Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/1358/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1358/2007 Généré par l'IA

Multi-Issue Transaction and Filing Dispute Appeal Affirmances and Dismissals

Numéro de cause ATAS/1358/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Frais judiciaires à la charge de l'autorité
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerns various disputes arising from transactions and filings across several years, with the court addressing numerous distinct factual scenarios and claims. The court's reasoning generally involves applying established legal principles to the specific facts presented in each matter, often resulting in affirming or denying relief based on whether the record supports the asserted claims, statutory compliance, or contractual obligations, which frequently leads to resolutions upholding the lower court's findings or dismissing appeals due to procedural or substantive deficiencies in the presented arguments or evidence.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Multi-Issue Transaction and Filing Dispute Appeal Affirmances and Dismissals: The court's reasoning generally involves applying established legal principles to the specific facts presented in each matter, often resulting in affirming or denying relief based on whether the record supports the asserted claims, statutory compliance, or contractual obligations, which frequently leads to resolutions upholding the lower court's findings or dismissing appeals due to procedural or substantive deficiencies in the presented arguments or evidence.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
objet du litige production de créance motivation sur le fond obligations contractuelles procédure civile insuffisance des preuves

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The provision is cited in order 14 regarding the imputation of court costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/1222/1999
Financial Transactions and Collection Disputes Appeal
A/1534/2001
Commercial Dispute Liability and Damages Appeal Affirmation
A/1479/2001
Commercial Contractual Disputes and Appeals
A/188/2005
Financial Transactions and Contractual Dispute Liability Appeal
A/3453/2006
Statutory and Contractual Disputes Resolution on Transactions

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The provision is cited in order 14 regarding the imputation of court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



           '())*'+) "'(,-.'+)

"

 " "#    # 

/0 - ! +. 1/0 +) 



  !"#$"%%  " &$"%%'" ( )*"

"

++     & (( ,      " $ %-./ 

           ! "# $%  &! !

   ,3011,  

 $"

14  $5$#1.63"#$  7#% *8" "4

34  %$ % 19 :# 3222 &55 " % &,#%"$ ;, !<= >5%"?"" "@&!$"!"$ % "# "< %  "#"$ $A< " @  !" % A  &$<# @&? 3/B%"@%"?"%&#%"$&"!#"4 ""%$ $"$ 5 $ ! :A " % C2 "* 3222 %    " %  (, , , +, , (4 ""    !  ! "%:A "%!!"%& %&%?&$% ! "?% %%,4

C4 39:#3221&$"%! "!&" $%% 4

94 (  !!" % 39 :" 3223 %   $% %:" ?  #%D "A%)E!"F#"%<#;,!<=)> &$ !$" % $@ %& 5" %  * 5$ %" #   " %  : * "  G- !" %  D# @ " %  @ %  *"A D@ %! ! $ $#" "  !!" # &- $" %  * 5$ "   %, *4  $%% """5@&DA!-D%?  #  " !   !" %  !*<  %  : * %""%%:# ** "E%"*"4  " @!""&"!&""!!*%"# "@&!"$%"#?H2B!"I"!*!< 7# %@@  $%4

H4 C"*3223DA$"%&$@  % %, * %  !"" " A "$ %&""$ %!  $"& !ID%"!"!%"!%1H?32 "4  $% "" $A "   ""  !"" %  *"$ "# % &$! %"   % %  !ID" &$ %&"  * %" #% " !"4&#%&$""" " !"?55""#!D-@%!"%*"4

64   % 19 # * 3223 &$ ! &" $% %   % % ? &   $# %  %$ % 19 :# 3222   !$#" %& AA#" %  $""4  &!! %  %  :"  !!" %  """% "$4



01//20322/  ,C011,   /4 %&" $5""%A: *%"#$""5$* &$ $: % 1J # * 3223  19 :# 322C ?  @ " @ %&"D!$% " % DA % &!! " % )4  %A %& *< ,"$ "  "A "  55"$  "* %"4 I"%"#%122B"!"%<1J# *3223!!$% %$" $4     " %   %A"@"%!!"%C5$#322C"$ -$"D@% "* %"  "" !",A " $%  1..2 %& 5" % "* %"  "" !",*" % "$ %&"$-"D< $@""  #A55"#"! * ,"$1..H"( 4

J4 %$%39# *322C&55"%& !;,!<= > %$&$!"! "%<3 322C4"! "$ % "" %$ @ &$ #" $"$   *$$5 %&  ! " ! "!&55$A%! ";,!<=>%3 32231 322C @&&"#$@%"@@:%" !! %%"$4

.4   !!" % H # * 3229    %A"@ %  *A D@ $@ %! # 1..6  ! % !$"D"%&$!%"""!",5" !@$%&"$ -$" #  1.J1 " 1..H  ! % !%-"D" G-"   *! 1..H"$%#%&"$ -$"32234!"$% "#"%!19 32234&F?!!" $%% I  %"  %@ @&  !" FA @ &$ F  " "#"$4 (  !!" $% "  !"$ !5 &$ !" "!"?%FD!:"!"%*"% , D?D"%""!"4!"?AF& %*""!"!"!"45" """% &$" 4(!$ <"% D"%H22?622 <"4  !$" !% ""?&$!%""%"#!"%$!% DA%&!%!$??%FG4%"!!* "#  D"  %$!   $A   !"4     !" ""!"*!&"A4

124 11 322H&$*"%&A!$"%@4

114 (!!"%11K"322H%% @%DA %,# % ) &$ !$"  5" 5$ % -% # !" % #" AD  @& %  % %F #F  ! %& "$ -$" D@ % "* %! 1..C " %  *AD@4  $%!!!"$%"#4



01//20322/  ,9011,  

134 33K"322H """@&!"$%"#!%" "" " 55"$ %  % %  # $"" % 122 B % 1J # * 32233.:#322C"%#"I"$$#$! $%"""4("F "! "#" DA  # * 3223    " *$#"@"%F !,@4&!!? $"!54

1C4   !!" % . !" * 322H   + %A %A"@  $#"   !" #" A #!$"%&A" !%&!"DD-!""D""@ "5"% -%5$4!"$%"#"?$## 4&$"""""4

194 36"*322H$"%&$@" % &!$" %@ " $"$  ! "   !"  @  !"" !$"%-!$?&55""5"A"<#"?"%& D%122 <""%& "$%@@ D%&455$A "%&  *AD@#%"@&"!$:$%!!$"4&#%  $%&$"!"?55"& !"@"#!D-@4

1H4 12# *322H+5 & @&#!"" %3.K"322H4&$""%@"!'" !"*# "#"$ !5 $A<  !D-@ " ! $!#"  DA "%$*"?" !!"4

164   % 1 %$ * 322H   + !$ ? &  @  $"% L" !"*#&$""%,#"" %!""4

1/4  11 :# 3226 &$ "   ?  F!" !   4   !!" % 1 5$# 3226  $% %A"@ %  *A D@#1..H?"%&"$ -$"%: *!""% < " " &$"" !! " AA#$   %  %< $  "" !","$ -$" D@ % "* %" #  $%#  32235"%55%&$!%"5"% -%#11 322H"""!",!"#"#%A!D 5"" !<&5"4 ": *%"!$@ $@ "  %$#" "$ %  : * %"   " %  *5$%""!"% *"$%D#%"4 """  !ID"&$% DA" !!% "%&55""# !" %*" " % !" % DA4   "" $A "  " !  !"  " $"" &" % !"4 &F!" "  @ &F!"$  !" "  ! % @" D ! :4  %" $A " $#"55" I !"@%55"%*%"4(



01//20322/  ,H011,   ! !-D@ " " &F!" " @ &$ " ""$ " !D*<"4  !! "< 5L4 %! %&5*!"$%&%!"" %"% 4&F!" ""@M(!#!"$ ! %& "< 5* "#" $ ?  !!" % , I  %& D  A# " % %" ?  #  "" """# % ! %&"#"$M ;!4 H % !!">4 $   $% "  @& ! % "# ?  % @" D ! : " "D$@ " !* %  "#"$%!"$4

1J4   !!" % $%!"" !5 % 12 :" 3226  " ""$ @"#"$!5#A*!""%" %  !%" % &%" $A<   %" " $A4  !" % A"$#$?HHB4

1.4  C2 "* 3226 &  " "  %" % &$  !:" % %$%&"%&@"%"%<1.:#322C"%&% ,"%<  1 # 322C4  %@ !  @ %  % $%!"" %&% !5"$"%$% %$"" "#$%!"%&$4

324 & 5 !:"%%$!%$5 %32 322/ %$!"%"""%&$4

314  " % C  322/ &$ " "  %$  " ?  " " ? &" %& " %&#%"$ "< %<  1 # 322C4  " A @  &F!" "" """# % ! %&"#"$ " "@55% "!!-D@"$? %4&F!" " @"""#"$ I !""%$5"# "F4  " 5" 5 # @ &*"" " % 12 B %  """@ "?""%##%"$"55"4

334  !$# % 1J : 322/ &" $ "  :" % 4  <# @ &!"$%"#"%?% "5#"!&,#%"$ " @  5* " &""  " & A @ &$  % , I 4 (&A"%&*"" "%"""@!%!"%A 5"#@&$%"!!$ ":"5!% N " " "" %& !    ( %! %  * $ " "# ":4'" I % """*"" "%1HB %A$%&#%"$"@%H/B"&#"%!!%"? "!$4

3C4 ($"$"?:A4







01//20322/  ,6011,    #"

14 5 $ " ? &"4 H6 4 1 "4  D4 3 %   A#  &A" :% ;>  * " %   '"  " @ % """ !$# ? O" H6 %   5$%$   !" A$$ % %" %   % 6 "* 3222 ; > @ " "#?5$%$O,#%"$%1.:1.H.; >4

34 ":"$%%$ !""%!$%%!!%": %8@"5 !"!"#*;"4H6 >4

C4 " "AF  &  %A$ %&#%"$ % " ? !" % &AA#"$A$?# %&#32234

94 @&"%&#% %&% ""%" ! F    $A" % &$ " %& < A$$ !*4 ( " &" !   &55 " @%$ %&"$ %  "  " #"A" !  5 %&"$  "<4  " $A% &% ""  " %&"" ! FA" ! !!$  "< !* % $A" % &$ @  ! % " ! @ &" $$ %!  %$ "$"*54:"!"%&"!#%&!!$"@ :A %"  !! !"4   :A  %" F   " &% """D$@"%&"$ "<@@!"" "AF &",?,% @% &% ""  5$ %&"  "<   5%"&"4J/49%<A "&,#%"$%1/:#1.61 ; > " @ &$  ":"$  !  "54  "E ! &""$ :% &"  #D ! $ @ &% "" " "$  "<   # % % ; + 12.  119 %4 3*>4  !! %$#!!$!:!%"##% %%!"" ;"4J/4C"9 >"!!*!A?% %%$#; + 1C2/C%4C>4

&!<&" $""""$ "<% %%$#4 #",%&F @"@"5%4

H4 F "  % &"4 J 4 1 " C   " $!"$ #%"$ O!"$ % A ""  !" @ " !$ $ ! "  % A %$4  $ :@OFL"!%O"#"$"##"%OI""""%"$ !D-@ ""%"!"I"FA$@OF""$!"$ #%O""" !ID%O !"#FD*"4(O"49   &#%"$ !" $" %& 5 "$ A$" %& %  %& %"4O#%"$"$!"$#%<@O"!""A#"$ !!?#%"F!""""%$"4



01//20322/  ,/011,   " $!"$ !"$ % "# "" !" ""  !" % O!""% % O$ ?  ! %  !5   %  %O"#"$  "# @ !" I" * " I" FA$ %   "" !" $" %  "$ !D-@ "4%O!"$%"#%A%$O"#"$@ !" I" FA$ %  !"  # %O " !5  %O " % %O"#"$;"46 >4"$!"$!"$%A""% " %O *%O!"%!*"$%A%O$ D$% "# $@*$ @ "  %$"  "" % " $" %O """?"$!D-@ ""@O!"!<"" ""  %$%!""FA*;"4/ >4

(  :!%  " %&#%"$   % %" %   "  " $ @ "  $%P  "  $@ $ @*:"#%&!"$5"@& !"%&$#; + 112  3/H %4 9 12H  32/ %4 3>4 @&  % &"#"$ % &$  %$ $ @ 5" %$5"  -   %  5%   %$%&% $%% N! """%&$#!"$ %"#%&"$$%%"#"$* "FA*; +11H 1CC%4312H1HJ%41P + !*$%1.#3223HH9021>4

64 ( &"4 3J 4 1   %  " "$  #A  1 :# 3229 &$  %" ?  " & " #% ? 92 B  4  " " $D$ ""F%&#%"$=92B @"H2B  % 62B ",@""/2B ""<4

/4  !!" % $#""$ $ ;! F !  % &%" &!"$ % "# &#%"$ &""" ? &"$A"$ !D-@  "> !!"&""%5"%&% $%4!!#$"*%"% &$?%!""&% "":A*%% "@ $% %"  54 &!!$" % %$ $% #I"    !"%&""!A%%"F"4:!%%!$$  "8D % $% ! F !  % &$#" % &#%"$  % &""" ? &"$A"$   % &F  %  % "$ " " &$#$ "%""#%% A; +1331HJ%41* "  $5$P (   !#  %" %    = $A&D%),*"( )Q ),83222!436J>4

 &,#%"$&""% 5" %&% $% 5% !!" % $% """ %"$ ? &55 % &,#%"$  F!" % $% %$!%" % &""" %&  F  !"@$ !  " %&*#" $% % &  ; + 13C  1/H>  F!" !%" !  !"  @  F!" $% %$ !  :A % ! <  % %< " ;( 1../ !4 C1J %4 C*P    !$% % ""#  ,#%"$ "D< +*A



01//20322/  ,J011,   1...!4193>4%&$#"%&#%"$"8D% $%"? !"  :A "  &$"" % "$ " ? %@ % @  " ! @ "#"$ &$ " !* % "#4  "  %$ $% """  $$ " " ! %$"  @ "#F  !"  * " FA % &$ ; + 13H  361 %4 9 "  $5$>4

 @#!*"%&!!" $%@"%$" " &" @  !" "AF " 5" &*:" %& $"% "$ @  !!"  5%  % F   !" @& ! $A "  %$"!"F! $!!F $@&"$"$$"*  !  % & < @  %!" % "F" $% " &!!$"%"" $%""5@ %&F!""%K " "#$4 % "&$$ "%$" "! # !*" &"  &A % - % !#   %$A"   !!"    F!"  * " *  " ; + 13H  CH3 %4C133162%41"$5$>4

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

.4 &!< "% !"$%"#%H2 B%"#"$%!"$?#&FL"!"! """% DA  !"  $"" !  !" % % DA "  ""%*%"@%55"4(*% ""



01//20322/  ,.011,   # % $%!"" !5  " $ @  " !" "#%!%"%&%"$A<%" "$A4

 " # @ &F!" "  @& ! % "# ? H2 B "    %  !"$ % &$  5* !"$ "" " M %$ "  $ ?  "" % %M4  #" ""5 % ""@&F!"5"$5$?%"<#"!&, #%"$4  55" &""  " &!D*$"   @   55" % 5L """ % 5" " "  <#" ! % %  $%4 (&A" % !"$ "" % "  %#"I"%$$ 55"! !%%A% "#"$ !%<@&$"" %&F $"% 7# %*8" "!%"!$4

""#"%&% ""@!"$%"#%&$"%&!" %#"" " $%%H2B%"#"$%!"$4

124 @%!"%A,&"!"@$! " 5   @  &*"" " %  """@ " !4

@&#%"$"$#$*%&@I"""% :!%"%$%"A* F %3HB5 % "  !" % %55$" $$ " @ !#" 5  # %& "#"$"#; +139C31>4

&" $"*"" "%12B4 ""!$"%  * ""!"!"#@&?" !!""!D*<" " $"A4 $    %  "5 : 8A  * % $ " @&*"" "!$:"5!4""$""%  &" $&#$?:""" I #$%"%1HB!"%A "5$?62B4

114 #%@!$<%#"%&% ""@"!"!$"% @&?% ,"?!"%1#322C4

134  * % $ <# 5 @& " *  " % % % &" % !""  !$ " & !!" @& &" !   % ""#!"$$%%"#!%%"&, #%"$!"" !"455"&-%!%%$" ? "" % # %$" " !   %  !""  # D-!"D$"@ % &"#"$ "# %& #% !" @ & " $"* @ ,"<" " %&F""#"$4 "" !$ $ ""!$ !"!"I"#$; +11H JJ%43>4  "< FA* % &F %& "#"$ "# %" I" F $ 



01//20322/  ,12011,   5"" "%&8A%!$""%"$ A"@5 "!5&"#"$F$:@&% D$ %& !"$D$"%" !! A!%"@ $"$ $A$ %  # !5 ; + 11/  3.2 %4 CP ( 3221 !4 13J%41*P%43%&I" 4%.5$#322H9202C$ $  620322H!413/P#$A " + %65$#32269.029>4

1C4 $"%@!$<%@%"I":"$4

194    N  "  *  -   % "" ?  DA  $  "%:"%32254!!"%&"46.41* 4







01//20322/  ,11011,  

  #"$  " "#    # 

!

 2 3/

14 $#*4

! 3

34 :""4

C4 &$  "5F$?32254" ?DA%"4

94 5   !" %  @O !#" 5   "  !$" I" %  %$ % C2 : %<  "5" !< % * 5$%$ ;(DRSD5@66229  >!#% "<%%" !*5 $ "F"4J3%5$%$ *5$%$%1/ : 322H ; +>P  $  %  %" %@   "5 " -%!#"!"A"%"% %"P%" I" %$  * 5$%$ ! # !"  ! # $"@ F %" % &"4 93  +4  !$" I" "  !<  ! % "#@$  -%!#%#"I":"?&#4  A55<  !$%"          )  ( -       

!5 %!$"I"""5$F!"@O?O555$%$ %!A55



01//20322/