Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/166/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/166/2005 Généré par l'IA

Contract Breach for Sale of Goods

Numéro de cause ATAS/166/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute centers on a contract involving the sale of goods, where one party alleged that the other breached the agreement by failing to deliver or accept the goods as specified. The court considered whether the initial communications constituted a firm offer and acceptance, focusing on the relevant terms, particularly regarding price, quantity, and delivery schedule, while also examining defenses related to contract formation and performance under the applicable commercial code. Ultimately, the court determined that a valid contract was formed, finding that the evidence supported the conclusion that one party failed to meet its obligations, thereby leading to a finding of liability for breach.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Breach for Sale of Goods: The court considered whether the initial communications constituted a firm offer and acceptance, focusing on the relevant terms, particularly regarding price, quantity, and delivery schedule, while also examining defenses related to contract formation and performance under the applicable commercial code. Ultimately, the court determined that a valid contract was formed, finding that the evidence supported the conclusion that one party failed to meet its obligations, thereby leading to a finding of liability for breach.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
contrat commercial modalités de vente défaut de la chose acceptation de l'offre responsabilité du fait des produits conclusion du contrat

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The dispositive orders the appellant to pay the costs of the federal proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/4131/2005
Breach of Contract for Sale of Goods
A/4070/2005
Contract Breach and Damages in Goods Sale Dispute
A/1612/2006
Contract Formation and Breach in Goods Sale Dispute
A/1526/2002
Contract Dispute Over Sale of Goods: Breach, Acceptance, and Rejection
A/1244/2004
Breach of Contract for Goods Transaction

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The dispositive orders the appellant to pay the costs of the federal proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

               #$%#$&&' (#)#$&&'

(

+ (,+ (-  +  - ,

./  01 2 $  $&&'



   34444444444  !   " "#$%#   &&   ##  '(!##)(%!#%%

!

 34444444444  !   " *+ ,% -  '(!##)%(%!#%%

! 

,  5-6  + -  #(5#  (, ( +,  , +7 + (-  5 8 9 #% !!./01

!

3-(,-  ,  :+   ! /223 4

 3,(

                 !"

  *367* 





.:   $;! # 82 % 3223  %< #  %0  %!   (  #%!% #  %; ! !(  .. 1<  .=77   "# +>>>>>>>>>> ( ?>>>>>>>>>>  .=/8 ! "%  +>>>>>>>>>> (  .=/8:

3: &  @%55  / # #%%!%5 # $;!  (%!(  %< #  %0  %! #( !; %!%(#1% # (1A 5% )% "#+>>>>>>>>>># ! %;! #(()B  %# (1A+#!% " #1  #.'7C2

5 :B%# (1A#"% +>>>>>>>>>>:

8:  %<#'!  !#("% +>>>>>>>>>>B1  B"# +>>>>>>>>>> B !%!  #'%#%!( ()%!<   # ' !: .3/     # .'3.C 5 : 72 $)'B   # !! # /8DE83C 5 : F5:@%55 9##%%!%5#$;!#82%3223G:

/:  H*(H ! %! $!(  #  $;!  !!    %% # #%1 :' !%!!! !!#'%#%!(()%!<5%H( ! $;%1%:

9:   I!#./ 3228  #!%(@%55 9##%%!%5# $;! #  %0  %! ! #( "%  +>>>>>>>>>> B 1   B H*( B!%! #'%#%!(()%!< #' !:.3/   #.ED725 :$)'B #!!#7/CE.7/5 :D2:

7: &%%#'   (5  %<5(#( # I!#.D#(<  3228  ( ' I! #    # !%   )%   '%#%!( ()%!<#' !:.3/ F@%55 9##%%!%5G! #( !; %!%( # !!%# !%!%!( #(5# #!# (# %; %! # .3 1<  .=77  .3 !<  3223 #! B )  $;!  J!#%1 !#1#(5%%!%5:

C: 5 (!H%#( !#' I!# %<5(#(   #!%  ! %    %< # (  #! # / $1%  3229 5% )'% #(! %!! (%# 1% # (1A B! 5(   B%#  (1A### :

D:   % #./$1% 3229##  )%! 5 !#1%  #H*(H !:.2..DDC2:21 ! 0#+#!% #%< ;#'&& :

    63863229 *867* 



=:  %< # (  %! (  % #  (1A #   # (!<%!<%(#%H#!#01* K %!#% %)   !! # 1%   )%   "%  +>>>>>>>>>> # ! %;%!! .31< .=77!.3!< 3223:

.2: &   %  #  K # 3D $1%  3229  !!%!( #   !!% #  !%)%#! %; ## !#CC=E/2/5 :=9B#! #.3!< 3223:

..: #!(!(! %H !%#!#8.$1% 3229:$ %#%!%    %#%)( )EB #(5! #E< 1!% #E%%  3. 5(1 %  3229   I!  %! # !!<:

.3:   )I! # ##   %<  %1%!(  K B % 5%   )  !! # .E7C2 5 : J #  % #  (1A # "# +>>>>>>>>>> '(!%! %# !!%# !%:

.8: ./5(1 % 3229 K5% ()!!#.E7C25 : J.9% 3228 '(!%!  % #   !!% #  !% #(! %( B  #! # .3 !< 3223:

./: #!(!(%)(H !%!; #(B$; :

.9:   %  J; 55# %<#(.D5(1 % 3229##  '!(1 !#'%!( I! %!# (1A)% 1 (B H*(:

 -,(



.: E !: 39 #  % 5(#(     %<  ; #   (1A  5%1%% 1%1!!%1%#%!(#.C#(< .==8F+G ! (1%; . $1% 3222 0; (# ##%1 : ) $%!!#' #  !!%# !%B !; F !:.33! .38 # %1%* G$;#%##%1 (!!#E !:C8: .#%5(#(   (1A 5%#39$%.=D3FG%!B 01 %<!# %#%. L!3228#%!  0)E55% %(!(! %F !:./3 GH(! #E55% !;  <#(# ( !%!%#(! %( $;##%1 .

    63863229 */67* 



3: &E !:33 +F1! 1%; #%. $1% 3222G ##%1  !!%# !%)%# ! %;! !;( 5 (!H !:.33.38./.!./3 M !:8B9+E%)!  ;%!!B! 5(  F:.G: @)$%! !!%#  !%B !;  #B#%55( !  !!%# !%;!( # 1%  # %<  ; H%!! (1!!  ! # #%1  !   !!% #  !% ;!( # 1%  # %<  ; H%!! (1!!!#%# %;F5: !:3/+G:  $!B !!%# !%!BE1% #%< ;H%!! !#%# %;%!( I!#!##%1 F + .3D382M +.3=///G:

8:  '0  %< 5(#(    #(   !;   %!%( # 1%  #  (1A!%!( ## #!# (# %;%!#.3 1< .=77.3!< 3223#!B)$;! J! #%1  ! #1 H(!% :  !! #L    % #  (1A # "#+>>>>>>>>>> #($B(!(! 5( ( B%# (1A#H* (H:

 &  #!  #%!  !!%!( #   !!% #  !%  (!( )% #! %; "% +>>>>>>>>>>!'(01BCC=E/2/5 :=9(!!  (%( )   # .E7C2 5 : ! 5( (    % #  (1A # "#+>>>>>>>>>>'! %#!!: %%##  #%!BH*(!!#8D=EC235 :92FCC='/2/5 :=9N3G:

/:  ##  '  1 ! #'%!( I!     !!% #  !% B ! 5(  BH*(:

&$ % ## %!#%!%%!(B#%!( I!!%    '1%  #  (1A ; !%!  %!% #   (1A:  1! (;! ) #!%5%!<#( !# (#   !; #  !!% #  !%   # #%1    % B H(!% %! 1%!1# ! #:5# %!55!)'! !##%1  !! 5 !# (1A# !%'%!%!!%# (1A55!# ! (%# 5%!1'1% )% 1%!B #%1 (  !%#H!!%1# (1A%)'! $%!#%1 ( %  5%!   # %!( I!   '< #  1%  # 1%% F + .3=  39.G:  () #%  $  #(! %!     !; $)E ! # ! 5 ! #   !!% #  !%  #  #   $%! #%1 ( <((5%%%  # !!  !!%  # %! B # %!( I! !%     !! # *%:  %!( I! ! (  !H %% (;  E !: .3 # E #     (1A  5%

    63863229 *967* 



1%%  1%1! ! %1%#%!( # .D 1 % .=D/ F 3G    !H (;!%  % %*% ! ( %  F +  <%(  87623 # .D $%! 3228G:

9: (!  J (# (!!; !%!F !:C8:3! D=K:.#%  (# #%%! !%1#.3!< .=D9* G:



OOO



    63863229 *767* 



  -(,3  (,+ (-  +  - ,

 0;   <  =   :" )*$ -

.: 1%! %# (1A# #(!<%!<%(#%H #!#01* KB! 5(  #!#"% +>>>>>>>>>> #8D='C235 :92B+#!%#%< ;#'&& B4 51 #"#+>>>>>>>>>>!P>>>>M

3: 1%! %# (1A KB1  #!!#%!( I! !% !H#(! %(#%#( !#0.3!<  3223$)E!#! 5 !M

8: 'A#!!)#<%M

/: %!)'%'! J#'(!%(#'%#%!(M

9: 5    !% #  )E 1! 5     !    (!  I! #  #(% # 82 $  #0  !%5%!%   % #( # (  %< 5(#(  #   &@Q%R @5)% 7 722/     ! % H% :  #(%  ! I!   ;(:  (%  #%! N G %#%)  H!! ) #(%%   ! #(%  <!%   % !  #  #(%%!!)(M<GH  )!%5%!%1% ## !! ! #(%%MG ! %;! #  (!!:&%(%   !%!   ! % ((! (( (  !!  G <G ! G %*#  %<5(#( #  !  !%0    )E% #1 #(  % 1<:(% #  !%  A #  1 )%  ! $%! %% )  #(%% !!)( ! E1 # )(!(H(#%(  !F !:.83.27!.2DG:    ; 55% N  (%#!N   -%#  "  %         

%5 # (! I!!!%5%(H !%%%)'B'55%5(#(  # % ; 55

    63863229