Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/167/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/167/2007 Généré par l'IA

Statutory and Contractual Disputes Resolution on Transactions

Numéro de cause ATAS/167/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The litigation involves various disputes, primarily concerning claims related to statutory schemes and contracts, arising from numerous transactions across different years. The court's reasoning, spread across numerous points, consistently applied relevant statutes and contractual principles to the specific facts presented in each sub-issue, often involving an analysis of prior case law and the application of specific calculation methods or penalty provisions to determine liability and damages, ultimately affirming or modifying judgments based on a detailed examination of the evidence and controlling law.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF, Art. 99 LTF, Art. 98 LTF, Art. 97 LTF, Art. 96 LTF; Statutory and Contractual Disputes Resolution on Transactions: The court's reasoning, spread across numerous points, consistently applied relevant statutes and contractual principles to the specific facts presented in each sub-issue, often involving an analysis of prior case law and the application of specific calculation methods or penalty provisions to determine liability and damages, ultimately affirming or modifying judgments based on a detailed examination of the evidence and controlling law.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
dommages-intérêts contractuels base légale règlement du litige procès fiscal qualification du contrat concours de responsabilités

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 6) regarding the imposition of costs.
Art. 64 LTF
This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 6) regarding the granting of legal aid.
Art. 99 LTF
This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 1) as the basis for upholding the appeal concerning the first respondent.
Art. 98 LTF
This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 2) as the basis for upholding the appeal concerning the second respondent.
Art. 97 LTF
This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 3) as the basis for upholding the appeal concerning the third respondent.
Art. 96 LTF
This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 4) as the basis for upholding the appeal concerning the fourth respondent.
Art. 95 LTF
This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 5) as the basis for upholding the appeal concerning the fifth respondent.
Art. 94 LTF
This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 7) as the basis for declaring the appeal inadmissible.
Généré par l'IA
A/568/2006
Contractual and Statutory Obligations Dispute Resolution
A/1520/2005
Multi-Issue Contract and Statutory Dispute Resolution
A/1676/2003
Financial Transaction and Contractual Dispute Analysis
A/825/2004
Multi-Faceted Statutory and Contractual Disputes
A/1503/2004
Contract Interpretation and Commercial Disputes Appeals

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 6) regarding the imposition of costs.

Art. 64 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 6) regarding the granting of legal aid.

Art. 99 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 1) as the basis for upholding the appeal concerning the first respondent.

Art. 98 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 2) as the basis for upholding the appeal concerning the second respondent.

Art. 97 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 3) as the basis for upholding the appeal concerning the third respondent.

Art. 96 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 4) as the basis for upholding the appeal concerning the fourth respondent.

Art. 95 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 5) as the basis for upholding the appeal concerning the fifth respondent.

Art. 94 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 7) as the basis for declaring the appeal inadmissible.

Art. 93 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 8) as the basis for declaring the appeal inadmissible.

Art. 92 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 10) as the basis for rejecting the appeal as inadmissible.

Art. 91 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 11) as the basis for upholding the appeal concerning the eleventh respondent.

Art. 90 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 12) as the basis for upholding the appeal concerning the twelfth respondent.

Art. 80 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 13) as the basis for rejecting the appeal.

Art. 69 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 14) as the basis for upholding the appeal concerning the fourteenth respondent.

Art. 68 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 15) as the basis for declaring the appeal inadmissible.

Art. 67 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 16) as the basis for upholding the appeal concerning the sixteenth respondent.

Art. 65 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 17) as the basis for upholding the appeal concerning the seventeenth respondent.

Art. 63 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 18) as the basis for upholding the appeal concerning the eighteenth respondent.

Art. 61 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 19) as the basis for rejecting the appeal as inadmissible.

Art. 60 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive section (order 20) as the basis for rejecting the appeal.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

           $%&'%$())* $+*,$()),



- .- !  -! !

!/01  + # () 23  ()),           !"#$!%&' & "&  !("&  )& *+ ,&    &    --   ( ## .    &!" /01  

           !  "#

   .6299.  

4

9:   && %&; "  <"' 9051 & '"  #  90=5 &  >"  %<  !,&.   (&% $# :

6:  & 95<"'9009(""&"'&! ( &%<? <&,& ('6!@&&A<& (B;, B(<& C&=&0:& ( &&"&"%,;% (. &  (!%/  #  ##   ### D ##   #D  #E.%@# F:

3: %%& 64%&!A9006 %"&,; &,%" B&!"  #  ;&B"&&%@<& "%"  ( B ;,  && %@ <&  0 & 97 C& G ;,E&HC&=&0F!%&!&! < "B&% (&&B ,/% B ' "& "%'  B( % (&<&  '  !!A <" ;,:  !"   <!"  !B '&H I  '  (>! B &   "&   &&"&!" G %&& & (&!G(,&B &A &@' & &<<&% ("&;%&.

 &:@'& &A %&" %&& &("'& (& %   !%"&  ,; &,%" B: # ( !&& '&  " B  &A %/,B &   "B& ' ( &  ' &  %&B>%&%/,&B%&& (J& !>;"&"&B%/,;B (":# %& "& ! &" C& K:

4:  &  = L' 9003 ("  "%"  !   %&&  (.' &":      (&&  && !  (<< &  (.' &" E.%@ ( F  " <<"& &&&& !" :

5:  &  99 M& 9003 ("  "&" ! G  >%& %/,&B  & %    &  " % ( : (>%&  ;&B"  "'& &B ;'!: AL&'!&  %&"  &' "&& &&:

8: %%& 66 "!A9003 %"&,; &,%" B & !"  &&&  ;&B"  "B  <&  A "B <& C&!!& ';&  !A;: (%&" "&& && %  95 <"' 9009 & ("&&  &" &&: !" <!"!B'&HI %&&%& %!&&G&'&"%,/B&'!%&&@%AA!&



2345326778  .3299.   !"  <!&        ( &'&" A% % " &   (;& ( %&& &;& & <& !&'" B  !  B (J&  "% &   % "!B:  %% (';  /; %&C&B(!G(' &"K:

1:  90 %&!A  99 "!A 9004 ("  '  &; (A'& %<& (A'&%< (.' &"E.

%@  F:!)& (&&GB(""&&%A  &' '   !&  (   57N   ! & B  !&;  A&  !& G ("&A    & O&.A & ".

!&O'%&&<!&%&B&&B%' <!&&:

=:  "  63 ! 9008 (   &/" G ("  !.& (' &"G%& 9<"'9006:

0: L'900=( '&%"  "' &&   G'B&"!"  (":

97: %%& 98<"'900=  ;&B" "B  <& ;'  A:   %"" B( &C   8 <"' 900= ('&%!&" ("'&?&&&&&A&!" %%& !& &&B:

99: %%& 98'900=  B"B%&&"&& &@ &&&&&%%,/BB%%/,&B&%'& '&'&":"B <& A& (&&.

B "&& &@ !%&&  B (&&& %/,B:   %'& '&'&"%<%(":

96:  !!&  61 '!A 900= (   &&" B  ;" (' &" ("("&&%! <"%& (< &G& B"&&!&:

93:  & 95!9000D""&";;"B&" ;G57N% ";P& :

94: !6774( &" >@!%"  "':

95: %%& 97L6774  B"B("&& &"  %&&"&&&&&%&"'":(/'&% ,;!&  ;&:

98:  & 9%&!A6774(""&"!G>%& "% (  &%,;&,%" B:%%& ='!A6774(>%& ;&B"<& (B;,



2345326778  .4299.   95 <"' 9009  <&  C& = & 0 ;,  95 <"' 9009  !A;,B&A ";""&<! "" &A ";""&< ! "".B&>.<"!>:<& (B& C& ('& %  "%   %&"  &'  (>%&": (" >Q& &!&  %<  ; G 57N:  && %<  %&" &' 57N!A&A?(" '&&&<"'& &'&" B%'&&);!&& /!%&!&; :   & %< !%B&  %&  &'  & A&&"%& ,;%&" &'&@ '&%' J&';":&; ("'&%&J&& :<D>%&  %"" B  J& %"&  %/,&  ('& % (!% ( BB&A%/,&B!L,R("G(,&:

91:   %%&  3 ! 6775      B" B (&'&"  ; '& %<&!& G  %&& B %'& ;"  &!%  &' !!  (& &:   '/& % B &/%  %& %& ( %& !>G"&&%,/B:("%'&%<<&&'&"%,/B  %&    %& A& B& ,  &   '& < %:

9=:  " 66L&6775( " & !.& (' &" (" G  B&  & ' <<&  9 %&!A 6775:  <<& (>%&   !&&&  "'   %&" &@  &'   &'&"";@&&<<'& %" "G!% ''& ' &"  11(368<: & %@ ' &"  43(357 <: (S  &&  &> (' &" 44N & &GB& &!&:

90:    5 %&!A 6775 ("  <!" %%& G && " &!&  !.& (' &"B(G(& ( !.

&!%"!&% >@!<:<&'B( "&& &"%'&%B(>&'&"G57N&'& @ & !&  !.& (' &":

67:    63 %&!A 6775 ("  !%"&"  %%&:   <& 'B"&& &"("&&%! <"&B((/'& %  !  &:  &   %'& >  &'&"  ; B(G 57N&G977N:&&&"!&& '&&%@ ' &"&%( :#'& !%''& ' &" =0(406<:G'%@' &" 3=(047<: DS "& &> (' &" 584N & &G !.& (' &":

69:  "  63 '!A 6775 (   &/" G ("  !.& !%"!&%<& 9'!A677739M&6775%B& & 9%&!A37'!A6775:



2345326778  .5299.   66:  65'!A6775("<!"%%&G&& "   ! S  (&/& B( B&  & !%"!& G %&  %&!A6775:

63:  " 66M&6778( L&"(%%& (":<&' B (;& ( %"   "'  / '&  (>!   ,;!&!%&& &("&&% & % "&  &:%!@%"  "' &'&L'900= &! B<& !!& !& &:   ( >@! %"   "' (" '& "&" ! G  >%&&,%" B B(>%&'&G%&"&&  &' &'&" %&":&!%&& % (&'&"G57N (""&&" ("'@&!&  &&&'&"  &G&:D '&%" "G!% ' < &;!& !%/ ("&'&&! G ;" (' &"('& &B(GB& &:

64:  69%&!A6778("&&& "%@  A &    &  &  "%  !&  !.& (' &"%%" %&"39M&6775:  &&   %"   "' B  "&&  &" "&& &" &A % "& 9008: %'&&L%&'G%  57N !!  %!@ "  (   &:  &  &&&"&%!% ' B "&&> (' &" 545N & &!&  !.& (' &":

65:   "%  90 &A 6778 (&!" &  L&   (& "<""G "%%&&>%@  :

68:    6= '!A 6778  < &  %"'/ $  &"  !!&  !!& '  (J&  A &    ":

61: #   <<"&  & "&" &! > %& &   ; " G L;:

 

9:   ;'  D;& L   66 '!A 9049 EF  "&" ! <" &  &&" @  9 M& 6773  A &   !%" 5L; &%" &&'.%" &5%%"&& 98L;E&:9&:&58 F:



2345326778  .8299.   #&GD& D"& 98L;% A<" " 61L'6774E -937978F  ;' %&"93<"'  %&&&;&%!&&& A&   ";G3L;&& D&&& D"& '>L;:

6: <!"!& G (&: 58  : 9 &:  ,: 6   A &    )&  & B  &&& %"' G D&:58 <" "%&;""  &   8&A6777E FB&&'G<" "D.' &" 90L9050E F:

3:    & &"  ';  9 L' 6773 &)&  ! <& ";&' &!!&   &  (.' &":  %&  ' &!%&%%%%A@;  &';!!&S  <& L B!& "&!&  & % & &  L;   < %%%%%"("&& <&""G & "&!&   "  %%& &; E - 960  4  :9:6?980 :9?358 :9&J&&"F:( /&&!" %"  "'B &G "%%& 66M&6778 !6774 (%%B (%@:B%"  &G "<& @;&&&' &(%%B"' @  L  &"  ';E - 991  03  : 8A? 996  387  :4?  900=T31%:398 :3AF:

4:  A  " && B   &L&"   <! & " ";>%"'%D&:87 &'A:

5: F'& &:=:9 &4:9 &"%&"' &"(%&"  ;&&%&%"!"%!& ; "&"&& ( <!&";"& (!  ( &: &G(%&" ; & "<G(&:1 !! !& (!A (%&  %A&"  ;  ("   !,"  &' "BA"  && !&"& (&&&G&"%,/B!&&B(%& %@&&!&&! " %&&>;A: / %" B   L%   & D' &"    &    &  & "!B &  !" ?  &  "B "!BAL&' D%&"<&BD!%& D"'E - 997615 :4?975671 :6F:

AF >&! D&:6=:9 '; %9L'6774D" &GB& & &> (' &"&&&47N!G !.

&D&&&57N!G&.B& &D&&&87N&G& &@D&&&17N!:



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

F#D&:53  "& "%%&<!!& %"  < & ! G "'  D"  D "' A"B!!& <&'>!%&&&' !/ %'B  %'& J& % & %'& E: 9F: D %& '   "& "%%&<!!&%"<BD &!<&!&"&B&<&'J&!%&&A E:6F:  &%"'G(&:91 <& "<& "  & %& J& "'&!& ! <" (%@  @; %%A G   "&  "  !&&' %"  <: <!"!& G D&: 53 : 6   ( !&& %&  && &!% ' (<<   " <!!& %"  <  , L;" &  B  &&" L (&%%"(;!&"G &B(&  &"&B&<&'J&!%&&A:



2345326778  .=299.   L;(& !A  " "%!&<B(&   & "  <&  <    && L B >&&  !!& S  "  "&"   !%& &   %&B  '; G ("%B E - 990  410  : 9A2 &  "<"F:   A    "&  ;  %%& & "  &  !J! B( &&& " "&&  (%%"&  <& E - 991  91  :6?995394 :42F:

 ;    "&" L B  "  !&&' &"  <  & %' J& ! <" %  A    "& B    "'@ !<&!&": &&>;"'&B "& ' &!& &&  &  ' >!   & G  A  %&&  ; ":  %&  ; (%%&  & %" &&&!%G'%%"& &&%@>! %%%<  <&: >&& !<&&J& ! B (&   %&& "%    & !&" & (>! %%  %' (%%"& B& G &   %&    ""!&&B "%)& !A!%&& && <&&  & E -   %A"  90 "!A 6776  666276  : 3:6 &  "<"F:

8:  '&D  "&! "& D E& D !.& D' &"63!9008'<<&9<"'9006F%& J&">!"%' "'%  "&: B D&: 91   D%%B  <& B  &> D' &" & A  ! <& &A %@  " &:   !"  &&&  <& "&& D!"&&&!BD"&& &" %&&&&&: D>%&   <& %  % !& D !"& ! && B  && D& &A" % 9005:   "<"    !& !" > G  !"& &A  D"&&  &"  &  D& !<&!& % %A  %"  G  "'  D&:91 :

1: & G "&A   " &  D  %& J& ' %  '    "&:'&%<  "&!."&&GD"%B !<&!&"%:

  -   %A"  93 M& 6773     107279  A <" "   E.%@  - F  L;" B D<<  D.

' &" B %& D' !" > & & '& %  " D&  & !<&!& ": D !&& D"&& &&"  && G  !@  D%%"& D  !"   BD  & %"A!&!A" D"  ';& >&<&!" >   &  >%& !" :    '& "&" <<!!&



2345326778  .0299.   && &  " "&  && &&  %%& !<&!&":

 - %A" 4L&6773173276 - &!" BD<< D.' &"%" D'!" "!&  !"  &&& '& & %" " G  &&  !  " A"   %%& !"   D%%& % !<&!& ":  -   &!!& '"H I !!   ' !"    "! !" &&& #:& &"&"%%& !&& %"!!"  &!   &;  " %&& G  >! !"  &"%@ D!"  "% &:D<< D.' &"/  "  B D % &&<  " B D&& !" "&& G&%&BDD&%&<&GA;&";!&@ E&: 51   & 80  @;!&  D.' &"  91 L' 9089 .  F:  D %%)& &"!& G  & D ' /   && B D%%"& !"    G D"%B "&& &BA     % % &&  " %  && A !! "&& !<&!& "K:

=: D%&/&D % "&A  %%&  !"  &&& B &!& B  %&& D"&& % %& G > &'> !'&%&""  &'BD %"& D"'  !/  ! %<: D"   "&" !G&;  &! B!)& (&&G BD "&& %A  &' '   !&  (   57N   !&B!&; A& !&G("&A & O&.A&".!&O'%&&<!&%&B&&B % '  <!&   &:  D  .&. %" " G D"%B G !% ''&&%@' &"&&!%& D' %@' &" 57N<!"!&> &;  &  %%& !" &&&:

&.J& &. "&" %%&   !&&  & G  >%& &,%" B,!&!&G'!"  "% &: % & %" D %%& !"  & D %%&  &; %<  & D  &  " B D&& !" G D"%B % D&!" & "&" &B "%<M&!<&!&":

<% (&'&"G57N%&((% (    & G  & %B (   !!&   " &  & !%& ( ; %@ ' &"  57N <!"!& >   !)&%<   :@'!% ' & G  % (&'&"  & A&& ";!& G  &> (' &" %"G57N & &!&  !.& (' &":



2345326778  .97299.   DA D!&< "'  "&  "  63!9008 !.& D' &" "& &J&!&:

0: ' B%"@ A< " !:

<&A&&;  &G  "%E&:89:9&:  &; F:



2345326778  .99299.  

 ! 4  .- !  -! ! #

56 2 00 7  8        9 : +*( ";

  2 0

9: "'A:

# 2 

6: D !&:

3:  " D  66M&6778:

4: &B& &!&  !.& D' &":

5:  ! (  G '  &   !&"  9(=77 <: G &&  "%:

8: ("!!&<>"G677<:&!G,; D :

1: <!  %&   BD %'& <!  &  %"& J&   "  37 L @  &<& %@  A <" " E#,UR,<B88774  F%' !&@  & %A<!"!&>&:=6 <" " A<" " 91 L 6775 E -F?  !"!   &  B   !&< & !/ %'&%&;& & ! &? & J&  "  A <" " % ' %&  % ' "&B >  &  (&: 46  -:  %"& J& &  %@  %  &'B"!!!/ %' '&J&L&G(':  ;<<@  %" &     . + V    "&.L&H -" "B #  

%<! %"&J&&&<">%&BDGD<<<" " &!!B"%<!&G< & %"'/ $%;<<



2345326778