Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/1263/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1263/2007 Généré par l'IA

Contract Damages: Lost Profits Versus Overhead Expenses

Numéro de cause ATAS/1263/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Frais judiciaires à la charge de l'autorité
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute involved the proper calculation of damages stemming from a breach of contract, specifically concerning the calculation of lost profits and overhead expenses for a period following the breach. The court reasoned that while lost profits from collateral business ventures were speculative and therefore not recoverable, the injured party was entitled to recover a portion of its fixed overhead expenses that were reasonably attributable to the breached contract, as these costs would have been covered by the revenue from that contract, thus mitigating the overall loss.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Damages: Lost Profits Versus Overhead Expenses: The court reasoned that while lost profits from collateral business ventures were speculative and therefore not recoverable, the injured party was entitled to recover a portion of its fixed overhead expenses that were reasonably attributable to the breached contract, as these costs would have been covered by the revenue from that contract, thus mitigating the overall loss.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
calcul du dommage gain manqué inexécution d'une obligation contractuelle charges justifiées par l'usage commercial différend commercial dépens

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied to order the appellant to pay the court costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/652/2007
Breach of Contract Damages Calculation: Lost Profits and Statutory Interpretation
A/2276/2007
Damages Calculation in Breach of Contract: Lost Profits Methodology
A/1557/2004
Contract Breach Damages Calculation and Lost Profits Speculation
A/1762/2002
Contractual Breach and Liquidated Damages Calculation
A/1740/2002
Benefit of the Bargain vs. Recoverable Losses in Contract Damages

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied to order the appellant to pay the court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



            !"#$ %&&'  !%(# %&&'



  ) *)  * * )

*+,  %  !# -.,  %&&' 

   !"#$#  %

 %    !&' "#"#%()

*%

++, + + !5%  ++ + + -    %  %"./*""00"#""  #1

2    ++  22+   *%"34$$"+  



    

                     

 / 

"' %67*8%#$$389:;% % ;/% 9% * /%!   <%    !  "41# *  % !"41=% !*#86 #$$#'

#' +: 55%067*/%! *! % ;/% 9% *%!  /%*7 /%  * !  < %  /%!<) /%5  >  /% : !/?%*% 7'

=' 67* <%*<!5  * 5"% #$$3*!*!*% @55   % ;!"8 #$$3/%?!* /%*7'

.'  % ;!  *!/%* % * ** /%!<) /  *%/! * ** !5%/% *  >% **< %/%* > %*% 7 **%#86  #$$#*"% #$$3'

0' +  %% %   ++  ,   +  +  ++ +  +  -        . 6  #$$3  /%**  >  /*  % 7 /%  % *  #$@1#3 5%' 80 5%' *!%A* /%   "%   #$$3' +  %% %   2       ++   22+    #= 6 * #$$3 @< % /%*7;/%%% *>0@#=$5%'10 *"3@##$5%'%B   ++ + ( ++ +     @< %  % 7 !  5B *:!% >' *5    %% %    ++   + ( ++   +      . 6  #$$3 @< %  /%!<) *%5!%! C  2    ++  22+ < *!*!* *!* 9%* %*% 7@55  * )*!;*!"%!;%#$$#

1'  %    *% *  //%*   % ;  <>!  /%*      /%*  /%  "= <;% #$$3' D     %  5 %! < % *%< ! /%  7%/  C /%* %  "% !;%#$$#*%* /%!!*/ *%   %*%*'  % * /%  * >  % ; % *  6%  /%*7%;@< %#$@1#35%'80/%%*"3@."05%' %*%'

  

"' @%*'#0 5!!%% ;%/7/%!<)/%5  <  %< <** <  *!"3!;%"44=E2F*%!< 7% "%6< %#$$$%97/%!% <%'%>6 **     

                      /G%%/%** %* C/%*7%E%*'"##*"#=  < ( F 67  <%/!**@%*'3='" 5!!%% /%!<) /%5   #0 6  "48# EF  * C 9<  % ; *% / "%H*#$$= */%9>@55 %   !*!*% E%*'".# F?!*%@55 /%*7%; ! %!/%* * !*% !/%67 <%'

#' +@%*'##2E<*%< 7%/ "%6< %#$$$F   <%  /%**   %*  >  %*  % 7 * /%*7! 5%!* ?%*'"##"#="."*".# I%*'=C0 2@// >* /%7 **C*%5!%%E'"F'%:>6 */%**  %* C/%*7%%%/C 55!%*%/%** %* 7*!  < %   ;% /7 ? ** !<**  *   <% *  /%** %* 7*!< % ;%/7? **!<** * % 7E5'%*'#.2F'%6* C  /%**   %*  * C @< %   ;% /7 ? **  *      % 7  *!%A*   *   <% E 2 "#8  #=$I 2"#4...F'

 G/9  67  /% 9% *  %!  /%*7 /%  * !  /%**   %*  >  %*  % 7 /%  %'  * /%* **G/%*% 7#86 #$$#G*%/%*"%  #$$3*C>67* <%*<?!* %'

=' +  * /% *  /%**  >  /*  % 7 /%  % *  "3@."0 5%'  *  >  >  /%  % *  #$@1#35%'80 *!%A*)*!6C!*!!/% * ** /%!<) !5%'  % *C?(!/**8@3$35%'0$ E"3@."05%'J#F*(  *C (C**"$@="=5%'4$E#$@1#35%'80J #F%*>G*%>  *%**"@1$1 5%'0$'

.' 5%!* C  6% /% /   6% !*% * /%  /%*7 6>@**%5%*/%** %* %6 *  <%!;!!5   %/%** % *C *!%A*/* %% **( '  *!%A**!*?  !7@%*'"# @%%/%!<)/%5 <  %< <** <  *!  "8 <%  "48. E #F    *? %!7* %    (  * /!% % E 2"#4#00 '=F'

0'  !*  % /%B  /%!% !** 7%* * E%*' 3= ' #  * 84K'" %/%!%  *%* <"#/*;%"480F'

     

                       * 0 / )  ) *)  * * )

"' < *  K C *%5!%%  /*       "@1$15%'0$C2*  ;%/7 22+ 5<% %   > *!%A*/* % !%* 9"% #$$36>@**%5%*'

#' G)**>; '

='  *>/%!%*7%* *'

.' 5%  /%*    >G /<* 5%% %% *%  /%!* %%A*   !   =$ 6% 9  * 5 *  /%9  % ; 5!!% E+:L M%:5> 11$$.  F/%< %%* 9%% * /; 5%!*?%*'8# 5!!%% % ;5!!%"3 6  #$$0 E 2FI  ! %  %%  *  >%    * 5 * )/%<*/%*% 7*%%%** %I  * A*% %!  % ; 5!!% /% <  /*  /% <  !*% > ?  *   @%*' .#  2'  /%!* %%A* *  / 9  /   %%* <>!)/%< <*A*%6 *C@< '  7%55 9%  %! *J         ,N O ;+ 

/ 5%/%!*%%A*** 5 !?/%*   >GCG55 5!!% % /%7%55