Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/185/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/185/2006 Généré par l'IA

Appellant's Disclosures on Trust Assets: Admission vs. Waiver of Privilege

Numéro de cause ATAS/185/2006
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Frais judiciaires à la charge de l'autorité
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The appellate court considered whether certain disclosures made by the appellant, who was a party to an ongoing financial dispute involving trust assets, were sufficiently specific to constitute an admission of liability or a waiver of privilege regarding those assets. The court reasoned that the vague statements and general references to financial arrangements, while potentially relevant to the underlying matter, did not meet the requisite standard of clarity or specificity to be interpreted as an unequivocal admission or a knowing abandonment of legal protections concerning the specific trusts at issue, thereby affirming the lower court's finding that no such admission or waiver had occurred.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Appellant's Disclosures on Trust Assets: Admission vs. Waiver of Privilege: The court reasoned that the vague statements and general references to financial arrangements, while potentially relevant to the underlying matter, did not meet the requisite standard of clarity or specificity to be interpreted as an unequivocal admission or a knowing abandonment of legal protections concerning the specific trusts at issue, thereby affirming the lower court's finding that no such admission or waiver had occurred.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
privilège de responsabilité dispense de motivation trust objet du litige fortune obligation de renseigner

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive to rule on the procedural costs of the appeal.
Art. 64 LTF
Cited in the dispositive regarding the assignment of costs for legal aid.
Généré par l'IA
P/4302/2012
Appellate Decision on Fraud and Breach of Trust Conviction
P/23758/2014
Appellant's Breach of Trust Conviction Upheld in Financial Misappropriation Case
C/7970/2006
Estate Liquidators v. Asset Management Corporation Regarding Trust Documentation
A/2172/2005
Admissibility of Unauthenticated Admissions Against Interest
P/16057/2006
Appellant v. Former Associate: Breach of Trust and Asset Misappropriation

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to rule on the procedural costs of the appeal.

Art. 64 LTF

Cited in the dispositive regarding the assignment of costs for legal aid.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

   

#$%&'#())* +#',*#())-

+

! +! .+"  !. ".

./  '

 (' 01 ())-

  

 !!!!!!!!!! "

"

##      #    $   "./ % "&" '($  )" +,$ -*--    *

            !" 

3 *01 3

 2+

-4  !!!!!!!!!! 5" /"  *+ 6 *((' 7 588 " % 5.) 93):  ; "  "/ 5" %5%."/ % 53<=.> %:  - ?" *(('4   %@/ 6 "6/  %   6 %  /"/ A!!!!!!!!!! # 93):  /"/; % - ?6 *((,  ,( ? *(('4  6" /"/ / )  .)B  *C 6 *((' 6 88"  ,( ? *(('

) %  /.@4   )// @5 /"" "  >" % .. 9 ;  "" @5%."" %  /"/$ "" %  >" %6% %)  * ?" *((-4  6" 8./  .)B$ )  % *D 6 *(('$ @5 %/." %  )" %5%.""4

5)"   5 )%" /"/ %/ @5 6 *((24

#  8. .) )  . % ?" 7 6.& *((' "  """" % > "./% B "6$  " )) @ 5"// 6"

"6/ ): %  /"/ %"  )/% % "=4

*4  %/ % -1 %/.& *(('$ 5  ?"/  %.% %5%."/$ %/" @ %"  %E  )//%"  )"$ 5"// 6"

"6/ )  /"/ %"  /"" 7  8 5.)B/ " 5%.""$ " ) @  6"  " "/ 7 "6$ ):  ."$  > "./%4

,4 5"//  8./ ))" 7 %" %/  -1 ?6 *((24   E)@/ @

3 F?   ) %."" % "" /"/ 9<> @ ?56 )"/  % 5>>." ) &" . .);$

3  8" %   %" 5>> @  /"/ @  %  )" % "" 5 ) 8"  /$

3 .. 7  ?  5  /"/ 8"$ ?5/ %"."   ) %.% . %"$

3 ?  )6 ) 8 %588" % > "./%F4

'4 # %.% % 5 $ 5"//  )%"  E"" % .)" %6% % "" ): %   % .)" G 3  $  @   /"/ / %  /"/ % 8/6 7 %/.& *((* " % ?6 7 %/.& *((,$  %  /)$ B" "6/  @"/ % .)"& 7  % *(H )  /"/ % ?" 7 "& *(('$  @  ):36& % 5.&/ >// % " %  /"/ %"/ % -2 . *(('$  >/$   % @  6" 8./  %/. % )" %5%.""$  !!!!!!!!!!  /%"4

0,1+-0*((2

3 ,01 3

  )  )// @5 6" )/"/ 7 "" 8% +DH % " " @5 6" /%/  "  %  %/. %  8" %5%.""4

5 5" >/ ): %  /"/ I!!!!!!!!!! #7$ 8% %  /"/$ "  &"  8." @  5"//   /)  )/%"

) %5" %  /"/ @ 5"// 6" %/" 7 "" 8% ?@5 -D . *(('4

24  %/ % *1 )".& *((2$   " >6 % <=.>  )"." %. 5))" % 5"//$ %/" @ 3 )6"  6 6  %" E %."/ 7 .)" % *- 6 *((2$ B" /"/ /"& @5  %/"" ) 7 "" %" % )")" 8: %  /"/4 """

 6< @5):  ." )  /.@ 6 88"  ,( ? *(('$  6" "/ 7 )6  "6"/   % %" /"/  > "./% 7 ""  . ?@5 6.& *(('$   8./ @5  )6" ) )/"% 7 5%."/ % <=.>  %  )"  - ?"

*(('4

C4 5"//  "?"/   *C "& *((2 " %" %/4  :6 @ 5"6"/ "./% @5  E/ ): %  /"/  /"/ 88"/ 6  "." % 5 4  ""  %& @"/ %5.)B " %5.)B/$ >" @  /"/   6" ?. ))" )@  " %/" 5/"" 7 "" 8%4

14 6"/ 7  %/".$ 5  "/>." )"/ %  %/  ))" % *1 )".& *((24

D4  )" " /"/ "% )  & % /  ,- ?6 *((C4  "  )// @ J

F /"/  /"/ //  ?" *((- ) % . ."%" " .3.K.4 5 )/)/  )?" " E 5" 8/4 5 %L )"  .%" %5%."" ) @5 6" @ ? ) >> . )&"/4  "" % "6 5 /"/  @  - ? *((* ) @ ?5/"   &//8 %5 %/3% % 53<=.> 9> "./%;4  /"/ ?5  "6/  6 %  /"/ %) 8/6 *((*4

  "< %3)"</"4  /" %E 7 "6  @"/ % "<$ 5" ) /""  &//8 %5 %)=.$ ) .4

 !!!!!!!!!! /""  )/"" % "$  /"" />."

5 %  /"/4 5"  @ 5)" %  >" %  /"/4  . "" % >  %." .)""4 5"  @ " %/%/ ) E.) % 5>>." % ) ))/."4 5  . ." 7 % "."   <E %  )$  @"/ )84

0,1+-0*((2

3 '01 3

 ?" *((-$ %" %  /" %  /"/ 7 8/6 *((*$ ? 5 E/  "6"/   %  /"/4  8"  5E"" )  /."

9) % E$ "4;4

): . ." ?5 "/ 7 "6 )  /"/ .. "<$ .  > "./%4 56 & % " .) ) @ ? <" &"  %)=.4 5  "6/  ) . %5 .3".)4 5" ) 5 ) /"/ /$ ) @  /"/ 6" & %5 "< %)=./4

 6   %  %/.& *((2$  !!!!!!!!!!$ !!!!!!!!!! " .3.K.4 5 <"/  &" %  /"/ " ? .  .

7 . .)" %) ?6 *((C4 5 7 )/" %5" " @   /"/ A!!!!!!!!!!4

"  .." M ?5 %/ . %/. .. %."" 96 *(('; "

 %"  >" % .. 96 *((2;$   .5 ) /"/ %.%/ % > % %." )  /"/$ "" .)." ) @5 5B  6" ) &4    )  @  " )/   %/ /"" . "6" 6" %L K" ) %" "" )/%4

 E)" .5" %.%/ "  "//) @ ?5 %/ 7    *' . *((2 %)  /"/4  5/.> 7  .."37 ) % <=.> " ?56 ../ 7 "6 )  /"/ 7 ) ".)$  ?@57 %/.& *((2F4

+4 # @    /"/ >%/ 7 ?>4

 "+

-4   >6  N>" ?% 9;  /"/ .%8/ "  ""/$ %:  - L" *((,$  & " %  $ .)/ % 2 ?>$ %"  )/%" "  63)/%"$ 2 ))/" " -C ?>  9"4 - "4  " 2C ;4

#" 7 N" % N/" % -C ?> $ )  & 8/%/  *1 ?6 *((' 9 G -,(  -(C;$  %  >6  %)"/$  -, 8/6$  %)" "" >" )."""  & " %   % />   7 " ?> ""$ $ % N""" % N/" % 6E ?> 4

*4 8./." 7 5"4 2C  4 - "4  <4 D $  & " %   O"  " @ % """ )/6 7 N"4 2C

0,1+-0*((2

3 201 3

%   8/%/   )" >// % %" %   % C "& *((( 9 ; @ " "6 7   8/%/  N3<=.> &>" " N%."/   %N6&"/ % *2 ? -+D* 9 ;4

# .)/" ) ?> %  %N): "  /"&4

"?"/ %  %/ " 8. />E$   " 6& 9"4 2C " C( 9 P # D,(4-; " '+ 4 * %   >6  .": % <=.> 9#  * *(;4

,4 5/  %" 7 5%."/ % <=.> 5 "  .)  )"."  .) 9"4 D 4 - "4   ;4

E ". % N"4 ,- 4 , "4   $ N" ) %" 7 N%."/   % /%" % N< % "6$  ) @ 8E"  %/ @ )% N.)B P  )6"  8 %/&." P  @"/ %N/$ % ..& %N> %>" % N")   % %/"" %N )")" 8: 7 N")4

#  ?)%$  "6 @ ?" %N "" )8 .)& 7  %N .)B N ) %" 7 N%."/ @$ & @ / 8.." )  ")$  " 7 )%  %/ % N.)B  8 3 % .: %/"."4    "$  88"$  %/"" )  & %N %)"  N%."/ % <=.>  />.""  .": %N%."/   % /%" % N< % "6 9 G -*,  *,';4 " />%$  E"  /"" )/. "  %" 7 N%."/   % /%" % N< % "6 "  %" 7 N%."/ % <=.>4  " %.  :> >// @  ) @ "  %" % >" %6%  %"  )")" % N") N/:6 7 *(H  )$ " /)"/ ) EQ"  8   %/ % N.)B 9  #   (-0+*$ )4 ' R -C;4

 .)"." % N/ @ / 3.K.  ))" % "6  "" @ / P ""  6"  )" %N.)B P " @ )/"% " 7 % %."/ % <=.> 8 % ." % )/% % %88"/ % N") " % )6 )% "/."  "6"/ / %  ") @ " %NE"$ .."  & % %"    @N "  />.""  N%."/   % /%" % N< % "6$ @ E" " "/> % ) %  % B" %" 9 -++D$ R ,$ )4 D;4

"  )" 6/   %N/ %)" %N )6 / %  /"/ @$ ) % ." ./$ <<" 7 &" % %."/ 8 % ."  6  /"/ )%"  )/% /.@." %884

0,1+-0*((2

3 C01 3

 "" "  6< %88/" @  /  "6" %  )" .& 7  %N .)B @"" %/8"6." N")   %  8." % 3 S  )    " ) %N .)"." 6" 7 /%  & 84   6 % .K. @% N") " %NE"$ . @N " /$ ) " % /" %  ""$ .)" %/8"6." ""  6  /"/ 9 G -*,  *,';4

'4  5):$ 5"//  /"/ %."" %  /"/ %)  * ?" *((-4   %@/$  % 5% % .)" )$ @5 6" /"/ 7 5> %  /" % 3$ 6 % . ."%"4 % & .K.   5)" ) %"." %  >" %  /"/$ 8 " % "" @ 5"

 @$   @"/ %5%."" @$ "" %  >" %6%$ >"  %." .)""4  " 6 @  "" 58." %  ."$ %"/ % *C 6 *(('$  /"/ >/ )  !!!!!!!!!!$ )/"" % "4  5 " ) . 6 @5 6"   )&"/$ ""  .$ %58 % .: %/"."  %/ %  /"/4 5"// "  %  "/> % ) @ "  %& @"/ %5.)B " %5.)B/4

#  ?)% ."/$  )" %."" @  "" "

%88/"   / .)" %/8"6." ""  6  /"/ @ " %5E" ):  /" % ""4 $ 5"//  "6/ ?@5 6.& *((' )  /"/$  > "./%$ ) 7 ) ".) ?@57 %/.& *((24  O" 7 " />% @   %/ 6" %L K" ) )  /"/ ):  ."$ F  " )  @  " )/F4  " % %/" % 5"//$ "% )  & % /$ @5  @ @N  " >%/ 6  /"/ %  ": /""4 # )"   .. > %  /"/ " %/6 ) %/". 5 )  )" .& 7  %5 .)B/ 9K" % G --(0(,;S   %" % 5)" )." %5%.""  /@6@ @ 5/  @""/  /"/4   %" 5" "6  5): @5 6 *((24

 /@$ 5" 7 .)" % "" %" " %  . M   %/""

)  )")" 8: %  /"/$ @  %" 7 % %."/ % <=.> )" K" 6"4

  %/  ))" %"3 K" 8./ "   ?"/4

0,1+-0*((2

3 101 3

 . "+2  +! .+"  !. ".



340   5  6   78 '-( "9

  0 

-4 /   6&4

 0

*4  ?""4

,4 " @  )/% " >""4

'4 8.  )" %  @N )6" 8.  "  )/" K"

%  %/ % ,( ? %:  "8" ) ) ..%/ %/  & 8/%/ % $ #<TU<8@ C$ C(('   $  " E.)4  %/  )" K" )>/4  ./. %" J ; %@ E"." @ %/  " %/ &"   " ) %  %/ ""@/S &; E) ) @ ."8  ". )6 %.% "" " %/S ; )"  >"   %  )/""4 #  ./.  "" )  " //." /.//  "" ; &; " ; 3%$  & 8/%/ %   ) ) "  .":    @N %6 %/ 6&4  ./. %  ."   .B % )6$ @ " ?"$  @  %/ ""@/ " N6)) % @   /"/ E)/%/  " 9"4 -,*$ -(C " -(D ;4

 >88:  /%" J

3  V  W   

 ) 8. % )/" K" " "8/ E )" "  #/"" %N "" 7 N/. )  >88 

0,1+-0*((2