Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/1248/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/1248/2007 Généré par l'IA

Damages Cap Applicability to Pre-Judgment Interest in Award Calculation

Numéro de cause ATAS/1248/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case involves a dispute over the calculation of an award in a prior legal matter concerning business relationships, specifically concerning the applicability of a statutory cap on damages and the proper method for applying a pre-judgment interest rate to the underlying judgment amount. The court reasoned that the statutory cap applies only to the portion of the award representing damages, not to pre-judgment interest which is considered an ancillary component of the judgment, and thus the pre-judgment interest calculated at the specified statutory rate should be added to the capped damages amount to arrive at the final award, as the interest itself was not subject to the damage limitation.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Damages Cap Applicability to Pre-Judgment Interest in Award Calculation: The court reasoned that the statutory cap applies only to the portion of the award representing damages, not to pre-judgment interest which is considered an ancillary component of the judgment, and thus the pre-judgment interest calculated at the specified statutory rate should be added to the capped damages amount to arrive at the final award, as the interest itself was not subject to the damage limitation.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
calcul du dommage objet du litige taux d'intérêt épuration de l'état des charges montants compensatoires monétaires proposition de jugement

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Imposed the costs of the federal proceedings on the appellant, as their appeal was unsuccessful.
Généré par l'IA
A/2733/2005
Statutory Damages Cap Application to Prejudgment Interest
A/1603/2003
Damages Calculation: Prejudgment Interest and Penalty Assessments
A/2987/2007
Judgment Interest Calculation Dispute
A/1158/2007
Contract Damages and Prejudgment Interest Calculation in Goods Non-Payment Dispute
A/3264/2006
Statutory Interpretation of Settlement Calculation Caps Regarding Punitive Damages

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Imposed the costs of the federal proceedings on the appellant, as their appeal was unsuccessful.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



            !"#$$ #%&#$$

 ' (  '

  ') *'')  '* * )

*+,   - ./,  #$$ 

            )"##   !"#$#"%&'&& ( *+,#,

0.

1   ') *'')  '*  # * #$$  $ -#$$

  0   !"#$$ .22. 

  

3

         

                  

   .'2.  





2&45(2'004  .62.  

' ' 3 

 $" " ,!,  ' !7 '004 % ,7"%  !*"# " *!%"* !+"7% %

$$#,,"*608"+,'004,9,*$%,!))"*3%"!"$,#3 +"$"$%,#,)$%%6"+,%'004:

% ,7"%"!#,**99;<,%="+",%,#,%*%",3%"!" ;,"+",+",#)7%"7%#%"7"#!)#)*,!">"+,**"%) ,))7,%,#*  ",# < "!!,   $"# "+, $ $ !",##"!  # !,!))"*"$%#,##)",#:

"##"% ,7"%",,;*;%"!",##<"+",$"#*$#*<*!,"# %*%",;,%,"+",**9,>*"&0#$)7'004:

%<";#,"**,9,*"!7'004:

$"!,&!7'004%"!",##%?+"+,"##*#*!,"  &0 #$)7 '004 " ,7"% "!!)$"@*  $,?!# $%, ;, " 7, ** *$#* "$?#%"#)",#@"*A*$BC$"!%%.!,$",#,!:

"##!,%"!",##,,;D$#*!%")",!,!#"!,*D )"" ,7"%;<,%A!#,?%<"$,#C:

<,$%%*$"% ,7"%%"!",##""#),#$"9"!.#,),%*!$,#!, &0#$)7'004;,)";","##,:

 "# ! !, %" !",## %?+ ;<" @"  %<", ,+;* $" %" !"   $ $"# !#,* ;<%% *", )",9#) "# %<,!"$"!,* 78!,+<"@,3)$#;$%#%%+",#<"3!+,*!,#,# $$#,,"",E!"@)""",<"@,!"#*!*" 3#)# ;%"!",###<$$#",3%"#,,*%",:

% ,7"%"+$!**+,#,%<"$*!,*F

*' ' '  

%"%,@+,##%G@",#",8,!,",HI"**),9,*",#,*?# %&"E'006 ,7"%!""%#"##"!##!,"%#!)$#*8@# $*#,+,!.$*#,#$$%*"#&(8@#"#####H"F&%F(  IF

<3   %<"F /5 "%F '  6  %" %, # %" $!* "),,#",+  &' #$)7&5/H I%<"F(&%,%"%,9**"%#%"$",@**"%,# "##"!##!,"%#(!7'000H I#"$$%,!"7%$%#!"##+,#*#3



2&45(2'004  . 2.   %<"F("%F&H%",+#",9**"%I%<"F/0 $%#!"##+,#*#3 %<"F("%F'H%",+#",!""%I:

< %<!!!,%#<"@,<%,,@$%;%%"!)$*!,7"% !*"# #$*+3%<"F("%F'#;!<#%<"F/0 ;,#<"$$%,;:

%#"F/0/& $*+,!;,#,J

 D F/0*+,#,),9#J%="%,3*+,#,%#;"#"99",*@%*$" *!,#,*9,,,+,%"$$""KJ "I;< !,)   *%, *"7%, $"  $!* $*"%  < " )",? " ,9%!*%"*!,#,: 7I; # 9",#  # )=#  $+ +">  ,)$"# >,# ; % !"$+",!"K,+;"#%"$!*$*!*: !I;$","+"!%"*!,#,,$"#!)$9",#,+;*#*"7%,#$" $,?!: I; %" 8,,!, <" $"# #"* # !",# !!%#,# # $",#  )",? 3 !))*,8#,!9)%: I;%"8,,!,;,"#"*<*",$"#!)$#*!))%"%,%<;%# ,#$#,,##%"*!#",**+,%*#DF

 D F/&)"J&")"*+,#,,"##*$"*!,3%"8,,!, ;, "  %" *!,#, "# %# 6 ),# ?# %" *!+  ),9  *+,#,F '" )"  *+,#, ,  9,# $*#* " $%# " "# %# &0 "# 3 !)$%",9,!",%"*!,#,F!"#*+,#,%<",!%/0%"# *#+*F"#!!"#%"*+,#,$"+,%,<99,!"))#!)),!",  $! @**"%F # ",!%# (   ( # "$$%,!"7%# $" ""%@,F " )" ,  $",!%, ,,;%),9*+,#,!,%#!!%#,#;*"$%!"#L%" *+,#,#","),#+%%*!,#,$,#DF

 %#; % ,7"% #,) ; % ),9  *+,#, # *"7%, ,% , "% "%)  $",%%) %<"   #" 3 +" " 9 H!9F  M !*"),,#",+*F")$9%,$F &IF

"#%!"#<#$?!,%"$$""K;%"*+,#,<#$"#!+"7%"$),),9 ;%<"!#*<#$"#*9,,,9>*!,:

$"",%%#%")"*+,#,<,,;$"#%),9*+,#,;,>,#", %<#$?!:





2&45(2'004  .2.   <  "! ),9  *+,#, " ##  %" %, ##),* <# *"%,#*  %<#$?!:

%<+,$"#$",!%,!;%<*!,&0#$)7'004!,", !))9",)=#$++">,)$"#H"F/0%F7 I:

<,%<="$"#"+""@,"+"!%"8,,!,;,"7,!)$# 9",#,+;*#*"7%,#$"$,?!H"F/0%F! I:

%")"$?#%#;<*!%"*,!+"7%:

<%?+"9,#$"#"7"!)=#;% ,7"%"##>")  %" !+"7,%,*  !# " $,#  !#,*", %# "@)# ,+;*# $" %" !",##%&0#$)7'004:

%"+,%"!,9,!",<#$"#+$%#H"F/ I$,#;<"8 #"% ,7"%<"+",99!,+)$"#N<*!,%"!",###;% >%<"!)$$"#<)"*,%%;<,%9",%%!,@F



 * 4 3 )  ') *'')  '* * )

  / .

&F *!%"%")"*+,#,&!7'004,!+"7%F

'F ,;%"$!*#@",F "@99,?  "$*#,         M"O% P #"7%%

!$,!9)$*#"#,9,*">$",#",#,;G3$"%@99%



2&45(2'004