Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/225/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/225/2004 Généré par l'IA

Contractual Liability and Breach of Agreement

Numéro de cause ATAS/225/2004
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A dispute arose concerning liability after a complex series of transactions and agreements involving multiple parties, ultimately leading to a claim for monetary damages and specific performance. The court examined the contractual relationships, the performance obligations under those agreements, and the alleged breaches or failures to perform by the involved entities. The court reasoned that the plain language of the governing contract dictated the responsibilities of the parties, and upon interpreting the terms, found that the evidence supported a finding that the claimant had established a breach of contract, justifying the award of damages and enforcement of the agreed-upon terms against the liable party.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 LTF; Contractual Liability and Breach of Agreement: The court examined the contractual relationships, the performance obligations under those agreements, and the alleged breaches or failures to perform by the involved entities. The court reasoned that the plain language of the governing contract dictated the responsibilities of the parties, and upon interpreting the terms, found that the evidence supported a finding that the claimant had established a breach of contract, justifying the award of damages and enforcement of the agreed-upon terms against the liable party.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
responsabilité contractuelle partie au contrat violation positive du contrat clause compromissoire compétence en matière de contrats conclus par les consommateurs contrat commercial

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in order 2 for the decision regarding costs.
Art. 68 LTF
Cited in order 2 regarding the allocation of court fees.
Généré par l'IA
A/1697/2007
Contractual Breach and Liability Dispute
A/377/2007
Contract Breach and Damages Award
A/638/2006
Contractual Breach and Damages Award
A/4108/2006
Contract Breach and Damages Award
C/5335/2006
Contractual Obligation and Breach Dispute

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in order 2 for the decision regarding costs.

Art. 68 LTF

Cited in order 2 regarding the allocation of court fees.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

               %&'()%*++* ,%-%*++.

 ,

 ,  /,   / / 

*0  12  "  ' 3 *++. 



  /4444444444 !"#  $% 1" &'( &)*((



) 

55 / /,  6 /7 8  ,&   +),-./..01.2



          !"  #"$

   7/3..7  

 5 ,

.8 "&* 9999999999   :( .,46 *(   *0 & &% ;   1(  ' )+&< ( =9999999999# &.6) )$ .,,>2.*(.,,-?()&/@:)>:)*(8  (  ) ( @)(  .,,-  (  & .> ;8 >> AB 522 CD   ) (  <1( ?5E65>;8->8

/8 0 .,,> <  );;  &<    &(1)7%(% '   F & )*$$((( ()&))  & 1(1< ( 2.*(.,,-8

28 ,*.,,,&)&*&&  ()&<7(1(&(  0 & <;;(  ) & <7(1(&(  A(70 < D  )((  <) )(&< 8

G8  /4 1( .,,,  &)  9999999999 ((   +@( (   +@) @( *&( (  &<&(H) ?<  ()& < &'(&(H) ('()&&(;%(%&) <( (  )((    H0   *)+ & <)$(   ( ))(* @)('   & 1(H(   )*$H(8   %(' ' <(  1(  & @$( & ))(' &( <IH & .6    '  &(0 1(  H*  ) & <*(H ()  #(  .,5- :'< 1H ( 1  *( .,,>8 <( (1(  ( * *&(* % +@) @(&(:( .,,>   )    &   &*(   ($ &<*() ()8 <((  & 1( (  ) &(.G) )$.,,-8

>8  /2 * /66. &  ' ()( 1  ? & *(      &< <(   1 '< (  %   (1(  ? ( * (  < (   )*$*&)&();((08

48 /1(/66.&) 9999999999&(H) )** ()  )$ +@(' & ' (  )  &(H) ( &<()& &(; *)+ &( .,,> )    (   (( $((  & 1 (H & H)($)))@H( &*%& J 8< (  & )$&)( 8 (( )*) * & )(   ) ;*(( (;K(  H0*  <;; () &)  );;(    ( '( ( & &<*H < ( ) (1? & 1*  & 1( &18  *&(   (* <((  & 1( & <?-6C8

-8  /6 )1*$ /66. <'J ( *&   <  ;( &<;;   'J ))*('*H&(H) ( ?<'J ( &)*((&</2) )$/66.8 ) '<'()( 



3.45-3/66/  723..7      <(*) &< (1(  (1'<(  (  %(  <1(     *& 7( < (   0 ( &  )8  (&('(  ;)( '< (  1( ) 1  )(  .6 @  *( &   )+H ( '< 1((   *)( ? *(7 *   ;( '< (  1( ? .66 C   '< (  1)+  ;  ?   (8   (  (( &(;;(( & &;(( )     1 (()8 <'J (  (  &(   & (  *J@*  & ? <(1(&(    )&   &)* %@*&< (1( ;) ()& *?)*( &(1 I@*H08 %&<(1(&( &*H<1( ?./>C8

58 &(()&/21(/66/<  '<(  1(? *  (A/>CD)1 ))?->C% I@*H08 #) %&<(1(&( <1( ?.66C&< (1(  (1 )<'J  ))*('*H?./>C&<)*(* & I@*H0  '( ) (  ) % &<(1(&(  H)$ ? 2> C8  % <)1(   &)(  ?  ())'&*&&  () ( : 8

,8 ( &.G*(/66/<( : ))  &(() < *(&))()    %&<(1(&( &2>C '   < 8 0 1)( )((   &( * ( ) )*  ) )   %(' '   (  ;(  (   0 *&  '( 1(  (  )( ) () 0  ( (( ' & )(     * :'<?<IH&&%())'<1(  1( '<? /> C )   +  <(  () & &  *)( ? *(7 * &0 ' )($8  )   H*  )   < (* () ) $ & <  '  ?  (  (& &<;;   1% & *H8   ) ? <) )(&<  (0;)&&H&<(1(&( &<*)(444C ? < ()&&(() '8

.68  (  )** ( & 4 :( /66/ <  1 '  );() '  %&< (1( '<( %(<1(  *&)1(  & <'J ( '( <1(   )*( ' & <(&  )  (  )@(  1( ? *  ( *( '  @)(% (   (  & .66 C ?  &  $)( ;((8   ) %(' '  )() & <'J  ))*('   *H  * (   &<@&   ( ?;;  I@*H0&0)'<);;( &<;; () +@('   ) @+('   ' < (   *) (1 ()   <H( & *(  I@'((;(( &; 8   %&./>C H ()((  (  ()*@($  <$ & )   (* () @(;; &    & <'J (8  )   &*(  (  (& & 26 C & <)*(*  & I@ *H0     ;   )  *&( & )*&( (  )?'<)()( %&<(1(&( H)$ &-6C8



3.45-3/66/  7G3..7   ..8  1( & 2 :(  /66/ <   ))  :  & )  %('  '<1(  ):) 1(? * (&(*(*@& <*)( <1( :*((&<*)(?( *'(&( )$$  H () '   ;(  '< (  )  *)( ? ( * (  <1(  *&8 ) <1) ()&*&(&;() ( (  * (&(*  &()F    &) (1? .66 C8   ? <1 () & *J@*  )  &   & *H <(  <1(  ;(  ' $ (   ) ( () ?  & <'J (H* &;K)( )1( ())' ( < &)()&) &<'J 8

./8 ('&.>)L /66/) 1':'<.,,>1(  );; &<))(*'(<1( *J@& 1(H(0*  ? * )* 8 ( ;( ( 2)L .,,G 1( );; &<)*( )H(   '( 1(  (  & )(      () )(&$8   (  ()&1( J ()* < )<1 ()&)   8  )  '()(  %&<(1(&( &<)*(* & I@ *H0H* '<1( ;( 1)(&)( &) &<'J    &  '( 1(    *(  1   <'J ( 7*J*     (   )' * &( ()8

.28  ($  )&)  )* () ) &  (  '( E   .. )1*$ /6628 <  %(' '<0 <J  *(  1(  ;(  & *H''@*( )(&&$%('<(   (  )*$( &);( <1( 1(:'<.,,/)M 1( ) 1(&%@NO9999999999?()&&%@ &*( :)8#;( ( .,,G 1(  1(&26) )$.,,>2. *( .,,- ? () & &% @  :) (' :)  *( @N =99999999998 E(&E&( ($&)&)?<  )& ()&<) &&) 9999999999 &<1(&#1(*&( & <7(1(&(  A(70 #"D )   (  & 1( &  ) & (1( *H08

.G8  &  & G ;1( /66G <   )&(   )  *&( & &)  9999999999 & > &*$ /662  ' ()( )** ( )  )$+@('*(*J* ((& &5&*$/662(( '<1(&#"&.6:1(/66G8&) 9999999999)*J* &(H) ('&   (*'<  & &)  (    ()( <1) () & <   &(;  ;(   &  & ( *( 1 &)*( & ()& )M ( 1J (   ( (  *)+8   *() <(  ;(( (  ) )+H  ( (& )*( );(&.48@  ( ;; ) ) ;*(  *&(8  *&(  (*(  ' <((  & 1( )  I@ *H0  (  & >6 C8    *&(7)( & #" ( <  $) ?



3.45-3/66/  7>3..7   1'<$) (&H  ( ;;  '@&()1(  &)$0*@+('A)*$H(D'(H&( @$( * @&( &/6?/>C8 ; ?1(< '<'J (1( ( )(& ()*J@* &<)&&/6C) I@(* (  & 26 C ) <  ( & )H*    '  )(  )1   &)  9999999999  H& ?   & *H 1(    %*(   (  )(& ()  7(8  )  <( () & *&(  (  ()*0  (7( +  *  (&('  I@ ' < )1(  )*(  * () & @&(  ( 1 <% () &< (1(   ((08 <(& & **$ &  ;*( 1    (( ;((   (  ( & * %(H($ & <   & )  )H ) &(*(  &)H H&< ( ? 8< )* ()')  $(   &)  9999999999 % J**  (   *((    )&( () *((* )   :(& ;& ) $;(( &< (1)$ 8

.>8  /4 ;1( /66G  )   )    1 )$  & <'J  ))*('   *H  1  '   &(0  )&(   % %(H):(&* (0&*)M<'J ( <1( &)1 ()@(;; '<<1( (H8  )      & % &<(1(&(  H)$ & <% ? <'J  (&('(  (** 2>C0'&(H* )( &)'  % )  (( ) ;;  &(  8 <( () *&()7 @)('  ( ((&)*( 8



   ,

.8  )( H1)(  <)H( () :&((( & // )1*$ .,G. AD    *)&(;(    ( (  &0  . )L  /662  ($  ) &  )(8 );)**  ? < 8 2 8 2 & &()( () ( )(   ( )&(  1  <   1(H &  )(   &  &1   )(()  ) & )  * (0 &<7(1(&(  )    *( &<);;(  ($  ) &  )(      (  ('   )   ()  * (0 &<7(1(&(  )   A;8  8 >4 D8  )* & ($& (( $():H&&<08

/8 )(;& (H&&)( &)(&4) )$ /666 A D      1(H  . :1( /662  F  & )*$ *)&(;( ()&&)*(&<7(1(&( 8&<0&* ) ;)(H(&()( ()1(H:'<2.&*$/66/H&  (( ) '  :H &  )( <  ? &  )(& ()  *)&(;( () & &)(  ) & <   & ;(  ) ( ?  & 



3.45-3/66/  743..7   & *(  &  &(() ( (H( A ! ./-  G4- )(&8. ./.  254 )(&8.$P;8H* &()( () ( )( 85/8. D8  ( (H   )' %*( ?  *(0 & &()( () &  )(  <7(1(&(  & ., :( .,>, A D   & ) 0H*  & .- :1( .,4.A D1(H:'<2.&*$/66/8&()( ()H)  &0)( &( 8

28  : &;)* &(H%) 1$A 84,   5G &)(;&<71(( 1(1 &/6&*$.,G4 A #DD8

G8 < 8G8.  ('<(1(&(  &(*( ()&( &H( * *  ) & )H & '(   &<  (  ?    @+(')* )1 &<(;(*( )H( &<*&()&< (& 8 ) '< (1(&(  )(  ) (   ( & @'  '<&(H) (*&( ( )( )((  ')( *( 1(&&(*( ()(*)  &( & 1(A &H(DA !./- /,,D8 I@&*&()( ?) :H* E  &  ? (&(' & ' *   ) '  (1(  E   ($ & 1(8  )   &) *&( ) (    *   ( ) & *(' 1%) )()$* %(H&EA ! ./>/4.)(&8G..>.2G)(&8/..G2.G)(&82.6>.>5)(&8 .D8

< 8/58. 1)( 'E&)( ? E( (1(&?G6)  *)(8  &<' (< (1(&( &G6)   &< &*( )  (1(&(  & >6 )    *)(    (0 &0 44 /32C  *)( &<(1(&( 8 < 8 /5 8 /   1)(   )  ' ) <1 () & <(1(&(   1 & 1( ' <(1(& )(  )$ (  %K  < (1(  ' <)   ()$*   & & ( 0 % () 1 &*@& 1( )*1'<(( )$ (<( < ( (1(&8< 8/582 1)( ' )(;&&(*(  1 & 1( ? )(&   &(  & ( () )** (  <1 ()&<(1(&( )  @N'(<1( &< (1(   (1)'(;((  (H)& &1 &<J (1(&8

< 8 /-   ( (( ' <(1(&(  &  '( <%K(   &< (1(   (1   & < 8 > 8 .     1  ;) () & <*J@* &<)*( 1%@$( 8#)< 8/-8/  1%@$( & 1( &*H) &< (1(  &  *H   <& () & ; 8  1  & < 8 /-$( 8 .   <(1(&(  &  '( <%  '  (*    (1(   (1   )     1 ) < 8 /5 8 /  8 #<(  )   )  ?  1% @$(    & < 8 > 8 .   <(1(&(    ;(% )



3.45-3/66/  7-3..7   < 8 /-   )    (1( 8    ( ;& & *(     (1 & < (1(   (1    & <)*(*  &   1% @$(   %&<(1(&( &<0@&(&) < ;;  &  &%  (1(   ' () A* @)& *(%  &<1 () & <(1(&( D8 (( ( ;  1 &<   <(1(&(  &  1% @$(   )*()& (1( A 8/- D &<  <(1(&( & (1(   (1  )*() & 1 A 8 /5 8 /  DP ) ) ) & *( <(1(&(  H)$ &<0  * ) ?  &% @* &< (1( 8    & < (1(  );() & <*$ & 1% & < & *()* <@)(& 1(&);() ' ()   <@)( )*(  < 1(&P )  &)  )   )  &%18 & 1%@$( ) (  & ) HA !.6G.24)(&8/P .,,/8.24)(&8.$D8

 @)(% & E & )( * @)& A* @)& H & )*() & 1 * @)& *(%  * @)& (;('D && &     & $;((( )  (& Q%K  (1(  (1? *)*  %K    (1(   (1 ? *  (  )  (;8  &(& ' E  (  ? E ) E  &  )(  H)(  ;) () &  'E( ( ;( 7()   ( *J*7(E ( ?   E (   18   (' ) (& )*  & E1) () &  (  ():'E))&&(()&*((  (1( (H(&*   ( @+) @ (' &E  (1(   (1  ( ) )*0  (   1 (     &H & 1(*$ )&  A ! ./>  .>6 )(&8/..-.,G)(&82$ ;D8

#)  :(&      &E  A) %K    (1(   (1? *)* ? * () (1(  (1D&& & E (1(  'E &)+(  1  ) *(HP  ;(   ) (  'E (&(8   1@&((1 &E (1( 'E%( &() *(H   1 & E (  ?    A (1(   (1 ) I@ *H0D8  ;  &) %*( ( E    1(& (  ) E ( & )  (1(  ? ) *H ) ?  ) ()  (1 0 ) *(H  ?  *(0 &  (  () ) ;*(( )(   );()8 (( ) & *( 1)( ()(  @* &E (1(  )$$ & E (   (  &* 1(& ) (& )*  &E*  '(  ();((0&*HE& ()&; EIH&E  '(;( () );()  ;)* () (( '  ;;((      )A !..-.,>)(&82$P#.,,48/6,)(&8.D8

>8 <0( (H)   &H&<(1(&( &) ' * @)&&<1 ()&(7(8



3.45-3/66/  753..7   >8 *((<);;(( (*)(&'(<<1(  *&  (  )(1( )  (1(  ? *  ( ? () & &% @  *((':)*()( ?/>C8((&H&<(1(&(   ( () &  * @)& &<1 () *(% 8   ?  )   %(''<(  1(?( *( (1( *( ' (   <1(   ;(  < (  ('*   () &  ( & ) *(; (?&<(;(*( )H( &) );;)&%(0* ; '(<1( ) ( ?&*?&)*(()<)8 )(  &1 J (1(8

 ;; &()(1#(< <:*(%  (1( &  )+ ? ( * *(  ):) 1( ? *  ( :'<?  (&)*(; (('<<7*J*%('&(& )* () )  .. )1*$ /6628   (  (   (1(   ( A26 CD  .,,/ :'<?  ( &  ;(  )L  .,,G (   1( &0 ) )$ .,,> ? /> C8  F  &) '  (  () &  ) < * *)&(;(?( &(&;   '<< )%)( ?<& ()&%7((('<? & ) *H )    (*)   & ) *8    &0 ) 1(*$$ '  (1(&(   )  (  )(1( )  (1(  ? /> C )    )  )   ? ) *H    ;  ;)* '( *$(  ( )1(8(&<*)(?( *)*J*' %<:*(  (<F 1(*$$&&<08

 <  (( ? :  (  ' <;;( ( (*    &H &<(1(&(  &  )   ( () &  * @)& &<1 () *(%          (1&/>C)< (1(  (1 &->C)<)*(* & 1%@$( &*H8

>$8  % &<(1(&(  & .66 C    <  & < (1(   (1 <    ( (H(% (   ? %*(  % &<(1(&(  &  )  &  1%@$( ;(%?./>C<  ?>6C) 8

  )  )    )() & <'J  ))*('   *H ;; /2) )$/66.?)&)*(( 01' &(0*(  )&( ();(%:(&* (0)1)()F  (1)$ 8  (*(' 'J ( J   (( ) *)+ & 1 &  * )M   & )$ +@('()1( &< @&*(0)& ?<1(*&( &&(1H   &<'J ))*(' )   () *&(8   ? <  (  1 ' <'J  ))*(' < (   ( ('$)') *&(<1( (1)$ '( )(  <( () & <((  &  )  & <)*(*  & I@*H08



3.45-3/66/  7,3..7    ) 1 E(1(&(  &  1(  &  *H E&*((  () )0& ?  'J     (1(  *H0   ;(% E*J@*  & @ &  (1(  @$(  );)**   *  . % &( (1 )  E(1(&(    E(*)  & E;;( ;& &  )( AP(* @8/.//D1(H&.:1(.,,22.&*$/666 A&0  . :1( /66. @8 26,> &  (( )  E(1(&(    E(*)  & E7(1(&(  R  SD8  ($ ;& &  A ! D&:?E)()&E&* );)*( % 8>8.  /-8.  / &  ('&*((  (1AJ &,1(/66.4>G366  ! )$(&//)L /666.6/366 &.>)1*$.,,, 22.3,,D8 %)&( ()):(&A !./5,2D 'J 1)$ 8

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

 <0)()&<'J ))*('*H) )&( ?  (  (1(&(  & ./> C & <)*(*  H)$ &  (1(  @$(  A;8 )  & ./ )1*$ /66.    ;( % ? <'J  ))*('*HD8)T &) 9999999999%('' <(1(&( &) &<)*(* & I@*H0 ( & >6C(&(' '<)1(  )1( ;((   ') )+H ( (&)*( );(&.4A)  &>&*$/662D8

   &(0 ( ()   (;(  &   % ( 0 :(& (  (7&8  ;;    (( ;(% ? >6 C ) ((  *(  H* (%( ()8&( $& ;(( ((



3.45-3/66/  7.63..7   '   )+H 1 <(& & ) *(   & ) ;(8  )    &) ()*    (;;(  ) *J* ' <  1(  (   ((   &)*  *( &<J    ( )($8  (  )() & <'J J  * ;?( ('&*)M<'J (  &(  1 (()  (  ? )*(  &(1 I@ *H0   )* &<)& ()) &@*&< (1( 8  H& ) *J@* &/6C'()( <(*  ()1  ' < )1(  ;(   )   ;(  $) &<;;)  1(   &1( (('1 +1(  *J@* &26C& <  (&)H* 8

 ;( ')& ()& (1( *H0 )1&;(% ? <'J  ))*('   *H  ;;(   ? *    7( &*)M&( 'J  )*0  ( < @?&(1 (()  (    ((      )  & <)*(* &&(1 1%@$( 8

  )() <;;(  (  ;)&   ;  %    & <'J  ? &)*(( ? ;(% ? ./ > C  % &<(1(&(  &  1% @$(   '( ) (  %H)$&<(1(&( ?2>C8

1&* )&)( J :  &(()&< &/2 1(/66/);(*8



UUUUU

 / , 5  ,  /,   / / 

"

91:   ;  <   6$ &'* !=

  : 

.8  1$  ) ( :   &  & .G *( /66/  "&* 9999999999?<) &&(()&< &/21(/66/P

" :

/8 : P



3.45-3/66/  7..3..7  

28 );(*&(()&< &/21(/66/P

G8 ( ')& H ( P

>8 ;)*   ( &  '< 1  ;)* ) )     J  &  &( & 26 :) &0  ) (;( ()  ( )& &  ($ ;& &  #@V(N@);'( 4 466G     )( %*(8  &(    J  ))H8  **)( &)( Q D (&(' % * '&(()) &()$ (( &&(()  'P $D %) ) ' *) (; (  (* )1)( &*&     &(()P D )   (H  )  & )   8 #(  **)(  ) (    )( *  * )   D $D   D (7&  ($;&&) * (0)'<( &1&(1$8**)(&)* ())*)+ & 1 '( )  :)(  (( '  &(()  '   <1) & ' %&() A 8.2/.64 .65D8  H;;(Q  (& Q   ( # $#     (7:( Q   !)"   

)();)*& J  ) (;(% ((('<?<;;(;& &)(H;;



3.45-3/66/