& ?&#B!E ?&!,"!  8* ;" 7+-8 @A  !"' $ =B  &">

    58*-58..9 G5/  

'!&!"?"7&!K'8..G !"' ?&=CD,,"&"  #'#'&"@&':7/8 A F#'&D!,,"?&'<&> # &#?&'"'"!#'&"#?&;<"B!&:

8: (!D&':882@!B'&B"<&?"7&;B"&8...A   "B!&   ?&''"!  !&'" C" &'  &"< !' ?&'<# !,!&#' F&':788 78G 7/7'7/8 L&':G$* 2D??"C' ?&!<"!''$'&,#&&@:7A:!&)C!;!"' ?&''"! !&'"$?&'<&!&&?!$",,#&'&?&''"!!&'" <'#  B!"&  ">& ?< F"'' #B''  !'  "B!&  '  ?&''"!!&'" <'#B!"&">&?<F"''#B'' !'!"!&"<@,:&':8/2A:!& !;!' $  ?&''"!  !&'" ' $ DB!"&  ">& ?< F"''  !'   !"!  &"<  "'#&I'   !'  "B!& @ 2 78-  8G.L 278+///A:

 J?=   ;<  ?&"=& "'  !&!#  ?&'< ?& !"'"#  ?&''"!  !&'" C" &'  &"< ?&  &:  ' ?&'"'!' J?&' &"< 7+-9 J'&?&' 8..9 '$C;<'"B!&'BF#'!"&:

G: (!  !' ?&!"'   ?&''"! C" ?'  &"< ?&  &'2&:77.D.*H:'"CC"?&&'  2&: 8*D-/+:-*   "'#&I' E' #;$ #'# # ?&  "'"''"!  ?&#B!E#,&: ""&!"'$!F3#?!!'' 2&:D.8-:-. '"CD"!"'2&:78D+8/:+*!&'CJ'#,""'"B &C"!"'$!F3#?!!''2&:/8D7.G:+.:

/: !,!&#' $  ;&"?&  ?"  ;!& #'&"' ?!&  ?&'< ;CD!''&,&'?&''"!!&'"!& !;!"' "B!&#>##,"""&''?&''"!&!"'$"'#&I'!?'!"&& !''3": "'#&I'!'#'F""#<!D&':78 D!&!&?&#B!E?&!,"!B"" &B"B''"B""'#  7- B&" 7+-/ @ 8A ! !  'F &#<'"&  " "3" ' ?#&"& @ 2!?>"#G95.87-;"'8..GA

*:  #!'  & ?&M   ?&!#& #'' <&'"' @&': HG : 8  ' -+1:7!"&?&!#&""'&'"B78?'>&7+-*A:



    58*-58..9 /5/  

  $ * #  !"# "$"#  " $ #

(

+,-.-   / 0 1-- -  023 4 #$56

7: B"' ((   ((($'&,#&& !?'!"&    !  2&: /8D7.G:+. $  2    %    2     (   (  ((   (  3(  4  (  ( 5!           1  ( 16  ,B&:

8: B"' ((   ((($B&& ?!''  "'#&I'!?'!"&!"#&' =8..9;CD !''&,&':

G: JE!''C>!":

/: "'C?&!#&'<&'"':

*: ,!&  ?&'"   CD ?B' ,!&& &!& !'&  ?&#' &&I'   #"  G. ;!& =  !'","'"! ?& ?" &!# &#  &"> ,##&  &  ()N"O&)!,C" 9  9../     '&!" F?"&:  #"  ?' I'& ?&!!<#:  #!"& !"' P A ""C& F'' C #""!  &!&' #"& !>'"&  " ' ?   #""!''C#L>AF?!&?!&C!'","'"?!B!"&&'' '&#""!LA?!&'&"<'&!!&?&#'':("#!"&  !'"' ?  '&!" ##' ##&# ! ''& A >A ' A "3   &">,##&&?!&&?'&&'"=&&&!&CD" B&#&&"&&B>:#!"&&!&'"!&!&!E  ?&B  C" &!' ;!"'  "" C  #""! ''C# ' DB!??  C#'#F?#"#&!&'@&':7G8 7.9'7.-A: <&,,"=&  &#"'P       "22 Q&"( Q 

!?"!,!&?&#'&&I''!'","#F?&'"""CJ$J,,",##& &!"?&<&,,

    58*-58..9