Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/1425/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1425/2007 Généré par l'IA

Admissibility of Settlement Communications and Admissions of Liability

Numéro de cause ATAS/1425/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute centered on whether certain communications constituted settlement offers or admissions of liability, with the court applying the rule that offers to compromise are inadmissible to prove liability. The court reasoned that statements made during settlement negotiations, even if they contain admissions, are inadmissible if their purpose was to facilitate settlement, emphasizing the public policy favoring compromise. The admissibility hinged on the intent behind the communication, determining that expressions of an existing legal position made without an explicit offer to compromise or as part of ongoing settlement discussions were admissible, while direct offers to settle or concessions made within that context were excluded, leading to the affirmation or reversal of judgments based on which category the evidence fell into.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Admissibility of Settlement Communications and Admissions of Liability: The court reasoned that statements made during settlement negotiations, even if they contain admissions, are inadmissible if their purpose was to facilitate settlement, emphasizing the public policy favoring compromise. The admissibility hinged on the intent behind the communication, determining that expressions of an existing legal position made without an explicit offer to compromise or as part of ongoing settlement discussions were admissible, while direct offers to settle or concessions made within that context were excluded, leading to the affirmation or reversal of judgments based on which category the evidence fell into.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
pourparlers transactionnels motivation concession acceptation de l'offre clause exclusive de responsabilité notification des ententes

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of costs for the federal appeal.
Art. 64 LTF
Cited in the dispositive regarding the granting of legal aid for the federal appeal.
Généré par l'IA
A/1577/2006
Protection of Settlement Negotiations from Discovery
A/28/2004
Appeal Regarding Exclusion of Evidence of Settlement Negotiations and Prior Inconsistent Statements
A/2172/2005
Admissibility of Unauthenticated Admissions Against Interest
A/373/2000
Discovery Dispute Over Settlement Communications and Work Product Protection
A/873/2003
Evidentiary Rulings on Prior Settlement Admissibility

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of costs for the federal appeal.

Art. 64 LTF

Cited in the dispositive regarding the granting of legal aid for the federal appeal.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



           !"#$%!&''(  !%)&$!&''(



* +,*    * +

-.  "

 %" /-.  &''( 



 !"#$ % "&'( ' #'!!")#'!!*'#+%

'

,,     )  -       '"# !./0  

                   

   -613-  

 *  0+

) !' ! 8 9' 6774  )   ':# $    !# ;''!"!!"'&: <('#'#!#&#09' 6776=

52'>6774 )'##:"#&&'$''!#=

 )#  # )  &  ! 56 ;' 6773    !"!' ! ''$&&?(=

)  #'##  !"! &  ! 64 &'"> 6773 ' 6/ " 6770   (=

&!60&'">6770 )# >!#!) &!#!;'=

)!'!63(">6770 ) ':#$)#!#&&' :"':!89'6774:!'$&&'!)@&'!'#!60 ;6774=

+  +

  :"#"'$)'A43A5'A?A6!+()+' ;!BC  >'!*''< !'''&#($D'43!:#!#&'+##!!' !!3'>6777B C<''($:#!# D-(!'#!5/;5/4/B C=

"&#'&;+!!D&E'#'>=

    ';'#   > ! )'A 43 A 6   < &#(' <)  &'#+"'F':"#<) "+#!"!!)'## ! &!!#!!#&&' '(>=

)) !#&&'#'''( &!#! ;''!(>;'=

:"#"'$D'A35'A+ '<>''+!!' ">"'!:'!#&=

:"#"'$;&!''! >:#!#!  ' .  !' "F" <  &#! '  >;'  & '' <  ?!E!&E;':'B ,55740!A6= 5/G/&A25G !A6>C=



1234516770  -213-   :'<DDD '!!#+:&&'' <&#!('&E! >!#'!?!E=

D::' -!#&!'!E+&&>!#!;'=

)'A6/A5 'A-<#!#$)'A8A5 'A!&5;(6777- !&<''&!' !&#!;!!"''( $ <'''##<'>"'';+#!!#>=

)&&!##'#'&?>'!;':#$''=

)!':#!#!&&'E"' &&!##'# :+'$)'AG4A6'A B#'()'A3/ C !' (+;<)25!#">6776B:A ,560830!A5 565233!A 5>C= 

)'!#"#&)'A35'A (+!&5;( 6772  < @+ ! ' <  &#! ' "& ' &! ' '' )@& !) && +## ! !' !   B , 557  35 !A 8>=  H   :? ! ? :?  >! " I(?+?' J 5//6&A606<'6G '&A60G(A= K  +" ?'+!L'I ! I(?+&I  J ?'  ''!'M"!!IN'?'! ,'?:'I"37A>''+( !' !H 5//2 &A837'F''#C=

  &#! ;! ! &"E ' '  "  && ! ##'# <'!('''#'!('''#:#!#=

 )''# (  && ! ##'# <)  ! &  !# <)  "> ! &! !  !# &' &    !  !# <  ' ! )::  < ''  ' ' :' &&*' "" > B ,55/>255!A4&A262=5505/2!A5>:'&A5/0=570>537 !A 2> &A 534= O+  K  !?'  ! ?NI   5///  &A474A= + K  ""' !  ''' :#!#  A /2 ! 'A 8  'A= P ,1 PK &L???'M('! !?NI 5/// &A677C=

   ;&! !  )"& ! )'A 8 A 5  'A - " < (''()+!)'A6/A5 'A-'E>! !#!&#!)&&#:'!'&'E!=

)('!:!$&&!##"'>;':=

)' ' 'E  ' '""' !#'"'  !+# ! "&@'# ! )::  ); < (F'  '+ & )'##  <  "&'"' !  ! '  ! ''# "&#'' B ,  42175 ! 27 ( 6775 !A 6=



1234516770  -813-   ,568586!A6 55/>264!A4>'#:#'#C " !::'#$#!<'!:'B@&' &@"&= ' !"'': (AQ'!"'':''RS 6E"#!A 6776  &A6/6''T3//= , 42175!27(6775C=

)&&''&;'>!)'&!<'&(& < )''# : !+  <  '  )('' $ ##  &#!   '    #?#'  & '! ;':# B , 570 > 544 !A 6> '  &A54GAC=<''>+')&&#'':("!+&#! &#'!"''(BP ,1 PK &A'A &A672-678= 1    1P  '''' (A A5682C=

!#!!#>)'&:#&!'#'+E &>E"$#!=

'&?$''#<<'"&"' #('>! &#! B , 568  586 !A 6  55/ > 264 !A 4> ' #:# '#C  +'!#:'?+''&('&!';':  ' @( !) &#!   &&'' $ )U'' ! ! @ ''# ;!  ". +' ' : ::' & +' @ '.!"''!;':"!''''B ,563 68/ !A 8= ( $ && ! )'A 6/ A5 'A ' !  +' &!' !#!'&('!)'A8A5 'AJ ,5645/5!A6 204!A6>1  55/>264!A4>= ,566572!A18&A555= ,55/5!A2&A2= O+K &A'A &A473A=P ,1 PK &A'A &A678A= 1   1P   &A 'A   5688 C= & "&'  "': < '$D+!:!''!'!;':#=<'!#'"' D' :'<D''#D'&+<D'+('!B , 42175!27( 6775 !A 6= , ! 62 ( 6772     G5/176 !A 6A5= , 568 

522 550550!A2 5/0!A5 57G67!A8C=

) )&E  : ' ! '' <) )' ## & ! !@  ' )&&''!#!63(">6770=

  '!   ;': &  " !)''  )'"# .' :"' "'(#!#&&&'!)@&'!;6774!#;$=

 )'"#  '  & (<  "&@'# !   & ;':  '!=

) &  ); ! '+ #'' "&'' & )#  !  " V  ' &'' <  " ! "' !"!# '(' !  & >: !#=



1234516770  -413-   )+!!!#!!@<)'##!&""'V)#:"# &&''!#'!!#'<&#E!' ?!E! &!#!;'#''+!=

D;':!E!D!!!#&!'A



1234516770  -313-  

  1 +0  +,*    * +

 

5A !'!!#!63(">6770

6A ''<'!(>;'A

2A .!RA

8A !"D'"#$('""!,A5777 --$''!!#&A

4A '#""'!G77:A$?+!)'"#A

3A :"  &' !  <D &(' :"  '  &#' F' !  !# ! 27 ; !E  ':' &E ! > :#!# B?NI?:<3 3778  C &(!"'E!!' &> :"#"'@'AG6!:#!# >:#!#!50 ; 6774 B ,C=  "#" !  !' !<    "': ' ".!&('&'+'!'!"!'=!' F' !#  > :#!# & ( &'  & ( #'< @ !' ! )'A 86  ,A  &#' F' '  &E  & ! ' (<#""".!&( !('F';'$)(A  +::E  &#!'         ,, H  H

&:"!&#'F''':#@&'<D$D:::#!# !&+::



1234516770