Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/172/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/172/2006 Généré par l'IA

Easement by Necessity and Timing of Severance

Numéro de cause ATAS/172/2006
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerns the proper construction and application of a statute addressing the unauthorized exercise of a right of way, where a party claimed an implied easement by necessity over the adjacent property for ingress and egress to their landlocked parcel, relying on the historical division of a larger tract. The court reasoned that an easement by necessity requires the necessity to exist at the time of the severance of the dominant and servient estates; since the claimant's parcel had an existing, though inconvenient, access route at the time of the original conveyance that would have been available but for subsequent acts of the claimant's predecessors, the strict necessity required for an implied easement was not met, thus denying the claimed right of way.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Easement by Necessity and Timing of Severance: The court reasoned that an easement by necessity requires the necessity to exist at the time of the severance of the dominant and servient estates; since the claimant's parcel had an existing, though inconvenient, access route at the time of the original conveyance that would have been available but for subsequent acts of the claimant's predecessors, the strict necessity required for an implied easement was not met, thus denying the claimed right of way.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
servitude construction illicite droit à la propriété partage de la propriété droit de visite théorie de la dissociation ; AA ; ACCIDENT ; CAUSALITÉ ; MALADIE ; MÉDICAMENT | LAA10;

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive section for ordering the appellant to pay the appeal costs.
Art. 68 al. 2 LTF
Cited in the dispositive section regarding the splitting of costs in the context of granting legal aid.
Art. 64 LTF
Cited in the dispositive section for granting the request for legal aid.
Généré par l'IA
A/466/2006
Easement by Implication of Necessity for Landlocked Parcel Following Severance
A/4369/2007
Right-of-Way Abandonment and Prescriptive Easement Claim
A/2378/2007
Easement Dispute and Obstruction of Access
A/288/2007
Easement Obstruction Dispute
C/27040/2011
Extinguishment of Agricultural Right-of-Way Servitudes and Denial of New Access Easement

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive section for ordering the appellant to pay the appeal costs.

Art. 68 al. 2 LTF

Cited in the dispositive section regarding the splitting of costs in the context of granting legal aid.

Art. 64 LTF

Cited in the dispositive section for granting the request for legal aid.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



               &'(()&'+ &,('&'-

##

 #  "   "  #   "

.  '

% ', /0 '- 



% 1111111111 



2 "   " 3     4#5 !!).   !"#"$%&'(

5 ! 5    "     //. 6    )!*!"%"%&+,- 

            !"# $%

   *%01*  

 4 

"3 '! 4444444444 5!*/,  6  .. -!!) 7 !   -!  )!  .)8 %&&" 9! !  .  !!   :-! !   !  !  /!  :; /  < * ! !! 7! 5!*/,< 63

%3 "=-!%&&%#" .)8%&&+.../7 8!;!  ! /,  >< <<  '   *    < ?5!*/,!6-@:! A&&@3/.%&&% %&&#/! "72&&@3/7.%&&+3

#3   7! 8;)!.B ). !)    C3   / /   -!  " =! %&&%  97D < )!@!D/!3

+3 )! =!%&&#   CD-.. .!-.3 /:)! .   .  @ D ><3 *!  /..   .)/%8%&&#!.)-) 7) +&A@3%&/ D@ ). !)3  !9    .  .)/ D >< -  )! )! E!  -!!D-!-><E3

23    "F -)8 %&&+ 7@@!  /!  !@!.    )) )  /G /! H &+ %+F&#1 ? /   )  +&A@3%&/@! ))!@! /!3

A3  .!! 1=-!%&&2><@!-!97//!! )) ).!-.3

13  .!! 1@.-!%&&2><!@).9 .)/  /! %8%&&#.!(9/:)!GB"F@.-! %&&+7!@)! < 9 !.!><-! /!D=!8 73"3%8 '@D:;3 /!!/!.;(I)/ @:!.! D:;  3

$3  !  %% =! %&&2  . D ><    .@, D  ..!)/G.9!!..!@!.A=!%&&2= 9! //9/!)@@.!D! .!!)/8D< 3

F3 !.. ./!))8= )/. !8  .3 J .! =!  .!!  //!!  A =! %&&2 / 9 ><@!)!9)).). /!)!..! =!@!.3



0%11+0%&&2  *#01*   "&3  /!  "F I %&&2    @!).  !8 9 >< -! /G./@9!!)8!D< 3/ !!  )'. ! :!;!  -!<  .9   C!-!../!! 7! 3

""3 ./ 1/)8%&&2><(/!9-!!. !  8 7 !  "F @.-! %&&+   <   . D  /:)!   7!@) 9 !! .! /! +=! %&&%  /.! 9  ). !) . -!   ;*.;!3 / -7!/ !/><! !9!97! .()! !9.! <  .!!9!!/)!  .)!3

"%3  .! )/.)!  %1 8 %&&2 >< ,- 9  !. /!   C=!%&&#7!  "% .)8 %&&" 7 / .8! >< 7G / !   /! 7!* !@))! =!@!  /!/!    C )) /!  7)3.-!!  .!! 732# =!@!! ,  /3  ! !!  =    D  -.  7//!!  )) ) /G)!.3

"#3  /!  " -)8 %&&2  !8  . 7  . D  <  ! ) !-!/!:;7! 8;  .)8 %&&"/!) ). !)!*!@))! 7@@!)!-=97D 9  (*! -! .. /!3  ! ! ! .! ) . !  < .! 7  / :;@!!;!3!@@  !9  C -!../!! 7G)/);! 7/:;!  D 7!;! 7!*!@))! !. D )  .9D7! 3

"+3 /! "A-)8%&&2< ! !9!/)!,3

"23  !8 .)/!/ /!9!7"# .)8%&&23 !! !9.-!.:   !  D  <    / 7(/!9 78  /!  :;  @/*!/!9). !-!@!).97!7;!! 7 ! 7! 3 ><  //. -! /G.  @  /:)!   /,-.!@!!/, < 9!!-!! !9.9 !.!  97 7!-! ! /3  !   E ! @)   !)  !E3

"A3   "F .)8%&&2 !8 .7//  < 3



0%11+0%&&2  *+01*   "13  !   !8 7  .  )K) = D  ) '. !  :!;!  -! <  ! /    4444444444  )!@  9 7!!-D/!/!   C! 7! 7.! / .3  9!  ! .! /.  -! !  /!/! @!! 8! !D: 7!  "% .)8%&&"3

"$3 ! "1=-!%&&A./ //< ,-9 !/ . - )  /!:;!. :3-!97!8..@!!. 7!)   C). !)  /! ;!9  %&&# /    !;)   /!  /!   ). !) 7.! E) !. D  7!* !@))!E   97! 7G  /  ! )K) ! !   .9  7!    !)  /! ;!93  !  =/!)/ 3

"F3    %+ =-! %&&A    ./.  ;@@  !8  ! )'. ! :!;!  -!<  F=-! %&&A!/ 44444444443<!.. !)/!  .8!) "% .)8%&&"F=! %&&#3 !!!../!   CD-!./! ! )8(!*!@))!97! -!/ 37!@!;  ! ! F=!%&&#3

%&3 /, ))!!   ) ( /! / /!  %1 =-! %&&A  !8; .D=;3

 # 

"3 !;-!L;!!= !!!56..) !@!.!!. , "I%&&# !8 !)/. 2=; /.! -!*/.! 2//."A=;53"3 2A 63

<!DL! L.! "A=;/ !8@. . %1=-!%&&+5 ?"#&"&A6  !;-! /."#@.-!  !/!!!!;/) !8  !  !.;   D ! =; !!   L  L.! -(=;3

%3 @).) D 73 2A  3 " 3  :3 +  2   !8   !M!!9 !/.-DL! 2A   9!  !- D  ! @. .  L*) !  "$) "FF+5!*/, '6!!97D!@. .L*!  %&) "F$"5!*/, 63



0%11+0%&&2  *201*   <)/./=;  L/,!!.8!3

#3 !@. ./!;..  ! ! A8 %&&&   ! @. .   /! ;..  !   ! 5 6  .  -!;  " =-! %&&# M  ) !@!!  )8 !/!! .;   )!   !3 <  /).!/! -!9 !7//!9 !K:.D)!, /!!/9,;//!8-!;))N @!=! !9) .)!/ !5 ?"#&%#&! 3"3"O ##2! 3"3%O ?"%F+! 3"3%O ?"%1+A1! 3""%A"#A ! 3+8.@.63,; /. 9D7//!9 .- ,= .-!;5 ?""1F#! 3A8""%#A& ! 3+O ' "FF$P#1/3#"A! 3#863 L//!9   L/,3

+3 !=. @) .!/.-/!-8532AD A& 63

23 ( )  73 " 3 % 3 8  ' 7 ) ! !   /!   7!    ) N   !  7 )/!:;3

 ! 73 "&   /.-! 9 7.  !  !) ). ! ///!.  .! .  7!  )) ( ). !)  G ./). ! !373"" 7 @. . 5!*/, 6/.-!/!9/! 7.;) -. : .9 !- 7! 3

<73+2 7. !-! )/G7  ! 9!.!!)). !3 !(8 7-!  7!  / M 7!  .  )/!! !)/ / 7/!-! )!!./ /!/,/)/ /.. 7-!53+A3" 63

@!732+ /.-!9@! /!)D7 @ .!.)/.:!83!).;)! !! .!/97!/!/ !(/!-.!@!  .).!,.)!9 /!3

A3  7/,  / !  @! .   /! /  !8  .9!!Q

*  7 / .8! 8! 97.;. 9   ! !*)K) !@).  <  : .9 ! %&&#3 /  <    .. );.  !@). /!97D ./!  .)/  



0%11+0%&&2  *A01*   @  /:)!   7 . D >< -  )! )! , !  9 >< 7  . D  <  /  .-/!:;3

*    7! ). ! .8! /  ) '. !  :!;!  -!< 9!)7/!-!=!%&&% 8%&&#33

* ! !./!   C.9: 7! .8!O! 7! )'. ! :!;!  -!< 3

 -  ..) )!. ! //M 9  <  -! /   :;) @3 7/.;. !-  )/!! !)/ 9!  .! /     !/!! /.!. 8! / /88 )! !9) 78 7 !  !. / .).3

7 !! D  9 ><  /!  :;  @   .)  /!)3

.9 )!)!-. 7//!!=. <  ).D/ :;@!!;!3

RRRRR



0%11+0%&&2  *101*  

#   4 " #  "   "  #   " %

78/   9  :   ;< ,-' "$=

  / 

"3 .-83

% /

%3 7 )3

#3 = )  )!-. 7//!!)) ) /GH&+ %+F&#1?3

+3  )< D/ :;@!!;!3

23 !9/. ;!3

A3 @)  /!   9L /- @)    /. K   .!  #& = ,  !@!! / /! )) .  .  !8 @. .   <:S!T:@9! A A&&+     ! ()/!3  .!  / K /;.3  ).)! !Q 6 ! !9 ()9 .!! .!8!!/  .!! 9.O 86 (/ / 9 )!@ ! !) /-! )    .!!O 6 /  !;     /.3 <!  ).)!  ! /  ! ..) .)..   6 86  6 !*   !8@. . //)!,9L! - .!-83).)! )!)G  /- 9!  =! !! 9  .!! 9.  L-//  9..(/. !.53"#%"&A"&$63  ;@@!Q  .! Q       !! 88!

/!@) /.K!@!.(/!!!9LDL@@!@. . ./8!9/;@@



0%11+0%&&2