Sex Offender Registration Law Constitutionality
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThis case concerns whether a law requiring individuals convicted of certain sex offenses to register their address, employment, and enrollment information with law enforcement, and to notify authorities of any change, violates constitutional protections against bills of attainder and ex post facto laws, as well as general due process and equal protection principles. The court reasoned that the registration requirement is a regulatory measure designed to protect public safety, not a punitive punishment, thus it does not constitute a bill of attainder or violate the prohibition against ex post facto laws, even when applied to offenses predating the statute's enactment. Furthermore, the court found the registration and notification scheme was rationally related to the legitimate state interest in monitoring and controlling sex offenders, thereby satisfying due process and equal protection challenges, despite imposing significant burdens on registrants.
Regeste Legislator
Généré par l'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Sex Offender Registration Law Constitutionality: The court reasoned that the registration requirement is a regulatory measure designed to protect public safety, not a punitive punishment, thus it does not constitute a bill of attainder or violate the prohibition against ex post facto laws, even when applied to offenses predating the statute's enactment. Furthermore, the court found the registration and notification scheme was rationally related to the legitimate state interest in monitoring and controlling sex offenders, thereby satisfying due process and equal protection challenges, despite imposing significant burdens on registrants.
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IACited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the judicial costs.
Texte complet
&''(&)+ ,&-.'+&)+
,
,/ , /
01" - % -2 31" )+ !"#!$%& % "% !'"% (% % )) ' + %!" ,-.
! " ! # $% %
+2/45+
4/,
46 '78 %&"*4-99:,$" & !$6 ;" 4--< %&%" "$ % %&%" =' %!$ > %? 4--. $?>! '76 "$" $!> ! $> ')) ' + @+$> A = "%" B%" $ " . % 9 B 2334 @! $C % %A !%C =' "%%! $ %&%"%&%%=DCC+& & +!%% "&CC%$$? $% 76
26 %&%!!!E&DFG $4B%2334=' "%"&%! ' % D%41H%2334#% =CC% 'C% %7D6$"%" >22C"&2332 7 D $%D%7D6
06 "%" $ D7 $ * * ' *' *6
CC%""B# =! " $%%@ A 29!0 B% 23326 $$% "%" "%? 9 H% 2332 %! %76 "%" %%"= 77D %$%'"%$??!% #!%%!$% 'D $%D%&%% D"%% *I 8 "B# %%"6 !" % & "%" "7!% C$$" $ '!$%%%!%%%%D"6$%"$C '" ' $ "%" "&" !$% % '& %D$" = %% 6 '"%%$%" %&% $C !E&%6
56 '" "$" 49 B 2332 ! $> ' &% # %% $C !% % $!%6 "%" ! ?""C ' %7 '?&% $C % '%"7%$C 1&5B%23356 %7$ % H J% %!$ . & 2335 7 % !?7 '!$JD% %6
16 $$% 44 ! 2335 $"% )K %D$" C%"%% '77&% '"%% %" $%%% =" ='$&%%
L %&%"" %"7>6!" >& =' ', $ % $% '" % ;! = % 77> =' ;! !$"!% % CC%" $ "& "= '%%%#%"$%" %&6
/001/233. +0/45+ <6 %" $ ' $"% )K D7 %D$" =%%!%7 '$$!%"%?$$% ';$% 2-%?23356%#$%" %
L %&%""7> %6
.6 $$% ';$% 45 &!? 2331 $"%)K$,D%%$,D%D"$"7!%! %"$' "" = 7% %? !%C! &% J% "%" $?>! ' 7=$%;$=$% '"!B $%6 ' %%C $ ; '!$% C% $,D7= = B%% '" &,% & $7&!% & =' % %&!%B6'$&" ,!$%M! '"%% "$C;; '%%?$,D%=6 >='"$"%% $$%D7$,D%="=$%! C'$$"% 6C;"'$%" %&$ $D,=# 13L %&%" $%" $41H%2334"%%$""='',$ $?>! ' $,D=6
96 $$% 1&233<$"%)K!" % % %$ !" %%% $$" 7% %% $> C% %7DD $%D%7DD=%" $%" !"= % 7D $ 41 H% 23346 "7!% $" 7% "$ $%" %& !%% 7 '7 ; $ '? % D?" % '7 !%!%$ $%?4--.6*'$%" %&!! +!N%%% $41H%2334%'"%% %"'77&6
-6 & " $%%$C ' $" ".B233<# !$ 7 $ "%! 7" '& %" '"6 $ !$% ' $% & '& 21'<15 C6 ? " '=J%%% @A$?"$'CC C" " %%%= $%" %& 13L %&%" "7>$!%%%'% $%%%; '?%%!%$$"!% 43L !%% C% % $%" %& " $%% '%$%&& %" 1<'4<3C6@5'023C6 ;402332A$$% '!$, 25B23326?% 7" '& %" 15L6$$""= !$C '$$%$ ="$=!!E&&%"D" $>==B!%6 $!%&D$%J% "6
436 ' !!="#'"45B233<$B% " % !+% >4H%23326
/001/233. +5/45+
446 '" $"%" $ (% %%" $B% 44 B% 233<6>&$$%>!%=' "C>#O%&%" $%"# '"%% %"O$ $ $"?D7 '%&%" &7"6&%$=%#=%&%"$%;"%% P7" 5< ,% & C!% % ""!% ';$!% CN $$;!%C !$% C% = !%% C%!$%%'%&% "?!% '!$!% 7%!$=% 6
426 ; " 44 "!?233<' C!" % '"# !+% '& %" >4H%23326'%C "'& !" *&!" "7 @+$>*A=$%" %& '"%%=!E&%%!='!$JD+ '; % %&%" $ "7> $D,=!% & ? ' &C!% '!$"!% C!%6
406 '" $ '%!" ! % %B%" ; 2- B& 233. % % "6 > = ' "?""!% 7" '& 1 & 233< = O $% ! $(%%%#C%!" =%#'"&%%" '$ %&"7 %+O6 %% & $?% $$% ';$% ! Q $$% $"% 7& 6 ';$% ';$= CC%$#=%,$ '%&%""C>='CC!='"%$? %& # 13L %&%" $%"6 '" >+%+ = $$% '% $ CC!!% !%&"6 7 = !$%% !%% # D $ '!$JD% '! !$ % %& !$,6 % $ % % C7%&'& 1&233<6%%C = $" " ' $ "%! 7" '& %" "% =' ?%%!% $$"!% 23L % H J% $ !$%6 % !$%$ $%%' % +6
456 7CC ? "7%"%!J!!" ;%B%"% ; " 44 "!?233<6
416 $"& .C"&233.' %B% 6
4<6 ? " " ' % 41 ! 233.6 + ""R
O= B' "%? $$% 44 %? 2330 # '%%% ' B &$ %!%'"6 '%='$%6= +"%&%"B'$>&%%=!" 7""%6 $ !! " ' # %D$" % $ = "%% "%% %%6 ' " =% & ' $&% $ %&
/001/233. +1/45+ %&%"$"7>&%D%$=%'"&% "%% %!$%% C%='"%%&$6
' !!" #&'"C2331 + "?% 233<6'%%" ='', &%$ '!"%6 '%=B' =" !$$% 1 & 233< = "%% '"%% 77&"6 %% # !D # ' ; ?"=6 ' "7!% "" = '"&%%" ' %& !J! "7 ! $% $ &7?6 CC% '" % D7 $% %% =F !% &6 CC D=6 & ! % = %&%" $% ;6 ' =" =' ', &% $ ! C% ?B%& $ C 23356 ' & =' ', &% $ '!"%6=%%%!"= '"$&%%& '%&%""7>#13L6 CB& CC!%=%,$ '%&%"%&7" !Q '" %D7 $%%>"7>!%6'$%!%=', ;7"% $% '"6$%= % $%$ %;%%%#%"6'"CC% '"$ 7 !?7 #'%% %#% "DD!%O6
4.6 2-!233.' '% "%!"=% % %# !$C6 ""='"%% $"#!%%'" ?""C ' $!% = %% $C & ! % % ' !%" B> $%J%&7"6
496 '" 42 B 233. C% $% ?&%6 > = $$% ' ! ' $!% % %%!% CC% % $!%% $ %& !$6 % > '% ! !% ;= > & % ! Q 7" '& %"%%%7!%%; 23L6! '?&%C! ' %7 * $!%%% "77 & '%% $C6 $$#%"7 =%7?""C =&%"%"! 1&5 B%2335&%"%"%!$.&$ !" 677> "= $ $"% $" &, # ' C=+7%7 '?&%%"D"% ! !%6
4-6 41H%233.' "C"%;$$% ';$% % %!" = ! E& ' & %7 '?&%$CB%C%$6
236 "%"%!#'"%7 "#B76
/001/233. +</45+ /,
46 C!"!% # '%6 1< 6 4 %6 D6 2 7& '7% B @A ? % (% % = %%% $"& # S% 1< C" " $% 7"" % < %? 2333 @ A = % %&#C" "S+& %" 4-B4-1-@ A6
*!$"%$B7 S$>%"%?6
26 % %" &7 4 B& 2330 %(% ! C% "7%& %!!% % '+& %"6 $% & %!$%$$$$?>7 %&7!!%Q C% B =!% "%!% % $ % % B7 C $$$$$"'"%% C%""# % "%!% "$$%%7@ )42-5 6462: 4<- 64:01< 64%J%%"A6
*C ? ">&= "%7,%"%" % 4 "!? 233< ! %%% "%% C% B =!% "%!%!%%%!%#'"2332$"%%7;!" #!> $% $$" '"% %B=' 04 "!? 2332 % "D"% 7 & $% $$" $%"@ )403002 6262%260A6&% = =' % & = $% '% $ ! C" % '& %"' %B$ ) ,%&%%B '%%"6
06 = $" % # "C% >7 %% % % '$$%'$$=%"& >B %"&7@ )44.-0 6<?:4420<3 65: 4--9 T0.$604< 60?A6
? " %% = %B%" C! % " "7;%&?C!"!%#S%6<3 6
56 %7$% % '"# $%% 6
16 &% %6964 %564 %"$%"& %"'$%" 7%%$%$"!"$!% 7 "%"%% ' C!%"7"% '! ' %6 %#'$%" 7 % "C#'%6. !! !% '!? '$% $?%" 7 '" !D" %& "=?" %% !%"% ' %%%#%"$D,=!%%='$% $>%%!%%! " $%%;7?6 , $"
/001/233. +./45+ = B$ % S& %" % % % "!= % !" : % "= "!=?B%& S$%"C%=S!$% S"&@ ) 4432.1 65:43123. 62A6
<6 %%%#%"$,D=$&%!!%%%$D,=%( & %" '%6564 @&'%69 A6 > $ !! "= ' "%% $,D= ! C $ !! CC% # $ D7 $ '+& %" !% $%" 7='"$%!$JDC%$& ? &%": ! = % ;7? % J% "%!" ?B%&!% = $? @ ) 432 4<1: * 2334 $6 225 6 2? % "C":C6 )42.2-9 65CA6
.6 $& 7" '& %"' !%%@B7', A ? !% = !" "&%!% '% $"% &%C6%PD !" %#$%B7!% '"%% %"%# = =!%$=%&%"'" %$? %&6% "!" %%%""!% % $ "%! = %&; $% ?!% ;7 '" @ ) 421 2<4 6 5 441 405 6 2 445 045 6 0 431419 64A6
96 B7 %;! !>?B%&%!, $& = =' % $& $ " !% # $% $!%%% $% B7!% &? % %7;6 * $$% !" ; % % % $% = 'CC $$" '!? $&% =$= C $!" %$%6$$% "&%%"" @$ ;!$ ! ' % '$%" %& '& %" '%%% # '%"7%"$D,=!%A$$%'%% C% ' !" 6 $$&"%? % '"# $%%' !%%B7 ? !%=!" %C6'$$"% " !" &J% !$% '%% $ 7 %;%6 B$ $""%PD !" $;!$ '"&% '& %" '%%%#'%"7%" ';! %" % % '"&"!% % % & !!7 @ ) 422419 64?%"C":* $& % R"7'D K+?%* KU K+P2333 $62<9A6
'+& %" '%% C% ' !" C $$% !" %%% %"#'CC '+& %";$% !" "$ % '%%% ';!$%="$
/001/233. +9/45+ % '?&% !" '+& %" @ ) 420 4.1A ;$%$ %$$%=;$%!" "$ B7 $!> >%@*4--.$6049 60?: $" !%%&+& %"%D>)?74---$6452A6 '"&% '& %" %PD !" % # $% B7!% '"%% %" % # = = ! % $ = %&%" '" % $? %&6 % " !" %%% ""!% % $ "%! = %&; $% ?!%;7 '"@ )4212<4 65%"C"A6
* $$ ? $$"% $& $!% &? $" B ! @C6%6<4 %6 AB7'%$"$ >7C!! %;! !>?B%&%!, $&=='%$&$ " !%# $%$!%%% $%B7!%&? % %7;6 $$% !" ; % % B7 $% %D'CC$$"'!? $&% = $ = C $ !" % $ %6 '""!% "%!% $ & $?% ' $$% !" '% 7 "7%!%6 %"7 !$%=$% %7;!$%%%C%'?B% '"% C"=$$%C ;! !$% =' $ "7!% "% $% ;$!"='%"%""%?$ @!>A= $% %C" !" % % C = ';$% % ? !%&"6 * !%% $$ ? $$"% $& ? C" " $" 7 %=!> '$$"%%,$ ';$% $$%!" ;@ )421012 60A6
B7 '"% $$ $ !%C !$"%C ' ;$% !" %PD ';$% "%% $""!% !%% $"# $% B%C '"$% !" ; '"%% C% "6*B$ $%%% '"% ';$%B C%=+%% % % =' ;$% " $ %? C! !>&%6%= '%$"%"!%%% $ % $% # !%% "!% % $% " % ';$% $% ; %$"%% &7% $B7?%%!$"!% C! '&;$%!" @ )421012 60?/% "C"A6
/001/233. +-/45+ -6 '$>'"%%%; $%"" %& 13L= '%!" % ' %&%" "7> ? $$% ';$%" 7"$6
436 $$% 2-%?2335% 7% %% $> C% &% ;% % 7D !$=" $ 7 ,%$D *I 8='"&% '%D$%+ %!%= $41H%23346"7!%C%# !?7 C% $"% $ "?% 2335 = % %%C "$$%" %&6
""=''%%D%;""!%?B%C$%"%D"= % %& 13L %&%"$!%%%$%%" & "$!% $ !$%% % # '? D7 % $? $%"%%%%C"&"6
446 '"%="$$% ';$% %%=''%$ CC!!%!%&"6 >& #%"7 =';$%';$=$# =%,$ '%&%""C>='CC!='$%%
L6
? " %% $ % = $$% ';$% C ;! $$C 6 "%" "%? $ '!>% '"6$ "%$%;$!"$'"6 $%%'$$"% %%!" %6';$%'%;$!"'"&% '"%% %" $%" %& % !%% C% C H!%!%&"$% &6*%D"%%&%6 "% $""!% = % !%% C% $"%" $ '"6 %+ !%% = $$% ';$% "$ ; %> $"$B$ %&#&$?% &!" ;6
426 % # ;! ' ;% % $!%%% !%% ?+C " 6
406 '" "C> # '& !" %%% = $%" %&%%%6
456 ? "%%"%"= $$% 1&233< ="='$%" %& $%%"%%%> $ 41H%2334%%=' +!N=%C!"$ %B%"='"%% %"'77&%6$$ $%"" %& %&%" $%"%%% " =O$%!$(%%%#C%!" =%#'"&%%" '$ %& "7 %+O6 %% ?&% !% % '% $ CC% $ = ' '"% ';$% "%% $$" =
/001/233. +43/45+ ='$$" $$%"%?$!" %%%B7$%% % % !$% C% = ';$" !" %%% % 7""!% %#$ $%$$%% % C='%# 6 B$ $ $ ; %%% C% $ $"% ='# '$$"% '$%" %& $ !" C! @ ) 421 010 6 0?/ % "C" 4--1$655: 4-99$6135 62A6
416 ) % %% = '$$"% !" ='%C "' %J%%6C% %=C! %" 44 ! 23356 '7% '$%$,D%= '?&"%%%#%"6
, $ $$ = ' $% $ '& %" = '$%" 7'$"%"$&="$%%%#%"@%69 A !$ '%C%%!!%$ D"%#$%" $"$;!$!= ' %&C!% CC% @ 4-9- $6 022 : 4-93 $6 2<3A 7%= !%" @ 4-99 $6 130 : ') * % '& %"%'!$% 432<A6
4<6 %# "%! 7" '& %"6
4.6 DF " %C 7" '& %" % J% "&" ? ' !$ &6 & = '" % $ ?% ' '"%% $ & % !$" & =' $% ?% ;N% '%&%" = $% ?!% J% ;7" $> %%!% % ! " $%% !D" %& "=?"6 !$ &'CC%>7 DCC%;%!%=$? !%% ;&% C%%' &'% CC" $!%%% %; '& %" @!"%D 7"" !$ &: )403059 606542903 6443540< 62% 2?:B='04 "!?2332R %62962 : 4B& 04 "!? 2330R%6464 "%&'%64< : $4B&2335R %6 29 6 2 "% & '%6 4< A6 $" # !$ & &% $ !!% % # %: & & % & %" &% J% "%!" $ $$% # !J! !!% % ! C% & $%? 'C % # % & B=' !!% Q " % &%J%$!$%@ )42-220 65644294.5A6
& '& % J% "&" &% %% C% %% $C >% '%""6 '? ' & CC%&!% "", "C"; "%%%=%='"%%
/001/233. +44/45+ =J% %% 'CC C" " %%%= @+$> : ) 42< .< 6 0?/ % ??A6 ! = %% %%%= &% J% " % "$ '!? %$%$C $%@!%%" D $ P7 " & %%"/%"7 '%% "B % %; '$%A % "% ' "&% !% $& '$$"%6 " % 7? !;!! 21L %%%= $!% % !$% CC"% ""!% = $&% C & '%&%"%&@C6 )42<.9 61A6
& $ & "%! "%?% 7" &!?$"$ "%='%CC%&!%$"!!% "%!% "%% ? %" @ ) 42- 225 6 56064 % "C"A6 % J% "&" !> >% = $? ? =' &% >7 7"" "C" = '" ?% &%'%%%#%"6
496 '' %!%$" "#!$ 7 ? ' $%" %& 13L %&%" "7> C!"!% ; $%"7%"7!%$$?%#B$ C" "6
$ "% %; '?%%!% $$"!% 43L6 '" '%!CC% "%='?%%!% 23L%$ "=%6
&%#%"7 $$=! =%% %%%= &% J% " % "$ '!? % $ % $C $% @!%% " D $ P7 " & %%" / %"7 '%% "B % %; '$%A%"% '"&% !% $& '$$"%6 " %7?!;!! 21L%%%=$!% % !$% CC"% ""!% = $&% C & ' %&%" %&@ )42<.- 61?/:*2332$6.36 65?A6
" % 21L S%&% $ % $ !> 7"" % D= 6 C% % ;! ? S!? % % $% % = ! & D,$%D"%= % J% " %6 S, $ $" # " % %%$D C%%% "%!! !%% " D $ SP7 " & %%" %"7 $! "B %; S$%6 C% ? $%M% $" #"&%7? !% $& S$$"% CC% C% & S& !$% % S!? % %6
/001/233. +42/45+ ) $" "#?%%!% 41L$%!$%$% %%" "%7> % % S!$JD!% # CC% %&; "%" '%$%/ ?%@ ) $?" 03&!?2334522/34A6
% S?%%!% "%" C;" # 41L S %% $%7 S =% S" ?% !%% !$%% S"$@ ) $?" 49B%2330522/34A6
J% 20 %? 2333 @ ) $?" 4../33A ?C" " ="=SS,&%$ %?%%!% 43L !%%# %&%""7> S%&%"!$% "$"%%& = &% % $ % % & 7 7 "&% '%&%" = &% %% %"7 &% & =' !? 7C%C %&%" % "7> % $!%%% '% $% % % $%" ; D $ " = $&% $ CC% %&; % &% "&% $% %%= $7"6
C ) !%!!C% " %C%=S%""%& !%"#;%&#%!$$%6CC%%7""!% != !$," # %!$ $% 77% $$%!% ! = ; = %&% # %!$ $ @ J% ) 43 %? 2330 542/30: & *4--9$6492 65?4--9$62-.:2333$625%?-A6
" % %% %%%= %% $! # 'CC = $ $ ' 7 $& '$$"%6 "%% B7 %C$& %='%!"#&"C?+C " ' %$$"%6';!$%$% &%% =='%%" % $%" $& '$$"%%$%%$$7""; %'%$"%"$ B =%#"%%6%%B7 $% !%C$%%?%%$$"%# ' !%%: % '$$, % %#C$$(%$$$$"% !!!;$$$"@ )42<.1 6<$694420413 62% "C"$6412A6
'$> ? "% '&& B$ +"&=" ='43LCC%#$ "%!%%$"%"$'"% %!$$%6 7" '& %"%$' %$%% %# !+% &% >J%C!"6
4-6 *'7% C $!% , & = '%6 49 6 4 "%" ! C" 5>!"& 6 ;%! '%64964$!> $D @ & % &7 $ 4 B& 2335A
/001/233. +40/45+ "& =%$%? 'J%" $%"% %#%%C DD '!$$$$"%'% "B##& C &6
236 %%! C% '%64964 C7%$ !7 C" "!"%"% %$ !! %6' "# '7 %%&C!%"%% C%$$%" 'CC " $%%6 '%649 6 4 @ & % &7 $4B&2335A "% % "#'"7 CC !%> ' $!% @* 233< 6 51 6562 $6 4<5 V52./31W: J% 6 22 $%!? 2331 V 15/31WA6 '% ' $!%% "%='"%%&" DD ' !$ $%" D $ "% "%% %"@ )44<93 6<$694A6'& %"&% %& $!%$$ = CC%""$&"$'"$%&%&$$$"$ $$ !, % # "%% %" @* 2333 6 2? $6 .4 V53-/-9WA6 C% =' , % %" % '& %" % "%" ' $!% @+ '+& %" R *DXFD &X%7D% V*W *F *DD% 2>! " %D6410%%Y243A6
246 %& $!%$"$$=!%$$$"?% " $%% $& $ '+& %" %% ?B%&!% = !=?B%&!%='"@*233< 6 51 6 56464 $6 4<5A6 CC% ! " $%% % J% CC = $ # = % %" % $%? ! $%!% 'J% " $%" @Z+ * $6 %6 $691: * 2332 62$6442V0.3/-9WA6
226 $$% #'" %"D"%%!6
/001/233. +45/45+
5,/4 ,/ , /
%
6 1
46 "&?6
% 6
26 B%%6
06 %"!!% 233C6#D7 %6
56 C! $% =S $&% C! % $"% J% " 03 B > %C% $> ? C" " @*DXFDC=<<335 A$& !%> % $?C!"!%;%692 C" " ?C" " 4. B 2331 @ )A: !"! % = !%C % !, $&%$%7% % ! %: % J% " ? C" " $ & $% $ & "%= ; % '%6 52 )6 $"% J% % $> $ %&="!!!, $& &%J%B%#'&6 7CC> " % + [ \
$C! $"%J%%%C";$%=S#SCCC" " $7CC
/001/233.