Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/1320/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1320/2007 Généré par l'IA

Recidivist Sentencing Enhancement Based on Prior Convictions with Disbarred Counsel

Numéro de cause ATAS/1320/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The court reviewed multiple penalty enhancement determinations concerning prior convictions under a statute governing recidivist sentencing for subsequent offenses. The central issue was whether certain prior convictions, challenged as unconstitutionally obtained due to representation by counsel who was later found to have been disbarred, could be used to aggravate the current sentence. The court reasoned that the defendant failed to demonstrate that the counsel in the prior proceedings was constitutionally ineffective or that the convictions were obtained in violation of the right to counsel, and thus, the convictions were valid for use as prior offenses for sentence enhancement purposes, affirming the lower court's application of the recidivist statute.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Recidivist Sentencing Enhancement Based on Prior Convictions with Disbarred Counsel: The central issue was whether certain prior convictions, challenged as unconstitutionally obtained due to representation by counsel who was later found to have been disbarred, could be used to aggravate the current sentence. The court reasoned that the defendant failed to demonstrate that the counsel in the prior proceedings was constitutionally ineffective or that the convictions were obtained in violation of the right to counsel, and thus, the convictions were valid for use as prior offenses for sentence enhancement purposes, affirming the lower court's application of the recidivist statute.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
fixation de la peine usage antérieur responsabilité restreinte en droit pénal révision en matière pénale imputation de la détention risque de récidive

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive to rule on the costs of the appeal proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/4428/2005
Appellate Review of Enhanced Sentencing Based on Prior Conviction Elements
A/2627/2004
Petitioner v. State on Finality of Prior Convictions for Recidivism Enhancement
P/127/2018
Sentencing Appeal Regarding Multiple Offenses and Retrospective Concurrence
P/20040/2017
Appeal Regarding Sentencing and Custodial Measure for Multiple Offenses
PM/882/2016
Conditional Release Granted Despite Prior Convictions

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to rule on the costs of the appeal proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



           '()*+',--. "'(/,-',--.

"

 " "#    # 

01 2 ! ,( 301 ,--. 



 !"#$  % % & %'$ ()*$+,)+- 





%

     & ## )      %!" ./0 

           ! "# $%  &! !

   )+12+)  

 $"

24  ("2/,-% 567 5 ! 8+392//: 5%% ;)$ %"4

+4   55% !"   ,9$ 2//0  %% 5.<%7 $(%  =>5%? $%  @$ A)5@B =C  "!  (%  %' ($   5%" A5%" .C  "5  D ;<"E 5 <%  $  !!% <7  E <"5%% %  " $ 9!' %% D   %  $"!%  2//+4 &" %  5%"  %$ 5  " "%!"4

F4  " FG%2//-;""%"!'""6 ;% ;$ %" %@ @292//H4

H4  2/ ++ $!' 2/// ;"  "9" D  7 5.<%7  ) "4#55%%6D"9 %" +H$!'2///%(" 5 %;(% %@!<5%%  %" $% 5 $(  E4  (%   !"  %  . !  "5  D  E %  . !  $( D  !"%< !5%4 %% 6% %<7%!%" !%4

:4  +H9$  F6"$ +333 ;"  "9" D  7 ($  % 5 I% $"   E % "("  ! <'%4   55%  23 6"$ +333    %   %% 7 (%7% 55!%  %' !%? % %'  !5%!% " D ;%%  E4  !' %" %  "5  ? 'J J"5  %'(! <7  "5  !% "'<"7  " K.%7   %  !$ "%% %4  !%%5%%5%)$(?5".%!5%)

%".%<@ %'% 6"! %2//+5%)6% L2//+ %5%)!"(%D;L( H4

,4 22+,$+333;" $"9"D 7($  %4  (% %  %74  '%  "9 %  $( D  E  "(!%  ! <'% % ;% % ; %%!% % "54

04     20 9% +333  ' %%" &"  "%" !  %4



12/,-1+330  )F12+)   -4 55% : "!'+333 ;%" ;( 5.<%7 =%%%7;""%" ! %%%"D%% %  !%6 7;  5"%" 5@ $ I%"  E  7 &% 'J J"5%5"  ; " % $ %>'4  (%7  %' !%? %  !5%!%  5"4

/4 !+33H; %!5"  "$ %4

234   55%  235%!' +33H   *5  (% $%B "5  ? 5" %!% '%%" 5 !"%<   ' ;5"  "5  D  E "5  ? 'J J"5 '%%" %' !%? % %'  !5%!% " D  !!%  E % ;<"E %'%" (!%  ;%% !"%5)5<(  5 (< A%% 5@ 6%)?%  5 (<C  % !5 !  5  %5@%".%<@%  ;6%$% 9!' % $ "  6 %7 55%" % % ?% (( %M <9%$% (7 "5<"  5% % %' %%7    $ $  "$(4  !"  !%5 <5%%5$( ED 7 5.<%7 ) "%D 7($ %2//-2/// % +3334  " 7 ;"%%  %"  ;" ;(($4  5%  $ %<.!75"% "%% ;( %%% <! 5 "5%$+33H '4

224 #' ;?! 22$% /5%!'+33: 5.<% 5@  D  ?5%4   55%  +/5%!' +33:  (%7  %'   5%" "!%!% ' %  . !  "5 45! (%6 %%%7 ;" "(% $ !5$%" %   "%  "7   %4  !% "(!%  %'%"  ;<! %  55% 5  !  7%4 ;?5% ?% 5 %  %'   5%" .  6% 7 ;" 5$% D "%'  % ' %  % D  5%   @ %  "%% ;( %  %%  7  <!4 %  %% ;" 5 "(!% $ %%  "@ 5<J7$$% @!%4'L!5 5%% 5 9%6%5'5?57 !5%!%4  %?! % "  %'   5%"4  %   5 55% D )4  ? %'  5!%%% 5 D ;"  ;"   "%"   "  $(4  %' % 5"% 5 !'"%5%%!$45%"  %$% @75 '%%5%"!5$% "7  5!%%% 5 D ;"  ;"   !  564



12/,-1+330  )H12+)   5  (5!%5 ;$$ %%66% %%' 5%";!5I< $<"( ;$ 55%66!!%'$5%%@4!  " 5%%56%5$('%5%" %$ 5%5I%!""5 !!" 4

2+4 $!"  2-9$+33,=%% #$!" "( 5#! A)5@B#C "7 ;?5%   5$ 7  %?!  ;" % 5!4!%$%$56%7;?5% (%7"%'  5%""!%!%'%7%';%5 "!5"% 5%% 5 $ %4  % D % "(  7  !9%"  5 7 5"%%%' 5%"%$%6% "%"  !@ 56%!% !4  %! "(!% 7 ;<%   %?! &""$7%?!5! @7& "'%" $;L( 2:5!!% '% ; 5 D ;L(  2/  !!% ;<"E4 %  "'%   !!% %?7;"66%"6!%5  % %$"  7%" ;!5." %!5  7 6%  D  =7%' 5%";9!"%"$ % %7;%7!% ;%?!5! $% 5 5 !5%% % $  "5( <'% A$ %6  (NC 7 ;"%$54%!"(!%7;"5"% "7 $ %   %?!4  ;$   !"  ;" % 5' %%!%%O$5$5%" %$  %$%"4 % ;$ %""%""D%%4 ;"57 ; !%%;5."%"5"%%%?!5!  4"7%;(%5 ;55"% 66"% ; !I!"%% 6%! ;' ;?! %@ %?!4

2F4  "  +H$+33, ;  55!  % ;$ %"  ;" @5!9  ?@!!7%%6%  "4  6% ;  5@  D   "%   " % 7; 76  !6%!% "   6 %  ;$ !"    =4

2H4  +H!+33,!5"%"++9+33,&"6!55%D %% "5&%!"  %%D%4

2:4  9% D  55% %!!%  %6% !"     * 2/!+33,7%" ("%!B

                            



12/,-1+330  ):12+)              !        "      #$  #          #  # %  %&! !  

 #$ ' !   "  %       "#   &   ( (   &    %( &        #       )*+

,  &       ( (   #    '       

2,4   $ !"   2- 9% +33,   = %% 7 &"%%  %"  &"  &% 5 5"9"4  "5@% 5  7  %?! % 5! % 7 &" % @  %% !%%  O$ 5   !!% % %$  %$%"4  "   !%% 6%5!%755  ! ?5% 5"%%<5" %<(4

204 #  55%  2 ! +330  % ?5% &" 5"%  5'' %<   '  5 (<  %% 5@ 6%  6"! % D ;L( 2:)2,%%5@6%$%%')5"" 9!' % 2//+ (( %%"(!% !!'6" (<4  %%% D  %" ;%P% 5  5%"  %$   5!%74

2-4  "55% 2,$+330; 9%%)4 6%  6   ;$   =  #  2-9% +33, 5 7  !"  6!  5"" % .  7   55% ;?5% 4

2/4  %  2-! +330 ;" 5"%" 5  % %9%%  %%% "%'% D;%  "% 5"'!% D  7; ?5% 9  %  "4  % 6% (6D;%!" ;I%"%"  ;?5%5 . '%% 554

+34   "%!%  2/9 +330 ;%!" %  9%    5%5;%!%$%  "55%4

+24 "57 2+9%+330%5% 4 @$7!% (%7"7%?!"%%  %' 5%"4 %D*  5 5   %@ 5!      %?!4  % 55 5  7; % !%"   55%  %  ;%" ;(5.<%7 = : "!'+3337;5"%"



12/,-1+330  ),12+)      ; "   %  $ %>' 5@ $ I%"  E % 'J J"5 % 5"4  %%   (%  %' !%? % %'  !5%!%  "%" 5"  5"4

++4 ++G%+330;%!"5%"(!% 4

+F4 #"%"( "D9(4

 #"

24 6!"!%D&%4:,42%4<4+ ($&(% 9 AC '% P%% 7  %%% 5"$ D ;% :,    6" "   5% (""  %     , %' +333 A C 7 % %$D6" ";)$ %" 2/92/:/A C4

#!5"%59(  &5@%"%'4

+4 %9%"   " % 6! 5%      % $' A%4:, C4

F4 % %(  ;  7%  $  ;%!" "%%  %   "  "  F G% 2//- 5 7   %."  % &$ %"%@%4

H4 #  55 (""  %    & !%% 5%  "  " 6!!% 5"  6  < 9(" %  7%%"9 &%55"7%6 D % 7& %   % " % 7  %6% $I%  !5% %'4   '    "%  (  55% % "  % !I!7&%%%""%% &55"%  6% A * 220  20  4 + 22:  F2H  4 H1C4  % 5 ( $  "$  "   5  %%" 9  & !%%%% 5" D"$ & "%"6 6! 7 % "$%  6% $?   $? !.  5$ 5%'    D  55"% 9 7 66"% A *2+,+F 4 H'%"6"%"C4 %7"$%  "% % "! ?5%!% "(" D &%4 :F   A *  5'"5%!% 2+!+33HQ2H013F 4:4FC4

 9(&% !'  " "5!%67&%   % "  6%  6    %% 9 7 ?%% 



12/,-1+330  )012+)   !!%R%% ""%"  !5%% 5%7$(D &"57 A * 22/  H0/  4 2'1 %  "6"C4   '    "%  (  55% % "  %  !I! 7&%%%""%% &55"% 6%4<(!%  5%7   95   %  55 9%6   "% A *22020 4+22:F2H 4H1C4 "% %"!%7&"%"5' @(  %  %  555" !  7  5% !5%% &%5"%"557"&%"%" !@555"A 2//,1/0S+- 542:- 4FC4 &$?%% !6%%I% ! 7 &%   5%% "5    % !%" % &?! 55  5$ &55"% 7% D %   5%    ""!%%7 "5P% !'!5%% %% 6%%  %A * 5'" 2+%'+33:-13H 4F4+C4

:4 ?%! &%4-42%F %"5%"$ %";5%" ( %%5%7 %5"!"5!%  ( "4 " !9 7 ;?8% 5 ;%$%" %$ $% ;I% %%%   %"5<.7!%% %5%I%?("7;?%% "5%" $   ;%%%  !5I< ;!5  %$? <'%4 # ;%4 H   &$ %" 5% "% & 6!%" ("% & !  & %4;$ %"%"5%"$ @7;%5 %%($%"55D$ %?5%%%% "%4

% "5%" 5%"  %$ %% 5% %%  5%  ;5%%   ;" D !5   56   ! ;%$%"  %$ 7 5% I% '!% I% ?("    %% 5% "%   %" 5<.7!%4 ;5%" %$ ( ";%$%"7 5% I% ?("   5%  $ ; % 56  ; % ! ;%$%"A%4, C4%"5%"5%" (%% !% ;!' ;5% 5'%" ( ;"!<"  %$ "7'" 7 %   "%  %% !% "% ; %%%D%"5<.7!%%7;5%5@%%!%% ! " 5%%?('A%40 C4

#  95   % &$ %"    %    %  % "!7 %  !" M  %  "7 "!7'9%$ &5%"6%7&!5% &"$A * 223  +0:  4 H 23:  +30  4 +C4 7&   &%$%"  &"  " "!7 6% "6%  .     6    " & !"  !R5!%%% &"$5%" %$ &%""  %$%"'!%?('A *22: 2FF 4+23:2:- 42M * 5'" 2/$+33+::H132C4



12/,-1+330  )-12+)   ,4 # &%4 +- 4 2     % %"  $(  2 9$ +33H &"  % D  % & % $  D H3 T  !4  % % "<"!!%%? &$ %"BH3T!7%:3T ! !,3T!%)7%%03T!%%@4

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



12/,-1+330  )/12+)   5 &%%%D%"D%@$ %A *2+0+// 4:6M #+333542:: 4FC4

  %   95  %% %  "5  !! &!5<! "5  %%?!% "5  %%5$ %" 4$<9> &)$ %"7&5$7"!  %7 %P%%%D%"5<.7!%%D5%" (    "% )!I! & %%% D  %" 5<.7  !% 7  $  !  A * //  +-  4 +M # +33+ 54 F+  4 + 2//, 54F2/ 4+F+2 42%F+: 42C4

-4  55%  "$%%" " A5 ?!5  !  & % &5%"  %$ &$ %" &%%% D &%"(%" 5<.7  !%C 55%&%% 6% & !" 455$"%' %  &"D 5%%& !%%9('  !%7 !"  %  64 &55"%  " !"  $I%   !5% &%%5(  %?%495  5""  %L<  !"  5 ?!5   &"$%  &$ %"   &%%% D &%"(%"    &?!    %" % % &"$"!% %%$  !!(A *2++2:- 42' %  "6"M #   5$  %     B "(&< =)'%# =U =)L+33354+,-C4

 &)$ %"&%%  6% & !"  6  55%  !"  %%% %" D &66  &)$ %"  ?5%  !"   "5 %  &%%% &  ?! 5%7" 5  % &'$% !"   &  A * 2+F  20:C  ?5% 5 % 5  5%  7  ?5% !"   " 5  9(  5!@   @ % A# 2//0 54 F2-  4 F'M    5"   !%%$  )$ %" %<@ *'( 2///542H+C4 &"$% &$ %"%L< !" %D 5%  9(!%  &"%%  %" % D  7  7 ! % 5 7 %$%" &" % 5'  %$4  %  " !"  %%%  ""!% % 5 "%! 7 %$?  5%  '!% ?(  &" A * 2+:  +,2  4 H %  "6"C4

 7$5'% &55%!" 7% "%!% &% 7  5% %(? % 6% &'9% & "%  %" 7  55%  6    ?! !5% 7& 5 "(!%   "%5%?5!"55?!"7&%"%""%'  5   &!@ 7  5%  %?% !"  % &55"% %% !" %%67



12/,-1+330  )2312+)   &?5%% G!%!%$"4  !%&""!% "%!%5 $ 5'% &%  &(  !.  5$   "(% !! 55%  !! ?5% ! ' % '  % A * 2+:  F:+  4F2++2,3 42%"6"C4

/4  ;5@ ;%!"  !  % D  ?5% 5.<%7 5  4 # 55%  +/5%!' +33: !5%  "7% 95 % 5  P%  5 $ 5'%4  66% % ?5%6 !@!5@%7 !" 45  5    "%  5%  ;"4 # ?5% 7% ? (%%%%$%4

 #$7 %?! ;" % %' 5%""!%!%'4 %'"D%?!5$7 5%" %$%%4 ;%"(!%%' 5%"7!5I<;" ; 5%D $!%564

  55% !"  556  % 5%   ?!  ;"  % % 4#=  #%' %%?5%7%?!;%&5@ 5 "5 % ; %' 5.<%7  !I! 7    $ D   55"4 # I% 5.<% %  $ ?!"  %= "@%7%' 5%";% 5 "!5" % 7  !9%"  5 7 5"%%  % %' %$%6% "%" !@56%!%!4% "(!%  (!%  6$ ; %?! 5!  6% 7  %  !!" D !!  ( @ ;L(  2: % 7  "'%   !!%  %?7    "%"  !  6  6!%5  % %$%%7;!5."%!54  % 7  %'   5%" ; 9! "%" $ % % 7 ;5%"  %$ %  7!% D  %?! $  "5( %7$%%6  (%4

  .  5 %    " 7 ;$ !"   2-9$ +33,   =% "5$ %%$5'%466%); 5 ?!" ;" % ;% 5  5"%  5.<% ;(% ; !" %%4

 %%  6 ;?5% 555"  "% &% %%!6%!%"4%%?5%  5!  6!  ')6 "  %% "4   % 5 5"  D   "%  )  % @  !6%!% 5 !54



12/,-1+330  )2212+)  

234 # ;%4,/ 42'    5"     !%@  %%% 5%%;%6 5%%  ;  $%%' %   % ! D  6  9% 6?"  6%   <( " D  5"   "5 !!%   $ %( % +3364 % 2&33364

  $%  %% 5% "(   9%6   ! ;%!" D  "!!% 9% :3364

   

  #"$  " "#    # 

!

 5 60

24 "$'4

! 6

+4 ; !%4

F4  " 2,$+3304

H4 %"!!% :3364D<( ;%!"4

:4 6!  5%   7; 5$% 6!  %  5"% I%   "  F3 9 @  %6% 5@  ' 6" " A#<VJ<67,,33H  C5$ !%@  % 5'6!"!% ? %4 -+     6" "   ' 6" "  209+33:A *CM!"!  % 7!%6% !. 5$%5%(% % ! %M % I%  "  ' 6" " 5 $ 5%  5 $ "%7 ?



12/,-1+330  )2+12+)    %  &%4 H+  *4  5"% I% %  5@  5  %$7"!!!. 5$ $%I%9%D&$4

  (66@  " %        =  # .       

56! 5"%I%%%6"?5%7;D;666" " 5(66



12/,-1+330